Nandy demands ‘accountability at highest levels' after Bob Vylan broadcast
Lisa Nandy told the Commons she has heard from the BBC but was 'not satisfied with the response'.
Punk duo Bob Vylan led chants of 'death, death to the IDF (Israel Defence Forces)' during their Worthy Farm set last weekend, and face an investigation by Avon and Somerset Police.
London's Metropolitan Police is also investigating the two Bobs – who perform using the aliases Bobby Vylan and Bobbie Vylan – for allegedly making similar comments at Alexandra Palace in May.
Conservative shadow culture secretary Stuart Andrew told the Commons: 'Given the BBC are seemingly able to pull live broadcasts when things go wrong at football matches, for example, it's extraordinary that this didn't happen on this occasion.
'Can the Secretary of State update the House on the discussions she's had with the BBC, and why the same thing didn't happen on this occasion?
'What due diligence was carried out by them about the acts that were performing?
'And given as she's said we're still waiting for a response to the previous Hamas documentary, is she satisfied with those conversations she's had and the urgency that the organisation are taking?'
Ms Nandy replied: 'No, the answer is that I'm not satisfied with the response that I've had.'
The Culture Secretary previously made a ministerial statement in the Commons on Monday, when she said 'it should have been foreseeable that there would be problems with broadcasts'.
She told MPs then that she wanted 'rapid action to make sure this cannot happen again'.
In Thursday's update, Ms Nandy told MPs: 'I have received a reply to the very many questions that were raised by colleagues on all sides.
'I'm not satisfied with that, and I have gone back to the BBC leadership to ask for further information, in particular, as he mentioned, about the failure to pull the live feed, about the due diligence that was done prior to deciding to screen this act, and also about the level of senior oversight that took place in the BBC during the Glastonbury weekend.
'I think the BBC leadership will hear and have heard the strength of feeling in this House about this, and I expect further answers to be forthcoming imminently.'
The corporation removed the documentary Gaza: How To Survive A Warzone from its online iPlayer platform in February after it emerged its 13-year-old narrator was the son of a Hamas official.
In a follow-up question, Mr Andrew said: 'I'm as disappointed as she is that they haven't been able to come back with even basic facts.
'There were hundreds of BBC staff there and not being able to identify who ultimately had the final decision on whether to broadcast or not is not acceptable, and I think the chairman (Samir Shah) needs to inform her as a matter of urgency who that was and what action they are going to take.
'While I absolutely understand the independence of the BBC, just as artists can't hide behind artistic expression for vile commentary, neither can the BBC hide behind independence for accountability, and I hope she knows she has the full support of this side of the House as she pushes them for clarity.'
Ms Nandy said she was 'grateful' that Mr Andrew had made 'the very important distinction between independence and accountability'.
She continued: 'Given the seriousness of what happened – and particularly we heard in the House and I was able to bring to the House the absolute shocking stories of the impact that this has had on the Jewish community in this country – given the seriousness of this, I would expect there to be accountability at the highest levels.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
12 minutes ago
- Yahoo
BBC senior staff told to 'step back' from duties following row
The BBC has told a small number of senior staff to step back from their day-to-day duties on music and live events, following the broadcast of Bob Vylan's controversial Glastonbury set. The punk duo led a chant of "death, death to the IDF [Israel Defence Forces]" and made other derogatory comments during their performance, which was available to watch via a live stream on iPlayer. In a statement, the BBC said there was "no place for antisemitism" in its output, and that it was taking action to "ensure proper accountability for those found to be responsible" for the broadcast. The BBC also said Bob Vylan were one of seven Glastonbury acts it had deemed "high risk" in advance of the festival. The broadcaster said it would make "immediate changes to livestreaming music events", so that "any music performances deemed high risk by the BBC will now not be broadcast live or streamed live" in the future. The corporation's chair, Samir Shah, said the decision not to pull the live feed was "unquestionably an error of judgement". Earlier on Thursday, Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy told the House of Commons she was unsatisfied with the BBC's response after she had asked questions about due diligence, senior oversight, and the delay in pulling the live feed. "Given the seriousness of what happened, and particularly we heard in the House the absolute shocking stories of the impact this has had on the Jewish community in this country - given the seriousness of this, I would expect there to be accountability at the highest levels [of the BBC]," she said. Shadow culture secretary Stuart Andrew said the BBC's "belated response suggests a lack of vigilance and proper oversight", adding the BBC has "clear responsibilities when broadcasting live events". The BBC has also been criticised by the UK's chief rabbi Sir Ephraim Mirvis, while media regulator Ofcom said the corporation had "questions to answer". During their Glastonbury set, Bob Vylan's singer Pascal Robinson-Foster, who performs under the stage name Bobby Vylan, also spoke about a record label boss he used to work for. That boss would "speak very strongly about his support for Israel", and had put his name to a letter urging Glastonbury to cancel Irish-language rap trio Kneecap's performance, the musician said. "Who do I see on that list of names but that bald-headed [expletive] I used to work for. We've done it all, all right? From working in bars to working for [expletive] Zionists." In a message to staff on Thursday, director general Tim Davie said: "I deeply regret that such offensive and deplorable behaviour appeared on the BBC and want to say sorry – to our audience and to all of you, but in particular to Jewish colleagues and the Jewish community." The BBC said Bob Vylan had been deemed high risk following a risk assessment process applied to all acts appearing at Glastonbury. The duo, along with six other acts, were included in this category, but the BBC said they "were all deemed suitable for live streaming with appropriate mitigations". The statement continued: "Prior to Glastonbury, a decision was taken that compliance risks could be mitigated in real time on the live stream – through the use of language or content warnings - without the need for a delay. This was clearly not the case." The BBC noted that the live stream was monitored "in line with the agreed compliance protocols and a number of issues were escalated". Warnings appeared on the stream on two occasions, but, the BBC added: "The editorial team took the decision not to cut the feed. This was an error." Davie, who was attending Glastonbury himself on the day, was "subsequently made aware of what had happened and instructed the team that none of the performance should feature in further coverage". The BBC said the team on duty prioritised stopping the performance from becoming available on demand, meaning that the set would not appear separately on iPlayer or BBC Sounds. However, the live feed remained available for more than four hours, which meant viewers were able to rewind and view the content. "Given the failings that have been acknowledged, we are taking actions to ensure proper accountability for those found to be responsible for those failings in the live broadcast," the BBC said. "We will not comment further on those processes at this time." In a statement, Shah apologised "to all our viewers and listeners and particularly the Jewish community for allowing the 'artist' Bob Vylan to express unconscionable antisemitic views live on the BBC". "This was unquestionably an error of judgement," he added. "I was very pleased to note that as soon as this came to the notice of Tim Davie - who was on the Glastonbury site at the time visiting BBC staff - he took immediate action and instructed the team to withdraw the performance from on demand coverage." Since Glastonbury, Bob Vylan have had several bookings cancelled, including festival appearances in Manchester and France and a slot in Germany. In response to the cancellations, the band reiterated their position, telling followers: "Silence is not an option. We will be fine, the people of Palestine are hurting." Avon and Somerset Police have launched a criminal investigation into their Glastonbury comments. On Wednesday, London's Metropolitan Police said the band are also under investigation for comments they allegedly made during a concert at Alexandra Palace in May. After the media coverage of their comments, Bob Vylan said in a statement on Tuesday: "We are not for the death of Jews, Arabs or any other race or group of people. We are for the dismantling of a violent military machine". They added that "we, like those in the spotlight before us, are not the story. We are a distraction from the story, and whatever sanctions we receive will be a distraction". Bob Vylan dropped from Manchester music festival Did BBC's focus on one potential Glastonbury controversy miss another? Starmer criticises 'appalling' Bob Vylan IDF chants Bob Vylan coverage should have been pulled, BBC says Chief rabbi attacks BBC for airing 'vile Jew hate' at Glastonbury Bob Vylan: Who are the controversial rap-punk duo?
Yahoo
16 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Deputy PM lays flowers at Anfield for Diogo Jota
Angela Rayner says the news that Liverpool footballer Diogo Jota has died in a car accident is "heartbreaking". The deputy prime minister says she was in Liverpool for a local government conference when she heard the news, before visiting Anfield to lay flowers.
Yahoo
36 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Israel fighting 'very tough' war in Gaza, retired British Army colonel says
The world's focus on the Middle East has seemingly shifted back to the Israel-Hamas war following the conflict with Iran that culminated in the historic strikes on Tehran's nuclear facilities. For more than 20 months, Israel has operated in Gaza following Hamas' brutal surprise attacks on Oct. 7, 2023. The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) have been heavily scrutinized over their handling of the war, particularly when it comes to damage to civilian areas and the distribution of humanitarian aid. However, Ret. British Col. Richard Kemp told Fox News Digital that Israel is doing everything it can to avoid civilian casualties whenever possible. Kemp, who recently returned from a trip to Israel and Gaza, said that the war has been "very tough" as Hamas continues to embed itself among the civilian population or in tunnels. Israel Accepts Trump-led Ceasefire Plan That Could End Gaza War Within 60 Days "In my view, the IDF have been conducting it very effectively," Kemp said. "They've killed huge numbers of Hamas terrorists. They've destroyed a lot of Hamas' infrastructure, including some of the tunnels, but they've got a long way to go yet. The fight's not over yet." In Kemp's assessment, the fighting in Gaza will continue until Israel defeats Hamas, which becomes a difficult task for an army actively avoiding civilian casualties, something the former British officer said he witnessed "personally." Terror In Gaza: Hamas Offers Bounties To Kill Us And Local Aid Workers, Group Says Read On The Fox News App Kemp also told Fox News Digital that civilian deaths in Gaza are "unavoidable" because of how Hamas operates. He argued that this is part of the terror group's "primary objective," which he says is "to get the IDF to kill as many civilians as possible so they can achieve what they have achieved, which is the vilification of Israel, the isolation of Israel, and the condemnation of Israel — the accusations of war crimes and genocide — none of which are true." He commended the IDF, saying that Israeli forces have "done a quite extraordinary job that no other army probably could do of maximizing the destruction of Hamas while minimizing the deaths of civilians." While on the ground in Gaza, Kemp had the opportunity to speak with civilians and visit aid distribution sites run by the U.S.- and Israel-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF). He said the civilians who spoke with him were grateful for the aid and recognized the role the U.S., under President Donald Trump, has played. At the same time, they hold Hamas responsible for putting them in "the terrible situation they're in now." Hamas Faces 'Legitimacy Crisis' As Desperate Gazans Flock To Us-backed Aid Centers When asked about the criticism GHF has faced from the international community — particularly the United Nations — Kemp said that the organization is working in a way that is "uniquely suitable" for the situation in Gaza. He argued that the U.N. is attempting to apply a "standard template solution," which does not work for Gaza, as evidenced by the amount of aid stolen by Hamas. "Some of them told me it was the first time since the war began, 20 months ago, that they have actually received any free aid at all," Kemp told Fox News Digital. He said that in some instances, Hamas would steal aid and sell the goods at premium prices that many civilians could not afford. Kemp emphasized the need for other nations and major humanitarian organizations to support the GHF and noted the recent $30 million in funding the organization had received from the U.S. "No other country that I know of has directly contributed funding to the GHF, and they should do so because the GHF, not the U.N., is the future of aid deliveries into Gaza," Kemp told Fox News Digital. He also acknowledged that the U.N. has a role to play, but added that it must be "in the interest of the people of Gaza, not bureaucracy."Original article source: Israel fighting 'very tough' war in Gaza, retired British Army colonel says
