‘Let us close this': SC on 2018 defamation case against Tharoor
'Why do you want to be so touchy about this. Let us close this,' a bench of justices MM Sundresh and N Kotiswar Singh said, as it posted the matter for hearing on September 15.
The court added: 'That way, administrators, political personalities and judges are in the same group. They are sufficiently thick-skinned.'
During the Bangalore Literature Festival on October 28, 2018,Tharoor had allegedly compared Modi to a scorpion, following which Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader Rajiv Babbar filed a complaint against the Thiruvananthapuram MP in 2019.Babbar claimed that the remark not only targeted the Prime Minister but also amounted to vilification of the faith of millions of devotees of Lord Shiva. He further accused Tharoor of hurting religious sentiments and disparaging the Prime Minister.
Tharoor has, however, maintained that the remark was borrowed from an article published in 2012, when Modi was the chief minister of Gujarat. In his petition, Tharoor contended that Babbar's complaint was not legally maintainable as he is not an 'aggrieved person' under the law, especially since the person directly referred to in the statement had not taken any legal action. He also relied on the exception under the law on defamation that exempts any comment made in good faith.
Tharoor was stated to have merely made a reference to an article published in the Caravan magazine six years prior to making the statement.
Despite these arguments, however, the Delhi high court on August 29, 2024 refused to quash the defamation proceedings against him, asking him to appear before the trial court on September 10. The high court had said, prima facie, imputations like 'scorpion on Shivling' against the prime minister were 'despicable and deplorable'. The high court also said there was sufficient material before the judicial magistrate for summoning Tharoor under Section 500 (punishment for defamation) of the IPC.
Tharoor challenged the order in the top court in September 2024. In the same month, the apex court stayed the trial in the criminal defamation proceedings and had sought a response from Babbar and the Delhi government. However, the hearing could not proceed as Tharoor's counsel sought an adjournment. The court further extended the stay on the trial till the next date.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India.com
24 minutes ago
- India.com
Karnataka: Conspiracy To Transfer Muslim Headmaster? 3 Arrested For Poisoning Drinking Water Of School Children
In a shocking revelation, it has emerged that a water tank at a government school in Hulikatti village, Savadatti taluk, Belagavi district, Karnataka, was deliberately poisoned in an attempt to have a Muslim headmaster transferred. Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah confirmed that three individuals, including Sagar Patil, the taluk president of the Shriram Sena, have been arrested for allegedly poisoning the school's drinking water meant for children. In a post on X, the Chief Minister elaborated that the incident occurred around 15 days ago, and several children fell ill, though fortunately, there were no fatalities. "The headmaster of the government school in Hulikatti village, Savadatti taluk, Belagavi district, belongs to the Muslim community. With the malicious intent of having him transferred elsewhere, Sagar Patil, the taluk president of Shriram Sena, along with two others, has been arrested for poisoning the drinking water of school children. In this incident that occurred 15 days ago, several children fell ill, but fortunately, no lives were lost," the post read. CM Siddaramaiah congratulated the police who foiled the plot and showed "full confidence" in the judicial system to deliver appropriate punishment to the culprits who committed the act. "Religious fundamentalism and communal hatred can lead to heinous acts, and this incident, which could have resulted in the massacre of innocent children, is a testament to that. In the land of the Sharanas, who proclaimed, "Compassion is the root of religion," how could such cruelty and hatred arise? Even at this moment, I cannot believe it," he added. "BJP leaders who sow hatred in society in the name of religion to cook their political broth should introspect," the Chief Minister continued. "All forms of fanaticism and fundamentalism are dangerous to human society. To curb hate speeches and communal riots, we have formed a special task force, and we are taking all possible legal measures against such elements. For all our efforts to bear fruit, the public must also raise their voices against such forces, resist them, and file complaints," he emphasised. ಬೆಳಗಾವಿ ಜಿಲ್ಲೆಯ ಸವದತ್ತಿ ತಾಲೂಕಿನ ಹೂಲಿಕಟ್ಟಿ ಗ್ರಾಮದ ಸರ್ಕಾರಿ ಶಾಲೆಯ ಮುಖ್ಯೋಪಾಧ್ಯಾಯರು ಮುಸ್ಲಿಂ ಸಮುದಾಯಕ್ಕೆ ಸೇರಿದವರು, ಅವರನ್ನು ತಮ್ಮ ಊರಿನಿಂದ ಬೇರೆಡೆಗೆ ವರ್ಗಾವಣೆ ಮಾಡಿಸಬೇಕೆಂಬ ದುರುದ್ದೇಶದಿಂದ ಶಾಲಾಮಕ್ಕಳ ಕುಡಿಯುವ ನೀರಿಗೆ ವಿಷ ಹಾಕಿದ ಶ್ರೀರಾಮ ಸೇನೆಯ ತಾಲೂಕು ಅಧ್ಯಕ್ಷ ಸಾಗರ ಪಾಟೀಲ ಸೇರಿದಂತೆ ಒಟ್ಟು ಮೂವರನ್ನು… — Siddaramaiah (@siddaramaiah) August 3, 2025 Huvinakone Village Incident Earlier, the Karnataka Chief Minister, reacting to the incident of water tanks at a government primary school contaminated by miscreants using pesticide, resulting in four children falling ill in Shivamogga district, on Friday, described the episode as an act of terrorism. According to the news agency IANS, the incident was reported from Huvinakone village in Hosanagara taluk of Shivamogga district on Thursday. IANS quoted Siddaramaiah as saying, 'The state government has taken very seriously the incident in which miscreants allegedly mixed pesticide into the drinking water tank of the government primary school. In my view, this heinous act, seemingly intended to cause mass deaths of innocent young children, is no less than a terrorist attack.' 'Thanks to the alertness of the school's cooking staff, a major tragedy was averted. I commend the kitchen staff for their timely intervention,' he added. The Karnataka Chief Minister said that he has instructed the police to conduct a thorough investigation, identify the culprits behind this act, and ensure they are punished with the strictest penalties. A case has been registered, and investigations into the incident are currently in progress. On Thursday, two water tanks at the government school were found to be contaminated, with one tank containing a particularly high level of pesticide. The issue came to light when some students noticed a foul smell while washing their hands with water from the second tank. Sensing something unusual, they alerted the teachers.
New Indian Express
24 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
Land 'illegally' owned by Assam CM to be distributed among poor after Congress comes to power: Gaurav Gogoi
"Unlike the loot and injustice under the Himanta Biswa Sarma regime, Congress is preparing to bring a new government based on progressive land policies and economic development," Gogoi said. All India Congress Committee General Secretary (in-charge of Assam) Jitendra Singh said the people of Assam now seek change through elections. "They are yearning to be freed from the misrule of Himanta Biswa Sarma, which has become synonymous with authoritarianism and corruption. Today, not just in Assam but across the nation, every citizen, including children and women, bears a debt burden of Rs 50,000 per head. "To rescue the country from this unstable economic condition, people are demanding change, and in Assam too, the Congress, under the leadership of Gaurav Gogoi, is preparing to form the next government by defeating Himanta Biswa Sarma in 2026," he added. Assembly elections in Assam for 126 seats are likely in March-April next year. The Extended Executive Meeting decided that starting in September, the Congress will intensify its organizational activities and begin a series of campaigns against BJP's alleged corruption. Gogoi also accused both the Sarbananda Sonowal and Himanta Biswa Sarma governments of deceiving people with false promises, having failed to implement the various reports and suggestions by different committees. He noted that the Extended Executive Meeting saw participation from representatives of various communities across Assam and included long deliberations on protecting the rights and interests of indigenous people. Following these discussions, economic and political resolutions were adopted. These include comprehensive proposals to reform the economy, rescue indebted Assam, create employment, and ensure inclusive and equitable development for all citizens.
Indian Express
24 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Congress says common man's dream of owning a house ‘shattered', BJP retorts: ‘claims baseless'
Claiming that the collector rates have been increased varying between 100 to 250 per cent in several districts across the state, the Congress has slammed the BJP government in Haryana, saying the steep hike will 'shatter' the common man's dream of owning a house. The state government, however, refuted the Opposition's claims, calling it 'rumours', 'baseless', and 'devoid of any factual basis'. In a statement released on Sunday evening, the government said only 8.37 per cent areas across Haryana that fall in the category where 'transaction value exceeds the collector rate by more than 200 per cent, a maximum of 50 per cent hike in collector rate has been implemented'. Collector rates are the minimum value at which any property can be registered in the government records. These rates serve as the benchmark to estimate the registration fee and stamp duty that needs to be paid while buying a property. The government's spokesperson added that in 72.01 per cent areas across Haryana, where the transaction value falls within 0 to 35 per cent of the collector rate, a 10 per cent hike in collector rate has been implemented. 'Nowhere has the rate been increased by more than 50 per cent. In fact, in many areas, the revision has been limited to just 10 per cent or 15 per cent. Moreover, even after these adjustments, collector rates in most places remain significantly lower than the prevailing market rates,' the spokesperson said. Addressing the media on Sunday, Congress MP Randeep Singh Surjewala said: 'According to an estimate, the increase in collector rate will put a burden of Rs 5,000 crore on the people of Haryana annually… the steep hike in collector rates will shatter the common man's dream of owning a house'. 'The hike has triggered widespread criticism and raises serious concerns about housing affordability, especially for the poor, middle class, and lower-income groups,' he added. Questioning the rationale behind this steep hike, Surjewala accused the government of burdening the common man to meet government's own revenue targets and benefit private developers. 'In 2022, the state government had promised a pucca house for every citizen. However, that dream now appears to be slipping away, as rising land valuation, inflated property prices, and increased stamp duty are making homeownership unaffordable for many. The average citizen, already struggling with EMIs, is now facing an additional burden due to inflated registration and documentation costs,' the Congress MP added. Making further assertions, the Congress leader said, 'The state budget for 2025–26 sets a revenue collection target of Rs 16,555 crore through stamp duty and registration fees — up from Rs 14,000 crore in 2024–2025. To bridge fiscal gaps, especially those created by declining revenues from excise and liquor taxes, the government has now chosen to increase the collector rates as a backdoor tax. The collector rate hike disproportionately affects the housing sector, triggering automatic price increases in flats, plots, and builder projects. This is especially evident in regions developed under the Deen Dayal Awas Yojana, where builders shall be passing on the cost to buyers. As a result, housing inflation will continue to rise, making even basic housing unaffordable for many'. Drawing a comparison between 2018-19 and 2024-2025, Surjewala said, 'Collector rates have been increased between 50 per cent and 250 per cent in cities like Gurugram, Faridabad, Panchkula, Ambala, Karnal, Rohtak, Rewari, and Sonipat. This massive jump has occurred even as basic civic infrastructure — roads, water supply, sewage — remains inadequate in many areas'. Surjewala also raised 10 pointed questions seeking the chief minister's reply, with the main ones being the absence of a clear, scientific framework for collector rate revisions, lack of mechanism to ensure affordable housing, and the alleged nexus between government and real estate developers. The government, however, refuted Surjewala and other Opposition leaders' claims. A government spokesperson said, 'Revision of collector rates is a routine annual exercise carried out transparently and in alignment with prevailing market prices. This revision is guided by a data-driven and rational methodology, which analysis the top 50 per cent of property registrations in each segment specifically, where the transaction value exceeds the prevailing collector rate'. The spokesperson added that the 'government's aim is to promote transparent transactions, effectively curb black money, and provide the public with the opportunity to buy and sell property at fair and real market values'. What does the government claim? — A total of 2,46,812 collector rate segments across Haryana have been revised, with increases applied according to their respective transaction value slots, government spokesperson said. — 1,77,731 segments, accounting for 72.01 per cent of the total, fall within the 0 to 35 per cent transaction value slot, where a 10 per cent increase has been implemented. — 19,966 segments (8.09 per cent) fall within the 35 to 70 per cent transactional value slot, where a 15 per cent increase has been applied. — 10,985 segments (4.45 per cent) where the transaction value exceeds the collector rate by 70 to 100 per cent, a 20 per cent increase has been implemented. — 11,078 segments (4.49 per cent) fall in the 100 to 150 per cent slot, where the increase is 30 per cent. — 6,393 segments (2.59 per cent) fall in the 150 to 200 percent range, where a 40 per cent increase has been applied. — 20,659 segments (accounting for 8.37 per cent of the total), fall in the category where the transaction value exceeds the collector rate by more than 200 per cent, a maximum increase of 50 per cent has been implemented.
