Medicines cheaper at pharmacies than clinics, patients report
Citing patients' feedback, he said those who buy their medicines at pharmacies often find them cheaper and more transparently priced than the bundled charges at clinics.
"Based on what patients have reported, the average price of medicines at community pharmacies is lower than at private clinics.
"Private clinics usually issue a lump sum charge after treatment, with no detailed breakdown. This makes it hard for patients to know how much they are paying for medicines specifically," he told Berita Harian.
Amrahi said the situation was even less clear when patients used medical or insurance cards, as claims were made directly to insurers.
"That's a difficult question to answer — what exactly is the cost involved in those claims?"
He explained that charges at private clinics typically include both the doctor's consultation fee and the cost of medicines, making it difficult to know the unit price of each item.
"In contrast, community pharmacies provide a detailed bill, showing the unit price of each product."
He added that prices of over-the-counter medicines are clearly displayed on shelves, while prices of controlled medicines can be provided on request, either electronically, in writing, or as a printout.
His comments come following the enforcement of mandatory price labelling for medicines, which took effect on May 1 under the Price Control and Anti-Profiteering (Price Marking for Medicines) Order 2025, pursuant to the Price Control and Anti-Profiteering Act 2011 (Act 723).
The ruling requires all private healthcare facilities and community pharmacies regulated under the Private Healthcare Facilities and Services Act 1998 [Act 586] to display prices for all medicines for human use — including prescription and non-prescription drugs, over-the-counter medicines, traditional remedies, health supplements, and extemporaneous preparations.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
a day ago
- New Straits Times
Root causes behind bullying in schools
KUALA LUMPUR: At least 10 key factors have been identified as driving bullying among school students, particularly in boarding schools, with the potential to cause lifelong harm to victims. Experts have attributed the emergence of bullies to a toxic culture of seniority, poor emotional management, lack of empathy, and the emotional toll of being separated from parents at a young age. Some students also succumb to peer pressure to avoid being seen as weak. Other contributing factors include the lack of proper religious or moral education, lenient school disciplinary systems that tolerate the "seniors bully juniors" culture, and a shortage of full-time counsellors and student-friendly reporting channels. Students raised in harsh, authoritarian environments or those previously bullied themselves were also more likely to become perpetrators. Adolescents who lack sufficient emotional education may struggle to manage stress, anger or social conflict healthily. In some cases, harsh upbringing at home can lead youths to displace their anger onto others. Child and Adolescent Psychiatrist at the Chancellor Tuanku Muhriz Hospital, Associate Professor Dr Fairuz Nazri Abd Rahman, said bullying behaviour does not form overnight but rather stems from a combination of environmental and personal experiences, including family dynamics and individual psychological factors. "One of the main contributors to bullying is the toxic seniority culture in schools and poor emotional regulation skills among students. "Being sent to boarding school at a young age can significantly impact a child's emotional and social development, making them more likely to bully others," she told 'Berita Harian'. She added that children exposed to harsh parenting, such as frequent scolding, physical punishment, or emotional neglect, may project their frustrations onto others. A lack of affection and attention may also drive them to act aggressively to gain recognition. "Some may also mimic the behaviour of family members if they witness their parents or siblings threatening, insulting, or physically hurting others," she said. In recent months, there has been a noticeable spike in bullying cases, especially in boarding schools, with many involving senior students physically harming juniors. Some perpetrators have been expelled or brought to court. In December last year, the media reported that the Education Ministry recorded 6,208 bullying cases involving students as of October 2024 through the Student Character Assessment System (SDM). Dr Fairuz said that some bullies act under peer pressure, not wanting to appear weak. The situation is made worse when schools are lax on discipline or implicitly endorse bullying behaviour among seniors. She pointed out that boarding environments, including religious schools (tahfiz), could emotionally overwhelm children under 13 who are still developing emotional maturity. Without close parental guidance, these children may struggle to express feelings like anger, jealousy or frustration, resulting in aggressive or bullying behaviour. "Parents are a child's main source of emotional safety and validation. Early separation can cause emotional voids, feelings of rejection, or neglect, which can manifest as negative behaviour towards peers," she said. Meanwhile, Universiti Pendidikan Sultan Idris (UPSI) psychology and counselling expert, Associate Professor Dr Fauziah Mohd Sa'ad, said the persistence of bullying cases reflects the toxic culture of seniority in schools, a lack of emotional monitoring, and the failure of comprehensive psychosocial support systems. "These cases not only affect victims emotionally and academically but can also cause long-term trauma that disrupts mental and social development," she said.
The Sun
a day ago
- The Sun
Silent crisis of underage teens
AMIDST silence and stigma, the numbers continue to rise. Malaysia is facing a growing crisis of underage sexual activity but existing norms, policies and school systems are failing to respond with the urgency the data demands. Just two months ago, Berita Harian reported a 17% spike in such cases in Kelantan during the first quarter of 2025 compared to the same period last year, with children as young as 10 engaging in sexual acts. Worryingly, many cases involved risky behaviour – exchanging explicit content, having multiple partners and even incest. According to the 2022 National Health and Morbidity Survey (NHMS), 7.6% of secondary school students had engaged in sexual intercourse while 5.7% were sexually active, a slight rise from NHMS 2017 (7.3% and 5.3%, respectively). Among those sexually active, only 11.8% used condoms and 11.9% used other contraceptives, underscoring a grave risk of teenage pregnancies. The same survey found that 10.7% of respondents had more than one sexual partner, sparking concerns about sexually transmitted diseases (STD) among adolescents. In 2022, 408 gonorrhoea cases were recorded among Malaysians under 21, making up 22.4% of all cases. This trend is not merely a moral issue or a lapse in individual judgement but a result of structural failures in education, healthcare, family engagement and public discourse. Despite policy frameworks on paper, the gap between knowledge and action remains dangerously wide. While most encounters are consensual, sex involving children is illegal in Malaysia. The Sexual Offences Against Children Act 2017 defines a child as under 18, prohibiting all forms of sexual abuse, including physical and non-physical sexual assault, grooming, sexual communication and child pornography. As the age of consent for girls is 16 in Malaysia, any intercourse involving girls younger than that is legally considered rape, regardless of consent. Despite lower rates of premarital sex than in Western countries, the rising number of teenage pregnancies suggests a mismatch as public discourse around these issues remains heavily stigmatised. Fourteen out of every 1,000 Malaysian girls become pregnant annually, averaging 18,000 teenage pregnancies a year. If not addressed, these can carry serious health risks for mother and child. Teenage mothers are especially vulnerable to mental illness, STD, premature rupture of membranes, poor nutrition, anaemia and excessive uterine bleeding – all of which can cause maternal death. Their babies also face higher risks of low birth weight, stillbirth and stunting due to nutritional deficiencies. Most cases involve unmarried girls from poor, less-educated backgrounds, for whom raising a child is financially impossible. As a result, many resort to baby dumping. Police data shows that at least 10 babies were dumped monthly between 2018 and 2021. Of the 449 recorded cases, only 149 babies were found alive. Without safe, accessible and stigma-free reproductive options, desperate girls, often too young and too poor to raise a child, are left with tragic alternatives. Baby dumping is not a moral collapse; it is a predictable consequence of systemic silence. Although abortion and contraceptives are legal under medical supervision, many turn to unregulated channels due to social stigma, risking unsafe procedures. A study found that Malaysian adolescents who smoked, drank alcohol or used illicit drugs were more likely to engage in sex. In contrast, lower rates were observed among those with close friends, supportive peers and strong parental bonds, indicators of robust social support. Evidence also shows that caregiver control, parental awareness, curfews and dating rules are linked to delayed sexual initiation and reduced risk-taking. The benefits of comprehensive sexuality education (CSE) in preventing unplanned sex, risky behaviour and harassment are well documented. Global research shows that CSE boosts awareness and literacy, promoting safer sexual choices. Yet in Malaysia, CSE implementation remains weak. Key obstacles include the lack of a standardised curriculum, insufficient teacher training and cultural and religious sensitivities. A further concern is adolescents' poor understanding of sexuality and reproductive health (SRH), especially among rural youths. While the Education Ministry has attempted to integrate SRH into co-curricular modules and primary instruction, the fragmented delivery, lack of training and resistance from communities have rendered these efforts inconsistent and ineffective. Though SRH content has been partially integrated into school subjects, it remains non-compulsory under the national curriculum. Most delivery occurs via external programmes. In primary schools, where it is included, students receive only 13 hours of instruction per year, and HIV education is limited to two sessions annually. To tackle the troubling rise in underage sexual activity, Malaysia must adopt a holistic approach. School-based CSE: Mandate CSE as a stand-alone subject in schools while integrating it into other subjects, such as biology and social sciences. A well-designed curriculum should promote health, decision-making and awareness of bodily rights. Sweden, the first country to make sex education compulsory, teaches key concepts such as puberty, reproduction, gender roles, sexual identity, relationships, STD and contraception. Given the link between substance use, pornography exposure and risky sexual behaviour, CSE should also include media literacy and substance abuse prevention. In Malaysia, CSE must be culturally and religiously sensitive, aligning with community values. Research shows that age-appropriate sexuality education should begin earlier, ideally before puberty, to equip children with the understanding to protect themselves and report abuse. This is vital in cases of incest, which often go unreported due to confusion, fear or manipulation by perpetrators. The rise in incest cases demands stronger safeguards for child protection through early education and open dialogue. Public destigmatisation and community engagement: Step up efforts to normalise conversations around SRH through nationwide awareness campaigns. Collaborating with community leaders, educators and youths will help dismantle taboos and foster support for sexuality education. Educator training and readiness: Require in-service and pre-service training for all CSE instructors. Equip teachers with accurate, up-to-date and scientifically validated knowledge and the skills to address sensitive topics such as sexual and gender-based violence, as well as sexual abuse. Partner with civil society to create teaching materials, frameworks and training workshops. Parental involvement in SRH education: Parents play a vital role in guiding and supporting adolescents. Open communication at home can reduce stigma and promote healthier attitudes towards SRH. Continuous policy review and research: The government must regularly evaluate the effectiveness of initiatives such as the National Reproductive and Social Health Education Policy and Action Plan and the Reproductive Health and Social Education programmes. Ongoing research is vital to close enforcement gaps, refine strategies and align with global best practices. Failing to act now will not only endanger the health and future of thousands of adolescents but also entrench a generational cycle of silence, vulnerability and neglect. Dr Margarita Peredaryenko and Avyce Heng are part of the research team at Emir Research, an independent think-tank focused on strategic policy recommendations based on rigorous research.
The Star
a day ago
- The Star
Medicine price display rule to stay
PETALING JAYA: The enforcement of the medicine price display requirement under the Price Control and Anti-Profiteering Act 2011 will continue in stages through a process of education, inspections, and advocacy until Sept 30. The Health Ministry said in a statement that warning letters may be issued for non-compliance, followed by the issuance of compounds from Oct 1. Full enforcement is scheduled to begin on Jan 1 next year. The medicine price display initiative, which applies to private healthcare facilities and community pharmacies, was first implemented on May 1. 'This initiative is a strategic collaboration between the Health Ministry and the Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Ministry. 'An educational enforcement approach was adopted for the first three months, ending July 31. 'During this period, 842 facilities, including medical and dental clinics, private hospitals, and community pharmacies, were inspected, with 57% found to be satisfactorily complying with the price display requirement,' the ministry said yesterday. Both ministries also acknowledged that a judicial review had been filed in the High Court by seven organisations representing medical and dental practitioners, as well as one private medical practitioner, to challenge the validity of the directive. However, the ministry clarified that no court order has been issued to suspend the implementation or enforcement of the ruling. Former Medical Practitioners Coalition Association of Malaysia president Dr Raj Kumar Maharajah said most clinics are not in favour of the rule but have complied regardless. He argued that the directive is misplaced, as private clinics do not operate like pharmacies and do not display or sell medicines over the counter. 'Unlike pharmacies that sell medicines, our permits allow us to dispense medication only after consultation, examination and investigations. 'Customers rarely come just to buy medicine and the drugs are not displayed on shelves. 'When we introduce laws, they must make sense. 'This rule seems more like a feel-good measure to reassure the public. But in reality, it serves no purpose,' he said. On the question of compliance, Dr Raj said clinics are ready for full enforcement and have nothing to hide. Federation of Private Medical Practitioners' Associations Malaysia secretary Dr Shanmuganathan Ganeson said the association understands the enforcement is still in its educational phase until the end of September and that compounds are unlikely during this period. He said members have been advised to cooperate during inspections and continue engaging in good faith. 'We've filed a judicial review, so we'll refrain from making detailed comments while the matter is before the court. 'If any clinic experiences overzealous or premature enforcement, we encourage them to inform the federation's secretariat so we can monitor and respond accordingly,' he said. The directive, effective from May 1, requires all private healthcare facilities and community pharmacies to display prices of all medicines intended for human use. This includes prescription and non-prescription drugs, over the counter products, traditional medicines, health supplements, and extemporaneously prepared products.
