Limited access to EU security database may hamper ‘robust' screening of asylum-seekers, government report says
A government report on the implementation of the EU Pact on Migration and Asylum has also warned of undue stressors on the asylum system, inadequate staff training, and the risk of backlogs and absconding leading to reputational damage.
The new immigration control system across the 27 EU member states has been adopted by Ireland and is set to come into effect in June 2026.
It will aim to tackle key inefficiencies within the current system, while also protecting external borders and supporting member states 'under migratory pressure through greater burden-sharing'.
A report prepared for the Government has highlighted how Ireland does not have access to certain EU security databases available to Schengen member states, and is limited in its access to the full European search portal.
There is concern, the report states, that, as a result, Ireland may not be able to adequately conduct screening or carry out 'robust identity validation' in line with the requirements of the EU Pact.
The Department of Justice told the Irish Independent that it was a central priority for Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan that Ireland's immigration system be robust and effective.
While Ireland would not have access to the entry/exit system, ETIAS and the Visa Information System, the Government had opted into the EuroDac system, which is a fingerprint database for asylum-seekers that will be upgraded by June of next year.
It will store official documents and photographs of asylum- seekers as well as their first place of application to help decrease secondary movement.
The department said that while Ireland could not opt in to the Schengen IT systems, the State intended to legislate nationally to align with its provisions.
It said the State would carry out screening on anybody who entered Ireland irregularly – this will consist of identity checks, health checks, security and criminal screening and gathering fingerprint data for the EuroDac database.
Last year, there were 18,560 applications for international protection, a 40pc increase on 2023, with more than 50pc of applicants coming from Jordan, Nigeria, Somalia, Pakistan and Bangladesh.
The report also says that Ireland has 'responded generously to the humanitarian situation in Ukraine' and granted more than 113,332 applications for temporary protection between 2022 and January of this year.
Figures show that the Department of Justice and state-funded migration operations delivered 934 voluntary returns last year.
The Government has also committed to providing 14,000 state-owned beds which it says will help support the delivery of the pact requirements. The acquisition of facilities for state-owned properties 'will deliver significant savings to the Exchequer' in the long run, according to the report.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
19 minutes ago
- Extra.ie
Minister lashed for plans to raise personal injury claims by 17%
Government TDs and business lobby groups have slammed plans to allow a 17% personal injury claims hike by the judiciary, warning it would 'wipe out' any progress in reducing insurance premiums. In a statement, the Irish Small and Medium Enterprises Association (ISME) strongly criticised Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan, who is set to bring a memo to Cabinet next week to legislate for the increase. ISME claimed that Fianna Fáil TD Mr O'Callaghan's support for the increase is 'a capitulation to vested legal interests and undermines years of work to bring down insurance costs for SMEs and consumers'. Minister Jim O'Callaghan. Pic: Leah Farrell/ Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael backbenchers also expressed concern over the proposal. One TD in Fine Gael, which currently holds the Enterprise brief at Cabinet, said the move 'is not at all in line with the Government's focus on reducing the cost of business'. Last week, it emerged that the Minister for Justice will seek Cabinet approval to begin drafting legislation to increase personal injury awards by 16.7%. The proposed hike, which will reportedly be brought before ministers on July 8, is based on a recommendation from the Judicial Council. The board of the council, an independent body representing judges across Ireland, is required by law to review personal injury guidelines every three years. The group proposed in December that payouts should increase by 16.7%, citing 'significant global and national inflation' in the period since the last review. Pic: Gareth Chaney/Collins Photos The recommendation was adopted by the council at large in late January and passed over to Mr O'Callaghan, who must put the amendments before the Houses of the Oireachtas for approval. The memo from the minister will come following sustained pressure on the Government to bring down the cost of premiums, with officials in the Department of Finance currently working on an updated Action Plan for Insurance Reform. ISME said the hike 'would lead to increases in insurance premiums for both businesses and consumers' and 'further reward a legal industry already profiting from vexatious litigation and huge personal injury payouts'. Neil McDonnell. Pic: Sasko Lazarov / The association said: 'Ireland also has 14 times more personal injury cases than England and Wales, with a population 12 times smaller.' The group's chief executive, Neil McDonnell, called the proposed rise 'indefensible' and said: 'Insurance costs have not fallen following previous reforms, and now the Government wants to undo the little progress that has been made. SMEs and voluntary groups will bear the cost while legal firms walk away with bigger fees. 'Minister O'Callaghan will have to make a decision based on social good, not on the desire to maintain legal earning power.' He also called for the Justice Minister to remove the judiciary from the job of setting the amount of awards and delegate it to an independent expert body such as the Injuries Resolution Board or the Workplace Relations Commission. Discontent is also brewing in the Oireachtas, particularly among members of Fine Gael, which is endeavouring to be seen as the 'pro-enterprise' party in the Dáil. Numerous Fianna Fáil sources also indicated discontent in the Justice Minister's own ranks and questioned whether the legislation to give way to the 16.7% hike needed to be brought forward in the coming weeks. Cork TD Séamus McGrath said the Government must do everything in its power to 'put a downward pressure' on insurance costs. 'The proposal to increase personal injury awards needs to be considered very carefully, and I will be raising my own concerns about the reported proposals,' the Fianna Fáil deputy said.
Extra.ie
34 minutes ago
- Extra.ie
Lack of accountability means artist supports are 'a slush fund'
The lack of accountability when it comes to artists' basic income means the scheme has turned into a Government slush fund, a TD has claimed. Carol Nolan was commenting on the response by Arts Minister Patrick O'Donovan to queries about the initiative. Mr Donovan said: 'The current pilot scheme costs approximately €35million per year, based on 2,000 recipients receiving €325 weekly. ' The lack of accountability when it comes to artists' basic income means the scheme has turned into a Government slush fund, a TD has claimed. Pic: Gareth Chaney/Collins Photos The net cost is likely to be less, given the high number of BIA [Basic Income for the Arts] recipients who were previously on social welfare supports prior to the BIA.' Mr O'Donovan also said 'evaluation of the pilot is continuous, as participants complete a survey every six months'. He said: 'My department is currently preparing a report examining the first 24 months of the scheme. A further interview research paper, written by an independent researcher, was published recently. Carol Nolan was commenting on the response by Arts Minister Patrick O'Donovan to queries about the initiative. Pic: Collins 'This paper collects the experiences of 50 BIA recipients, who have been interviewed by a sociologist.' Ms Nolan called the response 'almost absurdly laughable'. She said: 'It is clearly stated in the reply provided to me that the evaluation of the pilot is continuous because participants complete a survey every six months.' The Independent TD asked: 'Does the department really think this is what robust evaluation looks like [and] does it believe that a slush fund that has cost €100million to date is going to be criticised by the very same people on the receiving end of that cash?' Ms Nolan accused Fine Gael TD Mr O'Donovan of implementing outdated Green Party ideology, as it was imple – mented by former arts minister Catherine Martin, adding: 'The entire scheme just reeks of that particular form of cultural entitlement to vast sums of public monies that is particularly pervasive in the likes of RTÉ where control of publicly financed spending is way down the list of priorities.'
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
US tariffs, Gaza ceasefire, economy & dynamic pricing on gigs – Michael McGrath speaks on big issues facing Ireland
THE Irish Sun sat down with European Commissioner Michael McGrath in his office in the Berlaymont building in Brussels last week. 3 European Commission President Ursula Von der Leyen Credit: AFP 3 Proposals will be taken forward next year to help protect consumer rights in an online environment Credit: EPA The wide-ranging brief sees him deal with everything from gangland At the same time, the Commission is dealing with a trade dispute with the Here, Michael McGrath gives The Irish Sun's Head of Content, Mark May, his assessment of some of the current issues facing Ireland and the EU. ON TARIFFS AN agreement is needed as soon as possible and we're doing everything we can to get one. The US side is very clear on what the EU position is, what our expectations are. READ MORE IN NEWS We are a trusted partner, a very reliable partner. Businesses crave certainty, predictability and stability and we want that as quickly as possible. Negotiating comprehensive trade agreements or settlements can take a long time. So it may not be possible to have a level of detail that you would normally have in a trade agreement completed by July 9, but hopefully we can have the outline of an agreement that can provide the stability we need. Most read in The Irish Sun ON OTHER MARKETS WE are finding the EU is being reached out to increasingly by countries all over the world who view us as a reliable partner, a tough negotiator but one that honours deals once they are made. Others want that certainty so we are in negotiations with a number of countries in We are always expanding the network of trade agreements we have. It's in the region of 44 trading agreements with about 76 countries and we are confident that will be extended. It's not possible to replace the US as a trading partner nor is that the objective. But we also have to look at opportunities elsewhere and we're pursuing every option. ON BIG TECH THE Digital Services Act is our digital rule book. There are various actions underway against companies in areas such as product safety, So we defend the DSA as vital for our overall architecture of the digital space and we continue to uphold and apply it without fear or favour. It doesn't just apply to American companies (as has been claimed by the The DSA does not target companies from any particular country. It is equally applied. We reserve the right to set legislation in the European Union and to apply it in an objective and even-handed manner. ON GAZA WE need an immediate ceasefire in Gaza. We need the full restoration of access for humanitarian aid, including by the international organization. We also need the What we are witnessing in Gaza is abhorrent and it is untenable. The international community has to work together to find a solution. We need an urgent ceasefire and we need the trucks that are waiting at the border to be allowed to enter Gaza. It is unconscionable that we are watching scenes of children who are clearly malnourished and emaciated while thousands of trucks of food and medicine are waiting at the border. ON THE ECONOMY I KNOW from my previous role there are a range of economic forecasts published by member states, including by the Irish government, which is forecasting continued growth, for the economy. Similarly we recently had the commission forecasts for the European economy which are predict growth. We would like it to be higher growth and that's why we are a very serious around the competitiveness agenda. The issues of trade have been to the fore and are complex and changing, but there are levers that are within our control and that is maximizing the potential of the EU single market. Although a recession is not forecast, you never know what can happen with an economic shock. But maximizing the potential in the market is largely within the control of the EU and its members. ON DYNAMIC PRICING I WILL be developing the Digital Fairness Act. We will bring forward proposals next year to help protect consumer rights in an online environment and also focus on the protection of minors. It will look at issues such as addictive design, dark patterns, the role of social media influencers, and child protection issues in the context of certain video games. MEPs have raised the issue of dynamic pricing and we have given a commitment that we will examine it. It doesn't mean it was necessarily lead need to a ban but, at a minimum, more information is needed for consumers joining a queue to buy concert tickets. 3 European Commissioner for Justice Michael McGrath has vowed to develop the Digital Fairness Act Credit: EPA
