BBC admits it breached editorial guidelines by failing to reveal Gaza doc narrator was son of Hamas official
An independent probe into
4
The broadcaster spent £400,000 of licence payers' cash making the doc
Credit: BBC
4
The 13-year-old narrator was Abdulla Eliyazour - the son of senior Hamas official Dr Ayman Al-Yazouri
Credit: BBC
The broadcaster spent £400,000 of licence payers' cash making the doc, which was branded a propaganda show for the evil terror group Hamas,
In a shocking revelation, the main narrator of the heart-tugging, supposedly factual exposé - 13-year-old Abdulla Eliyazour - was the son of senior Hamas official Dr Ayman Al-Yazouri.
Investigative journalist David Collier, who exposed the identities of those involved, said: 'How did the BBC let a son of a Hamas minister walk around looking for sympathy and demonising Israel for an hour in a documentary?
'The BBC is publishing Hamas propaganda.
Read More
'The current hierarchy at the BBC has turned a once respected state broadcaster into a propaganda outlet for a radical Islamic terror group.'
The review has now found the Beeb breached editorial guideline 3.3.17, on accuracy, by failing to disclose to audiences the "critical information" of the role the 13-year-old's father had within the Hamas-run government.
The report found nobody at the BBC knew of the father's position when the documentary first aired on February 17.
But three people at Hoyo Films, the independent production company which produced the film, were aware, it concluded.
Most read in News TV
It added the report does not find the production company misled the corporation, but does find the firm bears most of the responsibility for the failure.
The review found no other breaches of the guidelines.
This comes after
Anger grew after Beeb bosses initially tried to defend the programme, and blamed London-based production company Hoyo Films for not revealing the boy's link.
But the contract between the BBC and Hoyo suggested the corporation had direct and regular involvement - and shows action should have taken action.
One section of the contract read: "We will address editorial compliance issues as they arise by having regular updates and phone calls with the commissioning editor."
The documentary was made by the BBC's Current Affair TV arm which paid award-winning Hoyo Films to craft the production.
But it was still unclear why the boy's appearance was allowed by the department's commissioning editor Gian Quaglieni.
Ex-boss Danny Cohen - former director of BBC
television
- demanded clarity as to who was responsible and whether Hamas were given licence cash.
Mr Cohen said: "The BBC needs to account for every penny spent on this documentary - £400,000 is a lot of licence-fee payers money.
"They should be transparently told where their money went and whether any of it reached the hands of Hamas.
"The BBC must also launch a wider investigation into systemic bias against Israel after repeated editorial failures since the October 7 massacres."
And,
in her letter to Director General of the BBC,
Tim Davie
, Mrs Kemi Badenoch said: "It is now clear to me that you should commission a full independent inquiry to consider this and wider allegations of systemic BBC bias against
Israel
.
"It is well known that inside Gaza the influence of the proscribed terrorist organisation Hamas is pervasive.
"How could any programme from there be commissioned, without comprehensive work by the BBC to ensure that presenters or participants were - as far as possible - not linked to that appalling regime?
"Would the BBC be this naive if it was commissioning content from North Korea or the Islamic Republic of
Mrs Badenoch added that it was "profoundly troubling" that the BBC initially defended the documentary insisting it "remains a powerful child's eye view of the devastating consequences of the war".
She said: "Surely it should have been immediately apparent that the programme was fundamentally flawed?
"An investigation must consider allegations of potential collusion with Hamas' and the possibility of payment to Hamas officials.
"These are not isolated incidents."
Left-wing bias is alleged to have tainted BBC coverage of the Gaza War ever since October 7 and has sparked numerous calls for a crackdown.
And a BBC reporter who triggered one of the first bias rows of the war was yesterday revealed to have sparked more fury with an inflammatory online post.
On October 17 - ten days after Hamas massacred 1,200 people and grabbed 251 hostages - Jon Donnison told viewers it appeared "an Israeli air strike or several air strikes" had blitzed Gaza's Al-Ahli Hospital.
It later emerged that a miss-fired Hamas rocket hit the medical centre in an attack reported to have claimed 500 lives.
But Mr Donnison was slammed on X for posting on Saturday: "The propaganda efforts by both Hamas and Israel over the hostage releases are pretty nauseating."
He took down the post and apologised yesterday after his comment triggered fury.
David Collier raged: "He sees Hamas abusing and torturing Israeli hostages on TV.
"Then he sees Israeli families indescribable happiness as their loved ones return.
"And he thinks they are the same - we should not be paying his salary."
Sarah Deech posted: "BBC
The BBC said previously: "Gaza: How to Survive a Warzone features important stories we think should be told - those of the experiences of children in Gaza.
"There have been continuing questions raised about the programme and in the light of these, we are conducting further due diligence with the production company.
"The programme will not be available on iPlayer while this is taking place."
4
Gaza: How to Survive a Warzone was pulled from iPlayer amid investigations
Credit: BBC
4
BBC director-general Tim Davie
Credit: PA
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
33 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Naga Muchetty gets pay rise dwarfing co-host Charlie Stayt amid ‘bully' claims as BBC salaries revealed
BBC Breakfast host Naga Munchetty received a huge pay rise last year - despite being reprimanded by bosses over bullying allegations. Advertisement 12 Naga's salary is almost double that of her co-host Charlie Stayt 12 The presenter was reprimanded by bosses over two incidents in three years 12 Naga found herself at the centre of a toxicity row on the BBC Breakfast sofa Credit: Splash , received a 10k boost despite finding herself at the centre of a BBC Breakfast toxicity row earlier this year. Naga, who has presented on the flagship news programme since 2014, has always been paid more than Stayt. Her pay packet accounts for 180 days of presenting on the Breakfast show, as well as her Radio 5 Live programme and election coverage. It comes as she was accused of hauled in by bosses over a sex jibe made at Radio 5 Live. Advertisement Read more in TV Key points in the BBC Annual Report Gary Lineker has topped the list of highest earners for another year BBC Breakfast star Meanwhile the number of people paying for a TV licence fell by around 300,000 last year - almost two per cent in all Scandal-hit boss Tim Davie was New MOTD host Mark Chapman's Tim Davies reveals Breakfast's editor Naga is said to have used a crude slang term for a sex act during an off-air break — before asking a colleague if they had done it. Most read in Showbiz The alleged remark stunned the Radio 5 Live studio and led to her being hauled before bosses. Advertisement She was reprimanded by a senior producer but no formal action was taken. The BBC Annual report - released today - revealed that Gary Lineker ended his time with the BBC by topping the Corporation's pay league for the eighth consecutive year. Its salary report showed the Top 10 earners at the BBC MOTD Star Gary Lineker retained his place as top earner for another year Gary Lineker - £1.35million Zoe Ball - £515,000 - cut from £950,000 Alan Shearer - £440,000 - up from £380,000 Greg James - £425,000 - up from £415,000 Fiona Bruce - £410,000 - up from £405,000 AND Nick Robinson - £410,000 - up from £345,000 Stephen Nolan - £405,000 Laura Kuenssberg - £395,000 - up from £325,000 Vernon Kay - £390,000 - up from £320,000 Justin Webb - £365,000 - up from £320,000 Naga Munchetty - £355,000 - up from £345,000 Radio 2 host Zoe Ball, 53, remained the Beeb's second-highest earner despite a significant pay cut when she left the breakfast show,. Advertisement She is now in the £515,000 - £519,999 grade, dropping from £950,000 to £954,999. Other top earners include Alan Shearer on £440k, Nearly 70 per cent of the BBC's top 20 earners received pay rises. One of the Beeb's former highest-earners, Huw Edwards, does not feature in 24/25's pay disclose list after he left in April 2024 amid an explicit image scandal. Advertisement The BBC has not escaped scandal this year, though. MasterChef's Gregg Wallace, was fired this week for inappropriate conduct. However neither would feature in the publicly-funded BBC's salary dossier, which discloses salaries above £178,000, because they are paid by external production firms or BBC Studios, the corporation's commercial arm. Advertisement Many big names, including Claudia Winkleman, Tess Daly, Graham Norton and Bradley Walsh do not feature for the same reason. 12 12 Lineker retained his spot as the Beeb's highest earner Credit: BBC 12 Despite taking a huge pay cut, Zoe Ball was once again the second-highest paid Credit: PA Advertisement It comes as under-fire Director General Tim Davie received a £15k pay hike despite systemic failure. He took home £540k. His pay boost comes just weeks after the BBC was forced to issue a grovelling apology for streaming Bob Vylan's "death to IDF" Glastonbury chant. Meanwhile the number of people paying for a TV licence fell by around 300,000 last year - almost two per cent in all. Some 23.8m licences are in force, down from 24.1m in 2023/2024. Advertisement Scandal-hit BBC boss Tim Davie gets pay RISE to £540k despite Gregg Wallace drama, Glasto coverage & Hamas doc scandal SCANDAL-HIT BBC boss Tim Davie has been given a sizeable pay rise to earn £544,999 a year. The broadcaster's annual report shows the Director-General's pay packet swelled by around £15,000 or 2.5% over the past 12 months - despite controversies including those involving Gregg Wallace, Bob Vylan and a Hamas documentary. The Beeb is required to publish the pay and expenses for all senior leaders earning over £178,000 annually "in the BBC's public services", according to its report. Davie - who took up his current role in 2020 - was paid an estimated £529,999 in salary and taxable benefits in 2023-24. Asked by The Sun why Davie had received a £15,000 bonus despite significant failures throughout the year, BBC's chair of the board Dr Samir Shah said: "His pay has been frozen since 2021 and I think that it is reasonable. "There is little doubt that Tim's pay is significantly under the (going rate). "If you look at the figures , trust levels have gone up - if you look at the report, the actual performance of the BBC has been exceptional." He added: "I have no problems with awarding him with what is a very small bonus - which still ends up [with] his salary being significantly lower than any of his peers in the sector." But because of a hike in cost to £169.50, the BBC says it gathered some £183m more from the fees. Despite the drop, it said the "vast majority of our audiences remained committed to paying the licence fee". It comes as The Sun revealed the Beeb asked John Torode to A Advertisement The dossier also upheld a complaint that an unnamed person used a racial phrase once several years ago. Torode confirmed to The Sun it referred to him, but said: 'I have absolutely no recollection of this, and I do not believe that it happened.' The BBC also told the MasterChef presenter to pretend he had mental health issues after accusing him of racism, it was claimed. The stunned Aussie, 59, was asked to resign over the weekend after being dragged into the Advertisement Shockingly, sources said the BBC and production company Banijay asked John to resign from the beleaguered show last week and claim he had mental health problems — to which he refused. 12 Tim Davie has received a substantial pay rise despite major scandals at the BBC Credit: Getty 12 The BBC asked John Torode to resign from MasterChef after an initial probe into his co-host Gregg Wallace Advertisement 12 The broadcaster was forced to issue a grovelling apology after streaming Bob Vylan's controversial Glastonbury performance In a farcical turn of events, the BBC was unable to specify the time or date of the allegation, narrowing it down to '2018 or 2019'. The Beeb admitted the future of Masterchef was hanging in the balance after the shocking revelations and probes into both hosts. A total of 45 out of the 83 allegations made against Gregg during his time on the show were substantiated, including one allegation of "unwelcome physical contact". Advertisement The corporation said the possibility of Gregg returning to MasterChef was "untenable". And they also issued a statement on the future of the new series of MasterChef, saying that, at this time, 'we are not going to make a final decision on the broadcast of the series that was filmed last year.' Earlier this month, the Beeb told how Bob Vylan were assessed as "high risk" before their performance at Glastonbury but were "deemed suitable for live streaming with appropriate mitigations". Chairman Samir Shah admitted that the decision to continue streaming the Advertisement Singer Bobby Vylan also shouted "from the river to the sea Palestine... will be free" - regarded by Jews as a call for Israel's elimination. Avon and Somerset Police confirmed The BBC later took down the broadcast on the iPlayer but was criticised for not cutting it off immediately after the anti-Semitic chanting, with the live feed continuing for another 40 minutes. Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer was among those who slammed the broadcaster and demanded an explanation for the decision to air the horrifying chant during the performance on the West Holts stage. Advertisement n a fresh statement earlier this month, the BBC said: "We fully understand the strength of feeling regarding "We deeply regret that such 12 MOTD star Alan Shearer was third highest on the salary list 12 Fiona Bruce also received a pay rise - landing her fourth on the list Advertisement 12 The BBC Annual Report was released today
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
BBC looks at licence fee overhaul as whopping 300,000 fewer Brits sign up for £174.50 a year cost
THE BBC is looking into a licence fee overhaul with hundreds of thousands of households refusing to pay up. The broadcaster's annual report released today says competition from streaming services has created a "moment of real jeopardy for the sector". Advertisement 6 A view of BBC Broadcasting House in central London Credit: PA 6 An estimated 300,000 households have stopped paying. The report revealed 23.8m licences were in force at the end of the year, down from 24.1m in 2023-24. The drop means a loss of about £50m in revenue for the corporation. It comes as BBC Director-General Tim Davie was shown to have been Advertisement Read more News And departing Match of the Day host Gary Lineker ended his time with the Corporation by for the eighth consecutive year, raking in £1.35million. Key points in the BBC Annual Report Gary Lineker has He was followed by Zoe Ball, who remains second best-paid at the Beeb despite her dramatic pay cut More than two thirds of the broadcaster's top 20 earners received pay rises BBC Breakfast star Naga Munchetty received a boost to her pay, but co-host Charlie Stayt's salary stayed the same Disgraced presenter Huw Edwards did not feature on the list after his exit from the broadcaster Meanwhile the number of people paying for a TV licence fell by around 300,000 last year - almost two per cent in all BBC boss Tim Davie Referring to the licence fee, BBC Chair Samir Shah says in the annual report: 'The fight is on, and it is vital we now think very carefully about the kind of media environment we want for the UK.' Most read in News TV He added they were searching for 'the best future funding model for the BBC'. Advertisement Shah said: 'I have already set out some views on this and the board will be saying more over the coming months,' he said. Masterchef meltdown as BBC asked John Torode to RESIGN over 'racist remark' before Gregg Wallace sacking 'But all of us are clear that we want to make sure we protect the BBC as a universal service and help it not just to survive, but thrive, for a generation and more.' Licence fee income increased slightly year on year, totalling £3.8bn in 2024-25. However, the small rise was down to the 6.7% inflationary increase in the fee to £169.50 a year. Advertisement 'The current collection method remains fair, effective, and good value for money,' the report said. 'As we approach the end of the charter, we will proactively research how we might reform the licence fee to secure the benefits of a well-resourced, universal BBC of scale for the long term.' 'Inappropriate behaviours' Today's report also features a column by Dr Shah in which he references the "profoundly shocking revelations" involving disgraced News At Ten anchor He announced in October the Beeb's board had commissioned an independent review into its "workplace culture". Advertisement It came in the wake of Edwards, as well as "several further cases of inappropriate behaviours and abuses of power", Dr Shah wrote. Top 10 earners at the BBC Gary Lineker - £1.35million Zoe Ball - £515,000 - cut from £950,000 Alan Shearer - £440,000 - up from £380,000 Greg James - £425,000 - up from £415,000 Fiona Bruce - £410,000 - up from £405,000 AND Nick Robinson - £410,000 - up from £345,000 Stephen Nolan - £405,000 Laura Kuenssberg - £395,000 - up from £325,000 Vernon Kay - £390,000 - up from £320,000 Justin Webb - £365,000 - up from £320,000 Naga Munchetty - £355,000 - up from £345,000 In his column, he added: "The first thing to say is that the BBC is a wonderful place to work. "Our staff are dedicated, hardworking and treat each other with respect. "However, there are pockets in the organisation where this is not the case. There are still places where powerful individuals - on and off-screen - can abuse that power to make life for their colleagues unbearable." Advertisement It comes after former MasterChef host Wallace launched The one-time greengrocer turned TV personality, 60, was axed after an The bombshell inquiry, carried out by law firm Lewis Silkin for production company Banijay, Most of them involved inappropriate sexual language and humour and a further 10 were made about other people - Advertisement Davie was also asked today about whether Wallace's co-host John Torode The director-general said: "There has to be follow-up, so the BBC, in some ways, we're quite simple on this, if someone is found to not live up to the values we expect, the independent company, Banijay, in this case, to take action and report back to us on what they have done. "These aren't BBC employees, but we absolutely expect action to be taken, that's the first thing I'd say." 'Get a grip quicker' Last week BBC bosses were Advertisement Ofcom boss Dame Melanie Dawes insisted there is a risk the public lose faith in the corporation if coverage isn't pulled swiftly and investigations are lengthy. The broadcaster had apologised after the band's lead singer chanted 'death, death' to Israeli defence forces during their festival set last month. The regulator also stepped in to launch a probe into Beeb doc Gaza: How to Survive a Warzone, The BBC previously admitted to breaching their own editorial guidelines by failing to disclose this to viewers. Advertisement An independent probe into the documentary was commissioned by the broadcaster earlier this year. The broadcaster spent £400,000 of licence payers' cash making the doc, which was branded a propaganda show for the evil terror group Hamas, In a shocking revelation, the main narrator of the heart-tugging, supposedly factual exposé - 13-year-old Abdulla Eliyazour - was the son of senior Hamas official Dr Ayman Al-Yazouri. 6 Tim Davie, Director-General of the BBC, has seen his pay rise despite controversies Credit: Getty Advertisement 6 Punk Duo Bob Vylan during the controversial Glastonbury set on Saturday Credit: PA 6 Gregg said he was 'deeply sorry for any distress caused' Credit: Pixel8000 6 Disgraced former BBC news anchor Huw Edwards Credit: AFP
The Irish Sun
3 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Axed Love Island star reveals what really happens when stars are dumped – and they don't even get their own luggage
AN AXED Love Island star has revealed what really happens when stars are dumped from the show. Former Islander 4 Axed Islander Chris Middleton has been spilling villa secrets Credit: chrisjmiddleton/TikTok 4 Chris was a Casa Amor bombshell who entered the villa last week Credit: Shutterstock Editorial 4 Sadly his time on the show was cut short Credit: Eroteme The Commercial Real Estate Asset Manager, 29, from Manchester joined Love Island as part of the However, he didn't manage to win a place in the main villa, and was sent packing during the The hunk in trunks has now given his verdict on his time on the show, and his been spilling secrets that viewers at home don't get to see. Taking to TikTok, Chris revealed the brutal way Islanders are removed from the villa, once they have been dumped. Read More about Love Island "Yeah, you are literally the moment that you see people leave the villa after a recoupling," he told fans. "You are straight out the door. You don't have no time to pack your bag. You obviously film the walkout." Continuing, Chris said: "You get exit interviews to do and stuff, but yeah straight out the door no time to pack the bag. "Your stuff will get sent to you, you get sent off to a holding villa obviously because the shows at the day later." Most read in Love Island Chris then said: "They [producers] can't have islanders wandering around because it obviously is a spoiler for the outcome. "So then you do two days one or two days in holding just a bit of a cooling off period. Maya Jama looks incredible in see through lace dress ahead of 'wildest Casa Amor recoupling ever' "You still don't have your phone at that point. "So it's just kind of mentally preparing yourself to come back to the real world really and just continue enjoying the sun." Chris was only on Love Island for a few days last week. Before going in the villa, he said: "If I meet the right person, I do fall fast. 4 Chris had his eye on Shakira in the villa Credit: Eroteme "The issue is I very rarely meet the right people! I lose interest quickly." But despite his best intentions, Chris failed to make a connection with the OG girls and was sent packing. During his time on the show, the At the time, fans speculated about his lack of screen time on Reddit. One wrote: "I'm wondering where Chris has gone?" While another added: "There's always one of them that kind of blends with the background and becomes invisible during casa, seems like Chris is this year's victim." This one said: "Feel bad for Chris with no screen time. Seemed like a good bloke." Love Island will continue tonight at 9pm on ITV2 . Love Island 2025 full lineup : A 30-year-old footballer with charm to spare. : A 22-year-old Manchester-based model, ready to turn heads. : A payroll specialist from Southampton, looking for someone tall and stylish. : International business graduate with brains and ambition. : A gym enthusiast with a big heart. : A Londoner with celebrity connections, aiming to find someone funny or Northern. : A personal trainer and semi-pro footballer, following in his footballer father's footsteps. : A towering 6'5' personal trainer. : A 25-year-old Irish rugby pro. : Love Island's first bombshell revealed as sexy Las Vegas pool party waitress. : The 24-year-old bombshell hails from London and works as a commercial banking executive. : Pro footballer and model entering Love Island 2025 as a bombshell. Giorgio Russo : The 30-year-old will be spending his summer in the sun, potentially his sister Alessia's successful tournament at the Euros in Switzerland. : Professional DJ from Manchester who appeared on X Factor 2016 in girl group Four of Diamonds. : Miss Bikini Ireland 2019 winner who hails from Dublin and works as a nail technician and personal trainer. Emma Munro: Harry Cooksley's ex who entered as a bombshell and works as a hydrogeologist. Departures : : Axed after an arrest over a machete attack emerged. He was released with no further action taken and denies any wrongdoing. : A model and motivational speaker who has overcome adversity after suffering life-changing burns in an accident. : A boxer with striking model looks, seeking love in the villa. : A teaching assistant from Broxbourne, Hertfordshire, who entered Love Island 2025 as a bombshell . : Works as a scaffolder day-to-day and plays semi-pro football on the side. Poppy Harrison: The bombshell broke up with her boyfriend after finding out she would be in the villa Will Means : The fourth fittest farmer in the UK according to Farmers' Weekly in 2023 entered the villa as a bombshell : An Irish actress part of the OG line-up. : 23-year-old personal banker from Glasgow who fancies herself as a 'good flirt'. : 27-year-old gym hunk who entered the show as a bombshell .
