Calcutta HC questions West Bengal about monthly allowance given to sacked non-teaching staff
Justice Amrita Sinha reserved the order in the matter but verbally questioned the state government for ' spending public money' through the disbursal of the amount, The Hindu reported.
The judge was hearing a writ petition challenging the provision of the allowance to the dismissed staff, according to the newspaper. The petition was filed by a candidate on the waitlist who was not recruited despite being on the merit list, allegedly due to irregularities in the hiring process.
On April 3, the Supreme Court upheld the Calcutta High Court's April 2024 order terminating the appointment of about 25,000 teachers and non-teaching staff by West Bengal's School Service Commission. The bench passed the order after observing that the recruitment process was 'vitiated by manipulation and fraud'.
The top court on April 17 permitted 'untainted' teachers to be retained until the end of the academic year or until fresh appointments are made, whichever is earlier. However, it did not grant relief to Group C and Group D employees, or non-teaching staff, whose appointments were also cancelled.
In response, the state government had announced in April that the sacked non-teaching staff would receive a monthly allowance until the Supreme Court delivered a verdict on review petitions filed by it, The Hindu reported.
During the hearing on Monday, the High Court questioned how the state government was paying a monthly allowance of Rs 20,000 to Rs 25,000 to the sacked non-teaching employees for 'sitting at home'.
'Thousands of [aspirants] remain unemployed but those whose appointments were cancelled are being paid to sit at home?' Sinha was quoted as saying by Live Law.
Advocate General Kishore Dutta, representing the state government, said that the amount was being disbursed in line with a government policy that cannot be disregarded.
The High Court noted that the money could not be given in a hurry as there were ' some protocols ' that had to be followed, The Indian Express reported.
Sinha also questioned the state government about whether there was any similar scheme for candidates who did not get jobs because of the irregularities in the recruitment process, The Hindu reported.
Dutta said that the allowance was 'being given purely on humanitarian grounds ' after the dismissed staff faced a ' sudden loss of livelihood '. He also highlighted that the scheme was 'temporary' and would end once the Supreme Court decided on the matter.
In April 2024, the High Court had passed its direction on the termination of the appointments based on the findings of a re-evaluation of the Optical Mark Recognition sheets from the 2016 recruitment examination in the case.
The re-evaluation found that the selected teachers had been recruited against blank Optical Mark Recognition sheets.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
20 minutes ago
- Hans India
Stalin inaugurates 729 new homes for Sri Lankan Tamils across five TN districts
In a significant step toward improving the living conditions of Sri Lankan Tamils in Tamil Nadu, Chief Minister M.K. Stalin on Monday inaugurated 729 newly-built houses in rehabilitation camps across five districts. The inauguration was conducted via video conference from the State Secretariat, in the presence of Revenue and Disaster Management Minister K.K.S.S.R. Ramachandran and Chief Secretary N. Muruganandam. Constructed at a cost of Rs 38.76 crore, the houses are located in refugee camps situated in Villupuram, Tiruppur, Salem, Dharmapuri, and Virudhunagar districts. These homes are part of a broader rehabilitation initiative by the Tamil Nadu government, announced under Rule 110 in the state Assembly in August 2021, aimed at upgrading infrastructure and living conditions in Sri Lankan Tamil camps spread across the state. As per the government's long-term plan, over 3,510 houses are to be built at a total estimated cost of Rs 180.34 crore in 35 rehabilitation camps. Of this, 2,781 houses in 32 camps across 18 districts have already been completed and handed over to beneficiaries. The state has also undertaken supplementary infrastructure upgrades in these camps to improve the quality of life. These include new internal roads, upgraded electricity lines, and enhanced drinking water supply facilities. The total cost of these civil works stands at Rs 7.33 crore. According to an official release, the rehabilitation programme is part of the DMK government's commitment to provide a dignified life to Sri Lankan Tamils who have been residing in 67 government-run camps across 26 districts of Tamil Nadu for decades, after fleeing ethnic conflict in their homeland. The Chief Minister, in his remarks during the inauguration, reiterated his government's resolve to continue supporting refugee communities through improved housing, access to basic amenities, and welfare schemes. He also emphasised the importance of integration and inclusion, ensuring that displaced populations can live with dignity and security. The ongoing rehabilitation efforts are seen as a model approach in refugee welfare, combining both humanitarian concerns and infrastructural development, and have received appreciation from human rights observers and community leaders alike.
The Hindu
25 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Kharge sees bid to exclude two crore voters to secure poll victory in Bihar
Attacking the BJP-ruled Central government over the Election Commission-mandated (EC) Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of Bihar's electoral rolls, Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge on Monday (July 7, 2025) called it an attempt to exclude two crore voters to secure a poll victory. Addressing a public meeting in Chhattisgarh's capital Raipur, Mr. Kharge called the exercise a 'fraud' even as he warned that the ruling party would regret the move. 'This [Prime Minister Narendra] Modi government is going to destroy everyone. Fraud has started in the voter list. Fraud happened in Maharashtra. Today, they are fighting elections in Bihar and there, 2 crore votes are being excluded. If you people want to win elections by excluding them, a time will come when you regret it. You will have to regret the wrong you are doing today,' the Congress president said. The assertions came on a day when the Congress along with nine other political parties challenged the SIR in the Supreme Court. 'Mass scale rigging' Further stepping up the party's attack on the EC over the issue, Congress general secretary (organisation) K.C. Venugopal in a X post called the SIR of Bihar's electoral rolls as 'blatantly unconstitutional' and 'mass scale rigging'. 'It has wreaked havoc across the villages and towns of Bihar — giving crores of voters anxiety about whether their right to vote will be stolen. This is mass scale rigging and mischief being carried out by the EC, under instructions from the ruling regime. We have faith that the Supreme Court will deliver justice,' Mr. Venugopal said. His party colleague and Rajya Sabha member Randeep Surjewala shared a news report in his X handle that claimed the EC had updated Bihar's electoral roll in January this year, the data were found to be 'robust and processed in June'. 'Then, suddenly, it was discarded,'Mr. Surjewala said, adding, 'This isn't voter list cleanup; it's an attempt to rob the public of their voting rights'. Mr. Surjewala asserted that 'the process called 'Special Intensive Revision' has neither any legal basis nor any mention in the rules'. 'This term doesn't even exist in electoral law,' he added. 'Jal, Jungle Zameen' At the Raipur rally titled, 'Jai Jawan-Jai Kisan-Jai Samvidhan', Mr. Kharge asked people to remain united in the fight to protect their 'jal, jungle and zameen' (water, forest, land), he also alleged that the ruling party in the State as well as at the Centre was eyeing the mineral resources of Chhattisgarh for industrialists. 'Today, people like Adani and Ambani have been coming here [Chhattisgarh] and occupying land. They are felling lakhs of trees [in forests for mining]. Modi ji has been destroying the lives of our tribal brothers and the people of Chhattisgarh,' he alleged.
Hans India
25 minutes ago
- Hans India
Prime accused in Bengal coal smuggling case residing in Vanuatu Islands: CBI
Former Trinamool Congress leader and the prime accused in a multi-crore coal smuggling case in West Bengal, Vinay Mishra is currently hiding at Vanuatu Islands with a different name, the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) informed a special court at Asansol in West Burdwan district of West Bengal on Monday. According to the CBI, although it was known for quite some time that he was hiding in the Vanuatu Islands, taking citizenship there after surrendering his Indian citizenship, is residing there with a different name has surfaced recently. The CBI also informed the court that this factor of his residing there had posed a new hurdle for bringing him back to India. The court had already declared Vinay Mishra as an 'absconding accused'. CBI also admitted that further progress in the investigation of the coal smuggling case was getting hampered because of the legal hurdles in bringing back Mishra to India considering that he is the prime accused in the case. As per CBI's records, Mishra left India in 2020, soon after CBI as well as the Enforcement Directorate (ED) started parallel probes in the coal smuggling case. In the same year, he gave up his Indian citizenship and started residing in the Vanuatu Islands. Both CBI and ED have identified Mishra as the main person responsible for channelling the proceeds in the coal smuggling case to different bank accounts, including overseas accounts and shell companies. CBI earlier declared an award of Rs 100,000 on him. Earlier, he had intimated to both CBI and ED through an advocate that he would return to India only if he was guaranteed that he would not be arrested by any of the two agencies. Mishra was reportedly very close to a number of top leaders in the ruling Trinamool Congress. His brother Bikas Mishra is also one of the accused in the coal smuggling case. Recently, Bikas claimed that if he opens his mouth, the incumbent Trinaool Congress-ruled government will be toppled, and that is why there are attempts to get him murdered in judicial custody.
