‘Heavy-handed': Former minister breaks ranks on antisemitism report
Former industry and science minister Ed Husic, who was moved to the backbench following a post-election cabinet reshuffle, said the report made 'some really important' points, but was concerned with certain sections and some of Segal's commentary.
'With the greatest respect to the special envoy, I wasn't entirely comfortable that she just singles out public broadcasting for attention,' Husic told ABC's RN Breakfast on Wednesday. 'There's a role to play across media on these issues, and I didn't necessarily think it was justified to point out the public broadcaster.'
Last week, Segal said reporting by the ABC on the war in Gaza was an example of 'manipulated narratives' that could lead to antisemitism.
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke both endorsed Segal's report when she launched it last week, though neither committed to implementing specific recommendations, and mainstream Jewish groups backed it as a vital blueprint to tackle antisemitism.
Loading
Husic, a Muslim, has previously broken ranks with the government over Israel and is the first Labor MP to criticise Segal's report. He said the government should be careful about rushing to adopt her recommendations. 'Let's take the time to think it through,' he said. 'A lot of thought's been put into it.'
There has been rising antisemitism in Australia, including arson attacks and racist graffiti on Jewish buildings, since Hamas' massacres in Israel on October 7, 2023 and Israel's subsequent war in Gaza. The government appointed Segal as the antisemitism envoy a year ago to find the causes of the issue and suggest solutions.
In a wide-ranging report delivered last week, Segal concluded that antisemitism was spreading in Australia and took particular aim at the cultural and educational sectors.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
10 minutes ago
- Perth Now
Albo fires back on China trip claim
Anthony Albanese has hit back against the Coalition's criticism of his 'indulgent' trip to China, accusing them of 'constant negativity' and a failure to acknowledge the importance of Australia's 'most important trading partner'. Liberal frontbencher James Paterson earlier said the Prime Minister's six-day trip was 'starting to look a little bit indulgent,' which he described as 'a Gough Whitlam history tour on the Great Wall of China' and questioned whether 'a visit to Chengdu to pose with some pandas, and whether a hit of tennis is strictly necessary'. 'I hope it's not for the Prime Minister's personal enjoyment,' Senator Paterson told Sky News on Thursday. 'I mean, the appropriate time to do a nostalgic history tour of Labor Party mythology is after you retire, in your own time, at your own expense, not on the taxpayer dime.' Prime Minister Anthony Albanese rejected the Opposition's criticism of his six-day China trip. NewsWire/ Joseph Olbrycht-Palmer Credit: News Corp Australia Sussan Ley also said she was 'disappointed' Mr Albanese 'didn't get the assurances that he should' about circumnavigation of Chinese navy warships in Australia, or the live firing exercises which were done without advanced notice. Asked for his response to the comment during a press conference in the city of Chengdu, Mr Albanese rejected the claims. 'I think the opposition have got some issues they need to sort out within themselves, including over the relationship with China,' he told reporters. He said China was Australia's 'most important trading partner', with one in four Australian jobs dependent on the relationship, and reiterated the importance of a stable relationship. 'They've just had an election result because in part, they themselves have characterised it as their constant negativity' and said the trip had been 'very successful'. 'They need to stop looking for reasons to say they're against and decide what they're for.' The opposition said Anthony Albanese's trip was 'starting to look a little bit indulgent'. NewsWire/ Joseph Olbrycht-Palmer Credit: News Corp Australia Mr Albanese also described Chinese President Xi Jinping as 'warm and engaging' and said China was a 'confident,' 'creative' and 'dynamic' country. Mr Albanese said he wanted to see Australia and China establish a 'stronger relationship' with 'more agreement and less disagreement' over the next three years, while acknowledging the two countries had different political systems, cultures and values. 'We have different values. So we understand that,' he said. 'What I'd like to see is to be able to talk about those issues regularly, get as much agreement as possible, but understanding of where our nations are coming from, out of understanding, can come greater co-operation.' Mr Albanese toured the Great Wall of China with Jodie Haydon on Wednesday. NewsWire/ Joseph Olbrycht-Palmer Credit: NewsWire Speaking after the press conference, Coalition education spokesman Jonno Duniam said while it was important to show 'deference to your host,' he questioned the value of the trip. 'We have our prime minister there on a multi-day trip, a range of high-level meetings with very little in the way of outcomes that can be perceived back here home in Australia,' he told Sky News. 'At the same time, we've got drills occurring in Taipei for potential and perhaps eventual invasion by Chinese forces of Taiwan's territory there. 'There's a lot of water to go under the bridge, but I'm failing to see the benefits of what you've don, or what will come from this visit.'
7NEWS
40 minutes ago
- 7NEWS
Ireland close to passing occupied Palestinian territories bill
Ireland appears closer to passing a bill that will ban trade with illegal Israeli settlements in occupied territories in the West Bank, sparking sharp criticism from US officials who have signalled the move could harm Dublin's relationship with Washington. US Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee accused Ireland of 'diplomatic intoxication' Tuesday in a sharp rebuke of the draft legislation, invoking a derogatory stereotype of the Irish people. 'Did the Irish fall into a vat of Guinness & propose something so stupid that it would be attributed to act of diplomatic intoxication? It will harm Arabs as much as Israelis. Sober up Ireland!,' Huckabee said in a post on X. Huckabee's comment comes after the Irish Committee on Foreign Affairs and Trade held pre-legislative scrutiny meetings this week to discuss the bill, which has drawn support from pro-Palestinian lawmakers and campaigners and criticism from several Jewish organisations and some in the Jewish community. The Irish Foreign Ministry has been contacted for comment on Huckabee's post. In an apparent attempt to deflect criticism, Micheál Martin, the Taoiseach, or prime minister, has said enacting the bill would be 'largely symbolic', as it aims to apply pressure on Israel to end the war in Gaza. 'This is one element of the government's approach to the devastating violence and the appalling humanitarian situation in Gaza and the West Bank,' Martin said in April. On Monday, the chair of the Jewish Representative Council of Ireland, Maurice Cohen, called the bill 'a performance of misguided effort'. 'It won't bring two states closer, but it might drive Jewish communities here in Ireland further into fear and isolation,' Cohen said. Republican Senator Lindsay Graham also weighed in on the bill, saying Tuesday that he hopes 'Ireland will reconsider their efforts to economically isolate Israel'. 'I do not believe these efforts would be well received in the United States and they certainly would not go unnoticed,' Graham said on X. If the legislation — Israeli Settlements in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (Prohibition of Importation of Goods) Bill 2025 – passes in Ireland's Oireachtas, or parliament, it will mark the first time a European Union member state has enacted such a law. The bill was first tabled in 2018 and has regained momentum since Israel's highly destructive military campaign in Gaza following the Hamas attacks of October 7, 2023. More than 58,000 people have been killed in Gaza since the start of the war, according to the Palestinian Ministry of Health. The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has said Israel's settlement policies and exploitation of natural resources in the occupied Palestinian territories breaches international law. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called the ICJ's ruling a 'decision of lies'. Solidarity with the Palestinian cause is longstanding across most of Irish society and politics, with many in Ireland identifying a shared historical experience of subjugation by an occupying state. Ireland became the first EU member state to call for Palestinian statehood in 1980, actualised in its formal recognition of the State of Palestine in May 2024. Israel closed its embassy in Dublin in December 2024, with Israel's Foreign Minister Gideon Sa'ar accusing Ireland of 'extreme anti-Israel policies'. Ireland has long rejected any accusation that it is anti-Israel. 'Ireland is pro-peace, pro-human rights and pro-international law,' then-PM Simon Harris said in response to the Israeli embassy closure. 'Ireland wants a two-state solution and for Israel and Palestine to live in peace and security,' he said. 'Ireland will always speak up for human rights and international law. Nothing will distract from that.'
Perth Now
40 minutes ago
- Perth Now
Minority government major issue as leaders court voters
Tasmania's Liberal and Labor leaders continue to talk down crossbenchers despite all signs pointing to another hung parliament. The island state heads to the polls on Saturday, after Liberal minority premier Jeremy Rockliff lost the confidence of parliament in early June. The Liberals hold 14 seats and the 11-year Labor opposition 10, with 18 required for majority. Opinion polls suggest neither party will pick up enough support for majority, with the latest DemosAU survey having the Liberals (35 per cent) ahead of Labor (25). It suggests one-fifth of the state intends to vote for an independent, with the Greens on 16 per cent support. Announcing funding for more basketball courts, Mr Rockliff reiterated he would not do a deal with the Greens, who held five seats in the past parliament, to form government. "There is a lot of light between what the Greens stand for and the Liberal Party, particularly when it comes to our key resource-based industries," he said. "The real danger is Labor, the Greens and radical independents could form government." Mr Rockliff has said he would work with "sensible" independents to form government, but has also labelled "single-issue" independents a risk to stability. Labor, the Greens and three crossbench MPs teamed up to pass the no-confidence motion against Mr Rockliff. Labor leader Dean Winter on Wednesday did not categorically rule out accepting Greens confidence and supply but has firmly said he won't "do a deal" with the minor party to govern. "I have said this maybe 1000 times. We will not do a deal with the Greens to form government," he told reporters on Thursday. "The Greens are the polar opposite to everything Labor stands for." Greens leader Rosalie Woodruff didn't give a direct answer when asked whether her party would consider providing confidence and supply to prop up a Labor government. "Tasmanians want a new government. We are working to be in the balance of power so that we can fight for the issues that we've campaigned on," she said. "(Those include) ending the stadium (and) putting the money into housing and healthcare and protecting the environment.' The Liberals and Labor support construction of a $945 million stadium in Hobart, a condition of Tasmania's licence for an AFL team. Mr Winter rejected an offer from the Greens to form government when Mr Rockliff lost the no-confidence vote. Tasmania went to the polls a mere 16 months ago when the minority government at the time collapsed. More than 100,000 Tasmanians, about one-quarter of enrolled voters, have already cast their ballot.
