Labour policies ‘obscured' by rows over welfare and winter fuel
He said that the party have 'a series of really commendable and absolutely essential policies' and also suggested a wealth tax as a change that could 'commend' them to the general public.
The week of Sir Keir's first anniversary in Number 10 saw the Prime Minister scrap a raft of the Government's proposed welfare reforms in the face of a backbench revolt.
Asked what has gone wrong in Government, Lord Kinnock told the Sunday Morning With Trevor Phillips programme: 'What's gone wrong is really the lack of a narrative, a story of the objectives of the Government and where they're working towards it and how they're working towards it.
'They are working towards it with a series of really commendable and absolutely essential policies.
'They are barely noticed because they're obscured by all the song and dance and noise, drums banging and cymbals clashing of the winter fuel payment… the welfare programme, the two-child benefit cap, the cuts in development aid, all those negative things that really are heartily disliked across the Labour movement and more widely, much more widely.'
He said that a 'cloud hangs over the accomplishments of the Government, which are substantial and will become greater, and people are not getting the message'.
Lord Kinnock said there are things the party could do that 'would commend themselves to the great majority of the general public' and that these included 'asset taxes'.
'By going for an imposition of 2% on asset values above £10 million, say, which is a very big fortune, the Government would be in a position to collect £10 billion or £11 billion,' he said.
Shadow chancellor Sir Mel Stride said he thought a wealth tax would be 'the worst thing to do' and opposed the idea of 'piling further taxes on the wealth creators'.
He also told the same Sky News programme that it had been a 'year of utter underperformance' from Labour.
'Whether you look at illegal boats, migrants coming across the Channel, that's now at record levels, far from smashing the gangs, they're smashing all the records as to the numbers coming into our country. If you look at the chaotic U-turns that we've just had in the last few weeks,' he added.
Analysis by the PA news agency found that Labour has seen a double-digit drop in support in the opinion polls since last year's general election.
According to figures collated this week, the party has averaged 24% in polls in the past month, down 10 points from 34% in the weeks following the 2024 election.
It is common for political parties to experience a slide in the polls after taking power – it has happened to every UK government bar one in the past 40 years – but a drop of this size is unusual.
The last time it was in double digits was 1992/93, when the Tory administration led by former prime minister John Major saw its poll numbers fall 12 points, from an average of 43% in the weeks after the April 1992 election to 31% a year later.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Guardian
12 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
Labour taking Reform threat in Wales ‘seriously', says Morgan
Baroness Eluned Morgan told Sky News voters in Wales needed to understand Reform as a 'threat', warning that 'things that they're used to' such as free prescriptions and free school meals for primary school children 'could be snatched away'. She said: 'We're taking it very seriously, and we think the threat from Reform is a very serious threat.' Her interview comes as polling by More In Common on behalf of Sky News found 28% of people in Wales would back Reform at the Senedd elections in 2026, putting the party in first place. Mr Farage's party is targeting the Senedd as it looks to build on its success at the English local elections earlier this year, and unveiled former Wales secretary David Jones as another ex-Tory defector on Monday as part of its push. The poll, published on Tuesday, showed Plaid Cymru in second place on 26% and Labour in third place on 23%, before a long drop to the Conservatives on 10% and the Liberal Democrats on 7%. If the results were replicated next year, it could mean the end of Labour's 26 years of domination in Wales, where it has held power since devolution. Baroness Morgan acknowledged there was 'a possibility' that Reform could become the largest party in the Senedd, saying it was 'really concerning', but added it would be 'difficult for them to rule by themselves'. But she ruled out entering a coalition with the party, saying: 'I wouldn't touch Reform with a bargepole.' The First Minister also insisted that Labour would be able to win voters back by being 'authentic' and 'clear with people about what we stand for', rather than trying to 'out-Reform Reform'. She said: 'I think we've got to lead with our values. We're about bringing communities together, not dividing them, and I do think that what Reform is interested in is dividing people and people do need to make choices on things like that. 'So, what I won't be doing in Wales is chasing Reform down a path where we can try and out-Reform Reform. I'm not interested in that, because those aren't my values.'
Wales Online
22 minutes ago
- Wales Online
New poll shows Reform UK's chances of winning Welsh election, and it's not good news for Labour
New poll shows Reform UK's chances of winning Welsh election, and it's not good news for Labour Wales' First Minister Eluned Morgan has said she 'wouldn't touch Reform with a barge pole' Nigel Farage has a negative approval rating, but is more popular than Eluned Morgan (Image: PA ) A third consecutive poll has shown Labour is projected to come behind Reform UK and Plaid Cymru at next May's Senedd election. This latest poll puts Labour 5% up on previous estimates of 18% but the poll, by More in Common for Sky News is the second to project Reform would be the biggest party in the Senedd. In terms of Senedd voting intention, the poll shows Reform in the lead with 28% of the vote, followed closely by Plaid Cymru, on 26%. Labour is third with 23%. The Conservatives would go from being the official opposition in the Senedd to having 10% of the vote. The polling, of 883 people carried out between June 18 and July 3, shows less than half (48%) of Labour's 2024 voters would back the party in a Senedd election if it were held today. For our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation, sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here Their largest losses for Labour are to Plaid Cymru (15%), followed by Reform(11%). However, a significant proportion of Labour's 2024 voters (13%) are undecided about how they would vote in a Senedd election. A YouGov/ITV Cymru Wales poll in May put Labour in third and Plaid top. A different poll, by Find Out Now, put Reform UK top. When the voting intention question were asked about a Westminster general election, Labour's vote share has also collapsed but with voters turning to Reform UK, not Plaid Cymru. Article continues below That poll puts Reform in the lead with 33% of the vote, Labour with 20% and Plaid with 16%. The Conservatives, who were wiped out at the last general election, have 12% of the vote. In terms of how people view the party leaders in Wales. As in England and Scotland, every major politician and party has a negative approval rating but the worst news is for Reform and Plaid Cymru. While Reform doesn't yet have a Welsh leader, Nigel Farage has a net approval of -7, as does Plaid Cymru leader Rhun ap Iorwerth. Conservative group leader Darren Millar does better than his Westminster counterpart Kemi Badenoch, with his net approval rating of -13, significantly higher than Ms Badnenoch's -27. However First Minister Eluned Morgan has an approval rating of -18. It is higher than Keir Starmer, the Prime Minister's who has an approval of -44. Keir Starmer is the least popular party leader among the Welsh public with just 17% of those polled in Wales thinking he is doing a good job. However, 61% think he's doing a bad job. In an interview with Sky News' Beth Rigby the First Minister has repeated that her party is taking the threat from Reform UK "seriously". Asked if she and other members of the "political class" are to blame for voters turning away from Labour, the First Minister accepted there was a "lot to do" to get voters back. "What I won't be doing in Wales is chasing reform down a path. Where we can try and out Reform, Reform. I'm not interested in that, because those aren't my values. Not interested in it. So what we'll be doing is offering a very clear alternative, which is about bringing communities together," she said. Article continues below Ms Morgan said: "There is a possibility that they could be the largest party, and that is something that is really concerning." However, asked if she would do a coalition deal with Reform UK, she responded: "I wouldn't touch reform with a barge pole."
The Herald Scotland
22 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
How Scotland's satnav socialists abandoned working-class people
The Tories' worst nightmare was the egalitarian society imagined by the early socialist thinkers and Labour leaders. It was where good health, a long life, decent housing and a high-quality education could be accessed by those whom they'd always viewed as the lower orders. After two world wars in which the mass sacrifice of those lower orders had preserved Britain's way of life, the Tories and the UK Establishment which relied on their protection had been forced to concede the territory they'd fought to keep for themselves. Inevitably, that also meant accepting other little improvements in the lives of ordinary people: maternity leave, paid holidays, sickness benefits and the right to withdraw your labour in pursuit of fair pay and conditions. Read more by Kevin McKenna It was only when Margaret Thatcher gained power that the British Establishment began to recoup some of its historical losses. Even then, the fightback had to rely on several lies. The assets of North Sea oil were used to find the billions to pay off the miners. MI5 agents infiltrated the leadership of the NUM. The right to buy your council house was portrayed as a means of social mobility for the working-class instead of the greatest confidence ever played on them and one which would haunt their descendants a generation later. Corporate predators were invited to first prey on Britain's public assets and then enrich themselves rather than invest in infrastructure. Mrs Thatcher's ruinous legacy would even contaminate the early years of Tony Blair's government when the Bank of England was gifted ultimate control of the UK economy by being appointed to set interest rates. However, the genie released by the post-war socialist reformers could never fully be recaptured. The class struggle was still being fought and won at a local level by the children and grandchildren who had benefited from the post-war social improvements. They had become lawyers, doctors, journalists and politicians and retained many in their ranks who could achieve small victories on behalf of disadvantaged communities. The struggle for working class dignity was evident in thousands of local collectives: the housing associations; the women's health groups; the community action forums; the sports organisations. It was reinforced by publicly-funded initiatives to help those whom multi-deprivation had left on the margins: the drug addicts; the elderly and infirm; vulnerable young people. Crucially, working-class children were given free access to art and culture and encouraged to seek full expression of their experience. Those seeking refuge here from lands British had ransacked and rendered unstable were much more likely to be welcomed in places where social activism and human compassion had replaced ancient suspicions. And then something curious happened. Without having to move a muscle or deploy any of its old, dark stratagems, the British right and its corporate acolytes are once more dreaming of establishing the world of their dreams. They have looked on in delighted wonder as the left in Scotland and the UK has begun to implode. The seemingly never-ending struggle for social justice has been replaced by Pride flags and workplace witch-hunts. The new left loathes working-class people more than the Tories ever did. Your progressiveness is now measured by the number of colours you can cram into a flag. Scotland leads the world in vexillologist activism. These affluent frauds couldn't locate an authentic working-class community without the aid of a geo-positioning device. They are satnav socialists. They spend so much time on the Buchanan Street steps that they'll soon be getting their own Council Tax band. A cohort of boutique young reactionaries who benefited directly from the activism of older feminists and trade unionists are using the tactics of the right wing that their grandparents had fought: cancelling, no-debate, hounding and intimidation. It's as though the struggle for working-class rights is too much like hard work and risks interrupting their TikTok activity. Much easier to get yourself a pair of pronouns and fish for likes on BlueSky. The Scottish Trade Union Congress is led by Roz Foyer, a millionaire property tycoon. No one in the STUC thinks her position is untenable. It means no Scottish union official can speak with any authority about homelessness or wealth re-distribution. The movement she leads and the Labour Party and the Scottish Greens and the Liberal Democrats have created a hostile environment for older feminists and real working-class activists. 'The popularity of Reform UK in Scotland is the inevitable consequence of abandoning real working-class people' (Image: PA) This is the principal cause of all the civic failures for which the Scottish Government is responsible: the vast overspends, the spiralling waiting-lists, the incalculable reputational damage of their persistent refusal to accept biological reality. If you've hounded a large number of talented people from your organisation because they speak the truth about men and women then you're left with scarecrows and rockets. Being authentically Catholic in public life is once more a risky enterprise: just as it was in the 18th century. Their loathing of the people they pretend to represent is evident in their response to Scotland's appalling drugs death crisis. They spend millions on a facility that feeds addicts more drugs instead of trying to help them fully recover. They actually believe that killing them slowly in a room with designer wallpaper is progressive. They locate this walk-in mortuary in a neighbourhood miles away from where they or their apologists live. When local people complain about the inevitable scenes of desolation in their neighbourhood they get accused of being right wing by the satnav socialists. The popularity of Reform UK in Scotland is the inevitable consequence of first abandoning real working-class people; then excluding them; then telling them they're bigots for asking too many questions. Next year, Reform will have several MSPs after the Holyrood elections. Not all of them will be as reasonable as Thomas Kerr and Ross Lambie. Inevitably, there will be far-right, British supremacists in their number. And the blame for that is all on Scotland's new, indolent boutique left. Kevin McKenna is a Herald writer and columnist. He is Features Writer of the Year and writes regularly about the working-class people and communities of Scotland.
