‘Private expressway for privileged': tunnel road project in Bengaluru draws criticism for ‘dropping dedicated bus lanes'
Mobility experts as well as Opposition BJP leaders have pointed out that the final Detailed Project Report (DPR) of the 16.75-km twin tube tunnel road project appears to have dropped the dedicated bus lane mentioned in the draft DPR.
Criticising the Congress-led Karnataka government on the issue on Monday, Bangalore Central MP and BJP leader PC Mohan said, 'Tunnel road final DPR quietly drops bus lanes, once again making it clear that the tunnel is only for those rich people who can afford ₹660 toll, not for the common Bengalurean. On one hand, they talk of free bus rides; on the other, they erase bus infrastructure itself,' he posted on X.
'How many Bengalureans can actually afford ₹660 a day? That's nearly ₹20,000 a month just to use this tunnel. This is not public infrastructure but a private expressway for the privileged, funded by taxpayers. It is a discriminatory, exclusionary, and anti–public transport move,' Mohan added.
According to page 195 in the final DPR, a diagram showing the 'lane open cut section' of the tunnel road indicates three lanes, including two driving lanes (for cars) and one emergency lane (for emergency vehicles) in the twin tube tunnels. However, in the draft DPR of the project, on page 171, the diagram shows two lanes (for cars) and another lane for buses/emergency vehicle services.
A dedicated bus priority lane has been a long-pending demand of public transport enthusiasts in Bengaluru. The Bengaluru Metropolitan Transport Corporation (BMTC) launched a bus priority lane (BPL) in November 2019 as part of a pilot phase that aimed to reduce traffic congestion and enhance the efficiency of public transport. It also aimed to cut down travel time on BMTC buses from 70 minutes to 50-55 minutes, saving close to 20 minutes for commuters along Outer Ring Road (ORR).
Proposal for bi-articulated trolleybuses
Further, the draft DPR also mentions the proposal of bi-articulated trolleybuses – an electric bus that operates by drawing power from overhead wires using two trolley poles, allowing it to move without the need for traditional fuel sources, like diesel. However, the report does not clarify who operates these trolley buses and whether BMTC was consulted before the option was proposed. Interestingly, the bi-articulated trolleybuses are not part of the final DPR.
Speaking to The Indian Express, B S Prahallad, technical director of Bengaluru Smart Infrastructure Limited (B-SMILE), said public transport will be prioritised under the tunnel road project. 'A dedicated bus lane infrastructure is part of the plan. However, we will still conduct a few studies, including traffic analysis, to design and finalise the bus lane in the tunnel road project.'
Satya Arikutharam, an urban mobility expert, said there seems to be no clarity at all regarding the scope of the tunnel road project. 'The draft DPR had proposed an electric trolley bus-based system which the final DPR has dropped. A patently bad proposal has now become worse. The DPR has numerous flaws and is unreliable and unviable. It's a costly distraction that hurts Bengaluru's public transport-based sustainable mobility goals,' he said.
Arikutharam pointed out that in the draft DPR, 'the level of service was stated as D (meaning more congestion) with a dedicated bus lane and providing only two lanes for cars. Now, in the final DPR, by dropping the dedicated bus lane from the design, all three lanes can be occupied by cars, which will improve the level of service to B (meaning less congestion). I urge the government to drop the car-only tunnel road proposal and focus on completing the Metro and suburban rail network.'
Sanath Prasad is a senior sub-editor and reporter with the Bengaluru bureau of Indian Express. He covers education, transport, infrastructure and trends and issues integral to Bengaluru. He holds more than two years of reporting experience in Karnataka. His major works include the impact of Hijab ban on Muslim girls in Karnataka, tracing the lives of the victims of Kerala cannibalism, exploring the trends in dairy market of Karnataka in the aftermath of Amul-Nandini controversy, and Karnataka State Elections among others. If he is not writing, he keeps himself engaged with badminton, swimming, and loves exploring. ... Read More
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Deccan Herald
8 minutes ago
- Deccan Herald
Dhankhar raises eyebrows as he leaves office; Trump slaps 'friend' Modi's India with 25% tariffs
Hello readers! We are back with a new edition of DH Political Theatre. The previous week witnessed debates and chaos in the Parliament as the Monsoon Session kickstarted with the much awaited discussion on Operation Sindoor, giving a chance to the Opposition to bombard the government with even more questions. The Opposition also took on the Modi govt on the US tariff row, indicating it to be the start of "bure din" as 25 per cent US tariffs came into effect for India. Let's dive in deeper and see what else happened in India this on Operation Sindoor, and the unanswered questions .Home Minister Amit Shah announced in Lok Sabha the killings of three Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT) 'A-category' terrorists who carried out the Pahalgam attack. In the House, questions were raised by the Opposition regarding the silence on why Operation Sindoor was stopped midway. Congress MP Priyanka Gandhi Vadra slammed the government for the violence in Manipur, Delhi riots, and Pahalgam, all of which happened under Shah's watch. In his 100-minute reply during the special discussion, the PM put up a brave front by saying India "taught" a lesson to those behind the Pahalgam attack, and stated that no country stopped India from carrying out the operation, hinting at Donald Trump's claims of having brokered the ceasefire. Trump has repeated his claim of ending the conflict between India and Pakistan nearly thirty times by saying he 'helped settle' the tensions using trade as a sharp attack, Rahul Gandhi accused Modi for carrying out Operation Sindoor to protect his "image". He also took a dig at him vis-a-vis Trump, saying, "We can't have a PM who doesn't have the courage to call Trump a liar, who can't use the Army as it is supposed to be."Amid all this, the silence of certain leaders made loud statements. "Maun vrat, maun vrat": Shashi Tharoor said outside the Parliament when asked about participating in the 16-hour special discussion. Tharoor has publicly praised Modi on Operation Sindoor, and participating in the debate would have meant 'attacking the government'. .'Kaun banega next VP?'.After the sudden resignation of Jagdeep Dhankhar, the question on who will be the frontrunners for becoming the next Vice President has become Election Commission has informed that polls to pick the VP will take place on September 9. With that, the I.N.D.I.A. bloc will be exploring a consensus candidate. Dhankhar cited health concerns as the reason for his exit, but Congress senses there is "far more to his totally unexpected resignation than meets the eye", and that there are "deeper reasons" behind the the ruling BJP-led NDA enjoying a majority in the electorate, it is likely to consider probable names soon. The BJP has a large pool of leaders to choose from for the were even speculations among politicians in Kerala that Shashi Tharoor may be chosen by the BJP. However, time will tell if BJP will choose an "outsider" for the crucial Constitutional post..'SIR: Attack on Democracy'.Several Opposition leaders demanded the rollback of Election Commission's voter roll revision in Bihar. The MPs raised slogans and protested against the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in SIR as "vote chori", the Opposition protested in both Houses of Parliament against the exercise, alleging that the EC's initiative was aimed at "disenfranchising voters" in Bihar ahead of the Assembly polls. Following this, the Supreme Court said it was overviewing the process of SIR as judicial authority, and would immediately step in if there was mass exclusion of all this, a bizarre event has rattled Bihar's administrative machinery, as a residence certificate was issued to a dog named "Dog Babu".Independent MP Pappu Yadav slammed the administration, and called out on how a dog is getting a residence certificate, while ordinary people cannot get row: 'Bure din for India?'.The United States announced 25 per cent tariff on Indian exports, and signed a trade deal with Pakistan. Trump called India a "friend", however mounted a sharp attack, and discontent over India's ties with Russia. The two countries can can take their "dead economies down together," Trump said. Following the tariff deal, Rahul Gandhi took a jibe at PM Modi and Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, and claimed everybody except them knows that the Indian economy is "dead". Rahul had said a trade deal with the US will happen and Trump will define it, while "Modi will do what Trump tells him to do".Samajwadi Party chief Akhilesh Yadav too noted that this is the beginning of "bure din" for India. In the midst of the tariff talks, the White House believes Trump should be awarded the Nobel Prize, as he "ended several conflicts around the world", saying it is well past rekindles 'Dalit CM' debateCongress President Mallikarjun Kharge recalled how he lost the CM's post in 1999 to S M Krishna, which seems to have rekindled the 'Dalit CM' debate within the party's state unit. Deputy CM D K Shivakumar backed Kharge and said that there is nothing wrong if a senior leader like him is expressing his emotions. Kharge's remark sparked a fresh debate on the long-standing demand for a Dalit CM in Karnataka, a hotly debated matter within the Congress party, an issue on which senior leaders and Ministers Parameshwara and H C Mahadevappa have openly spoken in the past. The BJP took no time in picking on Kharge's statement. Attacking the Congress for "tokenism" when it comes to "Dalit empowerment", Leader of the Opposition R Ashoka said, "Every time a Dalit rises in Congress, the Gandhi family ensures he is pulled down."More from KarnatakaRahul Gandhi has the evidence regarding the modus operandi for "vote theft" during last years LS polls, claimed CM Siddaramaiah, adding that Rahul will be in Bengaluru on August 5 to participate in a protest and submit a representation to the EC officials in Karnataka. Deputy CM D K Shivakumar too cited two instance of voter additions during the 2023 Assembly polls. He claimed that Congress wants to "save democracy" and does not want the EC to be a part of the political process. .What happened elsewhere?In a development that took Maharashtra politics by surprise, the Thackeray cousins were seen together at the iconic Matoshree, the home of former Shiv Sena supremo Balasaheb Thackeray. This was a second meet up of Raj and Uddhav in a fortnight's time, intensifying the alliance buzz. Meanwhile in West Bengal, CM Mamata Banerjee led her party to launch a second "Bhasha Andolan" to protest the "linguistic terror" she accused the BJP of unleashing on Bengali-speaking migrant workers in BJP-ruled states. .These were all the political updates of the week. Stay tuned to DH for all the latest news and we will be back with Political Theater next Stage Left,DH Newsletters Team
Hans India
8 minutes ago
- Hans India
Why not talk to Pakistan if dialogue with China is possible, asks Mani Shankar Aiyar
New Delhi: Senior Congress leader Mani Shankar Aiyar on Saturday called for the resumption of dialogue between India and Pakistan, while strongly criticising the current foreign policy approach of the Indian government, saying it "lacks both principles and direction." He also said that India continues to maintain hostility towards Pakistan while being open to talks with China. In an interview with IANS, Aiyar questioned why India continues to maintain hostility towards Pakistan while being open to diplomatic engagement with China, despite the latter's military proximity to Pakistan during recent tensions. "When India and Pakistan were engaged in a military conflict during 'Operation Sindoor', the Chinese Army was backing the Pakistani Air Force. If dialogue is possible with Beijing, then why not with Islamabad?" he said. Referring to Prime Minister Narendra Modi's statement during his Russia visit, where he said that "this is not an era of war" and that dialogue and diplomacy were the only solutions, Aiyar asked why that principle is not applied to India's dealings with Pakistan. "The Chinese Army was there with the Pakistani Air Force during the conflict. You (the government) are ready to talk to China, so why not talk to Pakistan? PM Modi says that this is not an era of war, so why are we fighting with Pakistan? He told Russia that dialogue and diplomacy are the only way, but we don't engage with dialogue or diplomacy with Pakistan. With China, the dialogue only started recently," he added. Aiyar also took aim at what he described as a rudderless foreign policy, questioning, "Our diplomacy neither has a knowledge of principles nor a goal, then what kind of diplomacy and foreign policy is this?" The Congress leader further raised the issue of US President Donald Trump's repeated claims of having brokered a ceasefire agreement between India and Pakistan -- claims that have been consistently denied by New Delhi. Aiyar questioned why the Indian government has not officially refuted President Trump's assertions more strongly. "Trump has claimed several times that the US brokered the ceasefire agreement between India and Pakistan, but our government is not ready to say that he is lying. The government does not have the courage to speak truth to power and their so-called friends and enemies," he said. "Trump's claims of credit for India's ceasefire agreement are accepted by Pakistan, but India has denied any mediation occurred. Hence, Islamabad is getting all the benefits, and we are facing the punishment," Aiyar added.
Hindustan Times
8 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
'Lok Sabha poll was rigged': Rahul Gandhi claims India's election system is ‘dead'
Congress leader and Lok Sabha Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi on Saturday launched a sharp attack on the Bharatiya Janata Party-led government and the electoral process in the country, alleging that the 2024 general elections were "rigged". HT Image Speaking at the Annual Legal Conclave 2025 in Delhi, Rahul Gandhi said, 'We are going to prove to you in the coming few days how a Lok Sabha election can be rigged and was rigged.' He further claimed that India's electoral system has collapsed. 'The truth is that the election system in India is already dead. The Prime Minister of India is the prime minister with a very slim majority. If 15 seats were rigged, he would not have been the Prime Minister of India,' he added.
