'So depressing': Glasgow reacts to O2 ABC site plan
Locals and heritage organisations in the city have also mirrored calls for a rethink of the design for the mixed-use student accommodation and hospitality site.
Stuart Robertson, director of The Charles Rennie Mackintosh Society, said: "It's all so depressing! The GSA 'Mack' has enough problems!
"Glasgow seems to have lost its way, lost its mojo, there is a lack of vision, our built heritage deserves much better.
"We would appeal to Glasgow City Council to refuse this planning application and request that the applicant re-submit a design that is sympathetic to an A-listed building of such world importance."
'So depressing': Glasgow reacts to O2 ABC site plan (Image: Vita Group)
READ MORE: Mack rebuild 'at risk' from ABC warns Glasgow Art School
Stuart's feelings have been mirrored by Niall Murphy, director of Glasgow City Heritage Trust.
He said: "The result of these plans is a generic building which could be anywhere.
"As a matter of urgency, the architects should look again at Glasgow's great classical tradition of commercial buildings, as they need to learn from them.
"They are building in the most fantastic setting next to buildings by two Glaswegians who were absolute masters of Architecture.
"A first-rate architect would rise to that challenge - but are we getting that here?
"I don't envy the councillors on the Planning Applications Committee their jobs in considering this application next week.
"However, I would ask that they remember the debate the committee had over the previous student housing proposal for the ABC site, which they refused in 2017.
"It was the best example I have experienced of local democracy in action.
"The committee weighed the matter and, such was the sensitivity of the site, decided to refuse a smaller scaled proposal than the one currently being considered.
"I hope this application receives the same degree of scrutiny."
The Mackintosh building (Image: Newsquest/Colin Mearns)
READ MORE: Plans for Glasgow O2 ABC recommended despite 'negative impact'
The Garnet Hill neighbourhood watch, representing local residents, has specific concerns regarding the proposed developments.
Chair Bill Beckett said while they are "very keen to see the site be developed", they believe it "needs to be done in the right way."
He added that their overall stance is a "resounding no" to the current plans.
Bill also said that residents expressed a strong desire for social housing to be prioritised, noting that there is a "crisis going on in homeless social care and social housing."
Many residents would prefer to see an independent music venue put back in place for entertainment, aiming to "bring back the old days."
The current site has been branded an 'eyesore' (Image: Newsquest/Colin Mearns)
READ MORE: Historic Glasgow venue is an 'eyesore' say furious locals
Dominic d'Angelo, chair of the Alexander Greek Thomson Society, said: "It's concerning because the proposal appears to completely override the objections both on light levels and the two A-listed buildings beside it.
"It'll be significantly larger than everything around it.
"We should not be selling the past in a desperate attempt to get more student accommodation into the city.
"There's an agreed need, but it should not come at the cost of, and be detrimental to, the cityscape we all live and work in.
"The fact that the site is derelict should not be a factor that allows them to build whatever they want - the current proposal will not 'add value' to the street and the area like they claim."
Niall agreed that an approval for this site would set a 'dangerous' precedent: "It risks sending out a message that Glasgow is happy to let its heritage be walked all over for the sake of commercial gain."
Stuart added: "The proposal is clearly contrary to development plan policy and supplementary guidance.
"In its current form, it cannot be justified except as a departure from said established policy and guidance.
"I cannot understand how this proposed redevelopment meets any of the criteria."
The Mack's rebuild is under threat (Image: Newsquest)
READ MORE: Pictures show how new plan for Glasgow's O2 ABC will look
If successful, the proposed Vita development, featuring their House of Social brand, will bring around £70million investment to Sauchiehall Street.
Over eight floors - including a basement - House of Social would include student accommodation, as well as a food hall, a public courtyard, a bar, a gym and more.
The student accommodation would feature 356 bed spaces, comprising 306 four, five, and six-bedroom 'houses' with a shared kitchen and lounge and 50 studio spaces. It would also feature a fitness centre, social and study spaces, café-style lounges, and cycle storage.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Glasgow Times
an hour ago
- Glasgow Times
Explained: the latest plans for Glasgow city centre streets
The latest plans for the City Centre Avenues project involve changes to key streets, including public transport routes and around city centre train stations. Which Streets are changing? Argyle Street (Image: GCC) The street from Queen Street to Stockwell Street/Glassford Street has been pedestrian-only since the 1970s. The new Argyle Street East Avenue project will run from Union Street/ Jamaica Street to Glasgow Cross. A one-way west-to-east bus route will pass through the pedestrianised section of the street, aimed at creating much shorter journey times and better public transport connections. The pedestrian zone is to be opened up and as well a the bus lane down the centre, a cycle lane will be created to the south of the busy street. Queen Street and Ingram Street Plans in the area will include a newly designed Queen Street and Ingram Street to make the area outside the Gallery of Modern Art more pedestrian-friendly. (Image: GCC) Permitting buses to travel east along Argyle Street will take traffic away from Queen Street and Ingram Street allowing changes to be made. New surfacing and wider 'level crossings' outside GoMA will give pedestrians more priority. More greenery and planters are planned to improve the appearance. (Image: GCC) The work will link into the redevelopment of George Square due to be completed in the second half of next year. (Image: GCC) (Image: GCC) Why are the changes being made? Angus Millar, Convener for City Centre Recovery and Transport, said: 'The Argyle Street East Avenue is about readying these famous streets for the century ahead. 'Recent decades have been tough for this part of town but we're seeing new turnaround developments on Trongate, major new retail offerings on Argyle Street and global employers investing in new headquarters just further west. That's real confidence in our city centre. 'The Argyle Street East Avenue is about creating the conditions for more of that. But also, giving Glaswegians a greener, more attractive city centre with an international look and feel they can be proud of.' When will work start? Contractors are being invited to bid for contracts and work is expected to start next year. How much will it cost? No specific costs have been publicly revealed but the work is part of the wider £120m Avenues Project. Who is paying for it? The funding for the Avenues projects is from the Glasgow City Region Deal, which was jointly funded by the UK and Scottish Governments with half a billion pounds each. Will there be cycle lanes? There will be a cycle lane along the current stretch of Argyle Street that is pedestrian only. What do people think? The Glasgow Times asked people on Argyle Street this week about the plan. Victoria Wilson was in town with her two year-old son Ollie. (Image: Newsquest) She said: 'There is plenty of room for a bus lane and for people to walk. I think it would be fine. 'The street is not as busy as it was years ago. If it makes it easier to get the bus, that's good.' Chris Seton, from Larbert, is a regular visitor. (Image: Newsquest) He said: I used to do a lot of driving in Glasgow. It has become difficult to get around. If buses can go right along the street it's a good idea. Improvement always helps.' Another man in town with his granddaughter who wished to be anonymous, said: ' I suppose if it's going to help people get around its not too bad. 'If it helps the buses move quicker, that's good.' Opinion online was less than favourable. Comments included: 'This is another reduction in space for pedestrians!' 'Don't allow vehicles through Argyle Street.' 'A road on Argyle Street, why are we going back the way? What a waste of money and public spaces.' What do you think? Let us know in the comments and at
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Beloved ABC star tragically dies after battle with cancer
Veteran reporter Peter Ryan has died aged 64 after a long battle with thyroid cancer. The Walkley Award-winning journalist, who worked as a reporter for 45 years with the ABC, was diagnosed with metastatic thyroid cancer in 2014. His family has confirmed he passed away in Sydney on Friday night. Peter began his career as a cadet at the Sydney Daily Mirror before landing a job at the ABC. He worked as the head of TV news and current affairs in Victoria, before becoming the ABC's Washington bureau chief and the founding editor of Lateline Business, which later became The Business. From A-list scandals and red carpet mishaps to exclusive pictures and viral moments, subscribe to the DailyMail's new showbiz newsletter to stay in the loop. In 2017, Peter won the Walkley Award for his coverage of the Commonwealth Bank scandal, which exposed deposit machines being used by drug syndicates to launder millions of dollars. His coverage contributed to the calling of the banking Royal Commission. In 2018, he was the National Press Club Finance Journalist of the Year. He was also awarded the Order of Australia Medal in 2022 for his service to journalism. Peter was a senior business correspondent from 2016 until he retired in June. Peter moved into palliative care and wanted to spend more time with his wife Mary Cotter and daughter Charlotte. Following his retirement, Treasurer Jim Chalmers said: 'Peter Ryan is an absolute legend. 'Every day as you wake up and you think about what's happening in the economy, if you only needed to listen to one voice to be sure that you got its essential elements, it would be Peter's.' The ABC has paid tribute to the veteran reporter in a statement following news of his passing. 'The ABC is deeply saddened by the death of our great friend and esteemed colleague Peter Ryan,' the statement read. 'After a distinguished 45-year career in journalism Peter retired from the ABC last month due to ill health. 'We extend our heartfelt condolences to Peter's family.' ABC News Director Justin Stevens also said Peter has left a 'significant legacy' and 'touched the lives of many'. 'Through his journalism, he had a profound impact on the lives of Australians and our society. It was a privilege to know him and work alongside him.'
The Herald Scotland
a day ago
- The Herald Scotland
Landlords must lose the fight over Scotland's rent controls
Last year, the government declared a national housing emergency, recognising record levels of homelessness, the toll high rents are taking on tenants, social housing waiting lists of nearly a quarter of a million across Scotland, and disrepair rampant across our housing stock. Yet as Professor Duncan Maclennan points out, the 'housing emergency' is a misnomer. Read More: This so-called emergency did not happen overnight; it has been created by design through the privatisation of our housing stock and unregulated growth of the private rented sector. Scotland's tenants have faced the hard end of these economic decisions for decades, and bold structural solutions are urgently needed in response. Tenants don't have time to wait. Rent controls, as outlined in the Housing Bill, are an important first step towards ending decades of housing misery. Robust, universal rent controls which have the ability to bring rents down could begin to transform our housing system by making private rented accommodation more affordable and disincentivizing exploitative landlordism overall. It's important to state that forms of rent control seen in recent temporary measures have included too many loopholes for landlords to exploit. Any exemptions to upcoming rent controls would create a multi-tier system, leaving thousands of tenants open to unregulated rents and undermining future policy efforts. The current consultation on rent controls has laid bare the Government's intention to appease landlords by introducing significant exemptions to rent controls. Ruth Gilbert, national campaign chair of Living Rent (Image: Newsquest) At this last hurdle rent controls are under threat. Since the government first committed to rent controls, the landlord and developer lobbies have eroded support for proper regulation of the private rented sector among politicians. The constant barrage of criticism - combined with empty threats of a mass exodus of landlords - have pushed a pliant government into conceding to appease the market at the expense of tenants. The most egregious exemption proposals concern 'build to rent' developments. The government has proposed a suite of amendments designed to encourage these sorts of developments, but this dangerous trend towards large-scale private developments is not something they should sensibly support. Build to rent properties are expensive, and beyond the reach of most tenants. Anyone who has walked through either Glasgow or Edinburgh recently will have seen these buildings springing up alongside billboards that promise convenient locations, fun perks, and luxury accommodation. Worryingly, this is just the start of the build to rent boom, over 3,800 units have been built, and there are 12,767 still in the pipeline. This explosion of the sector should highlight that it does not need any further government incentives. Indeed, across the UK the industry received over £1bn in investment from North America in the last quarter of 2024 alone. Developers' push for exemptions only highlights the business model they are touting. The bill, as introduced, already allows for above inflation rent increases, and so lobbyists' greedy demands for more exposes a model that is more concerned with creating dividends for overseas investors than delivering on the needs of Scotland's people. The government is deeply misguided if it thinks that expensive, luxury accommodation is going to fix our housing emergency. These are development sites which can and should be used for much-needed and genuinely affordable housing for social rent. Also proposed for exemption are mid-market properties. Mid-market tenants are some of the most vulnerable in our housing system. Apparently designated for tenants with low to middle incomes, mid-market properties exist to ensure that those unable to afford rents in the private sector and who cannot access social housing are able to better afford their housing costs. By threatening to exclude mid-market tenants from rent controls, this will see mid-market landlords able to increase rent however high they like with tenants left with no recourse to challenge it. For example, this summer at Water Row mid-market development in Govan, tenants were hit with a 10.6% rent increase after being given a rent increase of 39% before they had even moved in. The rent increase was delivered despite a previous commitment to keep rent below the local housing allowance. However, tenants had no legal recourse to challenge. It was only through Living Rent members organising together and fighting back did the landlord eventually concede and cancel the rent increase. This government needs to stop listening to the empty threats of landlords and legislate to protect those who have been most impacted by decades of mismanaged housing policy. Scotland's tenants need universal and comprehensive rent controls that bring rents down. Anything short of this will ruin the housing bill, undermine the possibility of a more just housing system for years to come, and damage the wavering trust that Scotland's tenants have that politicians will take the urgent action needed to end the national housing emergency. Ruth Gilbert is the national campaign chair of Living Rent
