EU eyes action over Hungary's planned Russia-style law
Tens of thousands of Hungarians took to the streets over the weekend after the Hungarian government tabled new legislation to monitor foreign funding for NGOs and media outlets or anyone deemed a threat to what it sees as Hungarian sovereign interest.
The bill is labeled "Transparency of Public Life' and the government says it is aimed at protecting
Hungary
's sovereignty from outside interference. But activists say it mimics Russia's foreign agent law and would similarly offer the Hungarian government sweeping powers to crack down on the press and critical voices in civil society.
The protests are the latest cry for help from Hungarians looking at the European Union to reign in their government.
Some of the protesters in front of the parliament in the Hungarian capital Budapest held a big flag of the European Union imprinted with the English word HELP.
What is Hungary's new 'transparency law?'
If the draft bill were to turn into law, activists say, the government could control media outlets and NGOs or even dissolve them.
In December 2023, Hungary passed a national law on the "Defence of Sovereignty" and established what it called a Sovereignty Protection Office (SPO) to investigate organizations that use foreign funds to influence voters.
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
עם ביטוח רכב של 9 תחסכו כסף. המחיר הכי זול אצלנו באתר
ביטוח רכב 9
לקבלת הצעה
Undo
With the new law, that agency will be responsible for investigating all kinds of organizations and authorized to blacklist those who receive foreign funding without prior government approval.
If blacklisted, organizations will also lose access to donations through Hungary's annual 1% income tax contribution scheme, potentially pay a fine of 25 times these funds, and their owners will be made to declare their assets.
Reports suggest that the country's secret services have been authorized to assist SPO in any investigations.
Tineke Strik
, Hungary rapporteur of the European Parliament, told DW that Hungary's transparency bill was aimed at "dissolving all organizations, all media outlets, even punishing all individuals, that criticize the government. That is exactly what the Russian law does."
Russia's foreign agent law was adopted in mid-2022, in what human right organizations described as a smearing campaign to discredit legitimate Russian civic activism.
"The law expands the definition of foreign agent to a point at which almost any person or entity, regardless of nationality or location, who engages in civic activism or even expresses opinions about Russian policies or officials' conduct could be designated a foreign agent, so long as the authorities claim they are under 'foreign influence,'" the NGO Human Rights Watch said.
Hungary's 'transparency' bill 'authoritarian'
Peter Magyar, the leader of Hungary's opposition Tisza party and the only Hungarian politician seen to be a credible challenger to Hungarian Prime Minister
Viktor Orban
's 14-year grip on power, also accused the government of adopting Russian-style legislation to strip funding for activists and journalists, including through EU grants. He said it was "copying its master, [Russian President ]
Vladimir Putin
."
A statement signed by 300 international organizations including the human rights organization Amnesty International described the bill as an "authoritarian attempt to retain power" that "aims to silence all critical voices and to eliminate what remains of Hungarian democracy."
The non-profit group Transparency International said the new bill threatened to "end civil society" and, if passed, would empower the government to "persecute with impunity."
It said the law would apply to EU grants and foreign donations as small as €5 ($5.70), and that "vague language" adopted in the bill left "wide room for political misuse, threatening a broad swathe of civil society — including independent media, watchdog organizations, and ordinary citizens engaged in public life."
Last year, Georgia adopted a similar law amidst much uproar at home and in Brussels. The move is suspected to have scuttled the country's chances of joining the EU.
But while Georgia is an EU candidate nation, Hungary is a full-fledged member of the bloc.
How can EU ensure Hungary aligns with the bloc's value system?
Zsuzsanna
Vegh
, a program officer at the German Marshall Fund of the United States, said that theoretically the EU could move ahead with the Article 7 procedure it first initiated in 2018.
The Treaty on the European Union outlines a procedure for addressing serious and persistent breaches of EU values by member states underArticle 7.
It allows for the suspension of certain rights, including voting rights in the Council of the European Union, if a member is determined to be in repeated violations of the EU's fundamental principles, such as weakening rule of law, democracy and freedoms.
"The EU could declare that there is indeed systematic violation of democracy and rule of law in Hungary and suspend its voting rights" in the Council of the European Union, where the bloc debates and decides its policies, Vegh said.
"But that is still a political decision and it is unlikely."
Some European parliamentarians have advocated that the EU slash Hungary's funding to force it to reduce corruption that has an adverse impact on the EU's financial interests. But experts say the same method could also be effective in encouraging Hungary to stick to the EU's value system.
"We urge the European Commission to increase pressure on Viktor Orban's government to cease violating EU values and EU Laws by immediately suspending all EU funding for Hungary in line with the applicable legislation to protect the Union's financial interest," more than two dozen EU parliamentarians wrote in a letter to the European Commission on May 20.
Vegh said that while some funds for Hungary had already been cut there was no precedent of the EU cutting all funding marked for a member state.
However, Teona Lavrelashvili, a visiting fellow with the Wilfried Martens Center in Brussels, said this could be done.
"Yes, the European Union can suspend funds to Hungary if its new transparency bill — or any law — undermines the rule of law or threatens the EU's financial interests.
This power comes from the Rule of Law Conditionality Mechanism."
She contended that a law that weakens civil society also undermines the EU's overall economic interests.
What can the EU do next?
The EU also has other options that it can resort to before cutting funds intended to aid economic development in Hungary and thus to benefit the general population.
Back in 2017, it managed to dissuade Hungary from introducing a similar transparency law by initiating an infringement procedure, a multilayered process through which the EU expressed its displeasure to Hungary. Upon no change in Budapest's attitudes, Brussels eventually took Hungary to the Court of Justice of the European Union (EU)
The court concluded that Hungary had "introduced discriminatory and unjustified restrictions on foreign donations to civil society organizations."
Since the new bill was tabled last week, the EU has refrained from scolding Hungary and merely said it is waiting to see whether it is enacted into law.
Vegh believes another infringement procedure is the EU's likely next step.
But the fact that Hungary is trying to push through the law again, may require the EU to change its approach and take a more stern stand.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NDTV
29 minutes ago
- NDTV
How Former Prisoners In Russia Are Rebuilding Lives in Ukraine
Kyiv: Since his release from a Russian prison in April, Stanislav Tarnavskyi has been in a hurry to build the life in Ukraine he dreamed about during three years of captivity. The 25-year-old has proposed to his girlfriend, bought an apartment and adopted a golden retriever. And that was just what he accomplished one week in July. But as busy as he is rekindling old relationships and creating new ones, Tarnavskyi cannot shake the trauma he and thousands of other Ukrainian soldiers experienced as prisoners of war. The UN says many endured beatings, starvation and humiliation at the hands of their captors - experiences that will leave lifelong scars. Tarnavskyi, who was captured during the battle for Mariupol in April of 2022, regularly has nightmares about the prisons where he was held. "I see the officers who watched over us. I dream they want to harm me, catch me," he said. When he wakes up, his heart pounds, anxiety surges - until he realizes he is in the outskirts of Kyiv, where he was forced to move because Russia occupied his hometown of Berdiansk. As the three-year war drags on, Tarnavskyi is one of more than 5,000 former POWs back in Ukraine rehabilitating with the help of regular counseling. Regardless of any physical injuries that may require attention, psychologists say it is vital to monitor former POWs for years after their release; the cost of war, they say, echoes for generations. In a photography studio high above Kyiv, Ukraine's capital, sunlight floods the white walls. After a shoot that lasted several hours Tarnavskyi said the brightness was hurting his eyes, which are still sensitive from years spent in a dark cell. But his mood couldn't be dimmed. The girlfriend who waited for his return had just consented to his surprise proposal. "I love you very much, I am very glad that you waited for me," Tarnavskyi said, holding a thick bouquet of pink roses and a ring. "You have always been my support, and I hope you will remain so for the rest of my life. Will you marry me?" Tarnavskyi said it was the thought of Tetiana Baieva - whom he met in 2021 - that helped stop him from committing suicide three times during captivity. Still, he finds it hard to talk with Baieva about his time in prison. He doesn't want to be pitied. Soon after he returned home, he was paranoid, feeling watched - a reaction to constant surveillance in prison. "If you stepped out of line, they'd (Russians) come and beat you. I still get flashbacks when I see (surveillance) cameras. If I see one, I get nervous," he said. But with each passing week, he is feeling better, progress Tarnavskyi credits to the work he is doing with a psychologist. Any small stimulus - a smell, a breeze, a color - can trigger traumatic memories for POWs, says Kseniia Voznitsyna, the director of Ukraine's Lisova Polyana mental health center for veterans on the outskirts of Kyiv. Yet contrary to stereotypes, ex-POWs aren't more aggressive. "They tend to isolate themselves, avoid large gatherings, and struggle with trust," said Voznitsyna. "They say time heals - five or ten years, maybe - but it doesn't," she added. "It just feels less intense." A 2014 study in the Journal of Behavioral Medicine found that Israeli ex-POWs and combat veterans tracked over 35 years had higher mortality rates, chronic illnesses and worse self-rated health - conditions partly tied to depression and post-traumatic stress disorder. The authors of the study said that is why it is crucial to monitor ex-POWs and give them specialized medical and psychological care as they age. That logic rings true to Denys Zalizko, a 21-year-old former POW who has been back in Ukraine for less than three months but is already sure his recovery will take a long time. "You can't fool yourself. Even if you really want to, you will never forget. It will always haunt you," he said. Zalizko survived torture, suicide attempts and relentless beatings during roughly 15 months in Russian captivity. The first time his mother, Maria Zalizko, saw him after his release, she barely recognized him. He was thin and appeared "broken", she said, with torment in his eyes. Zalizko's physical appearance is now almost completely different. His skin looks healthy, his muscles are taut and he has lots of energy. But still there is sadness in his eyes. Two things keep him moving forward and help clear his mind: music and exercise. "Pauses and stillness bring anxiety," says Zalizko. Like Tarnavskyi, he is receiving mandatory counseling at the Lisova Polyana mental health center. And like many former POWs, he still battles hypervigilance - listening for threats, scanning his surroundings. At night, sleep comes in fragments, and that was true even before a recent uptick in nightly drone attacks by the Russian army. For the families of POWs, the reintegration process is also a struggle. A psychologist advised Maria Zalizko to give her son space, to avoid calling him too often. But it is Denys who often calls her, sometimes singing over the phone - a skill she taught him as a child. "I love music. Music unites," he said, touching the tattoo of a treble clef behind his ear - inked after his return. Even in captivity, he sang quietly to himself, composing songs in his mind about love, home and war. Now he dreams of turning that passion into a career as an artist. "I've become stronger now," Zalizko said. "I'm not afraid of death, not afraid of losing an arm or a leg, not afraid of dying instantly. I fear nothing anymore." (Except for the headline, this story has not been edited by NDTV staff and is published from a syndicated feed.)
Time of India
37 minutes ago
- Time of India
Who is Ursula von der Leyen? President of the European Commission announces trade deal with US; calls it huge
Ursula von der Leyen, the European Commission's president since 2019, is the first woman to hold the position. She was chosen by national leaders to lead the EU through difficult times, and the European Parliament elected her to a second five-year term. She will serve as the Commission's leader until 2029. She speaks on behalf of the Commission in meetings of the European Council, G7 and G20 summits, summits with non-EU nations, and significant discussions in the European Parliament and Council. Why is the EU head in news? Ursula von der Leyen and US President Donald Trump struck a 'good deal' on Sunday to prevent the bloc from being slapped by punishing tariffs, as both leaders praised it. The stakes were high, with a deadline of August 1st approaching and a $1.9 trillion transatlantic commercial relationship at stake 'Together, the EU and the US are a market of 800 million people. And nearly 44 percent of global GDP. It's the biggest trade deal ever,' she said in a latest tweet. The leaders agreed that the 27-country bloc will pay a baseline charge of 15 percent instead of the threatening 30 percent, which will be a relief to many European businesses. However, not everyone will be satisfied with the agreement. The EU, on the other hand, has promised to invest an additional $600 billion in the US and buy $750 billion worth of American energy. Trump was prepared to increase the 10% duty to 30% if an agreement could not be reached by August 1.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
'Switch off our economy?' High commissioner to UK schools Western journalist on Russian oil; Doraiswami says Europe buys from same source it denies India
Indian High Commissioner to the UK Vikram Doraiswami NEW DELHI: Indian High Commissioner to the UK Vikram Doraiswami schooled the Western journalist over criticising India's oil imports from Russia and said that the New Delhi is the third largest consumer of energy in the world and imports over 80% of its products. "What would you have us do? Switch off our economy?" he asked. Speaking to British radio station, Times Radio, last week, pointed out the irony and said that many of the European countries are continuing to buy rare earth and other energy products, not oil, perhaps, but from the same countries that they're refusing to let India buy from. Asked about India's "closeness" with Russia and President Vladimir Putin, Indian high commissioner said, "We have a relationship that is based on a number of metrics. One of these is our long standing security relationship that goes back to an era in which some of our Western partners wouldn't sell us weapons, but would sell it to countries in our neighborhood that use them only to attack us. Second, we have an energy relationship today which is a result of everybody else buying energy from sources that we used to earlier buy from. So we've been displaced out of the energy market largely and the cost have gone up. These are we are the third largest consumer of energy in the world and we import over 80% of our product. What would you have us do? Switch off our economy?" "Third, we have, we also see around us relationships that other countries maintain for their own convenience with countries that are a source of difficulty for us. Do we ask you to come up with a little test of loyalty? " he added. Replying to question whether EU sanctions' on Russian oil impacted Indian refinery, Doraiswami pointed out that the India has the fourth largest refiner of energy in the world, and a number of countries in Europe buy refined oil from the nation. The European Union imposed ban on Russian crude-derived fuels, which will take effect from January 21 next year. The EU unveiled its newest sanctions against Russia in July, incorporating limitations on fuel imports processed from Russian crude oil.
