BJP asks CM to apologise for linking COVID vaccines with heart attacks as expert panel rejects claim
A panel constituted by the government concluded that there is no single cause behind the observed increase in sudden cardiac deaths. Rather, it described the phenomenon as multifactorial, with behavioural, genetic, and environmental risk factors contributing.
Bengaluru, Jul 6 (PTI) BJP on Sunday demanded an apology from Chief Minister Siddaramaiah for attributing a spate of cardiac arrests in Karnataka—particularly in Hassan district—to COVID-19 vaccination, after an expert panel found no evidence to support the claim.
'Siddaramaiah is deliberately making such statements because the vaccine was developed during Prime Minister Modi's tenure,' Joshi said in Hubballi. 'They assumed the pandemic would politically damage the Prime Minister—people would suffer and turn against him. But PM Modi handled COVID with sensitivity and care.' Joshi said that because the Prime Minister was widely credited with managing the pandemic effectively, the opposition was resorting to unfounded claims.
'After ICMR, NCDC and AIIMS refuted any link between vaccines and cardiac events, now the Karnataka government's own Jayadeva Institute of Cardiology—a reputed institution not just in the state but across India—has also found no correlation,' Joshi said.
He noted that the committee, led by Dr. Ravindranath, Director of the Jayadeva Institute, was set up by Siddaramaiah himself to examine any possible link between COVID vaccination and cardiac deaths. 'The panel has clearly stated that COVID vaccines are not the cause of heart attacks. Will Siddaramaiah apologise now? I strongly condemn his statement,' Joshi added.
BJP spokesperson Dr CN Ashwath Narayan also criticised Siddaramaiah, alleging that his statement was aimed at discrediting Indian-made vaccines and undermining the Prime Minister.
'He questioned the efficacy of a vaccine that saved millions of lives, without citing any scientific basis. Chief minister should apologise to the people of the state for spreading misinformation,' Narayan said.
The observational study conducted at Jayadeva Institute found no association between premature cardiovascular disease and prior COVID-19 infection or vaccination.
'Most global studies and reports did not find any causal link between COVID-19 vaccination and sudden cardiac events. On the contrary, vaccination has been shown to offer long-term protection against cardiac issues,' the panel noted.
Recently, Siddaramaiah had suggested that a spate of heart attack deaths in Hassan district could be linked to the COVID-19 vaccination drive. He had also claimed that the vaccines were 'hastily' approved.
His comments drew strong criticism from Biocon Executive Chairperson Kiran Mazumdar-Shaw. PTI GMS ADB
This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
24 minutes ago
- Mint
Markets with Bertie: The merits of international investing
Last week, Bertie brushed his navy-blue suit that was hanging limp in his wardrobe and collecting dust. After the bout of sneezing had subsided, he wore it and instantly felt uncomfortable. This was followed by a strong urge to peel it off, but after a few deep breaths, he decided to soldier on. The occasion demanded it as Bertie had been invited by a friend who works for his favourite newspaper to address a gathering of individual investors. The topic was the merits of international investing; again, something that Bertie feels strongly about. Of late, it has dawned on our man that he has become a kind of go-to expert on the subject. When his introduction, proclaiming as much, was read out at the event, it reminded him of the old saying, 'In the land of the blind, the one-eyed man is king.' Bertie did not expect a large turnout because whenever Bertie had broached the subject of international diversification with Indian investors, he had been given a polite ear, but their demeanour showed him that when it came to investing their money, India was the only place they really cared about. Therefore, Bertie was pleasantly surprised to see a full house at the event, attended by knowledgeable investors whose depth of understanding was reflected in their questions. When he mentioned that over the past year, 19 out of the top 25 global markets had performed better than India, nobody in the audience bristled with patriotic outrage. There was an acceptance that markets outside the US offered a good risk-reward profile for incremental investment. Bertie realized that the pain points for international investing were high transaction costs, taxes collected at source whenever money is remitted overseas, and a lack of access to markets other than the US. Apart from the logical reason of diversification, many investors were looking to secure US dollar returns on their investments as their kids would likely head overseas for their higher education. While the official discourse was supposed to be about international investing, the discussion invariably veered to the home market. For any market, Bertie began, there are three sources of investment returns for a dollar investor. The underlying earnings growth, expansion in earnings multiple and the currency effect, i.e. how the local currency behaves against the dollar. Bertie is of the view that in India, the pace of the first two is slowing. Overall earnings growth would be slower than the past five years, and there isn't much scope for the valuation multiples to expand at the headline index level. However, Bertie feels that the days of 2-3% annual depreciation of the rupee against the dollar may be behind us. This is so because the US fiscal position and high public debt will act as a heavy counterweight to the dollar's traditional status as a reserve currency. In general, investment returns in dollars could converge towards local currency returns in many markets, including India. Generally, by the time the discussion gets to currency dynamics, the audience's attention span is exhausted and gets redirected towards the dinner buffet. This audience surprised Bertie some more when they unanimously agreed to let the session spill over the appointed hour. It might sound like wishful thinking, but is this the new dawn of international investing out of India? Bertie is a Mumbai-based fund manager whose compliance department wishes him to cough twice before speaking and then decide not to say it after all.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
LatAm pivot
Times of India's Edit Page team comprises senior journalists with wide-ranging interests who debate and opine on the news and issues of the day. India must shed its protectionist mindset and trade more with resource-rich South America That Modi's ongoing five-nation tour includes Argentina and Brazil isn't a trivia. These two key South American nations can be important fulcrums of a potential Indian pivot to the continent. While India-South America trade has been steadily growing, it's far below potential. This has much to do with our unambitious approach to the region. True, India has a preferential trade agreement (PTA) with MERCOSUR bloc that includes Brazil, Argentina, Uruguay, Paraguay and Bolivia. The idea was that the PTA would be gradually expanded and upgraded to a free trade agreement (FTA). However, progress has been really slow and India's exports to Latin America in FY2025 stood at just $15.17bn – less than 2% of the region's total imports. But trade is back on the agenda during Modi's visits, and rightly so. While one still hopes that an India-US trade deal can be clinched, New Delhi must be prepared for all eventualities. And with Trump keen on using tariffs as a strategic weapon to achieve geopolitical goals – take the Lindsey Graham-proposed bill to hit countries buying Russian oil with 500% tariff – India must diversify its trade relations. South America is a natural resources powerhouse. With vast deposits of oil, gas, copper, lithium, rare earths etc it can power India's industrial growth, advance critical sectors like EV batteries, and bolster food security. The key for GOI would be to expand its diplomatic bandwidth and take a courageous approach to trade. We must cast away the protectionist mindset and be ready to compete. That's the only way beneficial FTAs can be worked out. Vietnam, which recently worked out a trade deal with US, has been following precisely this strategy, having inked 20 FTAs, with 16 already implemented. China already has a huge presence in Latin America. So, the latter is looking for balance. This is the perfect time for India to step up. Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email This piece appeared as an editorial opinion in the print edition of The Times of India.
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
Is world order in the middle of a tectonic shift?
People in the US, startled by the rise of Zohran Mamdani as a Democrat candidate for New York's mayorship, are now witness to an even bigger and spicier political potboiler: Elon Musk's announcement last weekend of the formation of 'America Party", a new political outfit. Till the other day Musk was considered a staunch ally of US president Donald Trump. He was made the head of the now infamous Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE). He ruthlessly chucked out many from their jobs citing the need to pare government expenses. His axe also fell on a host of schemes and departments that were considered foundations of the US democracy. Musk wanted the government to be run like a corporate entity. But then, he had run-ins with vice president J. D. Vance and other influential people, which ended in his unceremonious removal from DOGE. Since then, Trump and Musk have been publicly threatening each other. Musk alleged Trump was named in the Epstein sex case files in a post on X, the short-messaging platform he owns. Later, he deleted the post, but not before an enraged Trump got back at his former ally by threatening to deport him. Also read | A new 'terror pot' that may be kept boiling for now Being a beneficiary of government subsidies and doles, Musk knows his ambitions can be fulfilled only by being on the right side of the government. This is why he has launched his political party. Musk feels US citizens are tired of the system and yearn for a new dawn. But the question is, will he succeed? Especially at a time when 'Democrat Socialist" Mamdani is gaining ground in New York. Mamdani has garnered political support at a pace akin to which Musk amassed wealth. He has won the primaries for the New York mayoral elections and will create history if he wins in November. He would be the first Muslim mayor of New York. Mamdani, son of celebrated Indian film-maker Mira Nair, became a US citizen in 2018 and married a Syrian Muslim. His father is a Gujarati left-wing intellectual based in Uganda. Mamdani's views and principles set him apart from his peers. At times, he becomes so aggressive that even his colleagues fear his approach may be extreme. But Mamdani isn't bothered. Also read | Testimony to the enduring spirit of Indian democracy During his campaign, Mamdani connected with New York's large immigrant population. He promised free bus rides, and told people he would freeze metro fares the moment he won elections. He promised construction of low-cost housing blocks, fixing rents for residential properties, and the creation of free childcare centres throughout the city. He wants to rein in the state-sponsored grocery shop owners' cartel. According to estimates, the average New Yorker's expenditure on groceries and essential items has risen by 50% over the past decade to now stand at 10–12% of their total income. Mamdani also proposes to levy higher taxes on the rich. India has seen this brand of politics for decades, but, we are also the ones who have exemplified limitations to such politics. In contrast to India, communist countries such as China and Vietnam have created economic models which give equal opportunity to work with state-sponsored enterprises or pursue private entrepreneurship. Is it due to their success that 70% of the people polled last year in the US showed them gravitating towards the communist model? Also read | Firm and focused leadership keeps India on course It is in such a situation that a triangular tussle between Musk, Mamdani and the established political order promises to create history. People who understand the US system know that the country became great as people from varied backgrounds and ideologies had the same opportunity to live and thrive in harmony. With the rise of the right wing, it seemed that this space was shrinking. But Mamdani's rise and civil society's rear-guard actions have once again brought the US to a point where it's still considered a democratic ideal despite being an imperial power. Today, China and the Global South are challenging US domination. The world order set by the US and the western European nations at the end of World War II has started withering. This is the reason scholars are talking of a tectonic shift in the systems laid down by the West-backed capitalism and US imperialism. Increasing geopolitical constraints are heightening such apprehensions. Have we unwittingly reached a crossroads that's leading to a systemic change? Shashi Shekhar is editor-in-chief, Hindustan. Views are personal.
