France opens 'complicity in genocide' probes over blocked Gaza aid
The two investigations, opened after legal complaints, were also to look into possible "complicity in crimes against humanity" between January and May 2024, the anti-terror prosecutor's office (PNAT) said.
They are the first known probes in France to be looking into alleged violations of international law in Gaza, several sources with knowledge of the cases told AFP.
In a separate case made public on the same day, the grandmother of two children with French nationality who were killed in an Israeli strike in Gaza has filed a legal complaint in Paris, accusing Israel of "genocide" and "murder", her lawyer said.
The French judiciary has jurisdiction when French citizens are involved in such cases.
Rights groups, lawyers and some Israeli historians have described the Gaza war as "genocide".
Israel, created in the aftermath of the Nazi Holocaust of Jews during World War II, vehemently rejects the accusation.
The French probes were opened after two separate legal complaints.
In the first, the Jewish French Union for Peace (UFJP) and a French-Palestinian victim filed a complaint in November targeting alleged French members of hardline pro-Israel groups "Israel is forever" and "Tzav-9".
It accused them of "physically" preventing the passage of trucks at border checkpoints controlled by the Israeli army.
Lawyers for the plaintiffs, Damia Taharraoui and Marion Lafouge, told AFP they were happy a probe had been launched into the events in January 2024 -- "a time when no-one wanted to hear anything about genocide".
A source close to the case said prosecutors last month urged the investigation in relation to events at the Nitzana crossing point between Egypt and Israel, and the Kerem Shalom crossing from Israel into Gaza.
Around that time, hardline Israeli protesters -- including friends and relatives of hostages held in Gaza -- blocked aid lorries from entering the occupied Palestinian territory and forced them to turn back at Kerem Shalom.
A second complaint from a group called the Lawyers for Justice in the Middle East (CAPJO) accused members of "Israel is forever" of having blocked aid trucks.
It used photos, videos and public statements to back up its complaint.
- 'Genocide' complaint -
No court has so far concluded that the ongoing conflict is a genocide.
But in rulings in January, March and May 2024, the International Court of Justice (ICJ), the United Nations' highest judicial organ, told Israel to do everything possible to "prevent" acts of genocide during its military operations in Gaza, including through allowing in urgently needed aid.
In the separate case, Jacqueline Rivault, the grandmother of six- and nine-year-old children killed in an Israeli strike, filed her complaint accusing Israel of "genocide" and "murder" with the crimes against humanity section of the Court of Paris, lawyer Arie Alimi said.
Though formally against unnamed parties, the complaint explicitly targets Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli government and the military.
The complaint states that an Israeli missile strike killed Janna, six, and Abderrahim Abudaher, nine, in northern Gaza on October 24, 2023.
"We believe these children are dead as part of a deliberate organised policy targeting the whole of Gaza's population with a possible genocidal intent," Alimi said.
The children's brother Omar, now five, was severely wounded but still lives in Gaza with their mother, identified as Yasmine Z., the complaint said.
A French court in 2019 convicted Yasmine Z. in absentia of having funded a "terrorist" group over giving money in Gaza to members of Palestinian militant groups Hamas and the Islamic Jihad.
- Famine warnings -
Israel said last month it was easing the complete blockade of Gaza it imposed on March 2 but on May 30 the United Nations said the territory's entire population of more than two million people remained at risk of famine.
A US-backed aid group last week began distributions but reports that the Israeli military shot dead dozens of Palestinians trying to collect food has sparked widespread condemnation. The UN and major aid organisations have refused to cooperate with the US-backed Gaza Humanitarian Fund, citing concerns that it was designed to cater to Israeli military objectives.
Hamas fighters launched an attack on Israel on October 7, 2023. A total of 1,218 people died, mostly civilians, according to an AFP tally based on official Israeli figures.
The militants abducted 251 hostages, 55 of whom remain in Gaza, including 32 the Israeli military says are dead.
Israel's retaliatory war on Hamas-run Gaza has killed 54,677 people, mostly civilians, according to the health ministry there, figures the United Nations deems reliable.
The International Criminal Court has issued arrest warrants against Netanyahu and former Israeli defence minister Yoav Gallant for alleged war crimes and crimes against humanity in Gaza.
It also issued an arrest warrant for Hamas military chief Mohammed Deif over similar allegations linked to the October 7 attack but the case against him was dropped in February after confirmation Israel had killed him.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
2 hours ago
- News.com.au
‘Destroyed my life': Vladimir Putin's ‘secret daughter' slams him in cryptic post
Russian President Vladimir Putin's alleged secret daughter has spoken out against her father in a cryptic post, condemning the man who 'destroyed' her and 'took millions of lives'. Elizaveta Krivonogikh, a 22-year-old art school graduate living in Paris who is believed to be the leader's youngest daughter, shared the messages on her private Telegram, in line with her increasing openness on Instagram as she's started to share more images of herself, The New York Post reported. 'It's liberating to be able to show my face to the world again,' she wrote, according to German magazine Bild. 'It reminds me of who I am and who destroyed my life.' The Telegram chat, named 'Art of Luiza', references her work pseudonym Luiza Rozova. Ms Krivonogikh didn't explicitly name Putin in either post, but has also never shot down the popular theories surrounding her true parentage. The budding artist was born in 2003 after a suspected affair between Putin and her mother, Svetlana, the President's then-housekeeper. The bombshell was first revealed after a 2020 investigation by Russian media outlet Proekt, citing Ms Krivonogikh's 'phenomenal resemblance' to Putin. He isn't listed on her birth certificate, but 'Vladimirovna' was included, translating to 'daughter of Vladimir'. In 2021, slain journalist and Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny exposed Ms Krivonogikh's Instagram, which showcased her life of luxury and her family's staggering wealth that many have attributed to their connection with the country's pesident. While Ms Krivonogikh originally celebrated life in the spotlight, she retreated after Russia invaded Ukraine in 2021 and her Instagram was suddenly shut down. She's since returned to the platform, but was more reserved in her posting at first, hiding her face in many photos. She's now seemingly changed her tune – and swapped sides on the devastating war after previously mourning her inability to 'make an extra lap around my beloved St Petersburg'. Ms Krivonogikh has since denounced her previous lifestyle of obscene wealth, speaking openly against her alleged father's actions in Ukraine. She also works in a Parisian art gallery that specialises in anti-war works. Ms Krivonogikh also adopted an extra pseudonym, Elizaveta Rudnova, inspired by Putin's late ally Oleg Rudnov – a cheeky stab at her elusive parentage. Still, critics of Putin haven't quite bought her reshaped image and insist that she shouldn't be working in a space where she could be interacting with Ukrainians, regardless of her stance. 'Am I really responsible for the activities of my family, who can't even hear me?' Ms Krivonogikh wrote. Putin is also rumoured to share two secret sons, a 10-year-old and a six-year-old, with his former gymnast lover and Olympic gold medallist Alina Kabaeva.
The Australian
5 hours ago
- The Australian
Labor urges Israel to end Gaza war before hostage release
Labor is urging Israel to end the war in Gaza before the remaining hostages held by Hamas are returned, in a significant move away from its previous calls for the release of the Israelis to be the priority before a deal was struck to end the conflict and recognise Palestine. In her strongest language on the conflict and the urgency of achieving Palestinian recognition, Foreign Minister Penny Wong said there would 'be no Palestine left to recognise' should the global community wait much longer to do so. The comments are part of growing momentum within Labor to recognise Palestine in the near future, with Anthony Albanese revealing on Tuesday he had spoken to the leader of the Palestinian Authority, Mahmoud Abbas, overnight and committed to meeting him on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly next month. 'Prime Minister Albanese reiterated Australia's call for the immediate entry of aid to meet needs of people of Gaza, a permanent ceasefire, and the release of all hostages,' a readout of the call stated. 'Prime Minister Albanese also reinforced Australia's commitment to a two-state solution because a just and lasting peace depends upon it.' While Senator Wong has previously listed the return of hostages as being among the most-pressing priorities since the Hamas terror attack on October 7, 2023, the senior Labor senator said Israel needed to end the war before that outcome was achieved, not after. Senator Wong declared Australians were 'all horrified to watch the depraved spectacle' of Israeli hostages Evyatar David and Rom Braslavski 'paraded' around by Hamas, but said the onus lay with Israel now to end the war. 'What I would say is the government's view is the same as the 600 former Israeli security officials, who have written publicly, urging Prime Minister (Benjamin) Netanyahu to end the war and making the very important point that the end of the war is the only way to save the hostages,' Senator Wong told the ABC. She added that the Albanese government was clear in its view that it was a breach of international law to stop food being delivered, which she said 'was the decision Israel made in March'. Senator Wong did not rule out further sanctions on Israeli officials, but said her government would 'prefer to move with other (countries)' in taking such action in order for the move to have 'more effect'. The Foreign Minister's comments add to speculation that Australia will likely recognise Palestine in September, given other countries such as France and Canada have already committed to doing so. 'There is a risk there will be no Palestine left to recognise if the international community don't move to create that pathway to a two-state solution,' Senator Wong said. Opposition foreign affairs spokeswoman Michaelia Cash accused Senator Wong of using 'hyperbole to justify the Albanese government's premature rush to recognise a Palestinian state before there is a pathway for it to be viable'. 'Hyperbole is not foreign policy, and this is not a solution,' Senator Cash said. 'It's reactionary symbolism without substance. That may suit Labor politically but it is a deviation from Australia's longstanding foreign policy of a two-state solution. 'Australian foreign policy should not be being used to advance the domestic political priorities of the Labor Party.' The comments come amid some disquiet in Coalition ranks over the language used by the opposition foreign affairs spokeswoman, with concerns that the messaging was not palatable in some electorates. Ahead of his call with Mr Abbas this week, Mr Albanese submitted a request to speak directly with Mr Netanyahu. The request was made before Sunday's court-approved protest on the Sydney Harbour Bridge by pro-Palestinian supporters, which forced the closure of Sydney's largest road crossing for about five hours. Senator Wong said she had 'anticipated' would attract as many as it did, given 'the distress of Australians on what we are seeing unfolding in Gaza'. Executive Council of Australian Jewry co-chief executive Alex Ryvchin took a swipe at Senator Wong's calls for the war to end before hostages were released and said Israel had 'a moral obligation' to bring its people home no matter the cost. 'Israel has a moral obligation to do everything it can, diplomatically and militarily, to bring its starved and tortured people home,' Mr Ryvchin said. 'We would demand no less of our own government. 'We agree with the Foreign Minister that a permanent end to the war offers the best hope of saving the remaining hostages. 'But Israel accepted the internationally-brokered ceasefire that would have seen the unfettered flow of aid, the phased return of hostages and a pathway to a permanent end to the war. 'Hamas has rejected it since May. It is unsatisfactory for this material fact to be omitted, giving the false impression that Israel is the barrier to the ceasefire and not Hamas.' Read related topics: Israel Nation As Tim Gurner and Graham Turner blast the policy, smaller employers from the NSW-Victorian border say it's just another example of why it's easier to run a business 'across the river'. Politics Mining giant Fortescue's abandoned clean energy projects have left taxpayers exposed to millions in grants amid mounting scrutiny of government renewable subsidies.
ABC News
5 hours ago
- ABC News
Former Human Rights Watch chief Kenneth Roth says only Donald Trump can stop Benjamin Netanyahu and war in Gaza
The former executive director of Human Rights Watch, Kenneth Roth, says the one man who can hold Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to account and put an end to the war in Gaza is US President Donald Trump. His comments echoed those of Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, who last week called for Mr Trump to show real leadership on the ongoing war in Gaza. During an interview tonight on 7.30, Mr Roth — who is Jewish and the son of a Holocaust survivor — said world leaders must do more than voice outrage at the ongoing situation in Gaza. "There's increasing movement towards sanctioning Israeli officials who are responsible," Mr Roth told 7.30. "There's increasing legitimacy of the arrest warrants issued by the International Criminal Court, but frankly, the one person with leverage over Netanyahu is Trump. "He alone could condition arms sales and military aid to end the mass atrocity being committed in Gaza. "I don't think it's impossible to push Trump to do that. He is breaking with Netanyahu in various ways. He's spoken about that he's not yet at that stage, but it's possible to get him there. "That's what it's going to take to end these war crimes." Mr Roth's comments came after 90,000 protesters walked across the Sydney Harbour Bridge on Sunday, calling for an end to Israel's war in Gaza. Mr Roth said public opinion might be enough to force the hand of a populist leader like Donald Trump. "Trump is not indifferent to public opinion," Mr Roth said. Reasons for the shift include images of starving and emaciated children in Gaza being broadcast around the world, while the Israeli government issued multiple denials on the issue. The allegations of using starvation as a weapon of war have formed part of charges brought against Mr Netanyahu and former minister of defence Yoav Gallant by the International Criminal Court. Mr Roth, who is also a qualified lawyer, said he believed that nothing would see those charges rescinded. "Those are blatant war crimes," Mr Roth told 7.30. "They violate the Geneva Convention requirement that an occupying power allow access to humanitarian aid to a people in need. "That defines Gaza. "The fact that Netanyahu committed this crime … that he stops is not a defence to the months upon months in which he was committing the crime. Mr Roth believed the establishment of a Palestinian state would face obstacles, such as Hamas, past failures of the Palestinian Authority and Mr Netanyahu's unwillingness to see it happen. But he said the United States could play a major role in removing those obstacles. "Hamas has said that it would contemplate disarming and leaving Gaza if there were a clear path to a Palestinian state," Mr Roth said. "If we accept that as a negotiating position, then the main obstacle is Netanyahu, who basically has said, 'over my dead body, there's not going to be a Palestinian state.' "The only way to get past that comes back to President Trump. "It comes back to his enormous leverage. The $3.8 billion in annual aid he gives to Israel and massive flow of arms; if he were to say this only continues if you allow the Palestinian state, that allows us to stop the slaughter in Gaza, things like this can happen." Mr Roth told 7.30 he considered antisemitism "a real issue" for him and a real "hazard" for Jewish people, but criticised Australia's Special Envoy to Combat Antisemitism, Jillian Segal, for selecting a controversial definition of antisemitism to base her work on. In her recently released report, Ms Segal urged the Australian government to "require consistent application and adoption" of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism, calling it the "gold standard" in an interview with 7.30. Critics, including the definition's lead author, say it is being used to suppress legitimate criticism of Israel's policies. Mr Roth agreed. "This is a completely counterproductive approach to fighting antisemitism," he told 7.30. "The IHRA definition undermines the fight against antisemitism because it has come to be used over and over as an excuse to suppress legitimate criticism of Israel." The risk in the reliance on the IHRA definition, Mr Roth said, was to undermine the fight against antisemitism. "It cheapens the concept of antisemitism when it's very much needed. It basically prioritises defence of the Israeli government over the defence of Jews around the world," he said. "I have no problem with having a special envoy focused on fighting antisemitism, but if that envoy is really pushing a definition of antisemitism that amounts to defending and stopping criticism of Israel, that is counterproductive. "That is unhelpful for what Jews need to combat a genuine problem." Watch 7.30, Mondays to Thursdays 7:30pm on ABC iview and ABC TV Do you know more about this story? Get in touch with 7.30 here.
