"It Is Doing Wonders": Pak Defence Minister Praises Civil-Military "Hybrid Model"
Lahore:
Pakistan's Defence Minister Khawaja Asif and a close aide of ruling PML-N president and former prime minister Nawaz Sharif said the country is being governed under a "hybrid model" in which the military enjoys a major power share.
This is the second time this week that Asif, a prominent member of the incumbent Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif cabinet, admitted to the hybrid model, criticised as not mixed but a "fixed government to serve subsidiary interests" by analysts.
The defence minister's candid words during an interview with Arab News aired on Friday evening are being considered as an admission that Sharifs' Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) has the blessings of the powerful military establishment in Pakistan.
Asif described the civil-military hybrid system as co-ownership of the power structure as he said: "This is a hybrid model. It's not an ideal democratic government. So, this hybrid arrangement, I think it is doing wonders. This system is a practical necessity until Pakistan is out of the woods as far as economic and governance problems are concerned." He added if this sort of hybrid model was adopted way back in the 90s (when Nawaz Sharif was prime minister, twice), things would have been much, much better because the confrontation between military establishment and the political government would retard the progress of democracy.
The defence minister claimed that "the only realistic option" for the PML-N and the Sharifs is "to compromise with the military." Earlier, a day after Pakistan Army chief Field Marshal Asim Munir met US President Donald Trump at the White House, Asif on Thursday said in a post on X described the meeting as "the most important turning point in the 78-year history of relations," and added that the development is the success of the "current hybrid model of governance", involving the elected government and the army.
Sharifs' arch rival and former prime minister Imran Khan has maintained since last year that the February 8 general elections witnessed the 'Mother of All Rigging' that deprived his party, the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf , from forming the government. Khan also called the PML-N and its ruling partner, the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) led by Bilawal Bhutto Zardari as "mandate thieves." After Asif's open admission, the critics claimed that it has further buried the PML-N's earlier slogan of "vote ko izzat do (give respect to the ballot)," setting a future course of politics for the Sharifs that they would continue their politics as subservient to the powerful military.
"This (Trump-Munir) meeting has lifted the thin, see-through veneer of 'elected'. What the world has known for quite a while is now in the open... where is the centre of power in Pakistan and who is in control of real state powers? The political allies (military) in power have presented themselves as the 'government' now.
"Khawaja Asif and others now have to seek some legitimacy to praise the merits of the hybrid model, which actually doesn't mean a mixed but a fixed government to serve subsidiary interests," said senior analyst Dr Rasul Bakhsh Rais.
He said the current setup is, in fact, the third "hybrid regime" since the ouster of Imran Khan in 2022.
"Today the difference is that while Gen Ziaul Haq and Gen Pervez Musharraf created political fronts by cannibalising major parties, this time around the two major parties -- PMLN and PPP -- have willingly served as political facade," he said referring to the past two army generals who later became presidents.
Dr Rais said by handing victory to the PML-N and PPP in the previous elections, the military establishment has "reduced these parties to the status of an appendage in the hybrid order." He said the political capital of the PML-N and PPP is buried alongside their anti-establishment narrative. "Now, the priority of the Sharifs and Zardaris as well as the military establishment is to neutralise the third force - Imran Khan's PTI --- which is perceived as a danger for all of them," he said.
Senior journalist Matiullah Jan said on X, "What a fall from grace for a politician. This defence minister takes oath to defend the constitution which makes no mention of the so-called hybrid form of government." "The fact is that this system is not even a hybrid system but a pure and simple dictatorship with political pygmies at the heels of affairs," he added.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India.com
8 hours ago
- India.com
Advisor to anti-India Yunus caught with AK-47 rifle magazine at Dhaka airport on way to Istanbul, security let him go due to..., handbag was...
New Delhi: An AK-47 rifle magazine has been found in the bag of Asif Mahmud, the young face of the interim government of Mohammad Yunus of Bangladesh. The magazine was found inside Dhaka airport in the luggage of Asif, the advisor (minister) of the Rural Development and Cooperative Department in the Yunus government. What happened at Dhaka airport? This shocking incident happened when he was going to Morocco to attend the meeting of the Organization of Islamic Countries (OIC) as a representative of Bangladesh. When Asif went to the airport to take a flight, the magazine was found in his bag during the check. Asif is among those young leaders who played an important role in overthrowing the government of Sheikh Hasina by leading the students last year. According to the report of Northeast News, Asif Mahmud was going through the Identity and Security Check (INS) at the airport. During this, the scanning machine indicated suspicious items in his handbag. On this, the security personnel took Asif Mahmud's bag and checked it and found an AK-47 rifle magazine inside it. The airport management and security agencies are silent on this matter and the Yunus government is also trying to cover it up. Why was Asif not questioned? Despite finding the magazine, Bangladeshi security officials allowed Asif Mahmud to take a flight to Turkey. Asif Mahmud first went to Istanbul for the OIC meeting and from there to Marrakech, Morocco. The report claims that Asif Mahmud's handbag was not passed through the mandatory check and security process at the time of entry into the airport. In such a situation, the magazine was found in his bag just before taking the flight. Bangladeshi security agency sources have said that Asif Mahmud could not give a satisfactory answer to the officers regarding the question related to finding an AK-47 magazine in his bag. Asif made a weak excuse that he forgot to remove the magazine from the bag while packing. In such a situation, he expresses regret over it. The security officials accepted this and let him go. He was not questioned in detail about the magazine being found. Yunus government maintains silence Bangladesh interim government head Mohammad Yunus and Home Ministry advisor Jahangir Alam Chowdhury have maintained silence on this issue. There has been no statement from the government on such a big incident as the discovery of an AK-47 magazine inside Dhaka's Shahjalal International Airport with an important government figure. There are many discussions in the political corridors of Dhaka about why a government advisor has kept weapons like AK-47 with him.
Hindustan Times
3 days ago
- Hindustan Times
Did Zohran Mamdani lie on his naturalization form? Rep Andy Ogles wonders
Zohran Mamdani, the Indian-Ugandan-born candidate, who recently clinched the Democratic nomination for mayor, is being repeatedly torched by Tennessee Congressman Andy Ogles, who is even questioning the legitimacy of his U.S. citizenship. Ogles questions Mamdani's naturalisation, citing past rap lyrics related to a convicted charity, suggesting potential grounds for denaturalisation.(AFP. X/Andy Ogles) Raised in the US since Mamdani immigrated here with his family two decades ago. He became a US citizen in 2018. Since he has made a career out of state politics, having been elected to the New York State Assembly in 2020. ALSO READ| '100% communist lunatic, looks terrible': Trump attacks Zohran Mamdani after poll win Andy Ogles urges DOJ to 'investigate Zohran Mamdani' 'Bye bye, little muhammad! If you lied on your N-400 naturalization forms, you're going home,' Ogles wrote in a X post, that was posted last night. This continues a recent series of X post where Ogles urged federal authorities to investigate Mamdani's naturalisation, raising the possibility that he may have gained citizenship through 'willful misrepresentation or concealment of material support for terrorism.' 'Zohran 'little muhammad' Mamdani is an antisemitic, socialist, communist who will destroy the great City of New York. He needs to be DEPORTED. Which is why I am calling for him to be subject to denaturalization proceedings,' Ogles wrote in another post. While the claims stem from Mamdani's past career as a rapper when he reportedly used the phrase, 'Free the Holy Land Five / My guys,' a line alluding to the Holy Land Foundation, a Texas-based charity that was convicted in 2008 for funnelling money to Hamas. 'While I understand that some may raise First Amendment concerns about taking legal action based on expressive conduct, such as rap lyrics, speech alone does not preclude accountability where it reasonably suggests underlying conduct relevant to eligibility of naturalization,' Ogles wrote. 'If an individual publicly glorifies a group convicted of financing terrorism, it is entirely appropriate for federal authorities to inquire whether the individual engaged in non-public forms of support — such as organizational affiliation, fundraising, or advocacy — that would have required disclosure on Form N-400 or during a naturalization interview.' ASLO READ| From Hinge to headlines: Zohran Mamdani and Rama Duwaji, New York City's new 'it couple' What is Form N-400? The N-400, which every permanent resident applies to and has to fill out, is the process of gaining the status of U.S. citizenship. These are such questions as the mentioned membership in organisations, political parties, and engagement in any activities which may be deemed as a threat to the U.S. national security. 'The naturalization process depends on the good-faith disclosure of any affiliation with, or support for, groups that threaten US national security,' Ogles continued. 'If Mr. Mamdani concealed relevant associations, that concealment may constitute a material misrepresentation sufficient to support denaturalization under federal law.' ASLO READ| Who is Eric Adams, Zohran Mamdani's main rival in New York City mayoral polls? So far, Mamdani has not responded publicly to the accusations.
Time of India
3 days ago
- Time of India
Pakistan not getting Chinese J-35 stealth jets: Defence Minister Khawaja Asif says reports are only media chatter
Khawaja Asif, Pakistan's Defence Minister, refuted reports of a J-35A fighter jet deal with China. Earlier reports suggested Pakistan would acquire 40 jets at a discounted price. Defence sources claimed pilot training had begun. The deal was questioned due to Pakistan's economic situation. China remains a key defence supplier for Pakistan. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Reports had claimed a discounted deal Contradictory details from defence sources Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Pakistan's economic constraints raise questions China remains key defence supplier Past remarks on Indian jets also drew criticism Pakistan's Defence Minister Khawaja Asif has denied reports that the country has signed a deal with China to acquire J-35A fifth-generation stealth fighter jets. Speaking in a televised interview, Asif said there is no agreement between Pakistan and China for the purchase of the jets.'I think it is only in the media. It is good for sale, Chinese defence sales, you know,' said Khawaja Asif in response to a question about the reported delivery of the J-35A jets in media reports claimed that Pakistan was set to acquire 40 J-35A aircraft from China as early as August this year. The reports suggested the deal was being finalised at nearly half the standard export price, and that China was offering a major discount under what some described as a 'flash sale.'The J-35A is a twin-engine, multi-role, fifth-generation stealth fighter developed by China's Shenyang Aircraft Corporation. It is equipped with long-range PL-17 missiles and an AESA radar system, and has been seen as China's competitor to the U.S. the minister's denial, defence sources earlier said that the Pakistan Air Force had approved the J-35A acquisition and that pilot training had begun in China. The proposed agreement was also reported to include liberal payment terms, with the first deliveries expected by August reported deal came at a time when Pakistan is under economic pressure. The federal government recently raised its defence budget by 20% to PKR 2.5 trillion. At the same time, it cancelled 118 development projects worth PKR 1,000 billion and reduced the overall national budget by 7% to PKR 17.57 trillion ($62 billion).About 80% of Pakistan's military inventory comes from China. Systems such as the J-10C fighter jets and HQ-9 air defence systems were used by Pakistan during its most recent conflict with India. The addition of the J-35A was expected to further boost Pakistan's air strength, especially with India's AMCA fifth-generation fighter project expected only by now, official confirmation of any J-35A deal remains is not the first time Khawaja Asif has made headlines over unverified defence claims. During a televised interview with CNN, when asked for proof of Pakistan downing Indian fighter jets during Operation Sindoor, the Defence Minister said, 'It's all over social media , on Indian social media, not on our social media. The debris of these jets fell into Kashmir. And it's all over Indian media today and they have admitted.' The anchor responded by saying they were not there to discuss social media chatter. Asif did not provide concrete evidence or specifics, including the type of aircraft involved, and loosely referenced Chinese-made JF-17 and JF-10 jets.
