Mahashtra introduces Hindi as 3rd language in schools, move sparks backlash
Hindi will now be taught as the third language in English and Marathi medium schools in Maharashtra from classes 1 to 5, the state government said on Tuesday. According to the government order, Hindi has not been mandatory and will 'generally' be the third language. However, if at least 20 students per grade want to study any language other than Hindi as a third, the schools have an option to opt out.
The move, which aligns with the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020, drew sharp criticism from not just the Opposition but also Marathi language advocates, who accused the government of giving a 'backdoor' entry to the policy after initially backtracking, reported PTI. Congress, which is in opposition in the state, accused Maharashtra chief minister Devendra Fadnavis of "stabbing" the Marathi people in the chest.
The order gives an option to schools to opt out of teaching Hindi if 20 students from each standard wish to learn some other language.
"Those who wish to learn any other language as an option to Hindi, should meet the expectation of 20 students from each standard in a school. In such a situation, a teacher for that particular language will be made available or the language will be taught online," the order read.
If a demand of teaching any other language arises, either a teacher will be appointed or the language will be taught online, the order added.
For schools that follow other mediums of instruction, the three-language formula must include the medium language, Marathi and English, the order said.
The fresh move by the Maharashtra education department comes in contrast to what the state's education minister said earlier.
When the Maharashtra government tried to bring the three language policy earlier this year by introducing Hindi from class 1, it was met with severe backlash. Following this, state's School Education Minister Dada Bhuse on April 22 said that Hindi will not be compulsory.
'The decision to introduce Hindi from class 1 as a third language was taken earlier. However, many parents have suggested it be introduced from class 3 instead. We will consider these suggestions before taking any further decision," Bhuse said at an event in Pune last month.
He added that the three-language formula was 'on hold' and that the schools will operate under the current two-language system for now. However, the fresh move by the state government contradicts Bhuse's statements.
Deepak Pawar of the Mumbai-based Marathi Bhasha Abhyas Kendra called the action 'nothing but the backdoor imposition of Hindi'. "The government has betrayed the Marathi people. If we remain silent now, it will pave the way for dismantling the federal structure and the legacy of the Samyukta Maharashtra movement," he said in a social media post
According to Vasant Kalpande, former chairman of the Maharashtra State Board of Secondary and Higher Secondary Education, it will be difficult for the students at such a young age to understand the nuances and differences between Marathi and Hindi scripts and that it is not likely to find 20 students in a class who want to study some other language than Hindi. "The provision to make teacher available online is also an attempt to discourage opting for any other language than Hindi," he said. He also pointed out that in Gujarat and Assam, which are also BJP-ruled states, Hindi is not a mandatory third language in schools.
Maharashtra Congress president Harshwardhan Sapkal slammed chief minister Devendra Fadnavis and said he has 'once again stabbed a dagger into the heart of Maharashtra'. He called the option of opting out of Hindi 'a pretense of choice while a deliberate conspiracy to impose Hindi!'
'This is nothing but BJP's anti-Maharashtra agenda, a plot to destroy the Marathi language, Marathi identity, and the Marathi people. It is clear from this that the loyalty of Fadnavis, Shinde, and Ajit Pawar lies not with Maharashtra or the Marathi people but with the rulers in Delhi,' Sapkal said in a post on X.
'The Shinde faction, which repeatedly invokes Balasaheb Thackeray's name, controls the education department, yet they have stabbed a dagger in the back of Shiv Sena, just as they have taken a contract to murder Marathi.'
'Ajit Pawar is so desperate for power that he cares little whether Maharashtra, the Marathi language, or the Marathi people live or die. His only policy is to secure the finance department for himself,' he added.
With PTI inputs.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
33 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
MP Upendra Kushwaha seeks fairer representation in parliament for Bihar and UP
Former Union minister Upendra Kushwaha on Sunday claimed that states like Bihar and Uttar Pradesh have an inadequate representation in Parliament and delimitation was necessary to set things right. I would urge my Hindu brethren to show some magnanimity, Kushwaha said.(ANI file) Addressing a rally in Gayaji, the Rajya Sabha MP also termed as "misleading" the contention that better implementation of family planning measures had slowed down the growth in population of southern states and delimitation would put these at a disadvantage. "If we see the period between 1881, when the first census was held under British Raj, and the Independence in 1947, the rate of growth in southern states was higher. The reason being famines and pandemics hitting Bihar and adjoining states like Uttar Pradesh with greater severity", claimed the Rashtriya Lok Morcha (RLM) chief. The RLM is an NDA partner. He said, "If we look at the data, in southern states there is a Lok Sabha constituency for every 21 lakh people while in Bihar and UP 31 lakh people elect one MP. This militates against Babasaheb Ambedkar's principle of one person one vote and every vote having an equal value". Kushwaha blamed the "injustice" on the Congress, saying, "During the Emergency, in 1976, the Delimitation Act was amended, which disrupted the earlier practice of census and delimitation taking place together. Now, the number of parliamentary constituencies has been static for 50 years. Otherwise, Bihar would have 60 MPs, 20 more than its current strength in the Lower House". He also said, "Over the years, the rate of population growth in the south has declined not because of performance of governments in states but due to improvement in education, which they could afford much before the Hindi heartland could catch up". "Education has been spreading in the Hindi-speaking states and this will have an impact on the growth of population here as well. But until that happens, let the region's representation in Parliament be commensurate with its population", said Kushwaha. He also expressed solidarity with Buddhists demanding full control of the Maha Bodhi Temple at Bodh Gaya, where Buddha is said to have got enlightened 2,500 years ago. "I am myself a Hindu and not a Buddhist. But I would urge my Hindu brethren to show some magnanimity. They are free to have full control of crores of temples. Let them give up their claim on just one and prove that Vasudhaiv Kutumbakam is not a mere slogan", added Kushwaha. He also said, "Some may see me as a stormy petrel. When I was in the first council of ministers of Narendra Modi, my criticism of the collegium system in higher judiciary raised many eyebrows. But I consider myself a trailblazer. Today all parties are speaking against the discriminatory system of appointment of judges in High Courts and the Supreme Court".
Time of India
39 minutes ago
- Time of India
India is well-positioned to emerge as centres of gravity, says Anand Mahindra; calls for speed & private investment amid 'Globalisation 2.0'
A rising tide of protectionism is reshaping global trade, but it is not the end of globalisation—rather its rebirth, said Mahindra Group Chairman Anand Mahindra in his address to shareholders in the company's 2024–25 annual report. Mahindra believes this transition offers India a unique opportunity to emerge as a new centre of gravity in what he called "Globalisation 2.0". "India, too, will face challenges," Mahindra said, noting the evolving nature of global trade marked by shifting alliances, reduced dependence on China-centric supply chains, and diminishing dominance of the US market. He said the world is moving toward a "multi-polar, regional, and domestically driven" model of globalisation, in which India is well-positioned to thrive. "Ironically, the US shift toward de-globalisation may lead to a new avatar of globalisation… I believe India is well-positioned to emerge as one of the new centres of gravity," Mahindra asserted. He underscored India's advantages, including its stable democracy, reputation as a reliable partner, and a strong, apolitical military. However, Mahindra cautioned that the future remains uncertain. "Whether it be a country or a business, the winners will be the ones who can successfully navigate uncertainty and ambiguity—the ones who are resilient." by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like One of the Most Successful Investors of All Time, Warren Buffett, Recommends: 5 Books for Turning... Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Click Here Undo Referring to geopolitical volatility, Mahindra acknowledged that India faces risks, especially with 'our provocative neighbour', Pakistan. "I am optimistic that we can demonstrate the limits to our tolerance without impeding our path to economic ascendance," he added, quoted PTI. He pointed out that US-China decoupling, while uncertain, is likely to continue, impacting trade flows. "International trade has already slowed amidst heightened uncertainty and dampened investor confidence," he said. Industries relying on global supply chains—such as electronics and consumer goods—are particularly vulnerable due to rising input costs, he warned. Mahindra stressed that India must rethink its trade dependencies and diversify sourcing. He predicted increased localisation, re-engineered supply chains, and the formation of new trade networks globally. India's trade deficit, sectoral vulnerabilities, and rising competition must be addressed strategically. "The challenge will be to minimise the adverse effects, akin to how Lord Shiva confined the poison to his throat without letting it spread," Mahindra said, invoking the mythological reference of Samudra Manthan. But he urged India not to merely mitigate risks but seize this shift as a growth opportunity. "Instead, we can proactively view this as an opportunity to enable some 'Amrit' to emerge," he said. Mahindra emphasised that private enterprise must lead this economic transformation with speed and agility. India could benefit from China's adversarial stance, which may open up new opportunities in supply chains. Mahindra said India must focus on innovation, R&D, and manufacturing to capture market share from global competitors. "Restrictions on China and high tariffs for other competing countries could open new markets for Indian goods," he said. To make the most of the moment, Mahindra warned, India must act swiftly. "Speed and agility are essential, as countries like the Philippines and Vietnam are already touting themselves as future manufacturing hubs. We must act swiftly and strategically to secure our share of the Amrit." Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays and public holidays . AI Masterclass for Students. Upskill Young Ones Today!– Join Now
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
After Hindi imposition GR scrapped: Uddhav, Raj Thackeray cancel protest march, to hold victory rally now
With the Maharashtra government scrapping the Government Resolutions on the three language policy in primary school curriculums in the state, the much anticipated July 5 protest march, organised by the Shiv Sena (UBT) and the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) where the two Thackeray cousins Raj and Uddhav were expected to share stage, has now been cancelled. While Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Sanjay Raut announced that the July 5 march has been called off following the GR rollback, terming it as a ' Marathi people's victory, Uddhav announced that the originally planned protest on July 5 would now be converted into a celebratory public meeting or victory rally. 'The government's imposition lost to the unity of Marathi people. Now instead of the protest March, we will now hold a victory rally and gathering. The venue and final format will be decided in consultation with all participants in the coming days,' Uddhav said after the announcement of scrapping the GRs. MNS chief Raj Thackeray also termed it as a victory but reacted with a stern warning. 'We believe both GRs have been cancelled permanently — and it better be. If there is any attempt to revive this through the Narendra Jadhav committee, we will not allow that committee to function in Maharashtra,' Thackeray posted on X. He termed it as a decisive victory for the Marathi People and said that had the July 5 march taken place, it would have been so massive and it would've reminded people of the days of the Samyukta Maharashtra Movement. 'Maybe the government got scared of the unity of Marathi people — and if it did, it should be! This fear must stay! Now the government has announced a new committee. Let me say this clearly: Whether the committee's report comes or not – such attempts will not be tolerated government must etch this into its memory permanently. We consider this decision permanently revoked, and so do the people of Maharashtra. So do not try to create confusion again through any committee report. If that happens, this committee will not be allowed to function in Maharashtra. Let the government take note,' Raj said in his post. Addressing a press conference at his Matoshree residence in Mumbai, Uddhav Thackeray also launched a scathing attack on the state government, alleging that the attempt to introduce Hindi under the three-language formula was part of a 'hidden agenda' by the BJP which has be now completely defeated due to strong resistance of Marathi people. 'The BJP wanted to divide the Marathi community by creating a Marathi vs non-Marathi narrative and then pull non-Marathi votes towards themselves,' Thackeray alleged. 'But the Marathi people showed maturity. They did not fall for the trap. The movement was not against Hindi, but against imposition. And because it was about resisting imposition, the unity held.' he said. Thackeray said the state was hoping that the protest would fracture from within but it did not and hence the government was forced to withdraw the GRs. 'They believed the protest would splinter and that a divided Marathi voice would benefit them. But that didn't happen. That is why the GRs had to be withdrawn,' he said. Terming the BJP's approach a propaganda machine, Uddhav said that the BJP has turned into a factory of lies. 'They manufacture fake narratives, spread rumours, and use them to gather votes. But this time, they got a fitting reply.' He also criticised the formation of the Narendra Jadhav committee to review the language policy. 'Committee or no committee — we will not tolerate Hindi imposition. This time the GRs were rolled back. But let the government know: this issue is over. We consider the decision permanently withdrawn.' Calling on the people to remain vigilant, Thackeray added, 'Don't wait for another crisis. Remain alert and aware. The Marathi community's unity and anger were visible — and they must remain. Those trying to undermine Marathi are not outsiders, but insiders who have no emotional connection with the language.' On allegations from CM Fadnavis claiming that the three language formula was approved by Uddhav Thackeray himself when he was CM in the MVA government, Uddhav said the report cited by the government was never considered by the cabinet under him and he di not give any such approval. 'I didn't even read the report… The report was never under consideration and I never issued any GR. This government issued the GR so it should stop spreading lies now ,' Uddhav said. Earlier in the day, the Shiv Sena (UBT) held a symbolic burning of the government resolution (GR) at Azad Maidan, with several opposition leaders joining in to register their opposition to the three languages policy.
