
Despair and disbelief overcome victims of Mumbai train blasts as high court verdict brings case back to square one
Decades of fruitlessness have sealed the lips of Priti Sawant, whose husband, Parag (36), became the face of the tragedy.
Parag died in 2015 after a long spell in coma. Priti is currently employed with Western Railway at Bhayander station but declined comment to TOI, saying she did not wish to relive the trauma. She was an expectant mother in 2006, and her daughter was born after Parag's injury.
Harshal Bhalerao (23) of Vasai was killed in the blast. His mother Saguna said Monday, "No verdict will bring my son back. But the guilty must be punished."
Harshal's father, Yashwant, said, "Not a single victim's family will like this judgement. We have named our bungalow 'Harshal 7/11' after him. He was our only boy, now our daughter takes care of us." Harshal was on his first day of work in Andheri when he fell victim to the blast at Borivli.
You Can Also Check:
Mumbai AQI
|
Weather in Mumbai
|
Bank Holidays in Mumbai
|
Public Holidays in Mumbai
Artist Mahendra Pitale lost an arm to the bombing. He said, "The order is a massive shock. We believed the guilty would hang. If these men were not the perpetrators, then who carried out the bomb blasts? Why were they not apprehended? Nineteen years have passed and there is no justice. Is it going to take the law enforcement agencies another 19 years to find the real perpetrators?"
Pitale too was given a job by the railways.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Gold Is Surging in 2025 — Smart Traders Are Already In
IC Markets
Learn More
Undo
"My prosthetic limb is very expensive and I have to find sponsors or depend on trusts to be able to afford it," said Pitale, who has changed prosthetic limbs seven times in the past two decades.
"No one killed 200 people & injured 700...," tweeted chartered accountant Chirag Chauhan, who had suffered a spinal injury that left his legs and lower body paralysed. "Personally, I may have forgiven the terrorists and moved on with my life.
But the law of the land has failed to deliver justice today to the people who were left dead or disabled... Today is a very sad day for everyone. Justice got killed..."
Vishakha Seksaria, sister of Vrindesh, who was killed, said, "I am unable to digest this news. The accused had been convicted in 2015... how can they be acquitted now? My brother, Vrindesh, was like a pillar of support to us. After losing my parents during the pandemic, I'm now all alone.
The court order feels like a blow. I would like to discuss with the other (victims') families and petition the court to reconsider."
Subhash Saboo said, "I can never forget that day as my father (Nathmal) was on the train towards Malad and he never made it home. I have been trying to erase the memory for the last two decades but today the sorrow is searing through me and seeing the acquittal order has left me speechless."
Rishi Bobra (38), a gritty survivor who spent a month in the ICU, said he had nothing to say on the verdict and had moved ahead.
"I work for a securities firm. I drive or take the train to my workplace. l don't want to dwell on the past," he said. In 2016, Bobra had said that he felt the delay not just in this case, but in all cases is a reflection of the Indian legal system.
Garden landscaper Harish Pawar was injured when a train rod pierced his chest. He bubbled over in anger Monday. "It appears as if we the commuters are to blame for stepping out for work to support our families. Why was the evidence that was deemed acceptable by the lower courts for conviction, entirely negated by the high court?"
Vasai resident Raniya D'Souza lost her father, Manuel (36), when she was just six and a half.
Manuel, a chemical engineer and the sole breadwinner, was killed in the Matunga blast. "Our family struggled emotionally and financially, and the void left by my father has not been filled even after all these years," she said. Raniya is grateful to Western Railway for having granted her a job after graduation. Her younger brother, who was only two and a half at the time, does not have any memories of their father.
Calling the judgment unjust, Hansraj Kanojia, who lost a leg, demanded reinvestigation.
"If they are being set free today and go on to commit the same crime again, who will take responsibility? The case should be taken to the Supreme Court."
On Monday BJP leader Kirit Somaiya along with Kanojia and Pitale met additional chief security (home) I S Chahal at Mantralaya. They expressed unhappiness over the judgement and requested the state to challenge the decision in the SC.
(Inputs by Nitasha Natu, V Narayan, Somit Sen, Vishal Rajemahadik, Swati Deshpande, Vijay V Singh, Pushkraj Vernekar and Bella Jaisinghani)

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
15 minutes ago
- Time of India
‘No sir, we don't want to stay at Main Hostel': JU ragging scar yet to heal
1 2 Kolkata: The scars of ragging at Jadavpur University are yet to heal. More than 100 second-year undergraduate students have refused to relocate from New Boys' Hostel to the Main Hostel for their third year due to the traumatic experience at the Main Hostel two years ago. These students are from the same batch as the fresher who had in Aug 2023 died after falling off the second-floor balcony of the Main Hostel and several of them had also faced brutal ragging. In a letter to dean of students Rajat Roy, the students said they were yet to recover from the ragging incident that claimed the life of their batchmate two years ago and would agree to the shift only if they were not made to share either the floor or dining area or bathrooms with seniors. During interactions with the dean and some teachers on Wednesday they said they would not feel secure at the Main Hostel . After the 2023 ragging incident, JU had reorganised hostel allocations, assigning freshers to New Block and Old PG Hostel and second-year students to New Boys' and JPJU. Third- and fourth-year students were housed in A1 and A2 blocks of the Main Hostel and postgraduate students in B, C, and D blocks of the Main Hostel. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like These 11 Everyday Foods Might Be the Key to Knee Pain Relief Undo You Can Also Check: Kolkata AQI | Weather in Kolkata | Bank Holidays in Kolkata | Public Holidays in Kolkata "We are afraid to shift to the Main Hostel because some of us were victims of ragging in A2 block where we initially stayed as freshers. The death of our batchmate adversely affected our mental health. The ragging culture is still prevalent there," said a student. Another student pointed out that some of them were witnesses in the ongoing case at Alipore court and added, "The university should provide us a safe and secure residence." At least five students told TOI they would shift to private accommodation if they were assigned rooms in the Main Hostel. A senior university official acknowledged the concerns were genuine. "We will try to address these issues before the hostel allotment process begins," he said. Following the death of the Bengali first-year student two years ago, the university's probe panel report highlighted that "ragging in various form" was widespread at the Main Hostel, with A2 block being the most notorious. Freshers were subjected to physical tortures in "intro sessions" conducted by seniors. They were also stripped, forced to perform obscene dances, verbally abused, spanked and compelled to run errands for the seniors. "Some of the third-year students faced the 'intro' session as freshers two years ago. They are apprehensive of facing similar abuse if they return to the Main Hostel," said a teacher who spoke with boarders.


Time of India
30 minutes ago
- Time of India
Bengal cops launch spl helpline for migrant workers facing harassment
Kolkata: Bengal Police on Friday announced a special helpline — 9147727666 — for residents working in other states facing police harassment. Police said they will perform necessary checks and coordinate with police from other states. TOI had reported that Bengal Police received nearly 1,400 such applications and verified 1,000 of them. The verifications have led to release of migrant workers from detention. In a statement on X, Bengal Police said, "We are receiving reports from various sources that many people from Bengal working in other states are facing various problems and becoming victims of harassment. However, those who are affected, or their family members, do not have a clear idea about whom to inform about these problems or how to do so." You Can Also Check: Kolkata AQI | Weather in Kolkata | Bank Holidays in Kolkata | Public Holidays in Kolkata "We appeal to citizens from Bengal who go to work in other states and face any kind of problem, or their families, to immediately inform your local police station. You can also inform the district control room. Additionally, for the convenience of families, we are launching a helpline," state police added. "This number can only be used for WhatsApp. You can send a message with the necessary information, including your name and address. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like This Could Be the Best Time to Trade Gold in 5 Years IC Markets Learn More Undo We will verify each piece of information and coordinate with the concerned state to take necessary action," they further said. The step coincided with police in Bengal securing the release of a migrant worker in Gurgaon. Najmul Sardar, 23, from Bongaon in North 24 Parganas, was having lunch with his parents on July 20 when cops dressed in plain clothes allegedly barged in, dragged him out of his rental accommodation in Badshahpur in Haryana's Gurugram and bundled him into a police van, according to his relatives. Badshahpur cops said they suspected Sardar and six others of being illegal Bangladeshi immigrants. The young migrant worker was released from police custody on Friday after intervention from the Bongaon police station in Bengal. Sardar's family members said he had furnished both his Aadhaar and voter ID before the police. According to his relatives, police, while detaining Sardar, said they were taking him for document verification. "They said it would take 30 minutes. But nearly four days passed and there was no information of his whereabouts," they said. The situation took a turn for the worse when two of Sardar's co-workers visited the police station to inquire about him and were also reportedly detained. Sardar's family then reached out to relatives and local netas in Bongaon who alerted Bongaon cops. "His parents broke down in despair. We were informed immediately, and we wasted no time in taking action," said Sheikh Sabir Ali, Sardar's cousin. Bongaon police said, "Our team visited his home, gathered all legal documents and contacted officials at Badshahpur police station. Once we presented the necessary proof, Haryana police were satisfied and Sardar was released."


Time of India
44 minutes ago
- Time of India
Governor C V Ananda Bose returns Bengal rape bill after Centre flags concerns
West Bengal governor C V Ananda Bose (Pic credit: ANI) KOLKATA: West Bengal governor C V Ananda Bose has returned the Aparajita bill to the Assembly for reconsideration, citing serious objections raised by the Centre regarding proposed changes to Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), according to a high-ranking Raj Bhavan source. The Centre found that the Aparajita Women and Child (West Bengal Criminal Laws Amendment) Bill, passed in Sept 2024, contains changes in penal provisions for rape under multiple BNS sections, proposing "excessively harsh and disproportionate" punishments, sources said. A major point of contention is an amendment to BNS section 64. The state bill increases the punishment for rape from the current minimum of 10 years to either imprisonment for the remainder of the convict's natural life or capital punishment. The ministry of home affairs (MHA) reportedly deemed this as unduly harsh and inconsistent with principles of proportionality. Another change that MHA has objected to involves the removal of BNS section 65, which prescribes stricter penalties for sexual assault of minors. According to sources, Union govt believe scrapping this clause weakens protections for the vulnerable groups and risks diluting the intent behind age-based classifications in rape laws. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Brain tumor has left my son feeling miserable; please help! Donate For Health Donate Now Undo However, the clause that the Centre found most problematic is the one under section 66, making the death penalty mandatory in rape cases where the victim either dies or is left in a vegetative state. The MHA raised constitutional concerns, arguing that removing judicial discretion in sentencing violated established legal norms and Supreme Court rulings, sources said. State govt, however, said it had received no official communication either from the Centre nor the governor's office about these observations. Earlier, bills similar to Aparajita, like Andhra Pradesh Disha Bill, 2019, and Maharashtra Shakti Bill, 2020 - which had mandatory death penalty for all rape and gang-rape cases - were passed unanimously by state legislatures, but did not get President's assent. Trinamool Congress indicated the party would make it a political issue. TMC spokesperson Kunal Ghosh said: "The returning of the Aparajita bill is unfortunate, deplorable and condemnable... This has proved that BJP is unwilling to impose maximum punishment in these cases, as their members are implicated in molestations and rapes."