logo
‘One kid at a time': How children's books on male friendship could combat toxic masculinity

‘One kid at a time': How children's books on male friendship could combat toxic masculinity

The Guardian23-06-2025
This year's Carnegie medals for children's writing, awarded on Thursday, brought to light an unexpected trend. At a time of widespread public anxiety about the decline in boys' reading habits and the rise of the toxic influencers of the online 'manosphere', male friendship and masculinity were front and centre on the shortlist.
The winner, Margaret McDonald's superb debut, Glasgow Boys, tells the story of the relationship between two looked-after children on the threshold of adulthood who process trauma in different ways. Banjo's aggression and Finlay's avoidance could be seen as two models of dysfunctional masculinity. Luke Palmer's Play, also on the shortlist, tells a story of male friendship which touches on rape culture and county lines drug gangs, while teenage gang membership is the focus of Brian Conaghan's Treacle Town.
Nathanael Lessore won the Shadower's Choice medal (voted for by young readers). King of Nothing tells the story of Anton, a pre-GCSE hardman for whom reputation is everything. Anton hangs out with a thuggish crowd whose worldview is shaped by gang culture and Tate-like influencers. The arc of the plot – boisterously comic at first, but increasingly moving – shows how Anton's developing friendship with the uncoolest boy in the school changes his priorities.
Though the books were judged for their individual qualities, the panel's chair, Ros Harding, observes a pendulum-swing in publishing. 'We've gone from children's adventure books, where it was always the boy as the hero, then there was a backlash against that, making sure that girls could be the heroes as well, which then maybe led to some boys feeling that things weren't being written for them.' Now, she says, 'another wave of books' is addressing that.
McDonald says that in Glasgow Boys, she 'wanted to explore the spectrum of masculinity that both Banjo and Finlay exist on. Finlay is the more 'feminine' man who we perceive to be empathetic and introverted – a very gentle person. Banjo, conversely, is the 'masculine' boy: violent and aggressive.'
'People have been very curious as to why I have focused on two men when I'm not myself a man. But I don't think it would have been much of a question if I was a male author.' McDonald had a considerable struggle to get Glasgow Boys published – 60 agents and 20 publishers, she says, turned it down.
Does she think that one factor was a reluctance to publish books about boys? She believes the book's use of Scots dialect (it comes with a glossary) was an issue, as was the fact she was submitting it during Covid. But the decline in boys' reading, she suggests, might have created a vicious circle in publishing. 'I think because there's such a small readership it's difficult, in a business sense, to cut out the bigger readership – which is girls and women.'
Harding says her experience as a librarian is that most boys read more narrowly than most girls. 'A girl who likes reading will read anything. It doesn't matter whether it's a male protagonist or a female. Boys were just a little bit more resistant to that. I think they are more likely to want the male protagonist.'
When McDonald hears feedback on the book, male readers 'often focus on Banjo and Finlay separately, whereas my female readers focus on the relationships. A lot of boys who read it will be like, 'I related to Finlay', or 'I relate to Banjo', whereas none of the girls read that way. So it suggests a little bit of a difference in the ways in which boys go into books.'
The hope is that they go into books at all. The explosion in so-called toxic masculinity is taking place at the same time as statistics tell us that reading for pleasure, especially among boys, is on the decline. Novels are empathy machines: they invite you to imagine what it might be like to be somebody else. So they are, at least potentially, an antidote to the misogynistic influence of the manosphere and gaming culture. But it's precisely with social media and video games that they are competing for the attention of boys and young men.
Lessore says his book was inspired in part by discovering 'my little nephew and my cousin – who were, I think, nine and 13 at the time – were both watching Andrew Tate videos'. He sees the long-term effects of that in school visits he does, to expensive private schools and 'very, very underfunded state schools' alike. Children self-segregate: boys on one side, girls on the other. 'Gay' is being used as an insult once more, and boys have so little respect for female teachers that they have to call over male staff to settle them.
Sign up to Bookmarks
Discover new books and learn more about your favourite authors with our expert reviews, interviews and news stories. Literary delights delivered direct to you
after newsletter promotion
Does Lessore feel confident he's talking to the young men that books like his need to reach, though, rather than just about them? 'I start every school visit with the statistics that teenagers who read more tend to [get] higher paid jobs as adults,' he says. 'That usually gets them sitting up a little bit in their seats.'
In Anton's world, drawn from Lessore's own working-class south London background, he thinks boys can find something to relate to. 'Kids like that don't think they can be writers, and therefore they don't read – and therefore they don't get the empathy that can be learned from books.'
Lessore's influence seems to work. 'Even the more disruptive boys on the school visit tend to, you know, barge their way to the front of the queue to get their book signed. It's a drop. But, yeah, like: one kid at a time, one school at a time.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Most memorable Oasis lyrics of all time revealed – as survey finds iconic hit top of the list
Most memorable Oasis lyrics of all time revealed – as survey finds iconic hit top of the list

The Sun

time11 minutes ago

  • The Sun

Most memorable Oasis lyrics of all time revealed – as survey finds iconic hit top of the list

THE top 20 best Oasis lyrics have been revealed – with 'Don't look back in anger, I heard you say' named the most memorable in a recent survey. A poll of 2,000 adults also found 'I said maybe, you're gonna be the one that saves me', from 'Wonderwall' and "Can I ride with you in your BMW?' from 'Supersonic' were popular. 'You and I are gonna live forever' from Live Forever, and Stand By Me's 'Stand by me, nobody knows the way its gonna be" completed the top five. Other iconic lyrics to feature in the top 20 included 'All your dreams are made when you're chained to the mirror and the razor blade' from What's the Story Morning Glory, and 'We believe in one another', from Acquiesce. The study was commissioned by international mobility provider, SIXT, which, inspired by the lyric, is giving Oasis fans the chance to get behind the wheel of a premium BMW for a free rental as they travel to one of the band's upcoming London gigs from 1st to 3rd August. Andrew Smith, MD of the brand in the UK, said: 'The level of excitement around the band's reunion is rarely seen, so this is our own tribute, inspired by the lyrics we love.' It also emerged some of the most popular lyrics have proved influential for fans, with 13 per cent reconnecting with others because of one of the songs. While one in 10 (nine per cent) have booked a spontaneous trip after listening to one of the lines. A strong emotional impact (44 per cent) is the biggest characteristic of a memorable lyric – but 35 per cent said clever wordplay or rhyming is much more important. Additionally, 19 per cent look out for cultural or social relevance when thinking of lyrics that stuck with them. The studyalso found 28 per cent believe Oasis' music is perfect for a road trip – with 26 per cent saying they evoked happy memories for them. As a result, 14 per cent admitted they are riddled with jealousy watching other people get tickets that they wanted. Oasis fans swoop on pop-up barber shop the 'Gallaghairs' ahead of reunion tour gig With just 17 per cent of the fans polling managing to snag tickets for the ongoing tour according to the data. Andrew Smith from SIXT UK, which is handing out free bucket hats to anyone named Liam or Noel renting a vehicle from one of their London Wembley, Heathrow or Edinburgh locations during tour dates, added: 'We've seen a real surge in demand for premium vehicles, especially in cities along the tour route, and it's clear fans are keen to travel in true rock and roll style. 'We all know the iconic role the band has played across different generations so we're giving fans a chance to live out their own Supersonic moment.' TOP 20 MOST MEMORABLE OASIS LYRICS: 1. 'Don't look back in anger, I heard you say' – 'Don't Look back in Anger' 2. 'I said maybe, you're gonna be the one that saves me' – 'Wonderwall' 3. 'So, Sally can wait, she knows it's too late as we're walking on by' 'Don't Look back in Anger'' 4. 'You and I are gonna live forever' – 'Live Forever' 5. 'Stand by me, nobody knows the way it's gonna be' – 'Stand By Me' 6. 'Tonight, I'm a rock 'n' roll star' – 'Rock 'n' Roll Star' 7. 'All your dreams are made when you're chained to the mirror and the razor blade' – 'Morning Glory' 8. 'Tomorrow never knows what it doesn't know too soon' – 'Morning Glory' 9. 'We're all part of the masterplan' – 'The Masterplan' 10. 'In my mind, my dreams are real' – 'Rock 'n' Roll Star' 11. 'Let there be love, let there be love' – 'Let There Be love' 12. 'I'm feeling Supersonic' – 'Supersonic' 13. 'I want to talk tonight until the morning light 'bout how you saved my life' – 'Talk Tonight' 14. 'You gotta keep your dreams alive' – 'Keep the Dream Alive' 15. 'True perfection has to be imperfect' – 'Little by Little' 16. 'We see things they'll never see' – 'Live Forever' 17. 'We believe in one another and I know we're gonna uncover what's sleeping in our soul' – 'Acquiesce' 18. 'I met my maker, I made him cry' – 'D'you Know What I Mean?' 19. 'Can I ride with you in your BMW?' – 'Supersonic' 20. 'The future's mine and it's no disgrace' – 'I hope, I think, I know' 4 4 4

Christina Aguilera, 44, flashes her underwear beneath a daring black string dress as she leads stars at the Burlesque: The Musical world premiere in London
Christina Aguilera, 44, flashes her underwear beneath a daring black string dress as she leads stars at the Burlesque: The Musical world premiere in London

Daily Mail​

time11 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

Christina Aguilera, 44, flashes her underwear beneath a daring black string dress as she leads stars at the Burlesque: The Musical world premiere in London

Christina Aguilera was a vision as she attended the world premiere of Burlesque: The Musical at The Savoy Theatre in London on Tuesday. The Genie In A Bottle hitmaker, 44, left little to the imagination as she showcased her underwear beneath a daring black string mini dress. She teamed the striking look with black stockings and elevated her slimmed-down frame with a pair of sleek black heels. The pop legend completed her head-turning ensemble with silver jewellery and a bold plum lipstick. Christina posed up a storm on the red carpet before joining producer Steve Antin. The pair appeared in high spirits as they smiled for photos, with Steve planting a sweet kiss on Christina's cheek. The Genie In A Bottle hitmaker, 44, left little to the imagination as she showcased her underwear beneath a daring black rope mini dress Also at the starry event was Michael Marouli, Georgina Castle, Stewart F. Lane, Bonnie Comley, Matt Goss, Jess Folley, and Nick Collier. Following a sold-out run in Manchester, Burlesque The Musical is now playing at the Savoy Theatre for a strictly limited season until 6 September 2025. Christina swapped the spotlight for a seat in the stalls on Sunday 20 July, when she slipped into London's Savoy Theatre to watch a preview of Burlesque The Musical. The musical reimagines the 2010 screen hit that first turned her into an on-screen star. Christina previously displayed her thin appearance and sparked concern among fans who discussed rumours she might have undergone plastic surgery on her face to achieve her transformed appearance. Her frame has also sparked rumours among fans who wondered if she may have turned to Ozempic-like drugs to help her impressive weight loss. Despite the speculation among fans that she may have altered her appearance in some way, the Grammy-winning singer–songwriter has not addressed any of the rumours. She was previously rumoured to have had a breast augmentation after displaying a scar under her arm — which is a common place for the surgical incision — in 2010. Recently, Christina showed off her age-defying looks on the cover of the French magazine Carcy, which set rumours bubbling from fans who wondered if she had touched up her face. In October of last year, multiple plastic surgeons who had not treated the songstress spoke to about her seemingly transformed appearance, suggesting that she may have undergone a face lift to sculpt her cheekbones and smooth the natural lines between her nose and lips. Other cosmetic surgeons have shared similar opinions about her new appearance on social media. Although Christina has not directly responded to the claims, she recently said she no longer feels the need to 'give a f***' about the public scrutiny on her body. Following the speculation, she has since commented on the years-long 'obsession' over her weight in an interview with Glamour from August. 'When you're a teenager, you have a very different body than when you're in your 20s,' she said. 'I started to fill out, and then that was unacceptable because it was like, "Oh, she's getting thicker." Then I had industry people: "They liked your body and how you were as a skinny teenager."' However, as she has grown older, she revealed that she does not let comments about her weight affect her anymore. 'I have a maturity now where I just don't give a f*** about your opinion. I'm not going to take it on,' she stated.

Awkward moment Toni is PIED by Cach after trying to kiss him – as new Love Island triangle forms
Awkward moment Toni is PIED by Cach after trying to kiss him – as new Love Island triangle forms

The Sun

time11 minutes ago

  • The Sun

Awkward moment Toni is PIED by Cach after trying to kiss him – as new Love Island triangle forms

A VERY awkward moment occured on Love Island as Toni was pied by Cach after trying to kiss him. Toni and Cach have had a bit of a bumpy romance so far on the show, hindered by Toni and Harrison's will-they-won't-they situation. 5 5 But after Harrison decided to leave the villa, Cach and Toni have grown close once more, with Toni attempting to reignite their spark. This didn't go too well in tonight's episode, as Cach decided to reject her kiss on the terrace. Toni invites him to the Hideaway for a private evening discussion, but he's quick to suggest the less intimate setting of the terrace instead. Once up there, Toni asks Cach: ' You're confused?' to which he replies: 'Yes, I'm confused.' Toni then suggests she'll clear up some of his confusion, and leans in for a kiss. But it quickly becomes a move that creates yet more confusion, as Cach rejects her attempts. The next day, they discuss what happened at the first ever Love Island Festival. They share another private moment, during which Toni says: 'I'll be alright that you didn't kiss me but it still hurts.' He replies: 'I didn't kiss you then but that doesn't mean it's going to be a never…' Emotional moment Love Island star Cach admits he DOES still like Toni She presses on: 'Where do we go from here, now you denied me my kiss?' Of course, all the while, Cach has been getting to know Billykiss too, and the pair have shared a kiss already. Earlier in the series, Love Island fans were left outraged after a recoupling saw Toni sensationally steal back Harrison hours after he slept with Lauren. Humiliated Cach then broke down in tears following the shock betrayal. Last night, Toni and Cach spoke on the daybeds, and she teased him for giving her a score of 10 for her kiss during the challenge. She asked him: "Like, what do you think about me now?" Cach replied: "Well, obviously I still have feelings for you." Toni replied: "I was hesitant to speak to you after the Harrison thing because I didn't want you to feel like an option." Cach sighed and said: "You've made this bare complicated for no reason. I still aint got an answer for you right now. Other that I'm willing to talk to you still. The door is not completely shut." Cach told her he's still exploring with Billykiss but they haven't had the affectionate or sexual side. Love Island continues tonight at 9pm on ITV2 and ITVX 5 5

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store