New Zealand Reaches Deal With Canada In Long-Running Dairy Trade Dispute
Dairy exporters had been blocked from the Canadian market, despite the move being in breach of the CPTPP trade agreement.
On Friday morning McClay announced an agreement had been reached.
He says Canada has committed to making changes to its dairy quotas which will deliver up to $157 million to New Zealand dairy exporters.
New Zealand initiated formal dispute settlement proceedings over restricted access to the Canadian market for dairy exports under the CPTPP in 2022.
A dispute panel found in New Zealand's favour, however, Canada failed to fully comply with the panel's ruling. New Zealand threatened further action last year including the imposition of retaliatory tariffs against Canadian exporters.
"The government is pleased that this dispute has now been settled, and New Zealand exporters are guaranteed better access to the Canadian market," McClay said.
Canada said the changes have been negotiated with "close consultation" with its dairy sector and the amendments will result in "minor policy changes".
In a statement Canadian Agriculture minister Heath MacDonald said it was a "mutually satisfactory" resolution.
Under the agreement, Canada has committed to changing the way it administers its dairy quotas under CPTPP, including faster and more efficient access to quotas for New Zealand exporters, reallocation of underused quotas, and penalties for importers who misuse quotas.
"The CPTPP is a world leading agreement that unlocks significant opportunities for all parties, but its obligations must be upheld. Today's agreement reinforces support for the rules-based trading system," McClay said.
He added Canada was a long-stranding friend and trading partner of this country and "constructive engagement" had brought about a resolution.
Last year ACT Party trade spokesperson Dr Parmjeet Parmar called the dispute a "betrayal of our friendship".
She said if Canada could not comply with the CPTPP, it should be "booted out of the deal".
Deal welcomed
Fonterra is pleased to see the end of a long running trade dispute involving NZ and Canada.
Fonterra global external affairs director Simon Tucker told Midday Report Canada has a very protected dairy market and it has taken what he calls "dogged determination" by governments and officials to force Canada to comply with its obligations.
He said dairy farmers could sell millions of dollars of products into Canada but it is only a small part of the Fonterra sales which has revenues of more than $20 billion a year.
"Canada is one of those high value niches around the world which would be good for Fonterra.
"This was the right to do; to use the disputes settlement over this issue. We won, and then governments and officials have worked hard to force Canada into compliance.
"This is the right outcome."
Tucker said the win opens up opportunities for New Zealand to pursue further moves especially around Canada's protein subsidies which are considered unfair.
ExportNZ has also welcomed the deal, saying it will unlock higher export value for Kiwi business.
Executive director Josh Tan said the outcome was a win for New Zealand dairy exporters, and a win for the rules-based trading system.
"It's essential that our trade agreements function as they were agreed to - particularly in the current global trade context. Likewise, our trade partners should ensure they are playing by the rules."
Canada was a valuable trading partner for New Zealand, Tan said.
The Dairy Companies Association of New Zealand congratulated the Government for settling the dispute, which was first initiated under the previous Government.
Executive director Kimberly Crewther said the outcome proved that dispute mechanisms were still a valid and viable approach to be taken.
She said Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade estimated $157 million of trade revenue was not able to be used, due to breaches of the CPTPP.
"Previously, it was giving the majority of export licences under these quotas to its own processors, many of whom had very little interest in seeing imports occur and they could hold on to those export licences and not use them without any penalty," Crewther said.
"The changes introduce penalties... so that's a good improvement and we hope that it will lift the utilisation rates."
She said Canadian dairy farmers received subsidies, which brought low prices to global dairy trading among nations without farmer subsidies, like New Zealand.
"They're skewing the global dairy trade playing field quite significantly," she said.
"Unfortunately, Canada's not a stranger to having these sizeable impacts on trade opportunities for New Zealand exporters.
"Canada has a reputation for being amongst the most protectionist of dairy countries in the world, and they do that in a way that makes their market very difficult to access even with these CPTPP quotas, it remains 95 percent closed."
Crewther said New Zealand had "virtually no tariff protections" on dairy into the market, and openly imported dairy into the country.
"So we operate on an open basis, our farmers are not receiving direct subsidies and we are we're trading fairly in the world."
She said its first preference is an on-demand licensing system which ensured those applying for the quotas would utilise them appropriately.
"It's really important to hold them to account. This case has shown that dispute settlement can and does work, and it's important that New Zealand continues to move forward and uses these mechanisms where we need to."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Spinoff
an hour ago
- The Spinoff
What did Nicola Willis's cost-of-butter meeting with Fonterra actually achieve?
The butter price crisis prompted a high-profile meeting at the Beehive – but global markets, not politicians, are still calling the shots, writes Catherine McGregor in today's extract from The Bulletin. Was the butter meeting a damp squib? Finance minister Nicola Willis says she was surprised by 'the almost breathless excitement' around her Tuesday evening meeting with Fonterra chief executive Miles Hurrell, reflecting a week of coverage perhaps more suited to a major sporting event than a wonky meeting about dairy economics. The Post dubbed it 'the butter meeting heard round the country' while news sites ran red breaking news banners as Hurrell and Willis sat down to talk. With 500g blocks of butter topping $11 in some supermarkets, the stakes, at least symbolically, were high. Willis said the conversation covered many topics, but she did ask Hurrell to clarify how butter is priced and why New Zealanders often pay more than overseas consumers. The main outcome, according to the Herald's Thomas Coughlan? A suggestion that Hurrell will publicly explain the breakdown of butter pricing later this week. 'He was so good at communicating about [butter prices], I have encouraged him to provide that information to New Zealanders,' Willis said. Labour smells spin The political optics of the meeting have raised eyebrows, particularly given Willis's own six-year stint in senior roles at Fonterra, reports Bridie Witton in Stuff. Labour's finance spokesperson Barbara Edmonds questioned whether the meeting was more about performance than policy, arguing Willis should already understand how butter is priced. Willis pushed back, saying she worked in government relations and environmental strategy – not pricing – and refused to 'pre-judge' Fonterra's explanations. Her office also noted she meets with the dairy giant regularly, and the discussion this week wasn't solely about butter. Still, the intense buildup and media framing gave the impression of a high-level intervention, when in fact the levers to influence pricing remain limited. 'The lesson here is that performance politics doesn't work,' Newstalk ZB's Heather du Plessis-Allan said. 'In fact … it runs the risk of backfiring, which is exactly what's happening here.' So why is butter so expensive? As Blayne Slabbert explains in The Press (paywalled), 95% of our dairy products are exported and domestic prices reflect what those products earn overseas – a model known as export parity pricing. Recent Stats NZ data shows butter prices, driven by the global market, have surged 46.5% in a year, reaching an average of $8.60 per 500g. While world dairy prices dipped slightly in July, they remain far above historical levels. Global supply is tight, and demand – especially in China and Southeast Asia – continues to climb. 'You get to the situation we're in now where butter is at extraordinary heights and everyone wants their butter on toast,' High Ground Dairy consultant Stu Davison tells Newstalk ZB's Michael Sergel. 'We don't see it running right back to where we were five years ago.' That international appetite for grass-fed butter benefits our farmers and boosts export revenues, but leaves local consumers squeezed at the checkout. A changing role for Fonterra As butter becomes a lightning rod for public frustration at the cost of groceries, Fonterra may soon exit the retail fray altogether. The co-operative plans to sell off consumer-facing brands like Anchor and Mainland, focusing instead on its business-to-business operations. Writing in The Conversation, agribusiness professors Alan Renwick and David Dean say the move makes commercial sense. While some fear an overseas owner could lead to higher prices for consumers, they think it could help disrupt the current 'cosy' relationship between Fonterra and the supermarkets – potentially even bringing prices down. In the Herald, Clive Elliott, a barrister specialising in intellectual property, argues that the sell-off is a strategic error. 'Our prosperity and ability to remain a first-world economy depends on our ability to add value,' Elliott warns, arguing Fonterra is abandoning decades of brand equity. Regardless of who ends up owning the dairy brands, the butter pricing system is unlikely to shift dramatically. For now, New Zealanders will have to settle for an unsatisfying explanation rather than meaningfully lower costs.
1News
7 hours ago
- 1News
NZers are not getting a 'raw deal' on butter, says Nicola Willis
The Finance Minister does not believe New Zealanders are getting a "raw deal" on butter, but has accepted there is no getting away from how expensive it is right now. Nicola Willis met with Fonterra's chief executive Miles Hurrell at Parliament on Tuesday evening. While the two meet regularly, there was increased interest in the meeting due to the current price of butter. Willis had earlier said it was something she would discuss with Hurrell. Finance Minister Nicola Willis says the price of butter will be discussed at her meeting with the giant co-op. (Source: 1News) Characterising the meeting as "constructive and engaging," Willis said Hurrell was candid about the way butter was priced in New Zealand. ADVERTISEMENT Her summary of her meeting with Fonterra largely zeroed in on her drive to increase supermarket competition. The large proportion of what people pay for butter is dictated by global demand, which is something the government could not control. "Were that price to come down, you would expect that to be reflected in the prices that New Zealand shoppers pay," Willis said. Hurrell had told her that butter had once been the hardest product for Fonterra to sell globally, but the increasing demand was due to reporting on its health benefits. "It was once viewed as a bogeyman," she said. The meeting had reinforced Willis' interest in increasing supermarket competition to put downward pressure on the price of butter. "All roads lead back to supermarket competition. I continue to believe that is the most powerful lever that the government has on this issue. We will never be able to control global dairy prices. What we can influence is the amount of competition in New Zealand's grocery sector and we have a lot of work underway to address that." ADVERTISEMENT Fonterra had also observed the supermarket competition. Finance Minister Nicola Willis does not believe New Zealanders are getting a "raw deal" on butter. (Source: "Miles specifically conveyed that Fonterra operates in a number of markets around the world, most of which have a more competitive supermarket sector, and that it does feel different in New Zealand." She would leave it to supermarkets and Fonterra to argue who was charging what margin. "The sense that I got from my engagement with Miles is that it's a constant battle between them. Each party are probably going to point fingers at the other." Hurrell would not answer questions when RNZ approached him outside Parliament on Tuesday night, but a Fonterra spokesperson said the meeting was "constructive". Willis said she had encouraged Hurrell to front, in particular to explain what proportion of the margins go to Fonterra and what goes to supermarkets. ADVERTISEMENT Acknowledging that Fonterra's job was to get the best possible price for its shareholders, Willis also accepted New Zealanders saw the downsides of that when they were shopping. "I've been satisfied that I don't think consumers are getting a raw deal. I think that there is good work going on to ensure that there is pressure and competition from Fonterra to try and keep its prices low. But I get it. Butter is expensive right now. There's no getting away from that."
RNZ News
12 hours ago
- RNZ News
The Politics Panel for 23 Jully 2025
Wallace Chapman and the Politics Panel discuss and analyse the main political stories of the day. He is joined this week by RNZ's Corin Dann, the NZ Herald's Fran O'Sullivan and former government minister Phil Goff. On the slate today: Nicola Willis says Kiwis are not getting a raw deal from high butter prices (after meeting the CEO of Fonterra); Defence Minister Judith Collins told a crowd of graduating Army recruits last week that they should prepare for "combat"; just 38 percent of respondents to a Talbot Mills poll say the government deserved a second term; is the government using locla councils as a whipping boy and National seems to have found a bright spot in one area of it's party policy: Education. To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
