The 151 ballots that the NSW Liberals say should overturn the Bradfield result
Kapterian last week ended weeks of speculation and lodged a petition with the High Court, which sits as the Court of Dispute Returns to hear election challenges, in a bid to be declared victorious in Bradfield instead of teal MP-elect Nicolette Boele.
Boele, who will give her inaugural speech to federal parliament on July 28, won the once blue-ribbon seat after a recount of the northern Sydney seat, which saw her finish 26 votes ahead of Kapterian.
However in her petition, Kapterian says the Australian electoral officer (AEO) – who is the electoral commission's manager in each state – 'wrongly rejected at least 56 of the reserved ballot papers, where those ballot papers indicated a preference, by the voter, for the petitioner ahead of the first respondent'. Boele is listed as the first respondent.
'In each such case the ballot paper was not informal and should not have been rejected,' the petition says, referencing examples such as the officer 'not being satisfied that the figure 1 in one square was distinguishable from the figure in another square'.
Kapterian has not seen the ballot papers, and her legal team will only be provided with them once the AEC hands them to the court. However, her concerns were formed based on feedback and notes taken by scrutineers who were overseeing the final recount.
The AEO was tasked with reviewing and making rulings on 795 reserved ballot papers.
As well as the rejected ballots, Kapterian's petition says the AEO 'wrongly admitted at least 95 of the reserved ballot papers, where those ballot papers indicated a preference, by the voter, for the first respondent ahead of the petitioner'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
23 minutes ago
- Perth Now
Nats 'steers' rumbling in party paddock over net zero
A powder keg has been dropped within the coalition over climate policy as dissenters push for a net zero emissions target to be dropped. Opponents of the 2050 target are ramping up pressure on their leaders to ditch the target, saying it's hurting regional Australia and driving up power bills as Australia phases out coal and boosts renewable energy investment. The debate reignited after former Nationals leader Barnaby Joyce flagged a private member's bill to scrap the legislated target. "The last two elections we went forward with a policy supporting net zero and we've been handed our political derriere on a plate," he told reporters in Canberra on Wednesday. He argued Australia should focus on economic viability with big emitters like China, India and the US not making major cuts to emissions while Australia's power prices increased. India has a net zero by 2070 target, China by 2060 and the US had a 2050 target under the Biden administration but climate action has been largely scrapped under President Donald Trump. "Even if you believe every chapter, verse, what net zero was going to achieve, it's not going to achieve it because the world's not participating in it," Mr Joyce said. "So why are we on this sort of singular crusade by ourselves that has no effect on the climate but is incredibly deleterious to the standard of living and the cost of living of the Australian people - it's insane." Opposition Leader Sussan Ley refused to say whether the target will remain coalition policy as a review into its policies continues following their May election defeat. Liberals largely want to keep the net zero emissions policy; they lost a swathe of inner city seats amid concerns they weren't taking climate change seriously enough. "The electorate has told us in multiple elections that this is what they want, and we do have an obligation to leave the planet in a better place," Liberal senator Jane Hume told AAP. Labor has seized on the split over climate policy, with Climate Change and Energy Minister Chris Bowen saying the Liberals are being held hostage by their junior coalition partner. Mr Joyce has been joined by an unlikely ally in Michael McCormack, another former Nationals leader whom he rolled for the job in 2021. But the two have broken bread over a shared disdain for current leader David Littleproud after both were dumped from his frontbench. Mr Joyce, who was rolled by Mr Littleproud after the 2022 election loss, said he'd support a leadership bid by Mr McCormack, which he hasn't ruled out but acknowledged no imminent challenge. Mr McCormack denied the duo are white-anting their leader, arguing he's standing up for regional Australians who are bearing the negative impacts of renewable energy projects on their land and near their towns. Despite the duo touting leadership troubles for Mr Littleproud, other Nationals MPs hosed down the speculation, saying the talk was from a vocal minority aggrieved over climate policy and personal snubs. Liberal frontbencher Dan Tehan compared the two Nationals MPs railing against their leader as "two steers in a paddock". Mr McCormack said he took umbrage with the comments, joking that steers had been emasculated and he was "quite virile and ready to go as far as politics is concerned".
West Australian
an hour ago
- West Australian
Barnaby Joyce defends splitting from Coalition on net zero ‘crusade'
Nationals maverick Barnaby Joyce has defended his backbench rebellion on net zero, decrying the opposition's embrace of the 2050 target as a 'singular crusade' that he never voted for. Mr Joyce will introduce a private member's bill to repeal net zero and has gained the support of fellow former party leader Michael McCormack. Both MPs were banished to the backbench after the Liberals and Nationals had their brief post-election split – a move Nationals leader David Littleproud at the time put down to 'generational change'. But up the back, neither of the heavyweights need to follow the party line, posing a real threat to Mr Littleproud's tenuous authority and Liberal leader Sussan Ley's efforts to project a modern, united opposition. Cornered by reporters in a press gallery hallway, Mr Joyce was asked on Wednesday why he was rehashing a conversation that Australians had already had at two federal elections. 'No one can dispute power prices are going through the roof,' he said. 'No one can dispute that the power grid is becoming unreliable.' He also said it is indisputable 'that the geopolitical times that we live in have become vastly more precarious'. 'No one can dispute that you need a strong economic base if you want to defend our nation,' Mr Joyce said. 'And we are trying to achieve net zero – something that neither Russia nor China nor the United States, nor Indonesia nor Brazil or the majority of African countries or Southeast Asian nations are part of. 'You're in the minority group here, the minority of people in the globe, the vast majority of the GDP of the globe.' He went on to say that 'even if you believe every chapter, verse of what net zero was going to achieve, it's not going to achieve it because the world's not participating in it'. 'So why are we on this sort of singular crusade by ourselves that has no effect on the climate but incredibly deleterious to the standard of living and the cost of living with the Australian people. 'It's insane.' More to come
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
‘Insane': Barnaby's backbench rebellion
Nationals maverick Barnaby Joyce has defended his backbench rebellion on net zero, decrying the opposition's embrace of the 2050 target as a 'singular crusade' that he never voted for. Mr Joyce will introduce a private member's bill to repeal net zero and has gained the support of fellow former party leader Michael McCormack. Both MPs were banished to the backbench after the Liberals and Nationals had their brief post-election split – a move Nationals leader David Littleproud at the time put down to 'generational change'. But up the back, neither of the heavyweights need to follow the party line, posing a real threat to Mr Littleproud's tenuous authority and Liberal leader Sussan Ley's efforts to project a modern, united opposition. Cornered by reporters in a press gallery hallway, Mr Joyce was asked on Wednesday why he was rehashing a conversation that Australians had already had at two federal elections. Nationals MP Barnaby Joyce is leading a backbench rebellion on net zero. Martin Ollman / NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia 'No one can dispute power prices are going through the roof,' he said. 'No one can dispute that the power grid is becoming unreliable.' He also said it is indisputable 'that the geopolitical times that we live in have become vastly more precarious'. 'No one can dispute that you need a strong economic base if you want to defend our nation,' Mr Joyce said. 'And we are trying to achieve net zero – something that neither Russia nor China nor the United States, nor Indonesia nor Brazil or the majority of African countries or Southeast Asian nations are part of. 'You're in the minority group here, the minority of people in the globe, the vast majority of the GDP of the globe.' He went on to say that 'even if you believe every chapter, verse of what net zero was going to achieve, it's not going to achieve it because the world's not participating in it'. 'So why are we on this sort of singular crusade by ourselves that has no effect on the climate but incredibly deleterious to the standard of living and the cost of living with the Australian people. 'It's insane.' More to come
