'Very little has moved' on planned digital healthcare system
The Oireachtas health committee heard that a projected cost for the system cannot be shared yet. Health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill and Department of Health officials said this is due to ongoing negotiations with IT vendors.
Frustration was expressed by some committee members, including Fianna Fáil TD and GP Martin Daly.
'Ten years ago, I sat in the Department of Health and we talked about all of this, and very little has moved, to be honest with you,' said Dr Daly.
Department of Health assistant secretary Derek Tierney said the department is working towards a shared care record as a first step. This will join up existing IT systems, with plans to build a unified single system.
This means, for example, if patients go to a hospital emergency department, staff could access their GP records, pharmacy data, and information on previous hospital visits.
'We've appointed a vendor, work is underway,' said Mr Tierney. The plan is to run a pilot in Waterford and its surrounding community this year. 'And then widen that on a national basis over 2026 and 2027,' he told Sinn Féin health spokesman David Cullinane.
It is also expected to link up with digital health systems already in place in the North, which Mr Tierney said will be 'a game-changer' including for children.
'This takes time and effort, and funding commensurate with that time and effort.'
The committee stage discussion of the Health Information Bill 2024 also focused on sharing of data between patients and healthcare workers.
Questions were raised about a section which could allow doctors or institutions to withhold records temporarily.
Ms Carroll MacNeill pledged to work on this, acknowledging that a specific time limit may be needed. Examples included where a scan shows a patient has cancer, this would be better disclosed in person first.
'Significant capital investment'
During discussions on finance, she said 'very significant capital investment' will be needed to build a single system.
'We are in a live procurement process. It would require very significant capital expenditure,' she said.
She said public expenditure minister Jack Chambers is supportive of their plans.
Over time, they expect services such as Camhs (Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services) to be included. The system will cover medical card and private patients for GPs, she told Labour health spokeswoman Marie Sherlock.
The committee also heard that the new national children's hospital will be the first paperless hospital in the State.
Questions were raised about how records will transfer to adult hospitals still relying on paper charts.
Maternity hospitals have seen benefits of a partial roll-out, with University Maternity Hospital Limerick the latest to go live. It is expected that 70% of women and their babies will have digital records by year's end.
Department of Health assistant secretary Muiris O'Connor said patients will identify themselves in the system using PPS numbers.
The HSE App is part of the overall plan, and the minister said 80,000 people have now downloaded the app.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
17 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
'Very little has moved' on planned digital healthcare system
Digital healthcare will be a 'game-changer' for patients but concerns about the slow pace of progress have emerged. The Oireachtas health committee heard that a projected cost for the system cannot be shared yet. Health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill and Department of Health officials said this is due to ongoing negotiations with IT vendors. Frustration was expressed by some committee members, including Fianna Fáil TD and GP Martin Daly. 'Ten years ago, I sat in the Department of Health and we talked about all of this, and very little has moved, to be honest with you,' said Dr Daly. Department of Health assistant secretary Derek Tierney said the department is working towards a shared care record as a first step. This will join up existing IT systems, with plans to build a unified single system. This means, for example, if patients go to a hospital emergency department, staff could access their GP records, pharmacy data, and information on previous hospital visits. 'We've appointed a vendor, work is underway,' said Mr Tierney. The plan is to run a pilot in Waterford and its surrounding community this year. 'And then widen that on a national basis over 2026 and 2027,' he told Sinn Féin health spokesman David Cullinane. It is also expected to link up with digital health systems already in place in the North, which Mr Tierney said will be 'a game-changer' including for children. 'This takes time and effort, and funding commensurate with that time and effort.' The committee stage discussion of the Health Information Bill 2024 also focused on sharing of data between patients and healthcare workers. Questions were raised about a section which could allow doctors or institutions to withhold records temporarily. Ms Carroll MacNeill pledged to work on this, acknowledging that a specific time limit may be needed. Examples included where a scan shows a patient has cancer, this would be better disclosed in person first. 'Significant capital investment' During discussions on finance, she said 'very significant capital investment' will be needed to build a single system. 'We are in a live procurement process. It would require very significant capital expenditure,' she said. She said public expenditure minister Jack Chambers is supportive of their plans. Over time, they expect services such as Camhs (Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services) to be included. The system will cover medical card and private patients for GPs, she told Labour health spokeswoman Marie Sherlock. The committee also heard that the new national children's hospital will be the first paperless hospital in the State. Questions were raised about how records will transfer to adult hospitals still relying on paper charts. Maternity hospitals have seen benefits of a partial roll-out, with University Maternity Hospital Limerick the latest to go live. It is expected that 70% of women and their babies will have digital records by year's end. Department of Health assistant secretary Muiris O'Connor said patients will identify themselves in the system using PPS numbers. The HSE App is part of the overall plan, and the minister said 80,000 people have now downloaded the app.
Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
Digital medical records will start later this year to end paper patient files
The long-awaited shared care record, which will contain a range of information about the patient, and can be downloaded digitally, is aimed at ending the system of unlinked records being held separately in various health settings which causes inefficiency and other problems. Department of Health official Derek Tierney told the Oireachtas health committee that if for example a patient attends an emergency department, the shared care record could be drawn down with information from their GP, pharmacy and other hospital care. "It would mean those who are providing you with care would see a minimum level of information to help with the diagnosis or intervention," he said. He was speaking as Health Minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill was moving amendments to the Health Information Bill which will give effect to the digitalisation of patients records, amid criticism from members of the committee about how overdue the modernisation is taking. A GP would also have access to their patient's diagnostics 'at their fingertips', he added. The primary benefits are increasing the safety and quality of care to deliver better outcomes and also in saving time , he pointed out. The shared care record, or summary record, is a first step – but it will be several more years before a long-promised full electronic record which is more comprehensive will be available. The first hospital to get the shared care record will be University Hospital Waterford and surrounding community and it will be extended to other settings across the country over the next two years. He said the shared care record will collect fragmented information across the system and be combined in one, to give a unified view to a healthcare provider. The new national children's hospital will have electronic records, he added. By the end of the year around 70pc of births, along with mothers' information, will be captured in the electronic health record system. He added that "we are under no illusion that the roll-out of full electronic records will take time and money'. The minister said that "it will be staged system over time. The whole point is to have your record available to whoever is the provider'. She said it will have to be done safely and effectively across both the hospital and community healthcare system . She was asked by Labour party spokeswoman on health Deputy Marie Sherlock if it will be just GMS patients whose data will be in the digital record, and what the intention was around dental services and information held by private hospitals. Mr Tierney said all information, from both public and private care, would be included . The minister said the new system will require significant capital expenditure but could not say what the final cost would be, given that a live procurement process is under way. "We have a budget at present of €190m which is keepings things going at the moment and maintaining our cybersecurity,' she added.
Irish Independent
2 days ago
- Irish Independent
Introduction of alcohol warning labels pushed back due to cost fears
The labels, warning about the link with diseases such as cancer, were to come into force from May 22, 2026, whenever alcohol was offered for sale in a shop or restaurant. While the Department of Health had been sticking to the deadline, senior ministers began to express concern about the labels last April in the context of the trade tensions with the US. Alcohol labelling was cited as a significant barrier to American exports in a report published earlier this year by the Office of the United States Trade Representative. The drinks industry exports €450m of product each year, and the US is a major market, particularly for whiskey. Currently, 90pc of distilling in Ireland has been halted, following the imposition of a 10pc tariff on whiskey imports into the US. Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe was the first to signal there might be a delay, saying the labels would have to be looked at again in the context of tariffs. Tánaiste Simon Harris then said the timeline for introduction was 'under consideration', while Enterprise Minister Peter Burke said the requirement was being examined as the Government considered how to protect the competitiveness of Irish businesses. Last month, as revealed by the Irish Independent, Mr Burke formally asked Health Minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill to consider pausing the introduction of warning labels. Our domestic production sector is going through a period of very significant disruption In a letter to his cabinet colleague, Mr Burke expressed concern that the labels would mean increased costs for Irish producers and importers, and potentially add to the price payable by consumers. 'At the same time, our domestic production sector is going through a period of very significant disruption to supply chains and access to markets,' the minister also told the Dáil. Agriculture Minister Martin Heydon also formally requested a delay, citing concerns about jobs and investment. ADVERTISEMENT Mr Harris said that he believed the labels needed to be delayed, but still expected them to be brought in during this Government's term. The plan to postpone the requirement has now been indicated in a letter sent to members of the Government's trade forum by the Tánaiste. Pushing the deadline back to 2029 would still, in theory, keep the change within the lifetime of this Government. Having taken office in January 2025, it has a natural lifespan of five years. The drinks industry has been lobbying against the labels, with Ibec among those calling for a postponement on the basis that it would increase prices by up to 30pc. Alcohol Action Ireland has criticised the planned delay, saying that given the costs of alcohol-related harms, the Government should stand by law that was passed with cross-party support in 2018.
