'Pay them': As WNBA All-Star party wraps up, athlete pay comes into focus
Players took the court in Indianapolis wearing shirts that read "Pay Us What You Owe Us," after a meeting to discuss a new collective bargaining agreement (CBA) on Thursday that union members said was a missed opportunity.
Fans got the message, chanting "Pay them!" as Commissioner Cathy Engelbert appeared on the court at Gainbridge Fieldhouse after the final buzzer.
"To have the fans backing us - I think it means everything," said Napheesa Collier, the All-Star Game MVP.
It set the tone for the coming months, with the current CBA set to expire on October 31, after a two-day celebration of a league on the rise.
Advertisements featuring the WNBA's top players blanketed the city center and jersey-wearing fans poured into town, signaling a new era for the league with national viewership up 23% year-over-year for the first half of the season.
The only dent to the enthusiasm appeared to be the absence of Indiana Fever sharpshooter Caitlin Clark, who was expected to be the biggest attraction at the annual showcase in her home market but had to sit out the game injured.
But behind the scenes, players voiced frustration over what they felt was poor progress in their labor negotiations with the league, after opting out of their current collective bargaining agreement (CBA) early.
The Women's National Basketball Players Association issued a stern statement after the two sides met in Indianapolis on Thursday.
A day later, players fumed over the meeting that union President Nneka Ogwumike called a "missed opportunity," and she said the league had taken five months to respond to the WNBPA's last proposal.
"I feel as though, if there was a response to our proposal that reflected any type of change that incorporated what we had proposed, then perhaps five months would have made a little bit more sense," she told reporters.
Engelbert struck a more positive tone, saying she felt the meeting with players had been productive.
"(I'm) really optimistic that we'll get something done, that it'll be transformational," said Engelbert, who has overseen a remarkable period of growth for the league since taking the reins in 2019.
Key issues targeted by players include an increase in revenue sharing, with male counterparts in the NBA now taking home about half of basketball-related revenue, a far greater share.
Fixed costs almost certainly take a larger share of the WNBA's revenue, said Andrew Zimbalist, a professor emeritus of economics at Smith College, who said that 50% was nonetheless still "a perfectly feasible target for the women."
"The players have every reason to be aggressive here," said Zimbalist, who has consulted in the sports industry for players, teams and leagues.
"I wouldn't expect them to reach a 50% target immediately, but to reach it over two or three years seems entirely plausible."
Any disruption to the 2026 season stands to dent the tremendous momentum the league now enjoys, with two new clubs set to debut next year in Portland and Toronto.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
4 hours ago
- The Guardian
WNBA truths and fictions: the real state of the league in 2025
The WNBA is one of those leagues that is perpetually at the crossroads. In the 1990s, the league saw off the challenge of the American Basketball League (ABL), which paid higher salaries but lacked the NBA's marketing muscle, but perhaps that victory gave the NBA and WNBA a dose of complacency. Attendance steadily dropped for several years, and went through revolving doors from city to city – or into permanent hiatus. Now, with women's sports in the middle of a growth spurt and the dazzling skills of Caitlin Clark on display, the WNBA has an age-old issue: More money, more problems – or, at least, more critics conjuring up more questions. We live in a media landscape in which the fretting over 'generational talents' is so robust that NBA fans started panicking about Cooper Flagg when he had a poor shooting performance in his first Summer League game. As anyone knows from following her college career, she doesn't just have extraordinary shooting range. She can dominate a game with her passing even if her shots aren't falling. To be sure, Clark certainly has a lot of work to do before she turns the corner from being the league's most exciting player to becoming the league's best player. In her rookie year, Basketball Reference calculated her PER, a measure of overall effectiveness, at 18.8, nowhere near the top four of A'ja Wilson (34.9), Breanna Stewart (26.4), Brittney Griner (26.0) and Napheesa Collier (25.1). But PER tends to favor forwards and centers – such Clark's Indiana teammate, 2023 top overall draft pick Aliyah Boston, who was also ahead of Clark. Among guards, she was third. She also led the league in assists per game with 8.4, with only Alyssa Thomas (7.9) anywhere close. On the other hand, she also led the league in turnovers with a staggering mark of 5.6 per game – Thomas again was second at 3.6. This year, Clark is struggling with injuries, and most of her scoring and shooting numbers have dropped significantly. Given the ridiculously short window of a WNBA season, she may not have time to pull her season averages up to where they were last year. The WNBA actually has a trio of young 'generational talent' guards who have come into the league in the 2020s. The first was Sabrina Ionescu, a record-smashing triple-double machine from Oregon who had a slow, injury-riddled start to her pro career but has since made the All-WNBA second team three straight years – and surely had a case to make the first team ahead of Clark last year. The next is Paige Bueckers, who is putting together a rookie season almost on par with Clark's season last year. In a year or two, depending on when she declares for the draft, the WNBA will add USC's JuJu Watkins. In the media and player All-Star voting, the leader was Bueckers' teammate in Dallas, Allisha Gray. Funny how they don't seem to be held responsible for the Wings being in last place, and yet critics harp on Clark because Indiana isn't dominating. So the fans got it wrong in ranking Clark first and Ionescu fifth. But the players' votes were harsh on stars (Clark) and Olympians (Jackie Young was 12th; Kelsey Plum a bewildering 16th). For once, the media may have gotten it right, ranking her third. Truth or fiction: Truth In a recent anonymous survey of WNBA by the Athletic, a majority of respondents said Clark will be the face of the WNBA in five years. But it was a slim majority of 53.8%. Watkins was second, Bueckers was third. Next was the first non-guard, Clark nemesis Angel Reese, and A'ja Wilson, who was merely the MVP of the WNBA (for the third time) and the Olympics in 2024. And yet the WNBA is headed toward its highest average attendance ever (see below), propelled somewhat by Clark but also by the fervor behind the expansion Golden State Valkyries. While ratings certainly drop when she's out injured, they don't fall through the floor. Perhaps the fact that Clark has not immediately established herself as the best player in the league has made people realize that veterans like Wilson, Stewart, Griner, Collier and Ionescu know how to play some ball, too. Truth or fiction: Fiction In the cartoon Futurama, a female computer is horrified to learn that the men who have landed on an all-women's planet made fun of women's basketball. 'What??! Did you explain how the women's good fundamentals make up for their inability to dunk?' roars the computer, voiced by Bea Arthur. The men scoffed at the concept. But WNBA players' fundamentals are indeed pretty good, most notably free throws – the NBA's highest overall percentage of the past 10 years (78.4%, 2023-24) trails behind the WNBA's lowest (78.5%, 2024, down from 80.0% the year before and 80.8% in 2021). The WNBA is also more of a passing league than the NBA, which sees its stars shine in one-on-one isolations. In 2024, 68.6% of field goals in WNBA play were the result of assists. In the NBA last season, the number was 63.6%. In the NBA, you may see Anthony Edwards explode past a defender for a dunk. In the WNBA, you may see Caitlin Clark whip a pass through a seam mere mortals wouldn't have anticipated. True basketball fans appreciate both, and the US has a lot of true basketball fans. Truth or fiction: Fiction WNBA officials have had their share of detractors this year, among them standout players Angel Reese (Chicago) and Kelsey Plum (Los Angeles), coaches Natalie Nakase (Golden State) and Stephanie White (Indiana). The latter's criticism followed a game against the Connecticut Sun in which Clark was poked in the eye in the third quarter, and Clark's assailant was fouled near the end of the game with the outcome not in doubt, prompting a scuffle that saw three people ejected. White's complaint was a familiar refrain: 'The referees lost control of the game.' Did they? The eye poke on Clark drew a flagrant foul on Connecticut's Jacy Sheldon, while Clark and two Connecticut players got technical fouls for the ensuing fracas. In the last minute, Sheldon drove into Indiana's Sophie Cunningham, who pulled Sheldon down onto the floor. Cunningham could argue that Sheldon initiated the contact by lowering her shoulder and charging into her like a running back or rugby player, and that she accidentally pulled down Sheldon while stumbling backwards. But she and the Fever have embraced the notion that Cunningham filled the role of an NHL enforcer, protecting their star player when the refs wouldn't. Cunningham's jersey sales went through the roof, and entrepreneurs are selling commemorative T-shirts in her honor. Maybe the WNBA has found a new source of revenue? WNBA refs are paid far less than their NBA counterparts, so no one should be surprised if the men's league attracts more experienced referees. But the refs aren't the ones escalating things even after the flagrant and technical fouls have been called. And NBA refs aren't exactly above reproach. Even if we toss out the aberration of Tim Donaghy, the referee who spent time in prison after a gambling scandal, NBA referees have been the object of many fine-worthy infractions through the years. Anthony Edwards' fines in a single season could pay several WNBA players' salaries. Should WNBA refs do more to protect stars like Clark so that Cunningham won't feel compelled to do it herself? Maybe. But they'd also do well to avoid the absurdity of the 1990s, when the mere act of trying to guard Michael Jordan could draw a whistle. Truth or fiction: Mixed That's not the easiest set of questions, and it's just part of the league's to-do list right now. The WNBA has to manage expansion carefully while also landing a fair collective bargaining agreement to prevent a work stoppage. But these are also happier questions to consider than 'Will the league survive the season?'
Daily Mail
18 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Caitlin Clark receives injury update as WNBA return is left in doubt
Caitlin Clark 's status remains unclear, but the Indiana Fever sensation did get some good news on Thursday. After Clark underwent further medical testing on her ailing right groin, the team has announced that no additional injury or tissue damage was discovered. Thus far, Clark has missed three games, including the All-Star Game, but is currently traveling with the team. Clark is still working with medical staff on her recovery. She previously battled left groin and left quad strains earlier this season. She has now missed 11 of 24 Fever games on top of last weekend's All-Star festivities in Indianapolis. As a result, the WNBA 's Nielsen ratings have suffered in 2025 after shattering all league records during Clark's rookie season. MORE TO FOLLOW...
Reuters
18 hours ago
- Reuters
No timetable for Caitlin Clark's return to Fever
July 24 - When Caitlin Clark is ready to return from her third injury of the season, the Indiana Fever plan to share the news. Until then, Clark is out -- including Thursday's home game with the Las Vegas Aces -- until further notice with no timetable for her return from a right groin injury. Clark has played in only 13 of 24 games. She missed three weeks with a left quad strain and then a left groin injury sidelined her for two weeks. When she came back it was a brief break from the trainer's room. The Fever entered Thursday at 12-12, a half-game behind the sixth-place Aces (12-11). Indiana called off a scheduled shootaround Thursday morning and takes the court against Las Vegas following a 14-point loss to the Liberty in New York on Tuesday. Clark traveled with the team and met with doctors in New York. Clark missed last weekend's WNBA All-Star Game and said during the media sessions that the rash of injuries was unfamiliar, reminding her she's mortal. "This is the first time I haven't felt like a young body that can run around and sprint every day and just continue to do that," Clark said. "Being a professional athlete, you really have to take care of both your body and your mind -- it's been a journey learning about that." Clark is averaging 16.5 points, 8.8 assists and 5.0 rebounds per game but can't shake a shooting slump she credits partially to her leg injuries. For the season, she's shooting just 36.7 percent from the field and 27.9 percent from 3-point range. --Field Level Media
