Samoan government says sunken Manawanui wreck will stay where it is
The Royal New Zealand Navy ship ran aground with 75 people on board whilst conducting a hydrographic survey of a reef last October. All those on board managed to be rescued safely.
The ship has remained off the coast near Upolu, Samoa since then. Containers and fuel aboard the ship were recovered, but the vessel was not removed.
Prime Minister Fiame Naomi Mata'afa told 1News her cabinet were presented with a list of options regarding the wreck. (Source: 1News)
Now, after the Samoan government were presented with a list of options regarding the wreck, it has been decided the vessel safe enough to leave where it is.
ADVERTISEMENT
"Sometimes events just take over... Nature has taken over and it's become, you know, it's already been incorporated into the reef so to speak," said Prime Minister Fiame Naomi Mata'afa.
Samoa's Prime Minister Fiame Naomi Mata'afa. (Source: 1News)
"I mean all the toxic elements have been removed. So it's become an additional part, I suppose, of the reef," she told 1News.
'There's no accountability' - locals
Samoan locals from the village of Tafitoala claim they are still living with the consequences of the ship's sinking and say they want the wreck to be taken away.
"There's no accountability for what's going on. No compensation, but we lost a lot of things from here," said Tafitoala resident Faga'ilesau Afaaso Saleupu.
Tafitoala resident Faga'ilesau Afaaso Saleupu. (Source: 1News)
ADVERTISEMENT
Local authorities have maintained a 'no-go zone' around the site of the wreck, making it in inaccessible for fishing.
"Eighty percent of our people rely on the sea for food. Where are the fishermen going to go now?
"We acknowledge what you did by removing the oil and some of the pollutants materials from the wreck, but the wreck is still there-that's not clean," Faga'ilesau said.
Village high chief Tuia Pu'a Leota said the boat has "damaged" the village's shores.
"Our shores have been damaged, the coral reef has been damaged, the mangroves have been damaged.
"All of these damages need to be considered and need to be taken back to their natural status." he said.
Tuia, who is standing as a candidate in the country's general elections next month, said he will be "fighting very hard to ensure our district will get a fair compensation."
Despite fierce opposition from locals, the Samoan government disagreed - and said they were happy with the cleanup that had been done.
New Zealand Defence said they are still completing technical and environmental analysis of the wreck and surrounding area to inform future decisions of both governments.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
1News
15 hours ago
- 1News
Samoan government says sunken Manawanui wreck will stay where it is
Samoa's Prime Minister says the wreck of the HMNZS Manawauni vessel can stay exactly where it sank after being presented with options regarding the vessel's future. The Royal New Zealand Navy ship ran aground with 75 people on board whilst conducting a hydrographic survey of a reef last October. All those on board managed to be rescued safely. The ship has remained off the coast near Upolu, Samoa since then. Containers and fuel aboard the ship were recovered, but the vessel was not removed. Prime Minister Fiame Naomi Mata'afa told 1News her cabinet were presented with a list of options regarding the wreck. (Source: 1News) Now, after the Samoan government were presented with a list of options regarding the wreck, it has been decided the vessel safe enough to leave where it is. ADVERTISEMENT "Sometimes events just take over... Nature has taken over and it's become, you know, it's already been incorporated into the reef so to speak," said Prime Minister Fiame Naomi Mata'afa. Samoa's Prime Minister Fiame Naomi Mata'afa. (Source: 1News) "I mean all the toxic elements have been removed. So it's become an additional part, I suppose, of the reef," she told 1News. 'There's no accountability' - locals Samoan locals from the village of Tafitoala claim they are still living with the consequences of the ship's sinking and say they want the wreck to be taken away. "There's no accountability for what's going on. No compensation, but we lost a lot of things from here," said Tafitoala resident Faga'ilesau Afaaso Saleupu. Tafitoala resident Faga'ilesau Afaaso Saleupu. (Source: 1News) ADVERTISEMENT Local authorities have maintained a 'no-go zone' around the site of the wreck, making it in inaccessible for fishing. "Eighty percent of our people rely on the sea for food. Where are the fishermen going to go now? "We acknowledge what you did by removing the oil and some of the pollutants materials from the wreck, but the wreck is still there-that's not clean," Faga'ilesau said. Village high chief Tuia Pu'a Leota said the boat has "damaged" the village's shores. "Our shores have been damaged, the coral reef has been damaged, the mangroves have been damaged. "All of these damages need to be considered and need to be taken back to their natural status." he said. Tuia, who is standing as a candidate in the country's general elections next month, said he will be "fighting very hard to ensure our district will get a fair compensation." Despite fierce opposition from locals, the Samoan government disagreed - and said they were happy with the cleanup that had been done. New Zealand Defence said they are still completing technical and environmental analysis of the wreck and surrounding area to inform future decisions of both governments.
Newsroom
2 days ago
- Newsroom
Tourism's role in peace and prosperity
The Nobel Peace Prize has been won by presidents, fighters for the oppressed, people who've changed history and put their lives on the line for a cause. So when Washington-based Auckland-educated Lelei Tuisamoa Lelaulu found out he'd been nominated, it's not surprising he thought it was a prank. He is a Samoan development entrepreneur whose leadership has extended across the globe including the United Nations, the World Bank, the International Finance Corporation, and the World Indigenous Games. He chairs the Earth Council Alliance and a council at George Washington University School of Business. This year he told the Metropolitan Museum of Art to take its reimagined Rockefeller Wing arts collections on tour to the places they came from. Lelaulu is nominated 'for his work in reshaping the narrative around tourism – not just for leisure, but as a vessel of peace'. He's still trying to get his head around the nomination. 'It's a huge honour and I'm just a little bit stunned waiting for something to happen. It's a little bit overwhelming.' Lelaulu was nominated by NGOs associated with the Anglican Church and the United Nations. 'It was a bit out of the blue in a sense 'cause I don't really go to Anglican churches or any churches generally, so I thought it was a prank initially, and then they called back and it was true, and they sent the recommendation and I saw it and away it went. We'll see what happens.' But what does tourism have to do with peace? 'I think that tourism is the only real peace dividend,' he says. 'It's basically the industry of peace because if you think about it … this is the largest transfer of resources from the haves to the have nots in history – voluntarily. No one's forcing it. 'Then you think about the hundreds of millions of lives that have been lost because people tried to wrest resources from others over the centuries; it's just astounding but tourism has reversed all that,' Lelaulu said. If it's handled properly tourism gets resources and money to communities instead of corporations 'and it has enormous possibilities for allowing communities to improve their education, their health, their welfare and their dignity – their ability to live lives of dignity. That's why I think the industry of peace is tourism,' he says. Lelaulu explains to Lei'ataualesa Susana Lei'ataua in a special episode of The Detail that bilateral aid goes mostly to the treasuries of countries whereas tourism handled properly goes to families and the communities directly 'and it builds them up and gives them a whole new dignity of life'. But how does tourism fit in when it comes to conflict zones? 'In terms of conflict we have to end the conflicts before tourism can apply. It is very much the industry of peace because once there's peace then people tend to stream across borders to see what their former adversaries are like and what they did and how they live, and this then builds up connections between former adversaries and this is what I hope for,' Lelaulu said. Lelaulu is quick to point out the 'holus bolus' introduction of tourists is not the answer. The wine routes in France are a successful example of a planned approach to directing a huge percentage of tourists outside of an over-crowded Paris, benefiting the agricultural sector. He says we could take a leaf out of that book. 'New Zealand is obviously one of the most beautiful countries on the planet but it also has one of the richest cultural ethnic heritages that should be looked at, and pulling people out of the major tourist destinations is the way to do it.' Lelaulu highlights Māori tourism. 'It's incredibly innovative and very effective. If you look at what they're doing in the South Island, looking at Kaikōura and what the iwi are doing there that's enormous. It's one of the most successful tourism projects in New Zealand … and they're very, very generous with the local communities which is an important thing.' Lelaulu was a guest speaker at the re-opening of the Metropolitan Museum of Art's US$70m revamped Michael C Rockefeller Wing in New York, and had a strong message for them. 'We should move these wonderful pieces of art around the world so that more and more people should see them … move it overseas to the major art capitals of the world and also to the places of origin like Papua New Guinea, Tonga, Samoa, Fiji. Let the people there see the beauty of what emerged from their artists a long, long time ago.' Lelaulu suggested these collections would tour for six months at a time and door-take profits would be split with the destinations to upgrade and build 'museologically sound' facilities for the artefacts. 'In a sense as the collection goes around and as you return some of the artefacts now and then where applicable, the collection that comes back to the Metropolitan Museum is going to be richer and more valuable than the exhibit that left, so I called it a cultural diplomatic continuum.' The 2025 Nobel Peace Prize will be announced on October 10, with the award ceremony taking place on December 10 in Oslo, Norway. Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here. You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter.
1News
2 days ago
- 1News
Chinese consulate asks NZ film festival to can Philippine doco
Chinese officials have asked that a Filipino documentary be removed from future screenings at the New Zealand Doc Edge Festival, saying doing so would be in the interest of Chinese-New Zealand relations. The documentary, Food Delivery: Fresh from the West Philippine Sea, had its world premiere on June 30 at The Capitol Cinema in Auckland — after being withdrawn from screenings in its home country. The film was scheduled to premiere at the Puregold CinePalo Film Festival in Manila was pulled from the line-up days before it aired over what the film creators described as "external factors" earlier this year. It was then selected by New Zealand's Doc Edge Festival — the first to be able to do so. But, this week, festival organisers were asked to do as the Filipino counterparts had and cut the doco from its schedule. In correspondence seen by 1News, the Chinese Consulate requested the festival refrain from all future screenings — if it wanted to act in the "interest of public and China-New Zealand relations". The correspondence pointed out that New Zealand Prime Minister's Christopher Luxon's recent visit to China had been "fruitful". ADVERTISEMENT Festival organisers said the written request followed several calls to ticketing staff and board members, requesting that the screenings be pulled. "The documentary... is rife with disinformation and false propaganda, serving as a political tool for Philippines to pursue illegitimate claims in the South China Sea. Its screening would severely mislead the public and send the wrong message internationally," the email from the Chinese Consulate read. "This documentary disregarded history and facts, and is designed to amplify the Philippines' wrong position on the issue concerning the South China Sea and deliberately distort and hype up the maritime situation." Doc Edge general manager Rachael Penman said they've refused the request and willingly stand by all their filmmakers. "We are a voice for independent filmmakers," she said. "We programmed a film that we felt was really important to be seen and brings up a conversation with so many people. I hope that everyone does go and see this now, and has their own opportunity to make their own decisions about this film." 1News has reached out to both the Chinese Embassy and the Chinese Consulate via email and phone with questions around its specific concerns with the film and why it was appropriate to exert political pressure in such a way. While it didn't address those specific questions, the Chinese Embassy said as a "matter of principle we hope that publicly promoted content would reflect realities rather than spreading mis or dis-information". ADVERTISEMENT It also called for disputes to be peacefully resolved and expressed its desire for "countries outside the region to play a constructive role in this regard instead of doing the opposite". The Philippine Embassy declined to comment other than to say "it is aware" of the situation. Directed by Filipino filmmaker Baby Ruth Villarama, the tells the stories of local fishermen, the national Coast Guard, and the Navy as they work in the South China Sea – with a particular focus on the area around the Scarborough Shoal. Contained within the Philippines' Exclusive Economic Zone, China's had de-facto control of it since 2012 and has refused to accept an international ruling that said its claim over almost the entirety of the South China Sea has no legal basis. University of Otago senior lecturer in politics Nicholas Khoo said there is "absolutely no ambiguity" and the Scarborough Shoal is "Filipino territory". "The challenge is that China doesn't respect the Filipino position, nor does it respect the international legal issue that is at stake here." He said the situation "underlines the importance of New Zealand standing up for the international legal order" and for it to continue to "reassert our interest in freedom of navigation", adding that "there should not be an aggressive use of force to attempt to solve issues". ADVERTISEMENT Khoo said the film clearly contradicts China's narrative and that will be why officials are working to prevent its screening. New Zealand's Ministry of Foreign Affairs responded on behalf of government officials and said it fully supports freedom of expression. In relation to the territorial disputes, it said New Zealand does not take a position on individual claims in the South China Sea, but did want disputes resolved peacefully via diplomacy and in accordance with international law, in particular the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea. In China the film has also been heavily criticised. Commentators with its state-run network described it as revealing a "pattern of selective storytelling that serves broader political interests" and a "propaganda piece" that "dodges the gritty geopolitics of the region and the realities of the territorial issues and maritime disputes". Villarama told 1News today she had deliberately chosen to shine the lens on the people rather than the politics. "Because we really want to celebrate us as people, without politicising the issue. We want to diplomatically reach out and share our personal stories, because the more personal we go, the more authentic we can be with others." She said she held no animosity towards China, and invited those opposed to her documentary to go and watch "so they can know the truth about our people". ADVERTISEMENT "We don't have any agenda. There is no 'Western influence'."
