BJP leader Amit Malviya's ‘no language called Bengali' jibe sparks outrage, leaves Trinamool fuming
Mr. Malviya, who heads the BJP's IT cell and is the party's co-observer in West Bengal, justified the Delhi Police's description in a social media post.
'There is, in fact, no language called 'Bengali' that neatly covers all these variants. 'Bengali' denotes ethnicity, not linguistic uniformity. So when the Delhi Police says 'Bangladeshi language', it's shorthand for the linguistic markers used to profile illegal immigrants from Bangladesh — not a commentary on Bengali as spoken in West Bengal,' Mr. Malviya said.
The remarks left the Trinamool Congress leadership fuming, with several leaders of the party condemning them strongly. The TMC accused the BJP of 'systematically promoting xenophobia and othering, with Bengalis being deliberately targeted across states'. 'Such dangerous narratives must be condemned and resisted at every level,' the party said.
Trinamool Congress spokesperson Kunal Ghosh equated the remarks to 'linguistic fascism'.
'The BJP is hellbent on erasing one of the richest, oldest, Constitutionally-recognised languages of India just to whitewash the Delhi Police's bigoted profiling tactics. This is linguistic fascism, plain and simple. We dare the BJP to say this on the floor of the Parliament. We dare them to erase Bengali from the Eighth Schedule of the Constitution. We dare them to call Kobiguru's [Rabindranath Tagore] Jana Gana Mana a foreign song,' Mr. Ghosh said.
West Bengal Minister Shashi Panja described the BJP leader's assertions as an attempt to erase, belittle, and vilify the culture, history, and pride of Bengal.
'In his usual cocktail of arrogance, ignorance, and deep-seated hatred, @BJP4India's certified troll and keyboard mercenary @amitmalviya has now declared that 'there is no language called Bengali'. This is a calculated attempt to erase, belittle, and vilify the culture, history, and pride of Bengal,' Dr. Panja said.
'The BJP is threatened by Bengal. By its intellect. By its spine. By its refusal to bow down. And so, they try to delegitimise our language, our people, and our very existence,' she said.
Apart from leaders of the ruling party, prominent people of the State criticised the BJP leader's comments.
The controversial remarks have come at a time when the TMC has been raising its pitch in protest against the alleged targeting of migrants from the State over the past few months. The party has called for a 'language movement', and invoked Bengali asmita (identity) over such protests.
More migrants return
In another development, a group of migrant workers hailing from West Bengal's Dakshin Dinajpur district returned from Delhi. In a video shared on social media by the State's ruling party, the workers said that some men in uniform wanted money from them.
The Trinamool Congress said they were being subjected to brutal torture simply for speaking in Bangla. 'They were beaten, abused, and extorted by @DelhiPolice, which allegedly demanded bribes of ₹5-7 lakh for their release. These are Indian citizens, targeted solely for their language and identity. This is a hate-driven crackdown on the Bengali identity, enabled and emboldened by the Bangla birodhi (opposed) BJP regime,' the party posted on social media.
A few days ago, 12 youths, of whom 10 were from Pingla, and the remaining two from the Sabang police station area of Paschim Medinipur district, returned from Gujarat and alleged torture by the Gujarat Police.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
3 minutes ago
- Mint
PM Narendra Modi to address crucial NDA meeting ahead of V-P polls and amid Parliament logjam today
Prime Minister Narendra Modi will address the BJP-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA) parliamentary party meeting today. This get-together of the ruling alliance's MPs is being held after a considerable gap, news agency PTI said. The NDA meeting, which Narendra Modi will chair, will take place a couple of days before nominations for the vice president's election begin on 7 August. The NDA must announce its candidate, whose election will be a certainty due to the alliance's majority in the electoral college, by 21 August, the last date of nomination filing and the Monsoon Session of Parliament. The meeting also comes in the middle of a session which has been all but a washout so far, except for a two-day discussion on the Pahalgam attack and Operation Sindoor, due to a united Opposition's ceaseless protest against the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar by the Election Commission. PM Modi is expected to speak on a host of current issues as the Opposition has been raising the heat over the poll body's alleged partisan conduct favouring the government, and the Pahalgam terror attack and Operation Sindoor. The prime minister is also likely to be felicitated by the parliamentary party over his government's military response to the terror strike. The electoral college for the vice president poll includes MPs of the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha, and its current strength is 782. If the Opposition also names a candidate, a distinct possibility, then the poll is scheduled to be held on 9 September. Sources said Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju and a few BJP national general secretaries are likely to be coordinating with allies for the vice presidential poll. Since the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, when the BJP lost its majority but comfortably crossed the halfway mark with allies, the sessional meeting of the party's MPs was expanded to include its allies. PM Modi had addressed the first such meeting on July 2. However, no meeting has been held in the last few sessions. Before the last national elections, he addressed the weekly meetings of the BJP parliamentary party, which has now expanded to include party allies such as the TDP, JD(U), and LJP (Ram Vilas). The meeting is attended by MPs of the ruling alliance, and PM Modi often discusses a wide range of political and governance issues and, at times, touches on the government's agenda in Parliament. He often offers the MPs talking points to be raised in public, especially in their constituencies.
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
3 minutes ago
- First Post
Bangladesh a year after Hasina: A nation in turmoil as it marks Monsoon Revolution anniversary
In August 2024, the former Prime Minister of Bangladesh, Sheikh Hasina, resigned from her office and fled her homeland, marking the end of her 15-year-long reign. Here's what Bangladesh looks like a year without Hasina. read more A newly formed party led student demonstrations across Bangladesh on Sunday. They were commemorating one year since the fall of Bangladesh's former Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina. On August 5, 2024, Hasina, who had been in power for the past 15 years, resigned from the prime ministership and fled the country by helicopter. Hasina fled Bangladesh amid violent protests, which started as a student-led demonstration against the controversial quota system, to a full-blown ' Monsoon Revolution'. More than 300 people lost their lives in the violent protests that eventually led to the country giving powers to an interim government led by Bangladesh's Chief Adviser Muhammad Yunus. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD In the span of one year, a lot has changed in Bangladesh. However, the remnants of the July uprising and instability across the country remain. After Yunus came to power, he effectively banned the Awami League from contesting the election. Meanwhile, Hasina faced a plethora of legal cases. Not only this, the current ruling regime is also hunting down Hasina's relatives in a bid to bring corrupt politicians to justice. Here's what happened in and out of Bangladesh after the fall of the Hasina government: Trials and tribulations of Hasina and her family members On August 3 this year, Bangladesh's International Crimes Tribunal (ICT) commenced the trial of deposed PM Hasina in absentia. Hasina has been living in India since the UK rejected her request for refuge. Since then, Bangladeshi authorities have been asking for her extradition. In the case overseen by Bangladesh's ICT, Hasina has been accused of committing crimes against humanity related to the violent suppression of the 2024 student-led protests. The interim government-appointed chief prosecutor, Tajul Islam, in his opening statement, described Hasina as the 'nucleus of all crimes' and called for the maximum penalty. Hasina is not the only one involved in the case. The prosecution also named Hasina's two top aides — former home minister Asaduzzaman Khan Kamal and former Inspector General of Police Chowdhury Abdullaah Al Mamun — as the co-accused in the case. While Hasina and Kamal are being tried in absentia, Mamun is in custody and has agreed to be the 'approver' in the case. This is not the only case in store for Hasina. Just last month, the former Bangladeshi premier was also sentenced to six months in prison in absentia in a contempt of court case by the ICT. This was the first time the 77-year-old Awami League leader has been sentenced in any case since she left office in August last year. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Hasina's family members are also facing the wrath of the judicial system. UK Labour MP and Hasina's niece, Tulip Siddiq, is also set to face a corruption trial in Bangladesh later this month. The former British minister is accused of illegally receiving land in Bangladesh as part of a wider investigation into the regime of her aunt. Amid the increasing scrutiny, the World Health Organisation also sent Hasina's daughter, Samia Wazed, on indefinite leave. With these cases, problems for Hasina and her family are far from being over. Erasing Bangladesh's history and Mujibur Rehman's legacy While the demonstrations were raging on last year, protesters vandalised everything related to Hasina and her family, including tarnishing the legacy of Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman. One photograph featuring protesters climbing over Rahman's statue and vandalising it became a symbol of the July uprising. Destroying Rahman's legacy did not stop after the toppling of the Hasina government. In February this year, well after the Yunus government took over in Bangladesh, a large group of protesters vandalised and set on fire Bangladesh's founder, Sheikh Mujibur Rahman's residence in Dhaka during a live online address of his daughter. The house was an iconic symbol in Bangladesh's history as Sheikh Mujib largely led the pre-independence autonomy movement for decades from the house, while during the successive Awami League rule, it was turned into a museum. The residence in Dhanmondi was often visited by foreign heads of state and other dignitaries. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD While all this was happening, multiple reports suggested that the country's ruling regime is altering history books to fit their current narrative. Until this year, textbooks gave special exaltation to the country's first President Sheikh Mujibur Rahman for spearheading the liberation struggle. However, new books have expunged dozens of poems, speeches and articles penned by Mujib, alongside images of his daughter. Remains of the Awami League While Hasina and top leaders of her party left the Awami League, some of her party members and workers are still in the country. Soon after Yunus came to power, his regime banned the party from contesting in polls. Since then, party workers have been facing all sorts of atrocities at the hands of what they are calling 'goons of the ruling regime'. When _Firstpost_ asked an Awami League worker, who asked to remain anonymous, he had a simple response in Bangla: 'The country's situation is bad.' He said there have been multiple attacks on Hindus and other minorities in the country. When asked who these 'goons' are, the Awami League functionary said, 'They are goons from Jamaat [Jamaat-i-Islami], the BNP [Bangladesh Nationalist Party] and the NCP [National Citizens Party],' whom the Awami League functionary frequently called the 'B Team of Jamaat'. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD He said there have been clashes among workers of different parties, including the Awami League, causing further turbulence in the country. 'Robberies, rapes and contract killings have become common in Bangladesh. People are avoiding going out for this reason, especially Awami League workers. We are living like prisoners,' he told Firstpost. The Awami functionary maintained that while the Army is trying to get a hold of the situation, the lack of police presence in the localities has become a critical issue since the fall of the Hasina government. Mainstreaming of fundamentalist In June this year, Bangladesh's Supreme Court restored the registration of the country's largest Islamist political party, Jamaat-e-Islami. Following the 2013 judgement, on December 7, 2018, the Election Commission issued a gazette officially cancelling Jamaat's registration. The party soon appealed the High Court's ruling. The party has been known for its radical propaganda and involvement in extremist activities. Recently, Nahid Islam's newly formed group has been accused of hooliganism as well, with Awami League party functionalities often calling them the Jamaat's B-Team. Overall, the law and order situation of Bangladesh continues to remain at a deplorable state. We often hear cases of rape and mob lynching, given the fact that the July uprising and the changes that followed dismantled the police infrastructure in the country. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Economy after Hasina After Hasina left, Yunus's regime sought help from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to recover the country's economy, which had been ransacked due to the protests. To meet the IMF's economic reform conditions, the Nobel laureate launched a wide-ranging series of institutional, fiscal, and monetary measures. With this goal in mind, his administration appointed Ahsan H Mansur, a former IMF economist, as governor of Bangladesh's central bank. Soon after stepping into his new role, Mansur introduced policy measures designed to tame soaring inflation and a worsening banking crisis, including hiking interest rates, replacing the boards of 11 troubled banks, initiating efforts to recover bad loans, and repatriating laundered money. While these steps marked a strong start to the economic recovery, the results have been mixed. Although after Hasina's departure, inflation has eased from 11.6 per cent in July 2024 to 9.05 per cent as of May 2025, the youth unemployment remains a pressing concern. In May this year, it was reported that Bangladesh's unemployment rate had surged to its highest level in recent years amid ongoing economic and political instability. According to the latest quarterly labour force survey released today by the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS), the country's unemployment rate stood at 4.63 per cent in the October–December quarter of the current fiscal year. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD This marked a 3.95 per cent spike recorded during May 2024, when Hasina was in power. In light of this, the number of unemployed people in the country has risen to 27.3 lakh, which was up by 330,000 from 24 lakh in the same quarter of the previous year. While the Yunus regime attempted to stabilise the country's economy after Hasina, it still wasn't able to reduce unemployment rates, which affects the future of students who brought him to power in the first place. Hopes for the future Is the Awami League waiting for the return of Sheikh Hasina? Are the party cadre and leaders hopeful of her return? The Awami functionary told Firstpost in May that the party workers know Hasina's return wouldn't be easy. There are challenges, he said. 'The prosecutor pursuing the trial against Hasina and other Awami leaders at the International Crimes Tribunal [Bangladesh] is biased towards Jamaat,' he told Firstpost. 'While Hasina will get full party support with 20-25 lakh party workers standing beside her in Bangladesh, she can return systematically if the country's army ensures her security,' he said, demanding that the Army should ensure that all political groups in the country 'get a level-playing field' before an election is held. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD While challenges lie ahead for Hasina's return, her supporters hope that one day she will come back to her homeland. Yunus-backers also wait for her return but for prosecuting her for what they 'crimes against humanity'. Hasina supporters and a struggling Awami League, however, still has hopes for another turn of history, some time in future.
New Indian Express
3 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
Regionalism dictates BJP stance on nuns' arrest
The discourse around the recent arrest of two Kerala nuns on charges of human trafficking and forced religious conversion, and the subsequent bail granted by court, has revealed the implicit political compulsions of the BJP in the two states – Chhattisgarh and Kerala. While experts cited regional political dynamics as a plausible cause of the Chhattisgarh BJP camp's defense of the nuns' arrest, the party's Kerala unit may have seen it as a chance to mend fences with influential Church leaders. Kerala BJP rushed to intervene, with the state party chief welcoming the nuns as they walked out of Durg jail. The episode sent ripples in Kerala politics, as leaders from every political party was seen rushing to Chhattisgarh last week. 'Zero defect' target in aluminium production A flagship quality transformation initiative titled 'Quality Sankalp' by the Bharat Aluminium Company Limited (Balco) has set a target to achieve 'zero defect' across its diverse product portfolio. The unique monthly initiative engages over 300 employees and business partners across multiple units to foster a culture of shared accountability for quality within the Balco plant in Korba district. From raw material selection to final product inspection, rigorous quality checks are being systematically enforced. Raw materials undergo detailed scrutiny and extensive quality checks at each stage upholds product integrity.
