'Don't sweep us under rug': Black man challenges Vivek Ramaswamy on violence, race
Vivek Ramaswamy
faced questioning from an audience member who argued that Black history has been disregarded in American discourse.
The Ohio Republican candidate responded by acknowledging the need to face uncomfortable truths while highlighting America's foundation on ideals that it continuously strives to achieve, despite imperfections.
The questioner, identified as Robert, expressed his non-partisan stance on US public safety debates but raised concerns about the inadequate inclusion of Black American history in contemporary safety discussions.
"You have to understand how our people feel, because we were brought here in slave ships over 400 years ago, and we were treated like animals, like cattle hung on trees, families separated, our heritage taken from us so that we didn't know who we were as a people. Now, I say, you act like this is a new thing. This balance that you see out here," Robert challenged Ramaswamy.
"Well, look over the 400 years of all the violence that was perpetrated on our people… You want to sweep our history under the table, but you don't sweep the Ashkenazi Jews with the Hitler thing under the table.
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
People Born 1940-1975 With No Life Insurance Could Be Eligible For This
Reassured
Undo
by Taboola
by Taboola
All the things that you did to the other races of people, you don't sweep that under the table. But when it comes down to the black Negro, we can always sweep what happened to us under the table."
Ramswamy candidly added that the question made him a bit "uncomfortable" but said leaders should be expected to answer such difficult questions.
"Of course, we're not perfect. In fact, we're destined to never be perfect because we're not a nation comprised of gods, we're a nation comprised of human beings, and we're a nation founded on a set of ideals.
So, that means you will always be imperfect," Ramaswamy said in response to the race-conscious question.
Using China and Iran as examples, Ramaswamy noted that these nations avoid criticism for hypocrisy because they lack foundational ideals.
"Nobody ever criticizes China, or Iran, or whatever for hypocrisy, because to be a hypocritical nation, you have to have ideals in the first place," Ramaswamy said.
"I'm not going to say America was perfect for every chapter of our national history.
Of course not. We're a nation founded on ideals. We're nation founded on human beings, so we'll always fall short of those ideals," Ramaswamy continued. "But I would rather live in a country that has ideals and falls short of them. Than to live in a country with no ideals at all."
While Ramaswamy went on to say that no one's ethnic history should be swept under the rug, he also emphasized that recent events — including last week's viral video showing a brutal public beating in Cincinnati — must not be overlooked.
He urged Americans to face uncomfortable truths rather than avoid them.
"We have to confront what is true. Not just what makes us comfortable, but precisely when it does not," Ramaswamy said.
He expressed preference for a nation with aspirational standards, even if imperfectly achieved.
While acknowledging the importance of historical recognition, Ramaswamy emphasised that recent events, including the Cincinnati incident, warrant attention.
He concluded by redefining 'our people' as inclusive of all Americans, asserting everyone's right to live without fear of violence.
"And may I even say, if you're a hard-working American, to go into your city whether you're black or white without fear of actually being assaulted or battered, that ought to be the birthright of every American. That's what I want for 'our people'," he said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
29 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
India's economic resilience guards against tariff threats
The impact of the US's 25% tariff on imports from India appears to be far less catastrophic than what some had predicted. Meanwhile, the trade deal with the US remains in negotiation, and there is every reason to expect that once talks advance, the tariff rate could be scaled down. Estimates suggest that the 25% tariff might translate into an annual impact of just $10-11 billion — a relatively modest impact. While the India-UK FTA negotiations were multifaceted, the agreement was not solely about lowering tariffs or increasing trade volumes; it was also about redefining economic diplomacy in a multipolar world. (Bloomberg) With the American delegation scheduled to visit New Delhi later in August, both sides have ample opportunity to recalibrate their positions. Trade deals are shaped not by threats but by diligent negotiations between officials representing institutional interests of their respective countries. In that light, US President Donald Trump's statements seem part of a broader tactic aimed at bolstering America's bargaining position rather than signalling an irreversible shift in economic policy. Therefore, there is no need to panic. India's growth story is one of rising momentum, driven by deep structural shifts and smart strategic positioning. Over the past year, India has defied global headwinds that have hindered many advanced economies. While high inflation, tightening monetary policies and geopolitical uncertainty have strained markets elsewhere, India has maintained an impressive growth trajectory. India's ability to sustain high growth is anchored in robust domestic demand, strong public capital expenditure, and the sustained expansion of its booming services sector. At the same time, there has been a deliberate policy recalibration toward achieving self-reliance, integrating global supply chains and boosting manufacturing competitiveness. Initiatives like the Production Linked Incentive (PLI) schemes across sectors such as electronics, semiconductors and renewable energy have attracted substantial foreign direct investment. Moreover, the nation's digital revolution has firmly established India as a leader in the digital economy across the Global South. In this context, the recently-signed India-UK free trade agreement (FTA) takes on added significance. While the FTA negotiations were multifaceted, the agreement was not solely about lowering tariffs or increasing trade volumes; it was also about redefining economic diplomacy in a multipolar world. For India, an ambitious FTA with the UK offers several strategic advantages. One, it sends a positive signal to global investors, affirming that India remains open for business — both strategic and reform-minded. Two, the deal provides a pathway for India to build deeper trade links with advanced economies at a time when globalisation is evolving towards regionalisation. And three, the agreement reinforces India's effort to diversify its export markets — a crucial counterbalance to the uncertainties of US trade policy and the slowing pace of growth in some of its traditional markets. The UK is currently India's 18th largest trading partner, with bilateral trade exceeding $50 billion. The FTA will serve to lower existing tariffs, ease regulatory hurdles and promote greater mobility for Indian professionals. Even contentious issues, such as agricultural trade, though politically sensitive, appear manageable. The relatively modest scale of UK agricultural exports could provide the room needed to sidestep potential disputes, easing negotiation complexities on that front. At the same time, India's impressive economic performance is underscored by several headline-grabbing trends across its major sectors. For instance, in the realm of global supply chains, India has emerged as a formidable competitor in the smartphone market. This transformation illustrates how India is successfully capitalising on new geopolitical realities and diversifying manufacturing hubs. Additionally, macroeconomic indicators have painted an encouraging picture. With retail inflation falling to a six-year low of 2.1% in June 2025, the consumer sector has found its footing amid otherwise volatile global conditions. Employment metrics reveal a healthy labour market. Exports have seen a year-on-year boost of approximately 5.9%, while remittances have reached a record $135.5 billion. The Manufacturing Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI) in July 2025 hit a 17-year high of 59.2, reflecting robust industrial activity and strong global demand. Public health initiatives, too, have contributed significantly to the overall picture. The Jan Aushadhi Kendras, which offer affordable medicine and have saved citizens ₹38,000 crore in health care costs over the last 11 years, exemplify how policy initiatives are directly alleviating household expenses and improving standards of living. Energy and infrastructure sectors are part of this rosy picture as well. India has crossed the 1-billion-tonne mark for coal production — a symbol of its energy self-reliance — while simultaneously ramping up renewable energy capacity. With 22 gigawatts of solar and wind capacity added in the first half of 2025, India is on track to overtake the US in clean energy installations. In the digital domain, India's transformation is truly remarkable, which reinforces India's position as a hub of technological innovation. Furthermore, the growth of Global Capability Centres (GCCs) in Tier-II and Tier-III cities — now numbering over 1,700 and generating $64.6 billion in revenue — demonstrates a broader socio-economic transformation. With these centres creating tens of thousands of jobs outside the traditional Tier-I urban hubs, India is leveraging lower costs, burgeoning talent pools, and improved infrastructure to reshape its economic geography. In essence, while President Trump's statements may have generated headlines, the underlying data tells a more encouraging story. India's broad-based growth, strong macroeconomic fundamentals, and strategic policy shifts point to an economy that is far more robust and resilient than any single trade dispute could jeopardise. Rather than succumbing to external pressure, India is actively repositioning itself as a major player on the global stage, capable of turning challenges into opportunities. Ultimately, the narrative is one of confidence, adaptability and strategic foresight. India's economic resilience serves as a compelling counterpoint to any external rhetoric. The picture, then, is not one of crisis but of calculated evolution — a testament to India's ongoing journey towards becoming a robust and dynamic engine of global growth. Syed Zafar Islam is a national spokesperson of the BJP, former Member of Parliament, and former managing director, Deutsche Bank, India. The views expressed are personal.
News18
38 minutes ago
- News18
Don't give China pass, burn relationship with strong ally India: Nikki Haley
Agency: PTI Last Updated: New York, Aug 5 (PTI) The US should not burn its relationship with a 'strong ally like India" and give a pass to China, Indian-American Republican leader Nikki Haley said on Tuesday, amid President Donald Trump's attacks against New Delhi over tariffs and purchases of Russian oil. 'India should not be buying oil from Russia. But China, an adversary and the number one buyer of Russian and Iranian oil, got a 90-day tariff pause," Haley said in a post on X. 'Don't give China a pass and burn a relationship with a strong ally like India," she said. Haley, the former Governor of South Carolina, was the US Ambassador to the United Nations under Trump's first presidential term, becoming the first Indian-American to be appointed to a cabinet-level post in the US administration. In 2013, she officially announced her candidacy for the 2024 presidential election and withdrew from the race in March last year. Her comments came hours after Trump said India has not been a 'good trading partner" and announced he will raise tariffs on India 'very substantially over the next 24 hours" because New Delhi is buying Russian oil and 'fueling" the 'war machine". India on Monday mounted an unusually sharp counterattack on the US and the European Union for their 'unjustified and unreasonable" targeting of New Delhi for its procurement of Russian crude oil. Meanwhile, Trump, in an interview with CNBC responded to a question on China and its leader, Xi Jinping, and said, 'We have a very good relationship". Trump added that he might have a meeting with the Chinese President 'before the end of the year, most likely, if we make a deal." He said he won't have a meeting if a deal doesn't materialise. 'But we're getting very close to a deal. We're getting along with China very well." Trump added that China is 'very reliant" on the US. 'My relationship with them is very good. I think we'll make a good deal. It's not imperative, but I think we're going to make a good deal." He added that he has had a 'great relationship" with President Xi. 'We respect him a lot. They respect us a lot." PTI YAS GRS GRS GRS GRS view comments First Published: August 05, 2025, 21:15 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
News18
38 minutes ago
- News18
SAfrica poses no threat to US economy or its national security: Govt
Last Updated: Johannesburg, Aug 5 (PTI) South Africa poses no threat to the US economy or its security, the government said here, adding that the 30 per cent tariff on the country is 'inscrutable." 'South Africa's minimal 0.25 per cent share of total US imports makes the 30 per cent tariff on our country are inscrutable, especially when these same tariffs have been applied indiscriminately to all US trading partners globally. Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition Parks Tau and Minister of International Relations and Cooperation Ronald Lamola said in a joint statement on Monday. 'South Africa poses no trade threat to the US economy nor its national security," the statement added. 'South Africa isn't just a trading partner—we're a major investor in the US, with our companies sustaining American jobs. Similarly, over 600 US companies in South Africa contribute to our industrial growth and create employment," they said, adding that South Africa's goal is to preserve and grow the mutually beneficial relationships with the US. The ministers said that South Africa's agriculture exports are even counter-seasonal, filling the gaps in the US market rather than replacing domestic products, such as in the case of citrus exports. The ministers also challenged the calculation of the US-SA 'trade deficit" as announced by Trump, claiming that it ignores the substantial US trade surplus in services, as well as the complementary nature of the bilateral trade and investment relations between the two countries. But against the reality of the impact on local trade and industry, the ministers announced some mitigation plans. These include the establishment of an Export Support Desk, which will serve as a direct point of contact for companies affected by the US tariff hike, as well as support with diversification of markets. The desk will provide support measures for the diversification of export markets for increased resilience and facilitate the entry into alternative markets for affected exporters. Measures to assist companies to absorb the tariff and facilitate long-term resilience and growth strategies to protect jobs and productive capacity in South Africa are also being finalised. The ministers said that South Africa has been strengthening trade and investment partnerships with various trade partners. 'These efforts are bearing fruit, targeting markets across Africa, as well as in Asia, Europe, Middle East, and Americas," they said. 'We are also working with the Department of Labour on measures to mitigate potential job losses, using existing instruments within its entities that can be adjusted to respond to the current challenges," the statement said. 'While facing global trade challenges, South Africa is proactively building a more resilient agricultural sector. We've made significant progress in opening up vast new markets like China and Thailand, securing vital protocols for products like citrus and others," they added. Singling out China alone as a USD 200 billion market, the ministers expressed confidence in expanding South Africa's reach and creating new opportunities for its agricultural producers. The US is currently South Africa's third biggest trading partner, behind the European Union and China. ('Because) The US accounts for 7.5 per cent of our global exports, we will continue to engage the US with a view to conclude a deal that advances the interests of both countries. 'South Africa seeks to conclude deals that promote value addition and industrialisation, rather than extractive relations that deprive the country of the ability to beneficiate our mineral wealth by mimicking extractive colonial era trade relations," the statement firmly asserted. 'While the current measures present challenges, it also presents opportunities to build and accelerate the implementation of the African Continental Free Trade Agreement and to develop new partnerships in markets that have remained untapped, including ASEAN and Türkiye," the ministers shared. PTI FH RD RD RD (This story has not been edited by News18 staff and is published from a syndicated news agency feed - PTI) view comments First Published: August 05, 2025, 21:15 IST News agency-feeds SAfrica poses no threat to US economy or its national security: Govt Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
