'Humanitarian city' for Palestinians would be a 'concentration camp', says former Israeli PM
Israel's former prime minister Ehud Olmert said that the plans constitute a 'concentration camp' and would result in the ethnic cleaning of Palestinians, in an interview with
The Guardian
.
Defence Minister Israel Katz unveiled the plan during a briefing with reporters last Monday. It envisions building from scratch a closed zone in southern Gaza during a potential 60-day ceasefire in Israel's war with Hamas, currently under negotiation in Qatar.
According to Katz, the area would initially house around 600,000 displaced people from southern Gaza and include four aid distribution sites managed by international organisations.
The entire civilian population of Gaza – more than two million people – would eventually be relocated there.
Critics, however, have questioned both the feasibility and ethics of the plan, with Israel's opposition leader citing its astronomical cost, and one expert pointing to lack of infrastructure in the area necessary to accommodate so many people.
'It is a concentration camp. I am sorry,' Olmert said, when asked about the plans laid out by Katz last week.
'If they [Palestinians] will be deported into the new 'humanitarian city', then you can say that this is part of an ethnic cleansing. It hasn't yet happened,' he said.
The UN agency for Palestinian refugees has described the proposed facility as a 'concentration camp', while Britain's minister for the Middle East and North Africa has said he is 'appalled' by the idea
'Palestinian territory must not be reduced,' the UK's Hamish Falconer said on X. 'Civilians must be able to return to their communities.'
'Extremist delusions'
Israel's Defence Minister Israel Katz.
Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
Nearly 21 months of war have devastated much of the Gaza Strip, displacing most of its population, creating dire shortages of food and other essentials, and killing 58,026 people, most of them civilians, according to the territory's health ministry.
New arrivals to the proposed facility would undergo security screening to ensure they are not affiliated with Hamas, and once admitted, they would not be permitted to leave.
The Israeli military would provide security 'from a distance', Katz has said.
However, the criticism of the plan reportedly extends even to Israel's own security establishment.
Local media reported that army chief Eyal Zamir lambasted the proposal at a cabinet meeting, arguing it would divert focus from the military's two core objectives: defeating Hamas and securing the return of hostages taken on 7 October.
The broadcaster Channel 12 reported that unnamed security officials viewed the plan as little more than a 'gigantic tent city', and warned it could pave the way for a return to Israeli military rule in Gaza.
Advertisement
Such a move aligns with the long-standing goals of far-right Israeli ministers Bezalel Smotrich and Itamar Ben Gvir, key coalition partners of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
Both Smotrich and Ben Gvir advocate the re-establishment of Jewish settlements in Gaza, from which Israel unilaterally withdrew in 2005, and have repeatedly called for the voluntary expatriation of Palestinians from Gaza.
The projected expense of the initiative – estimated between 10 and 20 billion shekels (€2.56 billion to €5.13 billion) – has further fuelled domestic outrage as the cost of nearly two years of war mounts.
'That money is not coming back,' opposition leader Yair Lapid said on X yesterday..
'Netanyahu is letting Smotrich and Ben Gvir run wild with extremist delusions just to preserve his coalition. Instead of plundering the middle class's money, end the war and bring back the hostages.'
Olmert also told The Guardian: 'In the United States there is more and more and more expanding expressions of hatred to Israel. We make a discount to ourselves saying: 'They are antisemites.' I don't think that they are only antisemites, I think many of them are anti-Israel because of what they watch on television, what they watch on social networks.
'This is a painful but normal reaction of people who say: 'Hey, you guys have crossed every possible line.''
'Fantasies'
The Palestinian Authority was scathing in appraisal of the proposed facility, with its foreign ministry saying: 'The humanitarian city has nothing to do with humanity.'
That view was echoed by UNRWA, the UN agency for Palestinian refugees, which said the 'plan would de-facto create massive concentration camps at the border with Egypt'.
A Palestinian official with knowledge of the ongoing ceasefire talks in Qatar told AFP that Hamas rejected plans to concentrate Palestinians in a small part of the south, viewing it as 'preparation for forcibly displacing them to Egypt or other countries'.
Amnesty International, which has accused Israel of genocide, warned that relocating Gazans within the territory or 'deporting them outside against their will would amount to the war crime of unlawful transfer'.
On Friday, 16 Israeli scholars of international law sent a letter to Katz and Zamir also warning the scheme could amount to a war crime.
Michael Milshtein, an Israeli former military intelligence officer, called the plan one of many 'fantasies' floated by Israel's leadership amid mounting public frustration with the war's trajectory and lack of a political solution.
He also noted there was no existing infrastructure in the proposed zone, raising questions about provision of electricity and water.
'There is only sand and fields, nothing,' said Milshtein, who heads the Palestinian studies programme at Tel Aviv University.
'Nobody tells the Israeli public what is the price and what are the consequences of reoccupying Gaza, from the economic, political and security points of view,' he told news agency AFP.
'I really think that if people understand that the purpose of the war is the reoccupation of Gaza, there is going to be a lot of social unrest in Israel.'
Additional reporting by Emma Hickey
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
‘This is an unimaginable nightmare': Residents gather to mourn Palestinian-American and friend killed in Israeli-occupied West Bank
Palestinian flags covered their bodies and their heads were wrapped with keffiyehs as the two young men were lifted through the crowd. Hundreds of residents of Al-Mazra'a ash-Sharqiya, in the occupied West Bank , gathered on Sunday to mourn two of their own. American citizen Sayfollah Musallet (20) and Palestinian Mohammed Hussein Al-Shalabi (23) died last Friday – one was beaten to death by Israeli settlers, the other shot, their families and witnesses say. The men were killed after they went to agricultural land owned by local residents beside the nearby town of Sinjil. This has become a common Friday tradition, as Israeli settlers increasingly try to seize territory in this area – around 19km northeast of the city of Ramallah – and Palestinians attempt to defend it. The deaths happened three months after Israeli soldiers shot and killed 14-year-old American citizen Amer Rabee, in Turmus Aya, a town less than 5km away. READ MORE Musallet was born and living in Florida , where he worked at his family's Tampa ice-cream shop. He travelled to the West Bank on June 4th, his family said. Reading a family statement, his cousin Diana said Musallet was surrounded by settlers for more than three hours as paramedics tried to reach him, meaning they were unable to give him life-saving medical assistance. 'Saif was a brother and a son ... a kind, hard-working and deeply successful young man,' she said. 'This is an unimaginable nightmare and an injustice that no family should ever have to face. We demand the US State Department lead an immediate investigation and hold the Israeli settlers who killed Saif accountable for their crimes. Saif is not just a number. He is the kid that brings light in every room he walks into. We won't let him be forgotten.' [ 'Hanging on by a thread': Two days with activists protecting Palestinians from being forced off their land Opens in new window ] A US embassy spokesperson confirmed the death, telling The Irish Times: 'We offer our condolences to the family and are providing consular assistance. We have asked Israeli authorities for further details.' A state department spokesperson added that they have 'no higher priority than the safety and security of US citizens overseas', while referring questions about an investigation to the Israeli government. Men carry the bodies of American citizen Sayfollah Musallet (20) and Palestinian Mohammed Hussein Al-Shalabi (23), both killed during settler violence last Friday. Photograph: Sally Hayden Relatives of Mohammed Hussein Al-Shalabi (23) gather to mourn together the day after his death. Photograph: Sally Hayden Land near where settlers have been attacking in Sinjil, the occupied West Bank. Photograph: Sally Hayden A poster remembering American citizen Sayfollah Musallet (20) seen during his funeral on Sunday. Photograph: Sally Hayden Men pray at the funeral for American citizen Sayfollah Musallet (20) and Palestinian Mohammed Hussein Al-Shalabi (23), in Al-Mazra'a ash-Sharqiya, the occupied West Bank. Photograph: Sally Hayden An Israeli military spokesperson said a joint investigation had been opened by the Israeli police and the Military Police Criminal Investigation Division, and they could not share further details because the case is 'ongoing.' The military previously accused 'terrorists' of 'hurl[ing] rocks at Israeli civilians', saying a 'violent confrontation' later developed 'which included vandalism of Palestinian property, arson, physical clashes, and rock hurling'. A witness to Friday's violence said the settlers came 'like a gang' and 'made a trap', arriving while Palestinians were 'up in the farms' and using a vehicle to block the exit road. He suggested one of the reasons the settlers want to control the land is that it contains dozens of farms and water wells. Many American-Palestinians, like Musallet, regularly return to the area their family originally comes from and maintains a base in, even if they find full-time existence here unsustainable. 'We have to go to America to work,' explained one of Musallet's relatives. As a Palestinian living in the occupied West Bank, Shalabi faced restricted movement under occupation. Like many others there – who say Israel's stranglehold on the Palestinian economy hugely restricts employment opportunities – Shalabi was unable to find steady work and did whatever daily jobs he could find, said his uncle Samer Shalabi (55). Still, his uncle called Shalabi a 'happy kid' who would do 'things for the family to make their life easier'. [ Sanctions against individual settlers are hopelessly inadequate. The real settler organisation is Israel Opens in new window ] The day after his death, dozens of women sat in Shalabi's home, red-eyed and in shock. In the middle was his mother, Jumana Shalabi. She described the hours, on Friday, after she heard there were clashes and someone had died. 'My heart was worried,' she said. Because the military blocked the roads, witnesses said, friends and relatives were not able to search for Shalabi until late on Friday night, when they discovered his body. His mother believed he could have survived if he received medical attention sooner. 'He is the warmest son, warm with everybody. All the people in the neighbourhood, they loved him,' she said, crying again. Israeli human rights organisation B'tselem has documented at least 40 attacks by settlers in Sinjil over the last five years, including them setting fire to vehicles and homes in January this year, and last year cutting down olive trees, vandalising cars, stealing water tanks and chasing harvesters off their land with a drone. In 2022, settlement watchdog Kerem Navot wrote : 'It's clear that the settlers ... have their eyes on the land of the village of Sinjil,' saying an area of around 1,200 acres had been 'marked as a target for takeover decades ago'. As the settlers advanced, residents of Al-Mazra'a ash-Sharqiya and Sinjil issued calls to journalists. On July 4th, they invited The Irish Times to a 'civil peaceful demonstration and protest', saying, 'We can't access our lands due to the settlers' violent act[s] toward us. We have farms, homes and property and lands that we cannot attend to due to Israeli settlers blocking the roads, shooting at us, and throwing rocks on our vehicles.' Diana, a cousin of Sayfollah Musallet, reads a family statement the day after his death. Photograph: Sally Hayden A civil defence volunteer used his vehicle to transport wounded people following Friday's violence. Photograph: Sally Hayden Blood stains were still visible in a vehicle used to transport injured people the day after Friday's violence. Photograph: Sally Hayden One week later, the two young men were killed. Residents said more people were injured, with one civil defence volunteer showing The Irish Times streaked blood inside the vehicle he said he used to transport wounded people before the roads were blocked. At least 1,161 Palestinians have been killed in the West Bank since the beginning of 2023, according to the UN, including at least 22 women and 236 children. The vast majority – 884 – were killed by live ammunition, the UN says. Over the same period, at least 59 Israelis were killed in the West Bank, including nine women and nine children. Musallet's friend from the US, who asked to be identified only by his first name, Juma, said they were part of a 'bunch of guys in Tampa who used to hang out every day ... We used to go to his house just to chill. We used to go to the pool, we used to go to the range, we used to go fishing together'. Juma – whose family is originally from the same area – called Musallet 'the best of us ... He never drank, he never did any drugs. This kid was just the best human being you'll ever meet in your life'. [ Three Palestinians killed by Israeli army during raid by settlers Opens in new window ] The 23-year-old said he finds being an American citizen 'very difficult' now. 'The country I live in supports the killing of my people. It's hard ... You see what's happening in Gaza. I hope something changes ... You can see this new generation that's coming up. They're becoming more aware of what's going on around the world ... They're seeing what they're seeing.' 'What happened is something that is not acceptable, not easy to deal with,' said Shalabi's uncle, Samer. 'Two kids who were killed in a very cold blood ... If you look at the eyes of the people you find the anger and sadness.' He said locals are terrified now, 'but even with that, they will never leave here ... It's our country. We're going to stay here. There's no other place for us'.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
BBC ‘failed' to ask the right questions regarding Gaza documentary, says executive
A senior BBC News executive has said the broadcaster 'failed' to ask the right questions regarding the documentary Gaza : How To Survive A Warzone. It comes after a report looking into the documentary, which was removed from BBC iPlayer in February after it emerged that the child narrator was the son of a Hamas official, found that it breached BBC editorial guidelines on accuracy. The review, published on Monday, was conducted by Peter Johnston, the director of editorial complaints and reviews which is independent of BBC News, and found that the programme was in breach of accuracy for 'failing to disclose information about the child narrator's father's position within the Hamas-run government'. It did not, however, find any other breaches of editorial guidelines, including breaches of impartiality, and also found no evidence that 'outside interests' 'inappropriately impacted on the programme'. READ MORE Speaking on BBC's Radio 4 World At One programme, Deborah Turness, chief executive of BBC News, said: 'Our current affairs teams, day in, day out, week in, week out, are creating and pushing out incredibly controversial, difficult, complex documentaries. 'We have really good, best-in-class systems in place, but in this we failed, and we must put in place new processes which will enable us to continue with our courageous journalism with confidence.' She also added: 'It's about accountability. And I think what you can see today is that the BBC has taken this incredibly seriously. We have led a full and thorough investigation, which we are publishing full and transparently. 'Everything is out there, and we share the action plan that we're now putting into place to prevent this kind of mistake happening again. 'We are responsible for everything that we publish and everything we broadcast. We take it incredibly seriously, and we didn't run those questions to ground.' Ms Turness also addressed a second Gaza documentary, Gaza: Doctors Under Attack, which was originally commissioned by the broadcaster from an independent production company called Basement Films. However, the corporation delayed airing it until the review into Gaza: How To Survive A Warzone was released. The documentary, which includes witness accounts from frontline Palestinian health workers in Gaza and documents attacks on hospitals and clinics, was later pulled entirely and aired on Channel 4 earlier this month. Ms Turness said: 'We want to tell the stories of Gaza. We are telling the stories of Gaza. 'We've got long form projects in the pipeline. We are covering Gaza, and we're covering it with courage and without fear or favour. 'During that production, the BBC raised concerns around the social media activity of one of the journalists. Obviously, we are incredibly protective and conscious of our impartiality and our very high standards of impartiality, and we were concerned about the activity of the journalist concerned. 'We decided, in the light of those concerns, that we would pause broadcast of that documentary while waiting to see what the Peter Johnston report would bring us. 'The film company weren't happy with that pause, and they wanted the journalism to air sooner. So we were trying to find a way around that, trying to find a way without airing the documentary, to put the journalism and the voice of the doctors on our platforms. 'And then came a moment where the lead journalist went on the Today programme to talk about Israel's attacks on Iran and used language around Israel that was really not compatible with the BBC standards of impartiality and made it impossible for us to continue with the project. 'It was very difficult to imagine that it could meet the BBC standards of impartiality, and that it would have created at least a perception of partiality, had we aired it. 'And the right thing to do at that time was to walk away, because no BBC journalist could have said what that journalist said on air, and therefore we have to apply some of the same standards to those who work with us from the outside.' – PA
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Future of Israel's plan to force Gazans to southern city hangs in balance
As contacts continue aimed at clinching a Gaza ceasefire and hostage release deal, the future of Israel 's planned 'humanitarian city' in Rafah hangs in the balance. The plan, outlined by defence minister Israel Katz, envisages the forced transfer of Gaza's population to a tent city to be built on the ruins of the southern city of Rafah, now largely destroyed, beginning with the approximately 600,000 war refugees from the adjacent Muwasi humanitarian zone. Israel hopes international aid agencies will provide food, water and medical supplies to the area while the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) will secure the approach routes. The residents will be screened on entry and will not be allowed to leave. Israel argues that the plan will separate innocent civilians from Hamas fighters in other areas, who will no longer be able to surround themselves with civilian human shields. READ MORE At a tense security cabinet meeting on Sunday night, prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu and several other ministers criticised the IDF plan to establish the humanitarian city after military planners warned that it could take up to a year to build and cost €3.5 billion. Mr Netanyahu told IDF chief of staff Ltn Gen Eyal Zamir: 'I asked for a realistic plan,' telling him to draw up an alternative plan that would be faster and cheaper. Israeli experts in international law and the laws of war have warned that the humanitarian city constitutes a war crime and a crime against humanity, claiming that under certain conditions, it could also be considered genocide. Unrwa, the United Nations agency for Palestinian refugees, says the plan would create 'de facto massive concentration camps at the border with Egypt'. Hamas negotiators have rejected the idea as part of an Israeli plan to continue the war after an initial 60-day ceasefire, leading to a forced transfer of Gaza residents to Egypt or other countries. IDF officials have warned that Hamas opposition to the plan could topple a ceasefire deal and endanger the lives of the 20 hostages still believed to be alive. The Palestinian foreign ministry also rejected the plan, saying: 'The humanitarian city has nothing to do with humanity.' Israel's opposition leader Yair Lapid termed the plan an expensive fantasy of Mr Netanyahu's far-right coalition partners, who favour the re-establishment of Israeli settlements in Gaza. Former prime minister Ehud Olmert described the humanitarian city as a 'concentration camp'. The Israeli military launched a campaign to destroy Hamas in response to an unprecedented cross-border attack on October 7th, 2023, in which about 1,200 people were killed and 251 were taken hostage. More than 58,000 people have been killed in Gaza since then, according to the territory's Hamas-run health ministry.
