
Judge hears closing arguments in Saskatoon trial of man who stabbed partner to death
Prosecutor Cory Bliss and defence lawyer Brian Pfefferle made final arguments Wednesday before Justice Grant Currie at the 28-year-old's judge-alone second-degree murder trial.
The issue is not whether Hamp fatally stabbed his partner Emily Sanche on Feb. 20, 2022 — he admitted that at trial.
Rather, the defence contends Hamp was in a mental health crisis that left him incapable of knowing that what he was doing was wrong.
"There's only one explanation for why Thomas Hamp would have done this to Emily Sanche and it's he was suffering from an acute psychotic episode where he was not in touch with reality," Pfefferle said.
The Crown is suggesting that Hamp was in a drug-induced psychosis when he killed Sanche and then claimed an intruder had stabbed her and tried to kill him.
"From our perspective, it's very unusual that someone would commit a crime while deluded and then immediately suggest that someone else committed the crime," Bliss said.
Both Bliss and Pfefferle relied, to varying degrees, on a 25-page assessment done by forensic psychiatrist Shabehram Lohrasbe. The veteran doctor was hired by the defence.
Lohrasbe concluded in his report, based on five hours of interviews with Hamp and a review of notes kept by Sanche and her cousin Catherine, that Hamp "was acutely and severely psychotic" when he killed Sanche in their apartment.
"Psychosis was the dominant factor that drove his violence," Lohrasbe wrote.
"It is likely that his capacity to 'know' that his actions were wrong, in the real world, was severely impaired."
While testifying by video, Lohrasbe said he could not overstate the importance of the notes kept by Emily Sanche and her cousin. Pfefferle noted in his close that "her real time overview was not marred by memory, delusion, distortion or inaccuracy."
"The detailed notes and text messages that Emily and her cousin Catherine compiled, described by Dr. Lohrasbe as 'incredibly important documents' are rare in their depth and immediacy." he said.
"Dr. Lohrasbe, a psychiatrist with over four decades of experience and thousands of assessments to his name, testified that he had 'never seen anything like it.' Emily's text message chain, he testified was 'poignant, and so close to the offence' that it offered unparalleled insight into the rapid deterioration of Thomas's mental state."
Bliss offered a different take on the impact of Sanche's detailed record.
He suggested that a list compiled by the 25-year-old in her journal in the days before her death, which referenced the need for a mental health warrant and the necessity of seeing a doctor, actually provided the motive for the attack.
Hamp, already in a drug-induced psychosis because of his sustained cannabis use, would have seen the list as evidence Sanche was going to force medical treatment and planning on leaving him, Bliss argued.
This threat of a partner pulling away is often a trigger for violence in intimate partner cases, he said.
Bliss referenced how Lohrasbe was generally concerned about the impact of high-potency cannabis on a user's mental health. The doctor agreed that symptoms from drug-induced psychosis could look like mental illness.
"I think there is a real concern for the public that people that choose to take psychoactive drugs, and they lose touch with reality because of that, those people should be responsible for their crimes," Bliss said outside court after the day's proceedings were done.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CTV News
a few seconds ago
- CTV News
Man sentenced for robbing same CIBC branch twice
A man was sentenced Friday for robbing the same branch of the Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce in downtown Lethbridge twice in two months. A Lethbridge man convicted of robbing the same bank twice in two months is serving federal prison time. The CIBC in the 500 block of 13 Street North in Lethbridge was robbed in March of 2023 and then again in April the same year. Jamie Gerald Bagu, 53, plead guilty to the robberies. He was sentenced to seven years behind bars and given a firearms prohibition


CBC
a minute ago
- CBC
RCMP end search for missing Shediac kayaker
RCMP say they have called off the water and ground searches for a missing Shediac, N.B., kayaker, but say their investigation continues and they will pursue any new leads. Luc Bourgeois, 34, has been missing for three days. The Shediac man departed on a solo fishing trip on Thursday afternoon in a kayak from the Pointe-du-Chêne wharf. "Teams have been searching tirelessly the last couple of days and have covered a lot of area with no success," RCMP said in a statement Sunday. Bourgeois is described as about five feet six inches tall and 170 pounds, with long curly brown hair, a beard and brown eyes. He was last seen wearing black shorts, a blue and grey life-jacket, a Bass Pro Shops hat, sunglasses and black Under Armour sandals, according to police. A Facebook group created by Bourgeois's family remains active with nearly 6,000 members and is asking for people to help search for him.


CTV News
31 minutes ago
- CTV News
Investigation underway into fatal collision early Saturday in Carstairs
An investigation is underway into a fatal collision that took place early Saturday morning in Carstairs. At 6 a.m. that day, Didsbury and Airdrie RCMP responded to reports of a single vehicle collision at the intersection of Highway 2 and Highway 581 in Carstairs. Arriving officers, along with fire and other first responders, discovered that the lone occupant of the vehicle, a 53-year-old Calgary resident, was dead. The cause of the collision is under investigation.