logo
Complexities cloud Delhi's plan to give carbon credits to EV buyers

Complexities cloud Delhi's plan to give carbon credits to EV buyers

Mint08-05-2025
New Delhi/Mumbai: In a move that has sparked scepticism from industry experts because of complexities involved, the Delhi government is considering awarding carbon credits to buyers of electric vehicles (EV) in the national capital. The proposal, designed to promote the adoption of tail-pipe emission free vehicles, is part of the upcoming Delhi Electric Vehicles Policy 2.0.
'Collaboration shall be explored with development banks, carbon asset management enterprises to identify and evaluate various emission offset mechanisms and facilitate trading of carbon credits for the EV owners in Delhi," read the draft of the upcoming policy, which was shared with automakers for comment last month.
Mint
has seen a copy of the draft.
The thinking is that by avoiding the carbon emissions of traditional vehicles, EVs could accrue credits over their lifespan. These carbon credits could then be sold by EV owners in a secondary market, offering them a potential revenue source that would lower their total cost of ownership for the vehicles.
Emailed queries to Delhi's transport department, which is responsible for the EV policy, remained unanswered till press time.
Experts, however, warn of several uncertainties involved, including the methodology to be adopted, pricing of the credits, and the availability, or lack, of potential buyers. The price of these credits is also expected to be minuscule compared to the cost of running them, one expert said.
Vaibhav Chaturvedi, senior fellow at think-tank Council on Energy, Environment and Water (CEEW), said the move was a smart one by the Delhi government, but questioned how lucrative the incentive would really be. 'Unless there is some certainty or minimum price assurance in this regard, a prospective EV buyer might be left wondering about the cost saving due to carbon credits," he said.
Also read |
Foreign car firms eye trade deals for EV tariff reduction
Estimates from Nikhil Dhaka, policy lead at consultancy
Primus Partners, point to as little as

200-1,600 annual revenue from carbon credits for an electric car. Credit prices in the Indian market currently range from

100 to

800 per ton of CO₂, he said, adding that a typical EV offsets about 0.5–2 tons of CO₂ a year.
Accurately estimating CO₂ savings per vehicle would also be a challenge, Dhaka said, as it would involve tracking usage patterns, grid emission factors, and vehicle specifications. Implementing such a system would require robust tracking of vehicle usage, clear carbon attribution, and a user-friendly mechanism for consumers to claim, trade, or utilize their credits, he said.
'Without a well-established mechanism, carbon credits alone are unlikely to be a strong buyer incentive yet, but could gain value as India's carbon market matures," Dhaka said.
Connecting EV owners to carbon markets is another challenge. According to Deepto Roy, partner at law firm Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas & Co., if credits are given directly to EV owners, it will be difficult for them to access the carbon credit markets, where trading usually happens at a larger scale. 'It would be easier to give the credits to manufacturers or if the government steps in and buys the credits at a floor price, aggregates them and then sells them in secondary markets," Roy said.
Read this |
Tata Motors
considers new ICE models as EV adoption slows, competition intensifies
There is no precedent globally for carbon credits being awarded to EV buyers, Primus Partners' Dhaka said. However, similar concepts do exist for other stakeholders in the EV value chain. For example, China's credit system gives automakers carbon credits for selling EVs. Companies must meet credit quotas or buy credits from others, pushing manufacturers to produce more EVs.
Then, in California, electricity used for EV charging generates credits for charging companies. More than $2.8 billion flowed to EV charging suppliers in 2023, Dhaka said. 'This is analogous to paying EV drivers (or their utilities) for the carbon reduction from switching fuels. The lesson: well-designed credit programs can channel large funds to accelerate EV adoption, but they require tight regulation to prevent oversupply," he said.
I.V. Rao, distinguished fellow of transport and urban governance at research institute Teri, said that the proposed carbon credits policy for EV buyers could act as a boost if seen together with other incentives in the scheme. 'However, for effective policy implementation, you would need guidelines on how the carbon credits trade will work," he said. 'Based on usage of a vehicle and its age, some carbon credit incentives can be thought of."
And read |
India's clean mobility drive hit as electric two-wheeler subsidies miss target in FY25
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

PhonePe rolls out two co-branded credit cards with SBI
PhonePe rolls out two co-branded credit cards with SBI

Mint

time2 minutes ago

  • Mint

PhonePe rolls out two co-branded credit cards with SBI

Fintech firm PhonePe has rolled out two cobranded credit cards in partnership with SBI Card, largest pure-play credit card issuer. The two new products are PhonePe SBI Card Purple and PhonePe SBI Card Select Black. This marks the second such partnership by PhonePe after its earlier tie-up with HDFC Bank. These credit cards are issued on the RuPay and Visa networks, and are looking to broaden formal credit access while offering rewards on everyday spends. RuPay variants are UPI linkable, enabling seamless use across millions of merchants nationwide, while the Visa cards can be tokenised on the PhonePe app for secure digital use. Targeting the rising demand for integrated credit and payments, the PhonePe SBI Cards offer accelerated reward points on groceries, travel, utility payments, insurance premiums and in-app PhonePe transactions. The Select Black card, positioned as a premium variant, offers up to 10 per cent value back on PhonePe and Pincode app spends and 5 per cent on other online transactions. Purple cardholders can earn up to 3 per cent and 2 per cent respectively on the same categories. Additional benefits include welcome e-gift vouchers — ₹ 1,500 for Select Black and ₹ 500 for Purple — alongside annual travel vouchers, fuel surcharge waivers and complimentary domestic lounge access. In another news, PhonePe named former Meta India public policy head Shivnath Thukral as its vice president for public policy and government affairs. "Shivnath will be responsible for leading PhonePe's external engagement and discussions with policy makers and regulators," the company said in a statement, adding that he would work closely with founders Sameer Nigam and Rahul Chari. Disclaimer: Mint has a tie-up with fintechs for providing credit, you will need to share your information if you apply. These tie-ups do not influence our editorial content. This article only intends to educate and spread awareness about credit needs like loans, credit cards and credit score. Mint does not promote or encourage taking credit as it comes with a set of risks such as high interest rates, hidden charges, etc. We advise investors to discuss with certified experts before taking any credit.

NRI shocked by 3x price hike in small-town India, blames 'neglect' in viral post. But internet responds with hard truths
NRI shocked by 3x price hike in small-town India, blames 'neglect' in viral post. But internet responds with hard truths

Economic Times

time2 minutes ago

  • Economic Times

NRI shocked by 3x price hike in small-town India, blames 'neglect' in viral post. But internet responds with hard truths

A non-resident Indian shared his experience on Reddit. He was surprised by the increased cost of living in India. He noticed negligence in a small town. The town was more expensive than his last visit. Other users responded with their explanations. They mentioned India's rapid growth and changing culture. The post sparked discussions about cost of living and civic awareness. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads The Internet Reacts Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads A Reddit post by a non-resident Indian (NRI) has sparked a lively discussion online after the user expressed shock over the rising cost of living and growing public negligence in India. Titled 'Never expected India to become this expensive and negligent,' the post quickly gained traction, with many users, both in India and abroad, jumping in to share their NRI, who had returned to India for a vacation, said he was excited to spend time with his parents in a small town. But the reality, he said, was far from what he had hoped.'I came to India for vacation. I was excited about my visit. However, the reality is hitting hard,' he wrote. 'My parents are living in a small municipality town… Even my small town became 3x expensive compared to my last year visit.'He also shared frustration about what he called the country's increasing negligence. 'Too much negligence. No common sense,' he wrote, wondering how India had become so expensive in such a short post quickly attracted comments from fellow Reddit users, with many offering their own user explained, 'The reality of being an NRI is that time freezes in your memory. You expect the place you left to stay the same. But India is changing fast. It's in its peak growth phase.'Another added, 'There's a 'wanna-be' culture in India right now. Everyone's trying to imitate the West, and that's pushing prices up in some sectors, often without reason.'Many users pointed out that India's rapid urban development, inflation, and rising global influence have led to a sharp increase in prices, not just in cities, but in smaller towns as even said that while things may appear more modern on the surface, issues like poor civic sense and weak public infrastructure remain major This article is based on a user-generated post on Reddit. has not independently verified the claims made in the post and does not vouch for their accuracy. The views expressed are those of the individual and do not necessarily reflect the views of Reader discretion is advised.

MRPL shares rally over 6%; YES Securities sees better Q2 on improving refining margins
MRPL shares rally over 6%; YES Securities sees better Q2 on improving refining margins

Economic Times

time2 minutes ago

  • Economic Times

MRPL shares rally over 6%; YES Securities sees better Q2 on improving refining margins

Shares of Mangalore Refinery and Petrochemicals Ltd (MRPL) climbed as much as 6.4% on Wednesday to Rs 154 on the BSE, lifting their two-day rally to 10.6%, as investor sentiment improved on expectations of a recovery in earnings and a more supportive margin environment. ADVERTISEMENT MRPL's gains pushed its market capitalisation to Rs 26,709.61 crore. Despite the recent uptrend, the stock remains 31.5% below its 52-week high of Rs 224.80, touched in July 2024, though it has rebounded 55.6% from the 52-week low of Rs 98.95 recorded in March 2025. Brokerage Yes Securities retained its 'buy' rating on the stock following the company's first-quarter results last week, raising its price target to Rs 180 from Rs 160. The new target implies a valuation of 1.9 times FY27 estimated price-to-book value. MRPL had reported a consolidated net loss of Rs 271.97 crore for the quarter ended June 2025 (Q1FY26), reversing from a net profit of Rs 73.22 crore in the same period last year. Revenue from operations fell to Rs 20,988.03 crore from Rs 27,289.40 crore Securities attributed the earnings weakness to extended shutdowns and inventory losses. The company's gross refining margin (GRM) came in at $3.88 per barrel for the quarter, significantly below the brokerage's forecast of $7.3 per barrel. In comparison, MRPL had reported GRMs of $6.23 per barrel in the previous quarter and $4.70 per barrel a year underperformance was linked to a 45-day Phase-II shutdown—longer than anticipated—driven by severe rainfall, as well as lower plant utilisation and limited feedstock availability that hit product exports. ADVERTISEMENT Looking ahead, Yes Securities said the company is positioned to benefit from an uptick in refining spreads in the second quarter, supported by elevated diesel cracks and geopolitical risk premiums on crude following the Israel–Iran conflict. With Brent crude averaging around $70 per barrel, the brokerage expects near-term GRMs to remain firm in the first half of FY26. The brokerage also highlighted MRPL's advantageous crude sourcing mix, with over a third of its supply sourced from Russia at discounted rates, helping it maintain some of the highest GRMs among single-location Indian refiners. ADVERTISEMENT Over a three-year horizon, Yes Securities sees earnings quality improving as MRPL moves further into petrochemicals and retailing, while capitalising on integrated operations and upcoming pipeline infrastructure. Demand for value-added products is projected to outpace fuel demand, with the company targeting stable leverage despite elevated capex levels. MRPL's net debt-to-equity currently stands at 0.99x, with debt at Rs 13,230 crore. A potential merger with Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd (HPCL), while speculated in the past, remains unlikely in the near term, the brokerage said. Any such move would depend on the promoters, ONGC and HPCL, and may be deferred beyond FY27 due to tax-loss carryforwards from the OMPL merger. ADVERTISEMENT Also read | Aditya Birla Real Estate shares down 32% from peak. Can the stock reclaim Rs 2,400 post Q1 results? (Disclaimer: Recommendations, suggestions, views and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of the Economic Times) (You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel)

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store