
Turkey: Legal control as a weapon against journalists
For years,
Turkey
has been making international headlines for it's lackluster track record on press freedom and freedom of speech: Turkey is ranked 159th out of 180 in the latest Reporters
Without Borders
Press Freedom Index. According to the Turkish Journalists' Union, 18 journalists were in prison at the end of March.
However, the restrictions on press freedom are by no means limited to imprisonment: Judicial restrictions are also part of a repressive system designed to systematically silence critical voices. Measures including house arrest, bans on leaving the country, and obligations to report regularly to the authorities are increasingly being used as a means of exerting pressure.
Originally intended as an alternative to pre-trial detention, they are becoming an instrument of de facto punishment — especially for journalists.
Hundreds of journalists are not in prison, but at home, no longer allowed to practice their profession. Recently, many well-known media professionals in Turkey have been subjected to such treatment.
A protective measure or an unfair punishment?
According to the law, judicial inspections are intended to prevent suspects from escaping or tampering with evidence. They are used in cases where there is a strong suspicion of a crime and officials see a risk of people trying to flee the law or conceal their identities. However, such measures are also increasingly being used in the wake of accusations of libel for example or posting critical social media posts, in other words, for offences that do not fall into the "catalog of crimes" defined in law.
Veysel Ok
, a lawyer who has represented many journalists in Turkey — including German daily Die Welt correspondent Deniz Yücel — no longer sees judicial control as a straightforward means of safeguarding proceedings, but as a "penalty-like sanction."
"By law, these measures may only be imposed if the conditions for imprisonment are met. But this is often ignored in practice," explained Ok. Court orders have now become the norm, he said, especially in cases relating to freedom of expression.
"Some are confined to their homes for years and can no longer work as journalists. Even if they are acquitted in the end, they have spent their most productive years under these restrictions," said the lawyer. Even social media posts or political criticism can trigger such measures.
Increasing numbers of journalists face restrictions
"In the past, this was not so common," said Ok. "Today, control measures are imposed automatically — in political cases, against protesters or even against journalists. Almost everyone under investigation is now subject to some form of restriction."
This includes measures such as house arrest or bans on leaving the country, which prevent media professionals from doing their job. These, Ok said, also violate d the decisions of the
Constitutional Court
. He highlighted the case of activist
Nurcan Kaya
, in which the court ruled that such measures were only permissible if there were valid grounds for detention. Despite this, the practice continues, he said.
These measures have two objectives, explained Ok: "On the one hand, those involved are punished before a verdict has even been reached. The second goal is to create a climate of fear in a society that suppresses freedom of expression."
The overcrowded prisons in Turkey also encouraged the spread of judicial control, he explained. "There are currently over 400,000 people in prison. But hundreds of thousands are living in detention-like conditions — in their city or their home. They are not arrested, but controlled — it is a method that has long since become a punishment."
A bid to silence potential critics?
Erol Onderoglu, the head of Reporters Without Borders (RSF) in Turkey, is also concerned, viewing the widespread practice of judicial control as a direct attack on the right to free reporting, as well as a curtailing of the population's ability to inform itself freely.
According to Onderoglu, judicial inspections should only be applied in exceptional cases, for example when particularly serious accusations have been made. But in Turkey, a simple libel charge or a social media post is now enough to trigger restrictions on journalists.
For Onderoglu, the impact of this is clear: "This unlawful practice serves to deliberately harass and intimidate critical journalists. It is an expression of a preemptive will to punish."
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
BJP prepares for PM Narendra Modi's visit to UP's Varanasi on August 2
VARANASI: The Bharatiya Janata Party ( BJP ) is making extensive preparations to ensure the success of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's one-day visit to Varanasi on August 2. The PM is scheduled to address a large public gathering at Banauli (Kalika Dham) in the Sevapuri Assembly constituency. Dilip Patel , BJP Kashi region president, said the party aims to gather over 50,000 people for the event. Lists of two- and four-wheeler vehicles of party workers, office-bearers, supporters, and leaders from all eight assembly constituencies in the district are being prepared at the divisional level to facilitate smooth transportation. He said there is great enthusiasm among the public for the upcoming meeting. As in previous visits, the Prime Minister is expected to announce development projects worth thousands of crores for his parliamentary constituency, further accelerating Varanasi's growth. During his visit, the PM will inaugurate projects worth over Rs 600 crore, including the Sowa Rigpa Medical College at the Central Institute of Higher Tibetan Studies in Sarnath and the Varanasi-Bhadohi four-lane road. Additionally, he will lay the foundation stone for other development projects worth over Rs 1,650 crore. In view of the visit, Police Commissioner Mohit Agarwal and District Magistrate Satyendra Kumar jointly inspected the proposed venue at Sevapuri. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Access all TV channels anywhere, anytime Techno Mag Learn More Undo They reviewed arrangements and gave instructions to ensure adequate security and convenience for attendees. Officials were directed to set up parking so that no visitor needs to walk more than 500 metres. E-rickshaws will be available for senior citizens and persons with disabilities. The inspection covered the parking areas, entry gates, German hangar, stage, and helipad. Officials were asked to complete preparations for verification, barricading, drone surveillance, fire safety, emergency exits, signage, and alternative routes to ensure smooth and safe execution of the event.


India Today
3 hours ago
- India Today
14 Delhi government school students set to begin vocational training in Germany
Fourteen students from Delhi government schools are all set to embark on a transformative journey to Germany as part of the APAL Project 2025. This international initiative, led by Germany's Federal Employment Agency (BA), offers selected students a unique opportunity to undergo dual vocational training that combines academic learning with real-world industrial students will spend between three and three-and-a-half years in Germany, gaining hands-on skills and classroom instruction in various technical fields. The programme is designed to boost their employability and equip them with globally recognised a special ceremony held at the Delhi Secretariat on Thursday, Chief Minister Rekha Gupta and Education Minister Ashish Sood felicitated the students. CM Gupta praised the group for their dedication and perseverance, noting that their achievement stands as a powerful example of what is possible despite economic challenges. 'These young individuals have shown that determination and hard work can overcome all barriers,' she said. 'Their success is a testament to our government's ongoing mission to provide quality education and international exposure to students from all backgrounds.'The APAL Project-short for Ausbildung Programme for Auszubildende in Deutschland aims to strengthen global partnerships in vocational education. The programme not only bridges academic and practical training but also promotes intercultural exchange and long-term career Minister Ashish Sood highlighted the broader vision behind the initiative. 'This collaboration between the Delhi and German governments focusses on enhancing skills and employment opportunities,' he said. 'Once the training is completed, these students are expected to secure jobs in their respective trades.'He further noted that the initiative aligns closely with the national Skill India mission launched by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, marking a progressive step in creating a skilled, future-ready students' selection under this prestigious programme signals a growing emphasis on practical, globally relevant education and represents a promising path forward for many more young learners in Delhi.(With PTI inputs)- EndsMust Watch
&w=3840&q=100)

Business Standard
19 hours ago
- Business Standard
Deja vu: England, Spain to clash again in Women's Euro Championship final
There's a sense of deja vu about the Women's European Championship final that pits defending champion England against World Cup winner Spain. The two nations faced off in the World Cup final two years ago with Spain edging an open match 1-0. I think obviously that was a massive disappointment and I feel like from a collective we probably feel like we didn't have our best performance that day, but I think if you're trying to pull on that too much then you're going to be too emotional with too many things going on, England midfielder Keira Walsh said on Thursday. Obviously you think about it a little bit but I think for us, put it to the side and focus on the game on Sunday. We've got so many new players in this team who are really confident and bring so many things to this team, so it's exciting and we can just focus on the positives. Both teams needed 120 minutes to get through their gruelling semifinals. England's super-subs had their part to play again on Tuesday with late goals first taking the match to extra time and then securing a last-gasp 2-1 victory over Italy. Spain needed a moment of magic from two-time Ballon d'Or winner Aitana Bonmati to get past a resilient German side 1-0 on Wednesday. It will be a first Euros final for Spain but even before the tournament it had been the favorite to add the European title to its collection after winning the World Cup and Nations League in the past two years. Spain's triumph at the World Cup was marred by the Luis Rubiales scandal, after the-then head of the Spanish soccer federation kissed player Jenni Hermoso during the awards ceremony. Rubiales was subsequently charged with sexual assault and convicted a few months before the start of Euro 2025, bringing an end to one of the worst chapters in the history of Spanish soccer. Walsh, who made 100 appearances for Barcelona over two-and-a-half seasons, was playing in Spain at the time and witnessed the fallout first hand. I think the most important thing for them is that they can enjoy this final, there's not the controversy surrounding it, she said. I think just for the girls this time and as a friend and another football player, for them just to go and enjoy it. They play incredible football and they deserve to be there, so as a human being I just want them to go out and enjoy the game of football. Walsh doesn't feel Spain's star-packed squad received enough credit after the World Cup triumph. Obviously after the game there was a lot of controversy and I don't think for them there was enough spotlight on how incredible they played and how incredible some of their players were, it was all about the other stuff that had gone on, she said. I think as a professional that was disappointing to see. Obviously I have a lot of friends in that team and I think they probably deserved a little bit more than what they got. (Only the headline and picture of this report may have been reworked by the Business Standard staff; the rest of the content is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)