
Turkey: Legal control as a weapon against journalists
For years,
Turkey
has been making international headlines for it's lackluster track record on press freedom and freedom of speech: Turkey is ranked 159th out of 180 in the latest Reporters
Without Borders
Press Freedom Index. According to the Turkish Journalists' Union, 18 journalists were in prison at the end of March.
However, the restrictions on press freedom are by no means limited to imprisonment: Judicial restrictions are also part of a repressive system designed to systematically silence critical voices. Measures including house arrest, bans on leaving the country, and obligations to report regularly to the authorities are increasingly being used as a means of exerting pressure.
Originally intended as an alternative to pre-trial detention, they are becoming an instrument of de facto punishment — especially for journalists.
Hundreds of journalists are not in prison, but at home, no longer allowed to practice their profession. Recently, many well-known media professionals in Turkey have been subjected to such treatment.
A protective measure or an unfair punishment?
According to the law, judicial inspections are intended to prevent suspects from escaping or tampering with evidence. They are used in cases where there is a strong suspicion of a crime and officials see a risk of people trying to flee the law or conceal their identities. However, such measures are also increasingly being used in the wake of accusations of libel for example or posting critical social media posts, in other words, for offences that do not fall into the "catalog of crimes" defined in law.
Veysel Ok
, a lawyer who has represented many journalists in Turkey — including German daily Die Welt correspondent Deniz Yücel — no longer sees judicial control as a straightforward means of safeguarding proceedings, but as a "penalty-like sanction."
"By law, these measures may only be imposed if the conditions for imprisonment are met. But this is often ignored in practice," explained Ok. Court orders have now become the norm, he said, especially in cases relating to freedom of expression.
"Some are confined to their homes for years and can no longer work as journalists. Even if they are acquitted in the end, they have spent their most productive years under these restrictions," said the lawyer. Even social media posts or political criticism can trigger such measures.
Increasing numbers of journalists face restrictions
"In the past, this was not so common," said Ok. "Today, control measures are imposed automatically — in political cases, against protesters or even against journalists. Almost everyone under investigation is now subject to some form of restriction."
This includes measures such as house arrest or bans on leaving the country, which prevent media professionals from doing their job. These, Ok said, also violate d the decisions of the
Constitutional Court
. He highlighted the case of activist
Nurcan Kaya
, in which the court ruled that such measures were only permissible if there were valid grounds for detention. Despite this, the practice continues, he said.
These measures have two objectives, explained Ok: "On the one hand, those involved are punished before a verdict has even been reached. The second goal is to create a climate of fear in a society that suppresses freedom of expression."
The overcrowded prisons in Turkey also encouraged the spread of judicial control, he explained. "There are currently over 400,000 people in prison. But hundreds of thousands are living in detention-like conditions — in their city or their home. They are not arrested, but controlled — it is a method that has long since become a punishment."
A bid to silence potential critics?
Erol Onderoglu, the head of Reporters Without Borders (RSF) in Turkey, is also concerned, viewing the widespread practice of judicial control as a direct attack on the right to free reporting, as well as a curtailing of the population's ability to inform itself freely.
According to Onderoglu, judicial inspections should only be applied in exceptional cases, for example when particularly serious accusations have been made. But in Turkey, a simple libel charge or a social media post is now enough to trigger restrictions on journalists.
For Onderoglu, the impact of this is clear: "This unlawful practice serves to deliberately harass and intimidate critical journalists. It is an expression of a preemptive will to punish."
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


India Today
3 hours ago
- India Today
EU moves closer to US trade agreement with 15% tariff plan
After months of tense back-and-forth tariff threats, the European Union and the United States finally appear to be moving toward common ground. At the centre of this potential agreement is a 15% tariff that would apply to most imported goods — a move both sides hope will calm rising trade pressures and avoid a costly tariff battle.A breakthrough could be near, with both sides working on a deal that would implement a 15% tariff on most traded goods — a move aimed at cooling down the tariff to diplomats, EU member countries may agree to a 15% import duty on a wide range of goods, including vehicles. However, for products like steel and aluminium that go beyond a certain import quota, the tariff could go up to 50%, one diplomat said. Even though EU officials are optimistic, they know that the final decision depends on US President Donald Trump, as per news agency Reuters. A US official also said the talks are still ongoing and there may not be an immediate OF TRADE WAR STILL LOOMThe two sides have been working hard to make progress and avoid a major trade battle. But tensions rose again two weeks ago when Trump warned he might impose a 30% tariff on most EU goods if a deal isn't made by August has already placed a 25% duty on car imports and doubled that for steel and aluminium. He's also hinted that more products, including medicines, semiconductors, and copper, could be targeted there's no agreement by the deadline and Trump increases tariffs to 30%, the EU is preparing its own PLANS COUNTER TARIFFS If the US goes ahead with harsher tariffs, the EU is ready to hit back in a tit-for-tat move. It's preparing tariffs on over 90 billion (around $106 billion) worth of American goods - including well-known Boeing aircraft, cars, and bourbon EU is also considering using a special tool called the Anti-Coercion Instrument (ACI). This would allow the bloc to take a wide range of actions, such as:Imposing new taxes on US tech companies,Placing limits on US investments in Europe,Restricting American companies' access to European the warnings, EU and US leaders still hope to reach an agreement. European officials say their main goal is to avoid escalation and find common ground before the August deadline."We are hearing at this very moment that decisions may be forthcoming," said German Chancellor Friedrich Merz. Speaking before a meeting with French President Emmanuel Macron, he added, "We are meeting at a time that could not have been better."- EndsWith inputs from Reuters
&w=3840&q=100)

First Post
4 hours ago
- First Post
Macron meets Merz in Berlin as EU prepares $100 billion tariff retaliation
German Chancellor Merz greeted French President Macron in Berlin and stated that the two European leaders will debate 'trade policy, on which we are hearing in these minutes that there could possibly be decisions' read more German Chancellor Friedrich Merz and French President Emmanuel Macron hold talks in the library of the Villa Borsig, guesthouse of the German Foreign Ministry, in Berlin. AFP German Chancellor Friedrich Merz expressed hope Wednesday that EU and US negotiators gathering in Washington are making progress in their efforts to end the transatlantic trade dispute. Merz greeted French President Emmanuel Macron in Berlin and stated that the two European leaders will debate 'trade policy, on which we are hearing in these minutes that there could possibly be decisions.' US President Donald Trump has threatened to impose a 30% tariff on European products if the transatlantic partners do not reach an agreement by August 1. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD The EU has attempted to resolve trade issues with Washington through discussions, while developing precise measures for reprisal if necessary. US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said Wednesday that Washington was making progress on the tariff negotiations, with talks planned between the bloc's top trade negotiator and his American counterpart. EU Trade Commissioner Maros Sefcovic's talks with US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick on Wednesday afternoon came after Brussels said it was readying to pull the trigger on more than $100 billion in counter-tariffs should negotiations fail. Bessent, who is among the top US officials engaging with its key trading partners, sounded an optimistic note on Bloomberg Television. 'Talks are going better than they had been,' he said. 'I think that we are making good progress with the EU.'

Business Standard
5 hours ago
- Business Standard
We want to provide trade stability and have lowest tariffs possible: Macron
French President Emmanuel Macron said on Wednesday he would coordinate with German Chancellor Friedrich Merz and their other European counterparts on how to respond to the incoming US tariffs, adding he wanted those to be as low as possible. "Today, we are responding to the tariff offensive that has been launched with a determination that we share: to provide stability and have the lowest possible tariffs," he said alongside Merz ahead of a meeting between the two leaders in Berlin. (Only the headline and picture of this report may have been reworked by the Business Standard staff; the rest of the content is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)