'55% of local cigarette producers evade taxes'
The Institute for Public Opinion and Research (IPOR) released its research report today during a press briefing in Lahore. The report sheds light on the alarming rise in the illicit cigarette trade across Pakistan and the gaps in enforcing existing tobacco control laws.
During the briefing, IPOR Executive Director, Tariq Junaid revealed that more than 54% of cigarette brands available in the market are in blatant violation of national laws, particularly the Track and Trace System (TTS) and Graphical Health Warnings (GHWs). He highlighted that despite the implementation of GHWs in 2009 and TTS in 2022, enforcement has been practically non-existent, creating space for the illegal trade to thrive. Cigarette packs without health warnings and without TTS stamps are openly being sold in the market.
He pointed out that although legislation introduced in 2019 mandated that 60% of each cigarette pack must display a graphical health warning, six years later, 286 brands are still openly sold without any health warnings. This, he noted, is a clear breach of the law. Junaid added that, much like in other areas, the Track and Trace System appears to have failed in curbing these violations.
According to the report, a survey was conducted across 1,520 retail outlets in 19 districts, identifying 413 different cigarette brands being sold. Alarmingly, only 19 brands were found to be compliant with TTS requirements while 394 brands were found without stamps.
The vast majority lacked tax stamps and the legally mandated health warnings. Moreover, 332 brands were being sold below the legal minimum price of Rs162.25, with some priced as low as Rs40 — posing not just a regulatory challenge but also causing significant loss to government revenue.
The report further disclosed that 55% of illicit cigarettes are produced locally without paying taxes, while 45% are smuggled from abroad. This unchecked illegal trade is causing an estimated annual loss of over Rs300 billion to the national treasury.
During the session, Junaid also responded to questions related to tobacco sector regulations. He stressed that each time the government increases tobacco taxes, illegal cigarette sellers are the primary beneficiaries, as the lack of enforcement drives consumers toward cheaper, illicit tax-evading alternatives.
He urged the government to take immediate and decisive action by enhancing monitoring of retail outlets nationwide, ensuring full compliance with TTS and GHWs by all manufacturers, and launching a coordinated national crackdown on the illegal cigarette trade. These actions, he stated, are critical not just for ensuring legal accountability but also for safeguarding state revenue and maintaining fair business competition.
Junaid warned that this is not merely a regulatory shortfall, but a serious economic and legal crisis that demands urgent, integrated, and effective government intervention.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
6 days ago
- Business Recorder
FC personnel deployed to monitor GLT units in KP
ISLAMABAD: Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) Member Inland Revenue (Operations) Dr Hamid Ateeq Sarwar has said that around 144 personnel of Frontier Constabulary force have been deployed in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa to regulate/ monitor Green Leaf Threshing units, to strengthen enforcement for checking massive evasion in tobacco sector. During the last meeting of the Public Accounts Committee, Dr Sarwar stated that two platoons of FC have been deployed at 13 GLT units for the purpose of enforcement. There are only around 13 GLTs in Pakistan, all fully traceable, making them the most logical taxation choke point. In contrast, there are over 450,000 retail outlets, selling cigarettes and more than 50 cigarette factories – primarily in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KPK) and Azad Jammu & Kashmir (AJK) – where enforcement at post-processing levels is far more challenging. FBR to strictly monitor tobacco movement The FED at GLTs, fully traceable processing units—is a key tax enforcement mechanism designed to curb revenue leakage and illicit cigarette manufacturing. By documenting actual volumes processed by manufacturers, the system ensures declared production aligns with tax liabilities, strengthening the national economy. Unprecedented excise increase in recent years on the legitimate cigarette manufacturing companies and too low advance FED in previous years has led to the illicit sector to grow to more than 56% of the market. This increase has been fuelled by smuggled cigarette brands. FBR needs to analyse how much tobacco was processed at GLTs and how much adjustable FED was collected from cigarette manufacturers and how much of this adjustable FED was actually adjusted against the final liability. FBR also needs to check how the GLT processing corresponds with the leaf buying of these manufacturers. Sources told Business Recorder that the country's tax potential from the cigarette sector exceeds Rs 600 billion annually. The two multinational companies that hold 44% of the market paid Rs 292 billion in taxes. Contrary to this, more than 40 local manufacturers controlling the remaining 56% of the market paid a meagre Rs 5 billion. Over Rs 300 billion in tax revenue, more than the federal allocations for education and health combined, has disappeared into the black market. FBR Chairman Rashid Mahmood Langrial recently admitted that over 90% of the cigarette sector operates outside the formal tax system. The Track and Trace System, introduced to enforce compliance, is failing. Only 19 of 413 registered brands are compliant. The government has proposed deploying Frontier Constabulary units in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa to regulate Green Leaf Threshing, signalling the extraordinary scale of the breakdown in civilian enforcement mechanisms. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
31-05-2025
- Business Recorder
Cigarette industry demands effective TTS enforcement
KARACHI: Cigarette industry has urged the federal government for the special measures in the budget for effective enforcement of digital monitoring tools like Track and Trace System (TTS) to collect the billions of rupees additional tax revenue. As per estimates, Pakistan's illicit cigarette market is draining over Rs415 billion annually from the national treasury, shifting an unfair tax burden onto compliant manufacturers, which are the leading tax payer sector in the country. While illegal manufacturers evade taxes and regulatory oversight, legal companies bear nearly all the tax load despite having less than half the market share. This creates a distorted market where legal businesses struggle to compete, and consumers unknowingly support illicit trade through inflated prices and limited product choices. Industry sources said that illicit trade severely disrupts market balance, forcing lawful manufacturers to shoulder disproportionate tax costs. This not only harms the industry's growth but ultimately affects consumers who pay higher prices for taxed products, they added. 'Effective enforcement of digital monitoring tools like Track and Trace is essential to restore fairness and protect government revenues,' they said. Experts warned that if preventive measures are not taken in the upcoming budget, illicit trade will continue to erode government resources needed for public services, hinder economic development, and encourage illegal business practices that undermine the rule of law in Pakistan. Industry experts emphasise that cracking down on illicit trade through enhanced regulatory frameworks can reclaim billions in lost revenue and ensure a level playing field for all stakeholders. They said that the government can earn billions of rupees revenue by fully implementing the track and trace system in the industry. Several commitments have been made in the past to address this issue; however, enforcement actions on the ground have not been taken to curtail the scale of the illicit trade. In absence of the full implementation of the Track and Trace system, illicit operators are growing freely and depriving the national exchequer of much-needed billions of rupees revenue. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
23-05-2025
- Express Tribune
'55% of local cigarette producers evade taxes'
Listen to article The Institute for Public Opinion and Research (IPOR) released its research report today during a press briefing in Lahore. The report sheds light on the alarming rise in the illicit cigarette trade across Pakistan and the gaps in enforcing existing tobacco control laws. During the briefing, IPOR Executive Director, Tariq Junaid revealed that more than 54% of cigarette brands available in the market are in blatant violation of national laws, particularly the Track and Trace System (TTS) and Graphical Health Warnings (GHWs). He highlighted that despite the implementation of GHWs in 2009 and TTS in 2022, enforcement has been practically non-existent, creating space for the illegal trade to thrive. Cigarette packs without health warnings and without TTS stamps are openly being sold in the market. He pointed out that although legislation introduced in 2019 mandated that 60% of each cigarette pack must display a graphical health warning, six years later, 286 brands are still openly sold without any health warnings. This, he noted, is a clear breach of the law. Junaid added that, much like in other areas, the Track and Trace System appears to have failed in curbing these violations. According to the report, a survey was conducted across 1,520 retail outlets in 19 districts, identifying 413 different cigarette brands being sold. Alarmingly, only 19 brands were found to be compliant with TTS requirements while 394 brands were found without stamps. The vast majority lacked tax stamps and the legally mandated health warnings. Moreover, 332 brands were being sold below the legal minimum price of Rs162.25, with some priced as low as Rs40 — posing not just a regulatory challenge but also causing significant loss to government revenue. The report further disclosed that 55% of illicit cigarettes are produced locally without paying taxes, while 45% are smuggled from abroad. This unchecked illegal trade is causing an estimated annual loss of over Rs300 billion to the national treasury. During the session, Junaid also responded to questions related to tobacco sector regulations. He stressed that each time the government increases tobacco taxes, illegal cigarette sellers are the primary beneficiaries, as the lack of enforcement drives consumers toward cheaper, illicit tax-evading alternatives. He urged the government to take immediate and decisive action by enhancing monitoring of retail outlets nationwide, ensuring full compliance with TTS and GHWs by all manufacturers, and launching a coordinated national crackdown on the illegal cigarette trade. These actions, he stated, are critical not just for ensuring legal accountability but also for safeguarding state revenue and maintaining fair business competition. Junaid warned that this is not merely a regulatory shortfall, but a serious economic and legal crisis that demands urgent, integrated, and effective government intervention.
