logo
A glimmer of hope in Gaza? Inside the fragile ceasefire push as Trump hosts Netanyahu

A glimmer of hope in Gaza? Inside the fragile ceasefire push as Trump hosts Netanyahu

Independent10 hours ago
A proposal for a badly needed ceasefire in Gaza will be top of the agenda during a key visit between Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and US President Donald Trump this week.
After months of deadlock and a soaring death toll in Gaza, a potential breakthrough appeared when Trump announced a proposal for a 60-day truce, which he said could pave the way for discussions to end the 21-month-long devastating war.
On Sunday, Netanyahu flew to Washington DC – a third trip since Trump took office in January. As he boarded the plane, he said he vowed to bring home the remaining 50 Israeli captives held by Hamas militants in Gaza, adding: 'the discussion with President Trump can certainly help advance these results.
At the same time, an Israeli negotiating team flew to Qatar, where Hamas delegations are already meeting with Qatari and Egyptian mediators.
Reaching a deal has felt impossible in the recent past. Previous negotiations have repeatedly broken down, with Israel stating it would not consider a permanent ceasefire until Hamas was defeated. Hamas, for its part, has refused to engage in any talks that do not outline a definitive end to the war.
Speaking to officials from Israel and Hamas, those briefed on the negotiations, as well as US-linked mediators, it appears there is a genuine shift in momentum — although significant obstacles remain.
In Gaza, Palestinian health officials say that since the last ceasefire collapsed in March, Israel's unprecedented bombardment of the narrow strip has killed nearly 7,000 more people — pushing the overall death toll since 2023 to nearly 57,500. Most of the 2.3 million-strong population is struggling through famine-like conditions, as Israel has intermittently imposed full blockades on the entry of aid and supplies.
Hundreds of Palestinians have reportedly been killed by Israeli fire while attempting to collect food at controversial aid distribution points. Families — displaced multiple times and now living in tents — told me they can no longer survive under conditions which are 'worse than a Hollywood horror movie'.
In Israel, the largest group representing the remaining 50 Israeli hostages believed to be held in Gaza, has taken to the streets almost every week, demanding Netanyahu agree to a ceasefire. Fewer than half of those hostages are believed to still be alive. The families held another protest on Sunday evening, as Netanyahu travelled to the US, declaring: 'This is the time to save lives.' They have repeatedly told me that every day their loved ones remain in Gaza could be their last.
A turning point in Gaza? What's changed on the ground
There does, however, appear to be some movement.
An official close to the mediators in Doha told me that US guarantees that this deal would lead to a permanent ceasefire are a first and a key change that may help assuage Hamas's concerns. That official, who asked to remain anonymous as they are not permitted to speak to the media, believes that with proper promises from Washington, Israel's most powerful ally and primary arms provider, Hamas might remain at the table.
A different official, briefed on Israel's position, who also asked for anonymity, told me that added to this there is more 'flexibility' from Netanyahu to discuss an end to the war. Netanyahu has faced fierce pressure from the extreme-right members of his fragile, razor-thin coalition not to enter into any truce. Israel's far-right Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich has called any deal a 'surrender' and threatened to exit the coalition — a move that would likely collapse the government.
However, the Israeli prime minister is in a stronger position domestically after Israel's recent intense bombardment of Iran, which took out much of the military leadership and caused 'extensive' damage to Iran's nuclear facilities. That came on the heels of Israeli airstrikes in Lebanon that decimated the Iran-backed militant group Hezbollah — another of Israel's regional foes.
'There's a different kind of atmosphere altogether after Iran,' that official told me. 'Netanyahu is in a mindset to go for a deal.' Netanyahu reputedly hopes to use a Gaza ceasefire as a launching point to expand the Abraham Accords — the 2020 diplomatic normalisation agreements Israel signed with Bahrain and the UAE. The official added that Netanyahu hopes powerful regional players like Saudi Arabia may now be more inclined to sign on.
Meanwhile, Hamas's position has undoubtedly been weakened. The militant group, which led the bloody 7 October 2023 attacks on southern Israel killing over 1,000 people and taking more than 250 people hostage, is under extreme pressure to end the war. It is struggling to survive: short on commanders, deprived of much of its tunnel network, grappling with rebellious local clans, enduring relentless Israeli bombardment, and now facing a decline in support from its most powerful ally, Iran.
The lack of a military response from Iran-backed groups in the region to Israel's strikes on Iran — whether due to strategic restraint or lack of capability — has cast a long shadow over Hamas's strategic position.
Hamas officials told me they still have firm red lines, including the unfettered delivery of aid to Gaza, which they insist should not be routed through Israel's controversial aid mechanism run by a US-based company called the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation. They also want the complete withdrawal of Israeli troops from the territory and an end to the war.
And so that leads us to the potential obstacles.
Before Netanyahu left Israel, he said that Hamas had proposed changes to the US proposal which were 'unacceptable to Israel.'
A source familiar with the matter told me one of the main changes concerned delivery of aid: 'Hamas does not want GHF there, they want a mechanism run by the United Nations and the Red Cross'.
Hamas also wants Israel to withdraw all its troops. Those briefed on Israel's position have made clear that in particular Israel will not agree to withdraw from the strategic border between Gaza and Egypt — a nine-mile strip of land known as the Philadelphi Corridor.
In fact there are reportedly Israeli plans to connect it to a newly planned corridor around three miles deep into Gaza — named Morag after an Israeli settlement that used to exist before the 'disengagement' from Gaza in 2005.
Hamas has also objected to US guarantees that this deal would herald an end to the conflict.
'The guarantees to end the war, the wording that comes from the American administration it is not apparently strong enough for Hamas,' the official added.
Perhaps the most contentious sticking point is who governs Gaza in the future. Israel insists it cannot include Hamas in any future administration of the territory. There are also questions about whether the occupied West Bank will be dragged into the negotiations.
In leaked reports of phone conversations between the US administration and Israeli officials — published in the Israeli press last month — Washington reportedly signalled it would be willing to acknowledge 'limited Israeli sovereignty' in parts of the West Bank.
That has raised fears the US could effectively recognise Israel's de facto annexation of territory Palestinians hope will form the basis of a future state — including Israeli settlements, which are widely considered illegal under international law.
There is still a long way to go until a deal can be signed, and a lot that could scupper any agreement. But for the first time in a while all sides are at the negotiating table, and that for now is a glimmer of hope for the civilians suffering slaughter and starvation.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

John Swinney must get spending right after funding boost
John Swinney must get spending right after funding boost

Daily Record

time32 minutes ago

  • Daily Record

John Swinney must get spending right after funding boost

Get shopping list right, Swinney There is no shortage of options for the Scottish Government when it comes to spending the extra £5.8billion it will receive in funding by the end of the decade. The recent UK spending review by Rachel Reeves saw a commitment by the UK Government to investment even more in the NHS across England. That means in turn a cash boost for Holyrood thanks to the Barnett Formula, the long-standing mechanism used to calculate funding for the devolved administrations. While there is huge pressure on the public finances, it's worth repeating that overall spending is rising and not being cut by the Labour government. Keir Starmer has endured a difficult first year in power but he cannot be accused of bringing back austerity. Politicians in Holyrood and Westminster face extremely difficult decisions on where public money should be spent. SNP ministers have awarded record investment in the NHS but other parts of public life are struggling. The Record reports today on the grim conditions many police officers currently work in, with some police stations falling apart due to slashed maintenance budgets. But Scots see the impact of cut-backs to council budgets every time they leave the house. Roads are filled with ever-deepening pot holes, while many pavements are cracked and uncared for. And £5.8billion is a lot of money but it's not a magic wand. Not everything can be fixed in a flash. But making sensible spending decisions is something John Swinney and his government must get right. Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. Light in darkness The terrible scenes of death and destruction in Gaza have shocked the world. From the appalling Hamas-led October 7 massacre to the daily death toll of Palestinians, it has been the darkest time in the decades-long dispute. In such an intractable conflict, amid a horrific loss of life, with distrust and loathing on both sides, it is hard to have hope at all of any kind of resolution. If any progress is to be made, however, it is clear it can only be when the killing stops. A ceasefire is the first step but it can only be achieved if all parties are willing to talk. It is welcome, therefore, that Israel has finally decided to send a delegation to Qatar to discuss a Gaza ceasefire and hostage release deal with Hamas. US president Donald Trump is also due to meet Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu today. Hopefully, these are significant steps on the road to peace.

Israel resumes Gaza ceasefire talks despite ‘unacceptable' Hamas demands
Israel resumes Gaza ceasefire talks despite ‘unacceptable' Hamas demands

Times

time33 minutes ago

  • Times

Israel resumes Gaza ceasefire talks despite ‘unacceptable' Hamas demands

An Israeli delegation arrived in Doha to discuss a ceasefire in Gaza as Binyamin Netanyahu headed to Washington for a meeting with the US president. 'I'm determined to bring everyone back and to ensure that Gaza won't be a threat to Israel, Netanyahu said as he boarded the plane, in a nod to Israel's war goals of both freeing the hostages and crushing Hamas. On Sunday, the Israeli prime minister's office said Hamas was seeking to make changes to the draft deal that were 'unacceptable', but Israel still sent a mission to the Qatari capital to continue negotiations. Netanyahu said Israel's delegation could achieve an agreement, but only under the conditions accepted by Israel, adding that 'the discussion with President Trump can certainly help advance these results'. The deal, backed by Qatar and the US, sets out a staged release of some Israeli hostages held by Hamas in Gaza. It proposes the release of ten hostages and the bodies of 18 who have died in exchange for a large number of Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails, as well as more than 1,000 Gazan detainees who have not been accused of any crime. The staged release — a clause intended to allow Israel the option to resume fighting during the 60 days of truce, and for Hamas to keep hold of the hostages as a guarantee Israel will not — has come under criticism from the majority of the Israeli public, who want to stop the war. The group representing the families of most the hostages, the Hostages and Missing Families Forum, termed the staged release 'Schindler's list', referring to Oskar Schindler's list of Jewish employees he saved from being sent to concentration camps. They said everyone must be brought home at once. 'At this critical time, it is forbidden to conform to the various Schindler's lists being dictated, as if it was impossible to bring them all back a long time ago,' the group said. The staged release is a tactical step for both sides, one expert in Palestinian affairs at the Harry S. Truman Research Institute for the Advancement of Peace, Dr Ronni Shaked, said, and will not lead to the permanent end of the war civilians on both sides want. 'It's going to give for the both sides the reason to continue. Hamas is not going to give back the soldiers that were kidnapped. They will give everybody else, the bodies of the Israeli civilians, but not the soldiers,' Shaked, who is a senior correspondent on Palestinian affairs for the Israeli daily, Yedioth Ahronoth, said. 'They know the price they can ask for soldiers — similar to what they asked for in the Shalit deal in 2011. So they are waiting to stop the war and [the withdrawal] of the Israeli army from Gaza. But Bibi [Netanyahu] is not going to give it, and Bibi is not going to give it to even to Trump,' said Shaked. In 2011, one Israeli soldier, Gilad Shalit, was released for more than 1,000 Palestinian prisoners, including Yahya Sinwar — the mastermind of the October 7 attack that led to the war. Netanyahu and Trump will meet on Monday. The previous deal, similar to the current draft agreement, saw the far-right cabinet member Itamar Ben-Gvir quit the government, only to rejoin when the fighting resumed. He and other hardline ministers have threatened to do the same again after the cabinet voted on Sunday to allow in more aid to the Gaza Strip. The threat of collapse for any partial deal has precedent. Israel's government resumed fighting after the last ceasefire deal in March, when it chose not to move forward with a second phase of the agreement that called for discussions for permanent end to the war and withdrawal of Israeli troops from Gaza. 'The cabinet and the prime minister made a grave mistake yesterday in approving the entry of aid through a route that also benefits Hamas,' Bezalel Smotrich, who heads the finance ministry, said on Sunday. The distribution of humanitarian aid is one of the conditions for Hamas in the current agreement, reportedly demanding an end to the controversial US-backed Gaza Humanitarian Fund. 'While the leaders in Doha are bargaining with mediators to what line the Israeli withdrawal will be, and being stubborn [about] who will give out food, our people are hungry for food and ceasefire. The disconnection of the external leadership is costing … more land and casualties every day,' a source familiar with the discussions told The Times. Last week, Trump promised a ceasefire deal in Gaza that would see Hamas release hostages and end the long war. However, the current deal does not outline a plan for the future control and governance of Gaza. On Sunday, the Bedouin Gazan gang leader Yasser Abu Shabab, said that he wanted to confront Hamas over their rule of the Palestinian territory. 'We've tasted the bitterness and injustice inflicted on us by Hamas, and we've taken it upon ourselves to confront this aggression. We don't rule out confrontation with Hamas and we don't rule out civil war, no matter the cost,' Abu Shabab said to Makan, an Arabic language radio station on Israel's public broadcaster, stopping short of admitting to working with Israeli forces as alleged by officials inside Israel. Abu Shabab has been widely condemned by much of Gazan society for his connection to drug and arms dealing, and has been accused of links to Islamic State in the Sinai desert. Yet Israel's efforts to strengthen non-Hamas forces in Gaza are being echoed in the West Bank, where clan leaders in the southern part of the Palestinian territory reportedly offered to recognise Israel and break away from the Palestinian Authority, which partially rules the area and does not accept Israel as a Jewish state. 'We want co-operation with Israel,' Sheik Wadee' al-Jaabari was quoted by the Wall Street Journal as writing to Israel's minister of economy, Nir Barkat, adding that Hebron could become an emirate of its own and join the Abraham Accords alongside other states formally hostile to Israel. The expansion of the Abraham Accords has been touted by the US as the prize for Israel to end its war on Gaza. But while talks in Doha continue, Israel has continued to intensify its operations in Gaza in an apparent effort to force Hamas to capitulate to a better deal. About 80 people have been killed and more than 300 wounded since Saturday, according to the Hamas-run health ministry in Gaza, eight of whom were shot near the currently closed aid distribution centres. The fighting has killed more than 55,000 people in nearly two years. More than 400 members of the Israeli military have been killed, including a soldier killed in southern Gaza on Friday.

Israel launches airstrikes targeting Yemen's Houthi-controlled ports
Israel launches airstrikes targeting Yemen's Houthi-controlled ports

The Independent

timean hour ago

  • The Independent

Israel launches airstrikes targeting Yemen's Houthi-controlled ports

Israel 's military launched airstrikes early on Monday targeting ports and facilities held by Yemen 's Houthi rebels, with the rebels responding with missile fire targeting Israel. The attacks came after an attack on Sunday targeting a Liberian-flagged ship in the Red Sea that caught fire and took on water, later forcing its crew to abandon the vessel. Suspicion for the attack on the Greek-owned bulk carrier Magic Seas immediately fell on the Houthis, particularly as a security firm said it appeared bomb-carrying drone boats hit the ship after it was targeted by small arms and rocket-propelled grenades. The rebels' media reported on the attack but did not claim it. A renewed Houthi campaign against shipping could again draw in US and Western forces to the area, particularly after president Donald Trump targeted the rebels in a major airstrike campaign. The ship attack comes at a sensitive moment in the Middle East, as a possible ceasefire in the Israel-Hamas war hangs in the balance and as Iran weighs whether to restart negotiations over its nuclear program following American airstrikes targeting its most sensitive atomic sites amid an Israeli war against the Islamic Republic. Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu was also traveling to Washington to meet with Mr Trump. The Israeli military said it struck Houthi-held ports at Hodeida, Ras Isa and Salif, as well as the Ras Kanatib power plant. 'These ports are used by the Houthi terrorist regime to transfer weapons from the Iranian regime, which are employed to carry out terrorist operations against the state of Israel and its allies,' the Israeli military said. The Israeli military also said it struck the Galaxy Leader, a vehicle-carrying vessel that the Houthis seized back in November 2023 when they began their attacks in the Red Sea corridor over the Israel- Hamas war. 'Houthi forces installed a radar system on the ship and have been using it to track vessels in the international maritime arena to facilitate further terrorist activities,' the Israeli military said. The Bahamas-flagged Galaxy Leader was affiliated with an Israeli billionaire. It said no Israelis were on board. The ship had been operated by a Japanese firm NYK Line. The Houthis acknowledged the strikes, but offered no damage assessment from the attack. Their military spokesman, Brig Gen Yahya Saree, claimed its air defense forces 'effectively confronted' the Israelis without offering evidence. The Houthis then responded with an apparent missile attack on Israel. The Israeli military said it attempted to intercept the missile, but it appeared to make impact, though there were no immediate reports of injuries from the attack.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store