Tulip Innovation Obtains Additional Battery Patent Injunction against Sunwoda Group
The most recent decision arose from Tulip's action against Sunwoda Electronic, Sunwoda Mobility Energy Technology and their German affiliates Sunwoda Europe and Sunwoda Electric Vehicle Battery Germany based on the German part of the European Patent EP 2 378 595 B1. The oral hearing took place on 3 July 2025. The decision in favour of Tulip was handed down two weeks after the hearing, on 17 July 2025, granting Tulip the requested injunctive relief against the batteries at issue. Tulip's requests for additional relief were also granted, including obligations for Sunwoda to recall and destroy any remaining batteries in its direct or indirect possession, pay damages to Tulip in principle, and provide detailed accounting information to enable Tulip to calculate its damages claim.
The new injunction underscores the strength and breadth of the battery patent portfolio licensed by Tulip, and confirms that battery manufacturers implementing technology covered by the portfolio will face substantial burdens in litigation if they choose to operate without a license.
Giustino de Sanctis, CEO of Tulip, noted: 'This decision reinforces the value of Tulip's program and demonstrates our commitment to upholding fair and competitive market conditions in the battery industry. Tulip looks forward to discussing broad licenses under the portfolio with all companies active in lithium-ion battery manufacturing.' Andreas von Falck, Hogan Lovells Partner, added: 'We are very pleased with this confirmation of the strength of Tulip's patent position by the Munich District Court. The patent in this case has a maximum term of 21 December 2029. The decision is well reasoned and we are confident that the decision will stand on appeal.'
The patent asserted relates to the combination of electrodes and a battery separator, an important element for the safety and performance of a car battery. The batteries at issue in the case are specific models used in the Dacia Spring but the patent is applicable to any battery model to the extent that it makes use of the patented technology.
The decision is immediately enforceable against the provision of security but remains subject to appeal by Sunwoda, and Sunwoda has filed a separate nullity action relating to the patent that is pending.
Tulip is represented in the proceedings by a Hogan Lovells team including Dr. Andreas von Falck, Dr. Alexander Klicznik, Dr. Roman Würtenberger, Dr. Markus Kuczera, Lea Gröblinghoff, Dr. Michael Plagge and Dr. Yun-Suk Jang. Sunwoda is represented by A&O Shearman.
About Tulip Innovation
Tulip Innovation Kft. is an independent company founded to establish and manage the lithium-ion battery licensing program. Based in Hungary, the hub of European battery manufacturing, Tulip's mission is to collaborate with companies implementing Li-ion battery technology to ensure that their manufacturing operations have access to Tulip's robust IP portfolio. Led by a team of licensing professionals with decades of experience, Tulip has a unique combination of strong industry connections and expertise in negotiating and administering patent licenses. Additional information is available at www.tulipinnovation.com
Logo – https://mma.prnewswire.com/media/2736994/Tulip_Innovation_Logo.jpg
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
5 hours ago
- The Sun
HEIDELBERG agrees strategic partnership with defense specialist VINCORION
• HEIDELBERG moves into defense industry • VINCORION Advanced Systems GmbH specializes in power systems for safety-critical applications • HEIDELBERG impresses with high vertical range of manufacture and industrialization expertise • System partnership with VINCORION marks start of strategic collaboration HEIDELBERG, GERMANY - Newsaktuell - 29 July 2025 - Heidelberger Druckmaschinen AG (HEIDELBERG) is positioning itself in the defense sector with its first concrete project and is entering into a strategic partnership with VINCORION Advanced Systems GmbH. As part of a memorandum of understanding (MOU), both companies have agreed on a cooperation spanning several years, which is expected to be expanded in the future and to strengthen industrial performance as well as security of supply in the defense sector in the long term. This cooperation will see HEIDELBERG move into the defense market by developing, industrializing, and building power control and distribution systems for VINCORION. In this way, the two companies will help boost technological sovereignty and safeguard domestic value chains. Established technology leader for critical systems VINCORION has over 60 years of experience in developing and manufacturing state-of-the-art power systems for use in civilian and military applications. The company also develops cutting-edge technology, including rescue hoists for helicopters. 'Important step toward greater technological independence and a stronger industrial base' 'The partnership with VINCORION marks a milestone for HEIDELBERG and emphasizes our technology company's ability to industrialize complex products efficiently. We are looking to become increasingly established as a reliable partner in security-relevant areas,' says Jürgen Otto, CEO of HEIDELBERG. 'Our combination of technological expertise and reliable production in Germany is an important step toward greater technological independence and a stronger industrial base,' he adds. Strategic alliance for technological sovereignty 'This partnership brings together two German technology leaders with complementary strengths,' explains Kajetan von Mentzingen, Managing Director of VINCORION. 'HEIDELBERG boasts outstanding industrialization expertise and scaling capabilities. Together, we can boost Europe's technological sovereignty in a strategically important area, while also taking our international competitiveness to the next level,' he continues. High vertical range of manufacture in Germany HEIDELBERG is aiming to become established as a reliable partner for high-quality products and gradually expand this role within the defense sector. HEIDELBERG technologies offer key value-adding expertise covering hardware and software development, electronic component manufacture, machining, foundry technology, and the assembly of highly complex plant and system solutions in the heavy engineering sector. This makes HEIDELBERG an experienced end-to-end system partner with a portfolio that also includes the supply of spare parts and service operations. One capability that delivers particular added value is rapid scaling using existing infrastructure and capacities. 'The VINCORION project is our first opportunity to offer our industrial expertise to the defense sector,' says Michael Wellenzohn, Head of HEIDELBERG Industry. 'Our skills and infrastructure make HEIDELBERG a force to be reckoned with in heavy engineering when it comes to rapid scaling capabilities,' he emphasizes. Hashtag: #HEIDELBERG The issuer is solely responsible for the content of this announcement.
The Sun
11 hours ago
- The Sun
Regional Regulatory Misunderstanding, YBUOJ Responds Proactively to BaFin Advisory
COLORADO, USA - Media OutReach Newswire - 29 July 2025 - The Federal Financial Supervisory Authority of Germany (BaFin) recently issued a public advisory stating that crypto exchange YBUOJ was offering digital asset services to German investors without proper authorization—drawing significant market attention. However, the latest response of YBUOJ suggests the issue stems more from differences in regulatory interpretation and regional communication gaps than from any actual breach of compliance. According to publicly available information, YBUOJ is headquartered in the United States, where it holds a Money Services Business (MSB) license issued by the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) and is registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). These credentials confirm that YBUOJ operates under recognized federal oversight and meets established international compliance standards. In response to the concerns of BaFin, YBUOJ promptly clarified that it is not registered in Germany and that all of its operations strictly follow U.S. regulatory requirements. This statement aligns with the nature of the notice of BaFin, which is categorized as a routine consumer advisory rather than an administrative sanction. Such scenarios are not uncommon in the crypto industry. Binance, for example, is generally well-regarded in Germany, yet it has faced serious warnings or service restrictions in countries like the UK, Canada, and Japan due to lacking local regulatory approval. These cases underscore that recognition of foreign compliance credentials varies widely across jurisdictions. The mention of YBUOJ in the advisory of BaFin highlights the broader challenges cross-border crypto platforms face in navigating differing national regulatory frameworks, where misunderstandings and communication gaps can easily arise. In light of the situation, YBUOJ has expressed its willingness to fully cooperate with German regulators, offering relevant documentation and compliance materials to clarify the facts and dispel any misconceptions. In addition, YBUOJ also indicated it may seek to obtain a local license in Germany in the future to better meet regional regulatory requirements. In conclusion, this incident appears to be a matter of regional regulatory misunderstanding, not substantive wrongdoing. The prompt, constructive response and solid compliance foundation of YBUOJ reflect its strategic commitment to global regulatory alignment—and offer a reference point for other industry participants in managing cross-jurisdictional compliance.
New Straits Times
13 hours ago
- New Straits Times
EU car industry sees relief - and pain - in US trade deal
FRANKFURT: The car industry in the EU on Monday viewed the trade deal struck with the United States as a de-escalation – but one that still puts sand in its gearbox. German auto companies in particular were in for a great deal of export pain, as their share prices indicated. Shares in Porsche, Volkswagen, BMW and Mercedes-Benz all lost more than three per cent in trading Monday. The agreement eases "the intense uncertainty surrounding transatlantic trade relations in recent months", Europe's main auto group, the European Automobile Manufacturers' Association (ACEA), said in a statement welcoming the deal "in principle." But it noted that the 15 per cent US tariffs imposed on EU goods including cars "will continue to have a negative impact not just for industry in the EU but also in the US." German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said his country's economy – the biggest in Europe – would face "substantial damage" from the US tariffs agreed in the deal. But, he said, "we couldn't expect to achieve any more." The United States is a key market for European automakers, which last year sent nearly 750,000 of its cars to it, representing nearly a quarter of the sector's overall exports. While the 15 per cent rate is less than the 27.5 per cent tariff US President Donald Trump imposed in April, it is far higher than the 2.5 per cent levy European car manufacturers faced before Trump's return to the White House. A German analyst, Stefan Bratzel, said it could be expected that US consumers would pay two-thirds of the price hike caused by the tariff, while car exporters would probably swallow the other third. For those companies, "we might have to see whether it is possible for cost-cutting somewhere else," he said. The 15 per cent rate was similar to one reached in the deal the United States struck with Japan, another major car-exporting country. For German carmakers, the United States represents around 13 per cent of their exports. In the short term, a 15 per cent tariff will cost them "billions each year", said Hildegard Mueller, head of the national automobile manufacturers' association VDA. The situation has forced all the automakers to lower their 2025 profit forecasts and to look for ways to alleviate the pressure. BMW boss Oliver Zipse suggested in June that Europe could get rid of its own tariffs on imported vehicles made in the United States. That could benefit his company, which last year exported 153,000 vehicles from the Americas, and imported into Europe 92,000 cars that were assembled in the United States. Similarly, Mercedes is looking for help from the national or EU level. "The deal reached between the EU and the US is a first, important step that needs to be followed by other measures," a company spokeswoman told AFP. "Politicians need to keep working to get rid of obstacles getting in the way of free trade. We are counting on the EU and US to continue their constructive dialogue in the future," she said. Volkswagen is also facing tariff hardship for vehicles it makes in Mexico for the US market, announcing that its first-quarter results had been shaved by around 1.3 billion euros (US$1.5 billion) from a year earlier. Its Porsche and Audi cars are also exposed as they have no production factories in the United States. On Monday, Audi cut its revenue and profit targets for this year, though it said it expects them to rise next year. Volkswagen CEO Oliver Blume has suggested reaching a side deal with the United States that would take into account investments his company could make in that country. Volvo Cars, the Swedish carmaker owned by China's Geely Holding, has announced steep second-quarter losses because of tariffs. The European auto sector is now lobbying the European Commission to delay the timetable for making the European car market go all-electric, and to provide some sort of industry stimulus. With no help, European car factories, already facing uphill challenges, "will have to reduce production," said Ferdinand Dudenhoeffer, director of the Center for Automotive Research. That, he said, could affect up to 70,000 jobs in Germany alone.
