Nandy demands ‘accountability at highest levels' after Bob Vylan broadcast
Lisa Nandy told the Commons she has heard from the BBC but was 'not satisfied with the response'.
Punk duo Bob Vylan led chants of 'death, death to the IDF (Israel Defence Forces)' during their Worthy Farm set last weekend, and face an investigation by Avon and Somerset Police.
London's Metropolitan Police is also investigating the two Bobs – who perform using the aliases Bobby Vylan and Bobbie Vylan – for allegedly making similar comments at Alexandra Palace in May.
Conservative shadow culture secretary Stuart Andrew told the Commons: 'Given the BBC are seemingly able to pull live broadcasts when things go wrong at football matches, for example, it's extraordinary that this didn't happen on this occasion.
'Can the Secretary of State update the House on the discussions she's had with the BBC, and why the same thing didn't happen on this occasion?
'What due diligence was carried out by them about the acts that were performing?
'And given as she's said we're still waiting for a response to the previous Hamas documentary, is she satisfied with those conversations she's had and the urgency that the organisation are taking?'
Ms Nandy replied: 'No, the answer is that I'm not satisfied with the response that I've had.'
The Culture Secretary previously made a ministerial statement in the Commons on Monday, when she said 'it should have been foreseeable that there would be problems with broadcasts'.
She told MPs then that she wanted 'rapid action to make sure this cannot happen again'.
In Thursday's update, Ms Nandy told MPs: 'I have received a reply to the very many questions that were raised by colleagues on all sides.
'I'm not satisfied with that, and I have gone back to the BBC leadership to ask for further information, in particular, as he mentioned, about the failure to pull the live feed, about the due diligence that was done prior to deciding to screen this act, and also about the level of senior oversight that took place in the BBC during the Glastonbury weekend.
'I think the BBC leadership will hear and have heard the strength of feeling in this House about this, and I expect further answers to be forthcoming imminently.'
The corporation removed the documentary Gaza: How To Survive A Warzone from its online iPlayer platform in February after it emerged its 13-year-old narrator was the son of a Hamas official.
In a follow-up question, Mr Andrew said: 'I'm as disappointed as she is that they haven't been able to come back with even basic facts.
'There were hundreds of BBC staff there and not being able to identify who ultimately had the final decision on whether to broadcast or not is not acceptable, and I think the chairman (Samir Shah) needs to inform her as a matter of urgency who that was and what action they are going to take.
'While I absolutely understand the independence of the BBC, just as artists can't hide behind artistic expression for vile commentary, neither can the BBC hide behind independence for accountability, and I hope she knows she has the full support of this side of the House as she pushes them for clarity.'
Ms Nandy said she was 'grateful' that Mr Andrew had made 'the very important distinction between independence and accountability'.
She continued: 'Given the seriousness of what happened – and particularly we heard in the House and I was able to bring to the House the absolute shocking stories of the impact that this has had on the Jewish community in this country – given the seriousness of this, I would expect there to be accountability at the highest levels.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
34 minutes ago
- The Sun
Fresh hope for thousands of households suffering with extreme service charges planned by government law change
THOUSANDS of households will be able to challenge extortionate leasehold service charges more easily, the government has said. Households who live in leasehold properties pay fees to the person who owns the building or their managing agents for services including building insurance and maintenance. These service charges can include repairs and maintenance for things such as the roof, windows, drains and gutters. The payments are usually due twice a year and the exact amount can vary depending on the costs the landlord incurs. This can mean that they can be hit with surprise bills that can often run into thousands of pounds. Almost five million homeowners pay service fees, which have risen by 11% in the last year to an average of £2,300 a month, according to Hamptons. Leaseholders have been promised that the system will change by several governments and Labour when it was in opposition. The government is hoping to tackle this problem by forcing companies to be transparent about the fees they are charging, Sky News reports. The reforms will be introduced after a consultation, the government said. Leaseholders will receive standardised service charge documentation that will explain clearly and in detail how the fees are calculated and where their money is being spent. Other reforms will stop leaseholders from automatically having to pay for a landlord's legal costs even if they have won their case. The changes will allow homeowners to challenge unreasonable service charges more easily, housing minister Matthew Pennycook said. He added that the changes will put pressure on managing agents to reduce the fees. It will also introduce a strict new qualification system for managing agents to try and improve standards in the sector. Mr Pennycook told Sky News: "The system has some inherent inequities in it that do allow leaseholders to be gouged and particularly when it comes to managing agents there are unscrupulous people out there. "They are abusing leaseholders and there's poor practice. How do service charges work? Service charges are fees paid by a leaseholder or resident and are set by the landlord. The amount varies every year depending on costs to the landlord. The details are usually set out in your lease. Landlords usually calculate the fee based on what they think they will spend. At the end of the year they should provide a statement. Some leases allow landlords to ask for contributions towards a "sinking fund" which is a reserve that can be built up for larger scale works. These could include repairing the roof of the building or fixing issues with the foundations. "The reforms we are announcing today and reforms that are to come are going to bear down managing agents and ensure the sector as a whole is properly regulated." Unfair charges Some leaseholders have said that they have been charged unfair fees. Judges have made some landlords pay back up to £100,000 after the leaseholders took them to tribunal. In one example, the leaseholders were charged £135 to change two lightbulbs. In February 2023, it was revealed that landlords and insurance brokers were taking up to 60% of the £1.6billion leaseholders paid for building insurance as hidden commissions. New rules now stop insurance companies from choosing policies just to earn the highest commission. But brokers and managing agents are still allowed to take commissions. The government has previously promised to ban excessive building insurance commissions through the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024. Instead, landlords will only be able to charge a straightforward and fair "permitted insurance fee" for the work they actually do, making costs clearer and protecting leaseholders from hidden charges. However, these proposed laws still need further legislation to come into effect, and the government hasn't yet provided a timetable for this. A spokesperson for the Ministry of Housing previously sold The Sun that "far too many leaseholders" are being hit with "unreasonable and extortionate charges". New rules planned by the government also plan to introduce commonhold agreements to replace leasehold ones. Commonhold allows flat owners to jointly own and manage their buildings, which cuts out landlords and property management companies. But the proposed rules only apply to new homes. How to challenge fees Leaseholders have the right to request extra information from their landlord within six months of receiving a summary of costs. You can challenge a cost if you think it's unreasonable, the standard of work is poor or you don't think you should have to pay it. For example, you could question why you need to pay for lift maintenance if you live in a ground-floor flat and it's not included in your lease. Or you can challenge for communal services, such as a garden that is always closed or a concierge that never has any staff. To challenge these services you need to apply to a tribunal which has the power to rule on whether the service charge is reasonable or payable. In England this is the first-tier tribunal (property chamber). In Wales it's the leasehold valuation tribunal. Applying to the tribunal usually costs a fixed fee of £114, but you may be able to waive it if you have certain benefits. If your case is transferred from court to the tribunal, you'll only pay the difference between the court fees and the tribunal fee - or nothing if you've already paid more than £114 in court fees. If a hearing is scheduled, you'll need to pay an additional £227 hearing fee. Speak to the Leasehold Advisory Service online at or call them on 020 7832 2500 to find out more and get free advice on service charge issues. You could also apply to the Housing Ombudsman if you want to complain about how your service charge fees have been managed. The Ombudsman said cases have jumped by 25 per cent in the last four years. .
The Sun
34 minutes ago
- The Sun
Liam Gallagher's ex wife Patsy Kensit reveals if she will be going to see Oasis tonight as reunion tour kicks off
LIAM Gallagher's ex wife Patsy Kensit has revealed if she will be going to see Oasis tonight, as the reunion tour kicks off. The former couple were married for three years from 1997 until 2000, and during that time welcomed their son Lennon. 7 7 7 As Oasis legends Liam and Noel Gallagher get ready to return to the stage later today, fans may be wondering if Patsy will be going. Asked on Good Morning Britain today, the EastEnders star said: "My son. He'll be there. You have a lovely time. wait for him to see all of that and I'm happy for you. "I think it's a wonderful thing, but I Won't be attending. I think I've said enough now about about about that. "I send only love and light." INTENSE ROMANCE Liam and Patsy, who met on a plane in 1995, had a very intense relationship. The actress once described this to The Mirror, and said: "We just clicked on every level. He was protective and loving. When we were together there were fireworks, and a chemistry that lasted to the end". It's not surprising Patsy isn't going to any Oasis concert on the tour, considering she hasn't spoken to her ex-husband in 25 years. The split from Liam was particularly brutal, with the actress previously admitting how her heart 'broke into a million pieces' when he left. While the Oasis rocker moved on unscathed, Patsy told The Sun last year that she was "abandoned by the in-crowd" and the people she thought were her friends. 'I had lots of 'fancy' friends in the '90s – everyone wanted you to be hanging out with them, but I lost all of them when my relationship ended,' she said 'I hate 'phoneyism' and I was ditched by the whole community overnight – every one of them. 'I don't hold on to the disappointment, but it was disappointing because I was still very young and I had two children on my own. 'But I feel very lucky to have friends in my life who have always been there since I was 16 – my real friends. 7 'Women I can tell anything to and know it will never go any further. 'That wasn't true in the '90s.' Patsy also previously revealed how she cried "every day for three and a half years" during her relationship. PROUD MAMA However her time with Liam wasn't all doom and gloom as together they welcomed her beloved son, Lennon. Patsy couldn't prouder of her boy, who is forging a career as a musician and model. Lennon moved back in with his mum last year, and the actress told The Sun that they are incredible close, and even share clothes. 7 "He raids my wardrobe, too. Quite a few items have ended up in his room – jackets, scarves, shirts, a whole plethora of things," she laughed. 'Lennon's sense of fashion is something he had from a very young age. 'He was doing an interview the other day and he was asked where he got his style from and he said: 'My mum', which I was thrilled about! 'He started modelling when he was 15 when [stylist and fashion editor] Katie Grand, who is one of my oldest friends, suggested doing a shoot, then it just really took off.' Lennon has since modelled in campaigns for Burberry and Saint Laurent and is also in a band, while James is an artistic director who has worked with the Arctic Monkeys. SUPPORTING DAD Tonight, Lennon will watch his dad perform in Oasis, for the first time as adult. Speaking to this month's W Magazine, Lennon said: "I can't wait… It's a massive, monumental thing, it's going to be fantastic." He also revealed how, along with Noel's daughter Anais, he will attend every Oasis gig. Meanwhile, Oasis fans lucky enough to bag at ticket to tonight's first gig of the tour are in for a treat. It was revealed that Liam and Noel have already been rehearsing at Cardiff 's Principality Stadium, ahead of this evening's concert. A source told the Mail: "Rehearsals started on Monday, just the tech and band. "Liam and Noel arrived on Wednesday, but Liam left the rehearsals after just eight songs for Noel to carry on by himself." Oasis 2025 tour dates OASIS brothers Liam and Noel Gallagher have revealed a 17 gig comeback tour next summer - here are the details The Wonderwall hitmakers will delight crowds as follows: JULY 2025 4th - Cardiff, Principality Stadium 5th - Cardiff, Principality Stadium 11th - Manchester, Heaton Park 12th - Manchester, Heaton Park 16th - Manchester, Heaton Park 19th - Manchester, Heaton Park 20th - Manchester, Heaton Park 25th - London, Wembley Stadium 26th - London, Wembley Stadium 30th - London, Wembley Stadium AUGUST 2025 2nd - London, Wembley Stadium 3rd - London, Wembley Stadium 8th - Edinburgh, Scottish Gas Murrayfield Stadium 9th - Edinburgh, Scottish Gas Murrayfield Stadium 12th - Edinburgh, Scottish Gas Murrayfield Stadium 16th - Dublin, Croke Park 17th - Dublin, Croke Park SEPTEMBER 2025 27th - London, Wembley Stadium 28th - London, Wembley Stadium
Telegraph
35 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Steve Coogan claims working class is being ‘ethnically cleansed'
Steve Coogan has claimed working-class people are being 'ethnically cleansed'. The Alan Partridge actor told BBC Breakfast that the redevelopment of major northern cities did not 'actually benefit' the working class. Coogan, who endorsed the Green Party in last year's general election, appeared on the programme to promote co-operatives, which he said fought back against 'big business'. 'The problem with all these cities like Liverpool and Manchester is they've got all these big shiny buildings,' he said. 'But all the people who are disenfranchised have been ethnically cleansed from the area. They don't actually benefit. 'What the Co-operative movement does is tries to keep that money in the area and empower people and try to mitigate and push back against the effects of big business.' Coogan's remarks appeared to be a criticism of gentrification rather than mass migration. Going on to accuse Reform UK of ' racist rhetoric ', he added: 'What it's about is the system, the political system isn't really working for most working people. 'From the economy to public services, it just isn't having any kind of effect for ordinary people. 'The Government leans into big business and cosies up to them without actually delivering for working people. So people are struggling. They're ignored.' 'Reform's racist rhetoric' Coogan continued: 'We've seen all these benefits cuts from the party that is supposed to represent ordinary hard-working people and the Co-operative movement is basically the best way out of that. 'If the Government want to stop Reform making all these gains, instead of dealing with the symptoms of the problem by leaning into the racist rhetoric of Reform, they can deal with that by helping working people and the best way of doing that is to support the Co-operative movement.' Coogan is a former Labour supporter who endorsed Jeremy Corbyn in the 2017 and 2019 general elections. He signed a letter in October 2024 saying Britain was 'aiding and abetting' alleged Israeli war crimes in Gaza. During the interview, he also took aim at supermarkets and other large companies, which he said had 'driven out' smaller businesses in 'dying' post-industrial areas. He said: 'If you're a small business owner you're going to get driven out of business by people like Tesco who come along, build a huge. 'Any money that's generated [by a Co-operative] is kept in the local economy so it supports local business, supports social initiatives, so the money doesn't get sucked out by huge extraction that takes place on a global scale so that you create microeconomies where people support each other both socially and economically. 'And these towns in the post-industrial landscape that are dying can be reinvigorated. And the Co-op has demonstrably done that throughout the world and yet it started in this country and it's largely ignored in this country. 'So what I'm trying to do is shine a light on it and say local Co-operative movement. That's the best way out of any dire economic situation.' Coogan previously attracted criticism for calling Conservative voters 'ill-informed' and 'ignorant' before the 2019 election and saying earlier this year that Margaret Thatcher was so lacking in empathy that she would be diagnosed with a disorder today.
