Complexities cloud Delhi's plan to give carbon credits to EV buyers
'Collaboration shall be explored with development banks, carbon asset management enterprises to identify and evaluate various emission offset mechanisms and facilitate trading of carbon credits for the EV owners in Delhi," read the draft of the upcoming policy, which was shared with automakers for comment last month.
Mint
has seen a copy of the draft.
The thinking is that by avoiding the carbon emissions of traditional vehicles, EVs could accrue credits over their lifespan. These carbon credits could then be sold by EV owners in a secondary market, offering them a potential revenue source that would lower their total cost of ownership for the vehicles.
Emailed queries to Delhi's transport department, which is responsible for the EV policy, remained unanswered till press time.
Experts, however, warn of several uncertainties involved, including the methodology to be adopted, pricing of the credits, and the availability, or lack, of potential buyers. The price of these credits is also expected to be minuscule compared to the cost of running them, one expert said.
Vaibhav Chaturvedi, senior fellow at think-tank Council on Energy, Environment and Water (CEEW), said the move was a smart one by the Delhi government, but questioned how lucrative the incentive would really be. 'Unless there is some certainty or minimum price assurance in this regard, a prospective EV buyer might be left wondering about the cost saving due to carbon credits," he said.
Also read |
Foreign car firms eye trade deals for EV tariff reduction
Estimates from Nikhil Dhaka, policy lead at consultancy
Primus Partners, point to as little as
₹
200-1,600 annual revenue from carbon credits for an electric car. Credit prices in the Indian market currently range from
₹
100 to
₹
800 per ton of CO₂, he said, adding that a typical EV offsets about 0.5–2 tons of CO₂ a year.
Accurately estimating CO₂ savings per vehicle would also be a challenge, Dhaka said, as it would involve tracking usage patterns, grid emission factors, and vehicle specifications. Implementing such a system would require robust tracking of vehicle usage, clear carbon attribution, and a user-friendly mechanism for consumers to claim, trade, or utilize their credits, he said.
'Without a well-established mechanism, carbon credits alone are unlikely to be a strong buyer incentive yet, but could gain value as India's carbon market matures," Dhaka said.
Connecting EV owners to carbon markets is another challenge. According to Deepto Roy, partner at law firm Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas & Co., if credits are given directly to EV owners, it will be difficult for them to access the carbon credit markets, where trading usually happens at a larger scale. 'It would be easier to give the credits to manufacturers or if the government steps in and buys the credits at a floor price, aggregates them and then sells them in secondary markets," Roy said.
Read this |
Tata Motors
considers new ICE models as EV adoption slows, competition intensifies
There is no precedent globally for carbon credits being awarded to EV buyers, Primus Partners' Dhaka said. However, similar concepts do exist for other stakeholders in the EV value chain. For example, China's credit system gives automakers carbon credits for selling EVs. Companies must meet credit quotas or buy credits from others, pushing manufacturers to produce more EVs.
Then, in California, electricity used for EV charging generates credits for charging companies. More than $2.8 billion flowed to EV charging suppliers in 2023, Dhaka said. 'This is analogous to paying EV drivers (or their utilities) for the carbon reduction from switching fuels. The lesson: well-designed credit programs can channel large funds to accelerate EV adoption, but they require tight regulation to prevent oversupply," he said.
I.V. Rao, distinguished fellow of transport and urban governance at research institute Teri, said that the proposed carbon credits policy for EV buyers could act as a boost if seen together with other incentives in the scheme. 'However, for effective policy implementation, you would need guidelines on how the carbon credits trade will work," he said. 'Based on usage of a vehicle and its age, some carbon credit incentives can be thought of."
And read |
India's clean mobility drive hit as electric two-wheeler subsidies miss target in FY25
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scroll.in
10 minutes ago
- Scroll.in
India asks citizens to avoid travelling to border areas of Cambodia, Thailand amid clashes
India's embassies in Thailand and Cambodia have asked Indian citizens not to travel to the border areas of the two countries amid clashes between Bangkok and Phnom Penh. The diplomatic mission in Cambodia on Saturday issued an advisory urging Indians to avoid going to the border areas. The embassy also shared emergency contact details for Indian citizens requiring assistance. 'In case of any emergency, Indian nationals may approach the Embassy of India, Phnom Penh at +855 92881676 or email it added. This came a day after the Indian embassy in Thailand advised Indian travellers to check updates issued by Thai authorities. A link to an update shared by the Tourism Authority of Thailand said that 'border zones' had been affected in seven provinces because of restrictions and that martial law had been imposed in select districts. These places are not recommended for travelling, the Indian embassy quoted the Thai tourism authority as saying. The advisories came amid the worst border conflict between Thailand and Cambodia in 13 years. Fighting, which began on Wednesday, has involved heavy artillery, air strikes and rocket fire across several disputed border areas. At least 33 persons have been killed in the conflict. Of the 13 deaths in Cambodia, eight were civilians and five soldiers. In Thailand, six military personnel and 14 civilians were killed, AFP reported. While Bangkok has accused Phnom Penh of targeting civilians and using rockets, Cambodia has condemned Thailand's alleged use of cluster munitions, Reuters reported. The fighting marks a sharp escalation in a long-running dispute between the countries that contest several stretches of land along their border. At least 28 persons had dead in previous clashes between 2008 and 2011. A 2013 United Nations court ruling had largely eased tensions. But the current crisis was triggered in May after a Cambodian soldier was killed in a fresh clash, AFP reported.
Fashion Value Chain
10 minutes ago
- Fashion Value Chain
Innovation, R&D Focus, and Policy Reforms could Steer India to a $970 Million Vegetable Seed Hub by 2030
Valued at $8.45 billion in 2024, the global vegetable seed market is expanding rapidly and experts believe India is well-positioned to become its next major hub, provided the right policies are introduced and effectively implemented. With the government placing renewed focus on the horticulture sector through its comprehensive programme for vegetables and fruits, experts in a national conference asserted that strengthening IPR and introduction of biotech along with enabling policy support could drive the Indian vegetable seed market from $740 million in 2023-24 to $970 million by 2030, growing at a CAGR of 4.6%. Experts shared insights and perspectives at the National Workshop on 'Role of Vegetable Seed Sector in Making India a 'Global Seed Hub' 'India's rise in horticulture specially vegetable production is linked to the rich germplasm, diverse growing conditions, R&D innovations and strategic investments by the private and public institutions,' said Dr P K Singh, Agriculture Commissioner, Ministry of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare, Government of India. 'Horticulture has moved from the margins to the mainstream, driven by Seed sector R&D, hybrid seed adoption, and a shift towards a science-led seed industry. Yet, our global potential remains largely untapped.' At a national conference titled 'Role of Vegetable Seed Sector in Making India a Global Seed Hub' organised by Federation of Seed Industry of India (FSII) in Capital on Friday senior government officials, agricultural scientists, seed industry leaders, and policymakers deliberated on regulatory hurdles and ways of unlocking the country's export potential. 'India's seed sector is at a defining moment. With rich agro-climatic diversity, competitive production systems, a dynamic private sector, and strong public research institutions, we have all the building blocks to become a global seed production hub,' said Mr. Ajeet Kumar Sahu, IAS, Joint Secretary (Seeds), Ministry of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare. 'The Ministry is streamlining licensing, introducing science-based regulatory reforms, enabling digital traceability through the SATHI platform, and investing in modern seed infrastructure including processing plants, storage, and testing labs. These steps will ensure farmers get timely access to certified, high-quality seeds with full QR-code-based traceability, helping reduce crop losses, improve productivity, and protect them from spurious inputs,' he added. While government officials highlighted the enabling policy ecosystem being built to catalyze India's global competitiveness, agricultural scientists emphasized the transformative role of hybridization, biotechnology, and public-private collaboration in enhancing productivity. India currently exports about $120 million worth of vegetable seeds annually, mainly to Southeast Asia and the Middle East. Experts believe this could easily double or triple if long-standing policy hurdles are addressed, chief among them a backlog of over 100 Pest Risk Analyses (PRAs) pending since 2016, stalling trade worth an estimated $55 million. 'We call for a unified regulatory approach and the introduction of 'One Nation, One Licence' model for domestic seed registration and a single-window export clearance system. These, along with digitized approvals and longer duration license validity, are critical to improving India's ease of doing business in seeds,' said Mr Rajvir Rathi, Vice Chairman, FSII, Director, Agricultural Affairs & Policy – IBSL & Lead, Traits Licensing, Bayer CropScience Ltd. India's comparative advantages, diverse agro-climatic zones, low production costs, a vibrant R&D ecosystem, and skilled workforce, position it uniquely to lead the global seed trade. Already, over 300 companies operate in the country's formal seed market, contributing 80-85% of the value and investing more than $200 million annually in research. Beyond productivity, the vegetable seed sector has profound socio-economic ripple effects. It supports over 100,000 direct jobs, empowers women smallholders, and offers year-round income stability in rural areas. Nutritionally enhanced vegetables are also addressing hidden hunger by providing essential micronutrients at scale. As global food systems brace for climate and population shocks, the conference concluded with a strong consensus; India must reform fast, innovate continuously, and position itself as the world's most reliable and responsible supplier of high-quality vegetable seeds. The seeds of global leadership, it appears, have already been sown.
Indian Express
10 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Frequent disruptions in Parliament harm Opposition more than government: Kiren Rijiju
Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju on Saturday said that frequent disruptions in the House hurt the Opposition more, as they lose the crucial opportunity to hold the government accountable. The remarks came after the first week of the ongoing monsoon session was largely washed out due to repeated protests by Opposition MPs. Speaking at the Sansad Ratna Awards event organised by Prime Point Foundation, Rijiju recalled how bureaucrats sometimes express relief when Parliament is adjourned. 'Let me tell you, officers are relieved when Parliament doesn't function because they escape the grilling. The government can be held accountable in Parliament. When the House runs, ministers face tough questions. When it adjourns within minutes, those questions don't even get raised. Opposition loses more than the government when Parliament is disrupted,' he said. 'Those who stall the House think they are damaging the government, but in truth, they are weakening their own role in a democracy,' Rijiju added. Reinforcing the importance of parliamentary accountability, the minister said, 'In any democracy, the government must answer to the people through Parliament. That is why allowing the House to run is essential for a functioning democracy.' Reflecting on his journey in Parliament, Rijiju said he never considered Opposition MPs as adversaries. 'We are all colleagues. Before 2014, most of my parliamentary career has been on the Opposition benches. Political rivalries may exist, but there is no enmity,' he said. Drawing from a quote by Winston Churchill, Rijiju said, 'A new MP once asked Churchill about the people sitting across the aisle, and he said they were political opponents. But when asked about those sitting on his side, he said they were our political enemies. That is politics, but we are not enemies.' Rijiju also said there is undue burden on Indian legislators compared to their counterparts in developed countries. 'There, one MP represents approximately 66,000 people. Here, it is over 20 lakh. They are not asked to fix drains or get someone out of jail. But our MPs deal with personal grievances, infrastructure and law enforcement issues and are still expected to perform in the House,' he said. 'Despite all this, they are often criticised. Every elected MP deserves respect, it is not an easy job.' Recalling his own early experiences, Rijiju shared a humorous but telling anecdote. 'The first time I met Speaker Somnath Chatterjee, I had gone to request a room for MPs who smoke. He scolded me, saying, 'This is your first meeting with the Speaker and this is what you've come for?' I got a good scolding that day and learned I should approach such offices with more purpose.' He also reflected on how senior leaders like Atal Bihari Vajpayee and L K Advani set examples of decorum. 'Back then, we would think twice before speaking because stalwarts were listening. Now disruptions begin on day one. Maybe social media has changed the game.' Calling for more constructive media reporting, Rijiju said, 'Earlier, journalists would arrive at 9 am and cover parliamentary debates till night. Good speeches got coverage. Today, headlines go to who created the most ruckus. I remember Sharad Pawar once presented an excellent agriculture policy, but the next day not a single paper mentioned it. So now, MPs chase headlines because good work is neither reported nor recognised.' 'Negative news drives TRPs, not constructive action. It is a vicious cycle — both the MPs and the media are trapped in it,' he said. Rijiju congratulated all the recipients of this year's Sansad Ratna Awards, including Supriya Sule, Bhartruhari Mahtab, N K Premachandran, and Shrirang Appa Barne, who received special jury awards for consistent performance in the 16th, 17th, and the current Lok Sabha. 'Whenever any parliamentarian is recognised for good work, we should all celebrate together, cutting across party lines,' Rijiju said. National Commission for Backward Classes Chairperson Hansraj Gangaram Ahir took a swipe at the Opposition, saying, 'Those who claim to be followers of Babasaheb Ambedkar bring disrepute to the country by speaking against it abroad'.
