Turkish magazine condemned for allegedly depicting caricatures of Prophet Muhammad
In its 26 June issue, Leman Magazine published an illustration showing two angelic figures hovering above a bombed city, presumably over Gaza. One figure says, 'Salamun Aleykum,' while the other replies, 'Aleyhem Shalom.'
Social media users and commentators widely identified the figures as representations of Muhammad and Musa (Moses), prompting widespread outrage across the country.
Many public and government figures, including Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, condemned the magazine, saying, 'This is an open provocation hidden under the guise of humour. It is a heinous provocation.'
An investigation was launched into the magazine for "publicly insulting religious values", and the editor-in-chief, the manager, the cartoonist, and the director of drawings were detained.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
Interior Minister Ali Yerlikaya announced on X that police had detained the cartoonist behind the controversial image, along with Leman Magazine's graphic designer.
'The person named DP who made this vile drawing has been caught and taken into custody,' he said, adding: 'These shameless individuals will be held accountable before the law.'
In his tweet, Yerlikaya also shared a video of the moment when the cartoonist was violently detained.
The magazine has denied that it was a depiction of the Prophet Muhammad, as stated in a lengthy thread shared on its social media account.
Parts of the thread read, 'More than 200 million people in the Islamic world are named Muhammad. The artwork contains no direct reference to the Prophet Muhammad. The cartoonist intended to portray a Muslim individual killed by Israel, aiming to highlight the just cause of the oppressed Muslim population. There was absolutely no intention to insult or demean religious values. We reject the accusation directed at us, as there is no depiction of the Prophet Muhammad in the illustration.'
The magazine's editor-in-chief, Tuncay Akgun, told AFP by phone from Paris that the image had been deliberately misinterpreted and was "not a caricature of Prophet Mohammed". "We would never take such a risk," he added.
Some people are defending the cartoon, saying it should be only a crime to depict the prophet in an Islamic state, and Turkey is a secular state.
Zaman dik durma zamanı, 19 Mart ne kadar niyetli ve organize ise bu işler de o kadar organize, hesaplı ve yapay. Türkiye'de kimsenin dine hakaret derdi yok, birileri sineğin yağından çıkarıp darbeye dayanak etmek istiyor. Dini kisvede siyasal darbe yaprak dindar seküler herkesin… https://t.co/ebIGH7uTFe — Murat Somer (@murat_somer) July 1, 2025
Translation: No one in Turkey is interested in insulting religion; some are trying to extract meaning from nothing and use it as a pretext for a coup. Under the guise of religion, they aim to carry out a political coup and establish a regime where both devout and secular citizens are made subservient to others.
However, many people have disagreed and view the cartoon as an insult to Islam and Muslims.
Peygamberimiz Hz. Muhammed'e hakaret eden Leman isimli paçavranın kapısına kilit vurup yazanın, çizenin, basanın hayatını karartacak bir adalet istiyorum. pic.twitter.com/6MIoN6ZMpB — Marginale (@themarginale) June 30, 2025
Translation: I want the kind of justice that will shut down the disgraceful publication named Leman, which insulted our Prophet Muhammad, and ruin the lives of those who wrote, drew, and published it.
Protests
Many people angry at the cartoon took to the streets on Monday to protest against it, calling for the magazine to be shut down. Many met in front of the Leman Magazine building and prayed there as an act of protest.
Some people marched at Taksim Square in downtown Istanbul, shouting, 'down with secularism', 'long live Sharia', which also created backlash online, as the Turkish government has long banned protests there, specifically including Feminist Night Marches, pride marches and May Day celebrations.
Pride için yürüyüş yapcaklar diye bir aydır taksim kapalı yasak var genel diyolar?? Ama şeriatçi militan olunca bi anda açılmış taksim https://t.co/H97Zvx8voo — luctuosa (@Iuctuosa) July 1, 2025
Translation: They've kept Taksim closed for a month, saying there's a general ban because of the Pride march. But suddenly, it's wide open when religious hardliners are gathering.
An AFP correspondent reported that an Istanbul bar, a venue often frequented by Leman Magazine staff, was attacked by several dozen enraged protesters. This sparked angry scuffles with police, which quickly escalated into clashes involving 250 to 300 individuals.
In April, Amnesty International said that the 'Turkish authorities must lift all restrictions on a planned May Day solidarity demonstration in Istanbul's Taksim Square and allow people to gather peacefully in accordance with a ruling by Türkiye's Constitutional Court.'
Meanwhile, Ozgur Ozel, the leader of the Turkish opposition party, said, "I won't allow any disrespect toward the Prophet Muhammad, but I also won't stand by while people are targeted and vilified over something that wasn't disrespectful to begin with."
With politicians getting involved and individuals being arrested, the impact of the issue has grown in the country, becoming increasingly viral on social media.
The controversy over Leman's cartoon has once again brought to the surface the enduring tension between secular and religious worldviews in Turkey, a divide that has shaped the country's politics for decades.
Since the early days of the Republic, secularism has been enshrined as a foundational principle, while conservative and religious movements have steadily gained ground, particularly under the rule of the Justice and Development Party since 2002.
Analysts have long pointed to what they describe as a deepening culture war over religion, press freedom and national identity.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Gulf Today
33 minutes ago
- Gulf Today
The unique candidate
The Democratic party's candidate for New York City mayor Zohran Mamdani could face three rivals in the November election. In addition to uninspiring Republican candidate Curtis Silwa, two veteran Democrats have declared they are running as independents: incumbent Eric Adams and former New York state governor Andrew Cuomo. While Adams has fought off federal indictments for bribery, fraud, and seeking illegal foreign campaign donations, Cuomo was compelled to resign in 2021 after 11 women charged him with harassment. Mamdani is not burdened with such negative baggage and is unique on the US political scene. At 33, he is much younger than his rivals. He is the first South Asian to win a major party primary. As a foreign-born Muslim, Mamdani would be New York's first Muslim mayor if elected. He is a socialist and has a pro-Palestinian record in politics. He does not shy away from his record. He is a member of the Democratic Socialists of America, of the nine-member 'State Socialists in Office' bloc in the in New York assembly and of the Muslim Democratic Club of New York. His record appears to be free of corruption. For decades US citizens have been fearful of socialists who are falsely regarded as Communists and enemies of sacrosanct capitalism. US citizens pay a high price for such beliefs. During the 1950s, the country was plagued by a Communist witch-hunt led by Republican Senator Joe McCarthy. His successors lurk in today's Republican party ranks and leadership. Erratic, explosive Donald rump calledMamdani a '100 percent Communist lunatic.' For decades US citizens have rejected sensible federal and state policies on a variety of issues. For example, by refusing as 'socialist medicine,' they do not enjoy coverage by a national health system and are forced to rely on insurance companies which exact huge premiums to cover the high costs of expensive medical treatment. To make matters worse, the Trump administration seeks to defund Medicare and Medicaid and there are fears that social security, adopted in 1935, may not be able to meet the needs of pensioners who have paid into the system during their working lives. After al-Qaeda's 2001 attacks on New York and Washington, there has been widespread suspicion and antagonism towards Muslims. This has been exacerbated and exploited by Trump. During both his terms in office, he sought to ban citizens of majority Muslim states from entering the country by claiming that some might be planning to harm the US. Mamdani has won the support of young voters by being honest. He refused to renounce his support for the Palestinians and for the Boycott, Divest and Sanction (BDS) movement which seeks to punish Israel for its anti-Palestinian policies and actions. Sociology professor at New York's City University, Heba Gowayed told Al-Jazeera, 'The fact that he refused to back down from his position on Palestine is huge.' Furthermore, she added that he did this in 'an atmosphere where we've been told that holding that position is politically disqualifying [and] insisted on taking this position.' She remarked, 'The old guard personified [by Cuomo] was beaten by a democratic socialist, a young, pro-Palestinian brown Muslim kid who had 1 per cent name recognition as of February. It is phenomenal and remarkable.' While Mamdani has adopted a pro-Palestinian stand, he has visited Jewish temples and social centres to reassure voters among the 2.1 million Jews in New York City that he intends to serve their interests. In his view, local politics should have nothing to do with the foreign Palestine-Israel conflict. He has been adopted by two influential mainstream Jewish Democrats Chuck Schumer and Jerry Nadler as well as Democrat leftist Alexandra Ocasio Cortez and Independent Bernie Sanders who is also Jewish. The progressive Jews for Racial and Economic Justice declared they were 'thrilled' by his nomination. However, during the campaign, Mamdani encountered racist attacks from New York City councilwoman Vickie Paladino and Congressman Randy Fine, both Republicans. After Mamdani won, conservative Islamophobe Republican Congressman Andy Ogles called for Mamdani to be deported and denaturalised. On Palestine-Israel, Mamdani stated, 'There are millions of New Yorkers who have strong feelings about what happens overseas. Yes, I am one of them. And while I will not abandon my beliefs or my commitments, grounded in a demand for equality, for humanity, you have my word to reach further, to understand the perspectives of those with whom I disagree, and to wrestle deeply with those disagreements.' Mamdani was born in Uganda to Indian parents and immigrated to the US when he was seven years old but did not become a naturalised US citizen until 2018, presumably, after deciding on a political career. He earned a bachelor's degree in Africana studies from Bowdoin college and worked as a housing counsellor for non- white homeowners faced with eviction. He was a hip-hop musician before being elected to the New York state assembly in 2020, 2022, and 2024. His work on housing has prompted him to make affordable housing, as well as police reform and prison reform, a major issue in his campaign. He is married to Syrian American artist Rama Duwaji and the couple lives in an apartment in the Astoria neighbourhood. Mamdani shadowed Cuomo for much of the campaign although once ballots were counted, was ahead by 43.51 per cent to Cuomo's 36.42 per cent. Although they had raised similar funding, Cuomo relied on traditional 'fat cat' donors while Mamdani appealed to a wide range of small contributors whose donations committed them to vote for him. His campaign strategy involved creating a movement, recruiting mainly young volunteers through social media and, ahead of voting day, he asked them to 'knock on a million doors.' This is not a new strategy as it was used in 2008 by the presidential campaign of Barack Obama. Mamdani 's primary victory was an upset, an upset for traditional power brokers, for anti-Asian racists, anti-Muslim sectarians, and conservatives. They argued he was not a realist and too inexperienced a politician to manage New York's huge bureaucracy and deal with the city's mountain of problems. Nevertheless, New York is a Democrat city and unless he loses votes to Democrat rivals Adams and Cuomo who are running as independents, Mamdani is likely to defeat Republican Silwa in the November election. Photo: TNS
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Gazans criticise 'weak' Hamas as war drags on and lawlessness rules
Almost 21 months into the war, with Gaza 's cities reduced to rubble and more than a million Palestinians displaced, frustration and despair are spilling over in the voices of those living its daily nightmare. From shattered homes to crowded tents, civilians say they are being sacrificed in a political standoff that shows no sign of resolution. Amid continuing Israeli bombardments, crippling restrictions on aid and the breakdown of law and order, some Gaza residents are now openly criticising the leadership of Hamas, not out of political rivalry but from feelings of anguish, exhaustion and abandonment. One Gazan fled his home in Khan Younis, southern Gaza, with his family of eight and now lives in a tent in the nearby coastal area of Al Mawasi. Like many others, he has watched Gaza descend into what he calls 'a state of collapse'. 'In everything that's happening, Hamas is a weak player,' he told The National. 'It lost its ability to influence events months ago, except for a few isolated operations. And sadly, we − the people − are the ones paying the price. Every day, people are dying in a million different ways.' He describes a daily life consumed by fear and lawlessness, 'It's terrifying to even step outside your shelter. Criminals, armed gangs and hunger surround us. Aid is stolen in broad daylight. And yet Hamas still seems disconnected from the reality we live in,' he said. The man spoke as Hamas said it was studying new truce proposals put forward by mediators. But Gazans have had their hopes raised and dashed many times before, with neither Hamas nor Israel willing to cede ground on demands such as the disarmament of the militant group and the handover of all the hostages it still holds, or a full Israeli withdrawal from Gaza and a permanent ceasefire. '[Hamas] present themselves as victorious, but the truth is, they lost the moment this war began. They should have handed over the hostages to strip Israel of its excuse. Instead, they provoked the world and ignored our suffering,' he said. He says Hamas's messaging, especially from its leaders abroad, rings hollow. 'We hear their statements, but they're not speaking to us. It's as if we don't exist.' A resident of Gaza city's Al Sabra neighbourhood says he has seen the war take a heavy toll on his family. His three brothers are dead, among more than 57,000 Palestinians killed in the conflict. His father has been severely injured, and the family's home is gone. 'Hamas has effectively lost control over the Gaza Strip,' he told The National. 'Militias rule the streets, thieves roam freely and the Sahm unit Hamas formed to fight crime has no authority. Every day, we hear of new crimes and no one is held accountable. 'There's nothing left in Gaza to mourn. Still, Hamas acts like it's winning, when in reality, the people are losing everything.' For him, the final straw is the lack of empathy. 'I've lost everything. What has Hamas done for me? Nothing. Their leaders issue statements and videos that ignore our suffering entirely. 'We just want them to feel what we're feeling. Let them accept the proposal on the table. Let us eat, let us drink, let us live for a moment like human beings,' he said. 'Decisions about our lives are being made by people outside the country who don't suffer like we do. That's unacceptable. We're the ones paying the price.' In Al Shati refugee camp, in northern Gaza, another displaced man lives in a tent, after losing his home, job, car – everything he spent years working for. 'Hamas is treating us like a bargaining chip. Its negotiating stance is disgraceful and gives us no hope,' he said. He recalled a proposal for a ceasefire and hostage exchange put forward by the US Middle East envoy Steve Witkoff, one that many in Gaza saw as imperfect but a necessary step towards ending the bloodshed. 'Most people supported the deal. We asked Hamas to accept it. It didn't meet all our hopes, but we had no better options. We are not the strong side in this war. We are the ones dying in the streets, in the tents, in the hunger,' he said. 'Hamas's approach to negotiations completely ignores the sacrifices of the people. Tens of thousands of families have lost loved ones. Isn't that reason enough to compromise?' He believes Hamas should not only accept the latest proposals but also begin stepping back from the political stage. 'Let them strip Israel of its pretext. Let them end the bleeding. If they really care about us, they should step aside.' For another resident in a tent in Al Shati camp, the fault lies not solely with Hamas. 'I don't think Hamas is the one refusing to end the war. They're trying to reach a deal that would truly end it. But all the proposals serve only Israeli interests. [Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin] Netanyahu doesn't want peace, he needs this war to survive politically,' he said. He also sees the dilemma Hamas faces. 'Hamas is trapped. They can't withdraw without losing everything, and they want to achieve something meaningful. But what does it mean to end the war, release the captives, and make no progress on Gaza's future? Thousands have died. Their blood cannot go without a price.' For another man who was displaced with his family of three from Jabalia refugee camp to western Gaza city, while Hamas is to partly to blame for Gazans' current plight, most of it rests with Israel. 'Yes, Hamas bears part of the responsibility as the governing authority in Gaza, but the occupation holds the greater share of the blame,' he said. 'Hamas deserves criticism, especially regarding how it has handled the negotiations and the war, but the occupation is the primary killer,' he added 'Hamas did what it could and accepted many proposals, but it was the Israeli side − and the Americans − who refused and failed to engage with ideas to end the war,' he said. 'Hamas tried to preserve security through several initiatives, such as forming the Sahm security unit, but the occupation targeted every one of its movements.'
Middle East Eye
an hour ago
- Middle East Eye
Zarah Sultana quits Labour to start new party with Jeremy Corbyn
Zarah Sultana has resigned from the UK's Labour Party after 14 years to lead a new party with former Labour leader and independent MP Jeremy Corbyn. "Today, after 14 years, I'm resigning from the Labour Party," she said in a statement on Thursday evening local time. "Jeremy Corbyn and I will co-lead the founding of a new party, with other Independent MPs, campaigners and activists across the country." Sultana cited the Starmer government's support for Israel's war on Gaza as a reason for leaving, saying that "this government is an active participant in genocide. And the British people oppose it." The MP has been a particularly vocal critic of the Labour government's continued political, economic and military ties with Israel. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters She accused the political establishment of smearing "people of conscience trying to stop a genocide in Gaza as terrorists", an apparent reference to parliament this week voting to proscribe direct action group Palestine Action as a terrorist organisation, a move she strongly opposed. 'Socialism or barbarism' "We are not going to take this anymore. We're not an island of strangers; we're an island that's suffering," Sultana said. She added that at the next general election, "the choice will be stark: socialism or barbarism. "Billionaires already have three parties fighting for them. It's time the rest of us had one." Corbyn presents inquiry bill as UK spy planes continue flights over Gaza Read More » The MP said: "Westminster is broken, but the real crisis is deeper. Just 50 families now own more wealth than half the UK population." "A year ago, I was suspended by the Labour Party for voting to abolish the two-child benefit cap and lift 400,000 children out of poverty. I'd do it again. "I voted against scrapping winter fuel payments for pensioners. I'd do it again." The confirmation that a new party will be established, co-led by Sultana and Corbyn, marks a significant moment in British politics. It is unclear when the party will be officially launched. There is speculation that it could have a dozen MPs - including some defectors from Labour - which would make it a significant and prominent parliamentary grouping, and a serious headache for the Starmer government.
