What's in Trump's ceasefire proposal and can it end Israel's war on Gaza?
United States President Donald Trump said last week that Israel agreed to the conditions for a 60-day ceasefire, and negotiators could meet to carve out a path to finally ending Israel's nearly 21-month-long war on Gaza.
Hamas said it delivered a 'positive response' to mediators, with amendments, while Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called the Palestinian group's asks 'unacceptable' but sent negotiators to the Qatari capital, Doha, for talks nonetheless.
Netanyahu is set to visit Washington, DC, on Monday, where reports say Trump would like a deal.
'There could be a Gaza deal next week,' Trump told reporters on Saturday, adding that he had not been briefed yet about Hamas's counterproposal but that it was 'good' that they had responded.
Here's all you need to know:
What is Hamas asking for?
According to reports, there are three main demands:
At least 743 Palestinians have been killed seeking aid at GHF sites in Gaza in recent weeks.
In late June, the Haaretz newspaper reported that Israeli soldiers were deliberately ordered to fire on unarmed people waiting for food.
Humanitarians have repeatedly said they are able to distribute aid and food to Palestinians in Gaza and have criticised the GHF for furthering Israel's political agenda.
'It makes aid conditional on political and military aims,' Tom Fletcher, the United Nations chief humanitarian, said in May.
'It makes starvation a bargaining chip. It is a cynical sideshow … A fig leaf for further violence and displacement.'
Hamas wants the Israeli military to withdraw to the positions it held before it violated the ceasefire in March of this year.
In May, the Israeli military began extensive new ground operations in Gaza, killing hundreds of Palestinians, to take 'operational control' of large swaths of the Strip.
The Israeli military had already created the Netzarim Corridor, which splits the Gaza Strip into northern and southern sectors, soon after launching the war, and in April, Netanyahu announced the creation of the Morag Corridor in the southern Gaza Strip.
In March, Israel unilaterally broke a ceasefire that had been agreed in January, despite the conditions for the ceasefire being upheld by the Palestinian side.
This time, Hamas and other Palestinian groups want international assurances that this will not be repeated.
Hamas reportedly wants a US guarantee that Israeli air attacks and ground operations, which have killed thousands of Palestinians, will not resume even if the ceasefire ends without a permanent end to the war.
What does the original US-backed proposal say?
There is reportedly a key focus on the remaining Israeli captives in Gaza.
The plan is to release 10 living Israeli captives held by Hamas and the bodies of 18 others in exchange for Palestinians lodged in Israeli prisons. The release would be staggered over a number of days.
Fifty captives are still in Gaza, with about 20 reportedly alive.
On the question of aid, the UN and the International Committee of the Red Cross would contribute to distributing sufficient quantities to Palestinians.
Lastly, it calls for phased pull-outs of Israeli troops from parts of Gaza.
What is Israel saying?
Netanyahu reportedly agreed to the original US proposal but has called Hamas's amendments 'unacceptable'.
He has said he will not end the war until all captives are released and Hamas is 'destroyed'. The latter goal has been called impossible by many analysts and is believed to be an open-ended political objective for Netanyahu to continue the war as long as he believes it will serve his personal interests.
Netanyahu is on trial for corruption and is still widely blamed in Israeli society for the security failures that led to Hamas's Al-Aqsa Flood operation on October 7, 2023, during which 1,139 people died in Israel and about 250 were taken captive.
Analysts believe Netanyahu wants to continue the retaliatory war on Gaza until he can gain enough political leverage to dismiss the cases against him and build enough popular support to remain the leader of Israel.
Netanyahu's war has been supported by his far-right ministers, particularly Itamar Ben Gvir, minister of national security, and Bezalel Smotrich, the minister of finance. They want Israel's military operations to be intensified to kill more Palestinians and to stop providing any aid to the besieged and starving people in Gaza.
What is life like for Palestinians in the meantime?
Israel is still launching deadly attacks on Gaza, with at least 138 Palestinians killed in the last 24 hours, according to the Ministry of Health in Gaza.
In the occupied West Bank, bulldozers are demolishing homes, and Israel has killed more than 1,000 people since October 7, 2023.
People in the West Bank are also suffering recurring attacks by Israeli soldiers and armed settlers from illegal settlements, as well as severe limitations on movement and access to livelihoods.
What are the chances a deal will be reached?
Trump appears keen on reaching one, and Palestinians in Gaza are desperate for the Israeli attacks to cease.
However, one major roadblock remains.
'Israel and Netanyahu are not interested in reaching a ceasefire,' Adnan Hayajneh, professor of international relations at Qatar University, told Al Jazeera, adding that there is a 'very slim chance' of a ceasefire.
'What Israel wants is clear … a land without a people,' Hayajneh said. 'So Palestinians are given three choices … starve to death … get killed … [or] leave the land, but Palestinians have so far proven they will not leave the land, no matter what.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Jazeera
an hour ago
- Al Jazeera
Israel bombs ports, power plant in Yemen as Houthis fire more missiles
Israel's military has bombed three ports and a power plant in Houthi-controlled areas of Yemen, prompting the rebel group to fire more missiles towards Israeli territory. The Israeli military said on Sunday that it struck the ports of Hodeidah, Ras-Isa and as-Salif on the Red Sea coast as well as the Ras Kanatib power plant. It said it also struck a radar system on the Galaxy Leader ship, which was seized by the Houthis and remains docked in the port of Hodeidah. There were no immediate reports of casualties. The Israeli attacks late on Sunday were the first on Yemen in almost a month and came after the military claimed that it intercepted a missile fired by the Houthis in the early hours of the day. The rebel group, which controls Yemen's most populous areas, responded to the latest Israeli attacks by launching more missiles at Israel in the early hours of Monday. The Israeli military said two missiles were fired from Yemen, and that it attempted to intercept the projectiles. The attack set off sirens in the cities of Jerusalem, Hebron and near the Dead Sea. Israel's emergency service said there have been no reports of injuries or impact from the projectiles. The Houthis say their attacks on Israel are in solidarity with Palestinians in Gaza who are under Israeli attack. The group has fired hundreds of missiles at Israel and launched more than 100 attacks on commercial vessels in the vital Red Sea corridor, since Israel's war on Gaza began in 2023. The Houthis paused their attacks after a ceasefire between Hamas and Israel in January, but resumed them after the United States launched attacks on Yemen on March 15, killing nearly 300 people in the weeks that followed. The latest escalation comes at a sensitive moment in the Middle East as a possible ceasefire in Israel's war on Gaza hangs in the balance, and as Tehran weighs whether to restart negotiations over its nuclear programme following United States air strikes that damaged Iran's most sensitive atomic sites. In Yemen on Sunday night, the Houthi-affiliated news outlet Al Masirah TV reported that strikes hit the port city of Hodeidah, while the Saba news agency confirmed the attacks on the three power plants as well as the power station. A spokesman for the Houthis, Ameen Hayyan Yemeni, meanwhile, said the group's air defences forced 'a large portion' of Israel's warplanes to retreat. Locally-manufactured surface-to-air missiles were used to respond, 'causing great confusion among enemy pilots and operations rooms', he wrote in a statement on X. The attacks also took place after a grenade and drone attack on a Red Sea cargo ship set the vessel on fire and forced its crew to abandon it. No group has claimed the attack, but the United Kingdom maritime agency said it matched the 'established Houthi target profile'. Separately, Israeli forces also bombed Lebanon, claiming attacks on several Hezbollah targets in the country's south as well as the eastern Bekaa region. In a statement, the military said the strikes were directed at infrastructure used for 'storing and producing strategic weapons' and a 'rocket launch site'. Since a November 27 ceasefire formally ended more than a year of hostilities with Hezbollah, Israel has continued sporadic strikes on Lebanon. It says the group's activities run counter to the agreement, but does not provide evidence to back its claims. In addition to its ongoing war on the Gaza Strip, Israeli forces have launched attacks on the occupied West Bank, Syria and Iran over the past year.
Qatar Tribune
5 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
Brazil's Lula condemns Gaza ‘genocide'
Brazil's president says the world must act to stop what he describes as an Israeli 'genocide' in Gaza as leaders from 11 emerging BRICS nations gathered in Rio de Janeiro. 'We cannot remain indifferent to the genocide carried out by Israel in Gaza, the indiscriminate killing of innocent civilians and the use of hunger as a weapon of war,' President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva told leaders from China, India and other nations on Sunday. His comments came as Gaza truce talks between Israel and Hamas resumed in Doha and as pressure mounted to end the 21-month war, which began with Hamas's October 7, 2023, attacks in southern Israel. Lula said 'absolutely nothing could justify the terrorist actions' on that day, which resulted in the deaths of 1,219 people, mostly Israeli civilians. But he also offered fierce criticism of Israel's subsequent actions. Israel's military campaign has killed at least 57,418 people in Gaza, also mostly civilians. BRICS countries have been in disagreement over how strongly to denounce Israel's bombing of Iran and its actions in Gaza. (Agencies)
Qatar Tribune
5 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
Musk launches America Party as feud with Trump escalates
Billionaire Elon Musk has followed through on his pledge to create a new political party in the United States after President Donald Trump signed his controversial budget legislation, the so-called 'One Big, Beautiful Bill', into law. Musk in a post on X on Saturday declared the formation of the 'America Party', to 'give back' the people of the US their freedom and challenge what he called the nation's 'one-party system'. He cited a poll, uploaded on Friday – the US's Independence Day – in which he asked whether respondents 'want independence from the two-party (some would say uniparty) system' that has dominated US politics for some two centuries. The yes-or-no survey earned more than 1.2 million responses. 'By a factor of 2 to 1, you want a new political party and you shall have it!' Musk wrote on Saturday. 'When it comes to bankrupting our country with waste & graft, we live in a one-party system, not a democracy. Today, the America Party is formed to give you back your freedom,' he declared. The move comes amid a worsening of the feud between the world's richest man and Trump over the new budget law, which the Tesla and SpaceX CEO said would bankrupt the US. Musk was Trump's main campaign financier during the 2024 election, and led the Department of Government Efficiency from the start of the president's second term, aimed at slashing government spending. The two have since fallen out spectacularly over disagreements about the 'Big, Beautiful Bill'. Musk said previously that he would start a new political party and spend money to unseat lawmakers who supported the bill, which experts say will pile an extra $3.4 trillion over a decade onto the US deficit. 'They will lose their primary next year if it is the last thing I do on this Earth,' Musk had said. There was no immediate comment from Trump or the White House on Musk's announcement. Trump earlier this week threatened to cut off the billions of dollars in subsidies that Musk's companies receive from the federal government, and to deport the South African-born tycoon. 'We'll have to take a look,' the president told reporters when asked if he would consider deporting Musk, who has held US citizenship since 2002. It is not clear how much impact the new party will have on the 2026 mid-term elections, or on the presidential vote two years after that. On Friday, after posting the poll, Musk laid out a possible political battle plan to pick off vulnerable House of Representatives and Senate seats, and for the party to become 'the deciding vote' on key legislation. 'One way to execute on this would be to laser-focus on just 2 or 3 Senate seats and 8 to 10 House districts,' Musk posted on X. All 435 US House seats are up for grabs every two years, while about one-third of the Senate's 100 members, who serve six-year terms, are elected every two years. Despite Musk's deep pockets, breaking the Republican-Democratic duopoly is a tall order, given that it has dominated US political life for more than 160 years, while Trump's approval ratings in polls in his second term have generally held firm above 40 percent, despite the president's often divisive policies. (Agencies)
