‘Little Stupid' Superman hands James Gunn his third-highest Rotten Tomatoes score, beats Guardians of the Galaxy vol. 3 and 4

Indian Express

4 days ago

Superman 2025 first reviews are in, and while fans gear up for the grand reveal of James Gunn's directorial, the special premiere has critics clashing over the reboot. The new DC Studios and Warner Bros. collaboration, with David Corenswet stepping in as the new Man of Steel, has landed a mostly positive Rotten Tomatoes score, especially when stacked against the franchise's recent misses. But unlike Gunn's rock-solid legacy with Guardians of the Galaxy and The Suicide Squad, critics say this version of the superhero feels a bit stupid, but in a weirdly charming way. It's fun, but hard to box in as a hardcore actioner or a bold revival. Some are all in for the light, hopeful tone. Others think it softens the punch.
Also read: Superman theme reimagined with Indian classical instruments earns global praise: 'Wasn't ready for this'
At the time of writing, David Corenswet's Superman holds an 87% Rotten Tomatoes score, though that number is still moving as more reviews roll in ahead of the July 11 premiere. Zooming out, the 2025 reboot has already landed as the third highest-rated film in the DCEU, right behind Wonder Woman (93%) and ahead of Aquaman (65%), Man of Steel (56%), Justice League (40%), and Batman v Superman (29%). While critics aren't hailing it as James Gunn's best work in the superhero game, the film still secured top spot in his near-flawless record of comic book hits. It trails just behind Guardians of the Galaxy (92%), The Suicide Squad (90%) and beats Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2, Vol. 3, despite some calling the premise silly.
Also read: Superman first reactions: The James Gunn film is 'bold yet faithful' as DC studios embarks on a new journey
According to the Houston Chronicle, 'It's not a great movie, by any stretch, but it is a highly entertaining one with a solid cast, impressive effects, and an underlying message of love and respect.'
According to The Movie Minute, 'James Gunn's reboot isn't always super, but man, it sure does get the franchise flying off to a pretty high start.'
Jordan Hoffman wrote, 'For those holding out for a hero, and who need a jolt of truth, justice, and the American way, this is a strong summer treat.'
Reuben Baron said, 'Superman is zippy blockbuster fun. But amidst all its cartoon absurdity, it might just inspire people to make a difference in this universe.'
Hollywood Chicago wrote, 'This ain't your Granddaddy's Supes, but it's still good enough for a watch. The immigrant angle was pretty brassy of James Gunn, and scenically the film breaks new ground. But too much Supes torture, too little Supes presence, and Worst. Perry White. Ever.'
Despite mixed opinions, most agree this is a strong start for the new DC Universe. The box office predictions are massive. Analysts and trend trackers estimate Superman could pull in anywhere between $110 million to $200 million in its opening weekend. But with Scarlett Johansson and Jonathan Bailey leading Jurassic World: Rebirth, some fear Gunn's reboot might get overshadowed by dinosaurs. Still, Gunn has dismissed the talk that Superman needs to cross $700 million to be called a success. The film reportedly cost around $200 million to make, still within blockbuster territory. For those wondering what kind of Superman this is, it's not an origin story. Gunn's story explores who Superman is, what drives him, and what it means to still be hopeful in a world that doesn't always believe in heroes. He's scrutinised, judged, and grilled by the media, but he's not alone. He's got a loyal, faithful dog sticking by his side.
Superman 2025 official synopsis, 'When Superman gets drawn into conflicts at home and abroad, his actions are questioned, giving tech billionaire Lex Luthor the opportunity to get the Man of Steel out of the way for good. Will intrepid reporter Lois Lane and Superman's four-legged companion, Krypto, be able to help him before it's too late?'