Overuse of ‘Welcome to Country' Could Cheapen Its Significance: Opposition Leader
Speaking on the evening of April 27, Dutton was asked about a contentious episode over the long weekend during Anzac Day commemorations on April 25.
Boos and heckling could be heard during a Welcome to Country being performed during the dawn service at Melbourne's Shrine of Remembrance
At least three men were heard interrupting as Bunurong elder Uncle Mark Brown, with police later ordering a 26-year-old man to leave the venue.
Attendees reported hearing chants of, 'Don't welcome us to our country,' 'What about the Anzacs?' and 'We're here for the Australians.'
Some other attendees reportedly responded by then yelling, 'Shame on you,' at the group of men, which included a self-proclaimed neo-Nazi Jacob Hersant.
Related Stories
4/24/2025
4/27/2025
A similar situation occurred in Perth.
Created in the 1970s, the Welcome to Country and Acknowledgement of Country has become near-pervasive in Australian public life featuring before the start of official events, sporting events, and even on public signage.
Dutton condemned the booing during the solemn Anzac ceremony, but acknowledged a growing sense of annoyance in the community with Welcome to Country ceremonies.
'For the opening of Parliament, fair enough, it's respectful to do, but for the start of every meeting at work or the start of a football game, I think a lot of Australians think it's overdone,' he told the Channel 7 debate.
'It cheapens the significance of what it was meant to do.'
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese commented that he believed it was up to event organisers to decide whether or not they included a Welcome to Country ceremony.
Dutton's comments echoed the sentiments of an unidentified veteran who was interviewed in the aftermath of the booing at the Melbourne ceremony.
Channel Nine reporter Mark Santomartino spoke to the man at the Melbourne service who said there was a time and a place for everything.
'I have a lot of veteran mates who haven't come today solely because of the Welcome to Country because our friends died for this country, for this soil, and for them the 'welcome' is a slap in the face,' he told the reporter.
'It's not right to welcome veterans ... just listen to all the people that have died for this country, for them to 'welcome' us in this country is disrespectful.'
People First Party Leader Gerard Rennick also spoke out against the inclusion of the Welcome to the Country ceremony at Anzac Day events.
'It is disrespectful to our veterans and must stop.
'We are there to pay our respects to those who served our country and remember their sacrifices.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Insider
3 hours ago
- Business Insider
Controversy grows as DRC targets protected lands for massive oil and gas exploration
The Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) is facing mounting criticism from environmentalists, human rights groups, and global climate advocates following its decision to open 124 million hectares of land and inland waters to oil and gas exploration. The DRC announced the opening of 124 million hectares for oil and gas exploration to enhance its hydrocarbon sector and economy. The decision includes regions containing protected biodiversity areas such as rainforests and peatlands Pressure mounts both nationally and internationally for the DRC government to reconsider these plans due to projected environmental and social consequences. In May, the government of the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), through its Minister of Hydrocarbons, Aimé Sakombi Molendo, formally announced the expansion of oil and gas exploration during the 42nd ordinary meeting of the Council of Ministers. Molendo revealed that the Central Basin sedimentary region has been fully divided into oil blocks, with 52 of them newly opened for exploration. He emphasized that this move is part of ongoing efforts to promote the country's hydrocarbon sector and unlock its economic potential. The Council of Ministers acknowledged the update, stressing the strategic importance of these developments for the DRC's economic future. They noted that the initiative aligns with the government's broader agenda to strengthen national revenue generation through the oil industry and attract investment in the energy sector. The move, announced as part of President Félix Tshisekedi's broader economic strategy, includes regions that encompass protected rainforests, peatlands, and biodiversity hotspots, some of which are home to endangered species such as forest elephants and lowland gorillas. Critics slam move as setback to climate goals With an estimated 5 to 22 billion barrels of oil reserves, the DRC is pursuing a pro-investment agenda aimed at boosting transparency, operational efficiency, and upstream activity. However, the move has drawn sharp criticism from climate advocates who say it undermines global emissions targets and global climate goals. Conservationists argue that expanding fossil fuel infrastructure into ecologically sensitive areas threatens to destroy fragile ecosystems and violates the rights of Indigenous populations who depend on these landscapes for their survival. According to Earth Insight, in a report titled Forests to Frontlines: Oil Expansion Threats in the DRC, the organization calls on the Congolese government to cancel the 2025 oil block licensing round and instead pursue alternative development models that 'r espect Indigenous and community rights, sustain local livelihoods, and safeguard biodiversity and the global climate. ' 'What happens next in the Congo Basin will have consequences far beyond its borders, ' the report cautions. As the second-largest tropical rainforest on the planet, the DRC is home to an astonishing array of biodiversity—including elephants, great apes, endemic bird species, and thousands of unique plants that thrive in its intact ecosystems. The country's Cuvette Centrale peatlands store vast amounts of carbon vital to the fight against climate change. These rich landscapes also support the livelihoods, cultural heritage, and climate resilience of millions of people. Earth Insight further warns that over half of the DRC's territory, approximately 53%, is now covered by oil blocks, placing immense pressure on areas of critical ecological and cultural importance. This development threatens to disrupt local livelihoods and erode lands with deep cultural and spiritual significance, ultimately undermining the country's potential for long-term sustainable development. The controversy has also cast a shadow over international climate partnerships. These include agreements in which the DRC receives financial support from global partners to conserve its rainforests, the world's second-largest after the Amazon.
Hamilton Spectator
18 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
‘Time for action is now'; Mi'kmaq chiefs want to restart negotiations about on-reserve poverty
Some Nova Scotia Chiefs and negotiators held a press conference earlier this week to call on the Canadian Prime Minister to get a team back to the negotiating table for talks about distressingly low rates of social assistance for clients living on reserves in the province. They met in Eskasoni and included presentations by, left to right, Chief Leroy Denny of Eskasoni; Chief John Leonard Bernard of We'koqma'q; and Canadian Senator J.P. Prosper. ROSEMARY GODIN/Cape Breton Post Potlotek Chief Wilbert Marshall endorses bringing the federal government and Nova Scotia Mi'kmaq back to the negotiating table to discuss inequality between social assistance rates. Extreme poverty and government inaction were the focus Tuesday when several First Nations Chiefs and Senator Paul Prosper met before media in Eskasoni to make a direct appeal to Prime Minister Mark Carney. The chiefs called for Indigenous rights, self-determination and upholding laws and agreements already in place to be honoured as a way of eliminating inequality and insufficiency in social assistance rates between Mi'kmaq living on or off reserves. A single person who is not a homeowner living on-reserve receives $185.32 bi-weekly in assistance, which amounts to less than $14 per day. Someone living off-reserve receives $644 monthly. Neither amount is sufficient, the leaders agreed, but right now they are asking for equality. Eskasoni Chief Leroy Denny read a statement on behalf of Mi'kmaq social assistance recipients and their families in Nova Scotia. 'Since 2015, we have worked closely with Canada on preparations for our communities to resume the jurisdiction and control of our on-reserve social assistance program,' he said. 'In one month, it will be one year since Canada promised they were committed to addressing adequate resourcing at the Indigenous Service Canada On–Reserve Income Assistance Program.' PEOPLE ARE SUFFERING Denny said there have been negotiations on and off, as well as costly court orders for over a decade. In the meantime, people are suffering and living far below the poverty line. He said it affects people's mental health and well-being. 'Indigenous Services Canada delegates management responsibility to Mi'kmaq band councils in Nova Scotia to deliver its National On-Reserve Income Assistance Program. That federal program is required to be comparable with the Nova Scotia Income Assistance Program, but is not,' said Denny. He said the Mi'kmaq, Canada and Nova Scotia had been negotiating a self-governance agreement for social assistance on reserves since November 2021, but Canada halted negotiations last November after the Mi'kmaq submitted a plan based on provincial comparability. Now, the chiefs see a shift in government priorities away from poverty issues despite a 2019 Poverty Reduction Act brought in by the Liberal government of the time. It appears to have been put in the background by the Carney government's new 'Building Canada Act', also known as Bill C-5. The Building Canada Act was made into law earlier this year and is designed to streamline the approval process for major infrastructure projects. Yet discussions and agreements about poverty issues in First Nation communities have been ongoing since 1964. Canadian Indigenous leaders met with Prime Minister Mark Carney in mid-July in Gatineau, Que., to discuss the lack of consultation with Indigenous communities around the enactment of Bill C-5, which essentially puts infrastructure and building projects under the jurisdiction of a single minister and department to issue permits and approvals. Although provisions were made for addressing First Nation's environmental concerns, communities are fearful that their rights and generational wisdom may not be a priority. 'FRACTION OF RESOURCES' Independent Senator Prosper, a lawyer and former Chief of Paqtnkek Mi'kmaw Nation, accompanied the chiefs at the table on Tuesday. 'There's a distinct need to address poverty within Mi'kmaq communities and all First Nation communities,' he said. 'For far too long First Nations had to manage poverty with a fraction of the resources that exist within all reserves in Nova Scotia. A self-government agreement would deliver much-needed income to support programming at a level comparable to what Nova Scotians receive today.' The senator said he has advocated for poverty-reduction initiatives and included them as part of his pre-Fall budget submission, which he is about to hand in. 'Mi'kmaq leaders are asking for basic human and legal rights – the ability to access poverty-reducing income supports comparable to what other Canadians can access off-reserve.' 'Time for talk is over,' he said. 'Time for action is now. That's why I'm here.' Chief John Leonard Bernard of We'koqma'q said they are trying to end an intergenerational formula from the past that has been forced upon Indigenous people for many years. 'We can do this ourselves,' Bernard said. 'Our chiefs and councils have been governing in our own ways and with our own government structures that we created and feel are right for our own people.' 'We want to negotiate in good faith. We want to negotiate as partners. Our goal is to eliminate poverty.' FAIRNESS SOUGHT Chief Wilbert Marshall of Potlotek (Chapel Island) First Nation was succinct in his remarks. He lamented the fact that court orders and continual negotiations have a financial cost. 'We know our stuff,' Marshall said. 'We weren't born yesterday. Just listen. We just want you to be fair, that's all.' James Michael, the co-lead negotiator for the Mi'kmaq bands said: 'The rule of law is a guiding principle Canadians expect all governments to respect and adhere to. Unfortunately, Canada has not been consistent following the rule of law in matters of poverty reduction for Mi'kmaq individuals and families living on reserve in Nova Scotia.' Michael said Canada is still not in compliance with its own 1964 Treasury Board policy to align assistance rates between on- and off-reserve clients. 'On behalf of our social assistance clients and their families, we're calling on Prime Minister Carnie to re-start formal negotiations with our bands to complete the Mi'kmaq/Canada financial relationship in the sectoral self-government agreement,' said Denny. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
Los Angeles Times
a day ago
- Los Angeles Times
Leftist lawmakers gather to answer a question: How to beat the global right?
MEXICO CITY — In recent years, the far right has been remarkably organized, with leaders from far-flung countries sharing advisors, strategies and talking points. The Conservative Political Action Conference, a gathering of right-wing activists and elected officials that started in the United States, has gone global, hosting mega-events in Brazil, Argentina and Hungary. Foreign leaders, including Argentina President Javier Milei and El Salvador President Nayib Bukele, have raced the stage at CPAC, slamming socialism, calling for tougher policies on crime and railing against all things 'woke.' Now, the left is trying to compete. This week, political leaders, activists and strategists from a dozen countries across the Americas gather in Mexico City for what organizers are billing as the 'CPAC of the left.' The second annual Panamerican Congress includes a diverse range of participants, from a guerrilla-fighter-turned-politician from Colombia to U.S. Reps. Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.) and Rashida Tlaib (D-Mich.). The event's program acknowledges that leftists have not been in conversation across borders in the way the right has, and vows to 'remedy this crisis of hemispheric coordination.' In closed-door meetings and public events, participants will seek to address hemispheric themes such as migration, climate change and Trump's tariff threats. And they will debate existential questions: With elections looming across the region, what are winning strategies for the left? And how can it combat the growing influence of conservative, anti-establishment populists who are both inspired by — and influencing — the American right? 'We need solutions not only at the individual country level, but also at the continental level,' said Giorgio Jackson, an event organizer who served as minister of social development under Chilean President Gabriel Boric. 'We need broad, democratic, progressive alliances.' Chile's upcoming presidential election highlights just how much the ideological landscape of the Americas has shifted. Just a handful of years ago, the left was ascendant, with its candidates winning presidencies in one country after the other: Mexico, Argentina, Bolivia, Peru, Chile, Colombia and Brazil. Boric, a former student protest leader who was just 36 when he took office, embodied the trend, which some christened a 'new pink tide,' likening it to the period in the 2000s when Brazil's Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, Venezuela's Hugo Chávez and Bolivia's Evo Morales dominated regional politics. Boric campaigned on a promise that Chile would be the 'grave' of free-market orthodoxy and promoted a new constitution that would enshrine gender equality, environmental protections and Indigenous rights. But a national referendum on the constitution failed. And amid a sluggish economy and growing fears about organized crime and high levels migration from nearby Venezuela, his approval rating has slumped to less than 30%. Conservative José Antonio Kast, a Trump acolyte who has vowed hard-line security policies, is now leading in the polls for Chile's November presidential election. Vowing to fight crime has been a winning strategy for the right across the region, from Ecuador, where conservative President Daniel Noboa has declared war on organized crime, to El Salvador, where Bukele's mass incarceration of alleged gang members has brought down violence even while sparking concerns about violations of human rights. 'Polls in most countries suggest populations want harsh crackdowns,' said James Bosworth, the founder of Hxagon, a company that provides political risk analysis in Latin America. A strong hand — 'mano dura' — is popular, he said. The left, he said, needs to find a similarly powerful message. It's no coincidence that the conference is taking place in Mexico, where leftist President Claudia Sheinbaum won election last year in a landslide. Her Morena party holds a majority in both chambers of Congress and governs most states. The party's founder, former president Andrés Manuel López Obrador, was an economic populist, decrying the 'mafia of power' that he said controlled Mexico and vowing to 'put the poor first.' Celeste Ascencio Ortega, a Morena congresswoman from Michoacán state, said other countries should consider replicating Morena's popular welfare programs, which funnel state money to students and the elderly. 'We have to talk about an accumulation of wealth that benefits everyone, not just a few,' she said. Economic populism has also proved to be a winning strategy in New York's mayoral race, where Zohran Mamdani beat out establishment candidates in the Democratic primary by focusing on poverty and affordability. But leftists coming into office in the hemisphere now are hamstrung by harsh economic conditions. Long gone is the commodities boom that allowed Lula and others to spend generously. Today, inflation drives up food and fuel prices and the threat of a worldwide recession looms. Leftists also must contend with the aggressive politics of the region's global superpower. President Trump has cracked down on migration and has repeatedly threatened nations across Latin America with tariffs, recently saying he'd levy 50% taxes on imports from Brazil, citing a 'witch hunt' against Jair Bolsonaro, the far-right former president, who is on trial for allegedly plotting a coup. In Mexico, whose economy relies largely on exports to the U.S., Trump is threatening 30% tariffs on Mexican imports unless the country does more to combat drug trafficking and migration. The new taxes are set to go into effect Friday, just as the congress meets in Mexico City. Perhaps to avoid antagonizing Trump by appearing alongside prominent Democrats, Sheinbaum will not be participating in the event, although she may formally welcome its guests, and prominent Morena party members will take part. The left has suffered a number of losses recently. Kamala Harris lost to Trump. In Argentina, far-right firebrand Milei won on a promise to privatize much of government. Polls in Brazil suggest Lula is nowhere near as popular as he once was heading into next year's presidential vote. . But whether those shifts reflect real ideological changes in the region is up for debate. Many see the pendulum swing from left to right as a feature of politics in the hemisphere, where voters often clamor for change. From to 2018 until 2023, some two dozen national elections went against the incumbent party. 'For approximately 15 years now, there are practically no goverments across the continent that have been reelected,' Jackson said. 'These are very difficult conditions for any party.' Significantly, there will be no representatives at this week's event from Venezuela, Nicaragua or Cuba, countries with leftist leaders who have taken hard authoritarian turns. Bosworth said it was incumbent on the left to address those repressive governments, particularly Venezuela, where more than 6 million people have fled political, economic and humanitarian crises in recent years. 'Venezuela is the great failure of the left in Latin America, and it struggles to move beyond that,' he said. 'If this movement is going to do anything, they can't ignore the fact that Venezuela exists.'
