Republican senate tax bill would add $3.3 trillion to the US debt load, CBO says
WASHINGTON (AP) — The changes made to President Donald Trump's big tax bill in the Senate would pile trillions onto the nation's debt load while resulting in even steeper losses in health care coverage, the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office said in a new analysis, adding to the challenges for Republicans as they try to muscle the bill to passage.
The CBO estimates the Senate bill would increase the deficit by nearly $3.3 trillion from 2025 to 2034, a nearly $1 trillion increase over the House-passed bill, which CBO has projected would add $2.4 to the debt over a decade.
The analysis also found that 11.8 million more Americans would become uninsured by 2034 if the bill became law, an increase over the scoring for the House-passed version of the bill, which predicts 10.9 million more people would be without health coverage.
The stark numbers are yet another obstacle for Republican leaders as they labor to pass Trump's bill by his self-imposed July 4th deadline.
Even before the CBO's estimate, Republicans were at odds over the contours of the legislation, with some resisting the cost-saving proposals to reduce spending on Medicaid and food aid programs even as other Republicans say those proposals don't go far enough. Republicans are slashing the programs as a way to help cover the cost of extending some $3.8 trillion in Trump tax breaks put in place during his first term.
The push-pull was on vivid display Saturday night as a routine procedural vote to take up the legislation in the Senate was held open for hours as Vice President JD Vance and Republican leaders met with several holdouts. The bill ultimately advanced in a 51-49 vote, but the path ahead is fraught, with voting on amendments still to come.
Still, many Republicans are disputing the CBO estimates and the reliability of the office's work. To hoist the bill to passage, they are using a different budget baseline that assumes the Trump tax cuts expiring in December have already been extended, essentially making them cost-free in the budget.
The CBO on Saturday released a separate analysis of the GOP's preferred approach that found the Senate bill would reduce deficits by about $500 billion.
Democrats and economists decry the GOP's approach as 'magic math' that obscures the true costs of the GOP tax breaks.
In addition, Democrats note that under the traditional scoring system, the Republican bill bill would violate the Senate's 'Byrd Rule' that forbids the legislation from increasing deficits after 10 years.
In a Sunday letter to Oregon Sen. Jeff Merkley, the top Democrat on the Senate Budget Committee, CBO Director Phillip Swagel said the office estimates that the Finance Committee's portion of the bill, also known as Title VII, 'increases the deficits in years after 2034' under traditional scoring.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
44 minutes ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Celebrating Canada Day — and doing your part
Opinion Tomorrow's a good day to count your blessings for being in Canada. At the core of it all? It's good to be in a country that believes in the rule of law. That is the foundation of a nation, and a foundation Canada is widely respected for having. Judges are not picked for their fealty to particular politicians or parties — we don't have a Republican Supreme Court of Canada or a Democrat Supreme Court. Independent commissions pick justices at all levels for their legal skills and experience, and politicians appoint candidates from lists the commissions recommend. Russell Wangersky / Free Press Happy Canada Day (Though appointments sometimes skew toward eminently qualified jurists who may also have had histories with one political party or another.) Federal electoral ridings are, likewise, chosen by an independent agency, Elections Canada, which also ensures elections are held in the same manner and with the same rules in every province and territory in the country. Independent groups set electoral boundaries, so gerrymandering doesn't take place. Our prime minister cannot simply issue executive order-style edicts based on their personal whim. Politicians are not above the law. In other words, we have robust protections in the courts and in our political system to ensure power remains with the people and their democratically elected politicians. And there's more. We are a comparatively wealthy country that ranks highly in indexes that measure happiness — though, ranked as the world's 18th happiest population, we have slid a fair distance down from 2015's fifth place overall. (Much of the decline is owing to poor scores from Canadians under 30 and those in marginalized communities.) But even that is at risk, especially when we decide to pronounce over and over again that 'Canada is broken.' Repeat something often enough, and people tend to believe that it's true — even when it isn't, and even when they may not have any experience of what 'broken' really feels like. Ask those who come from a truly broken country what their life experiences are, and you might find they would be more than willing to swap countries with you in an instant. Canada may well be a country that, like many others, has serious issues. Issues that can, and should, be addressed. Crime, housing and health care are all pressing problems that require our attention, for certain. But Canadians aren't grabbed off the streets by faceless, masked militias. Doors aren't kicked in for warrantless searches. Weekday Mornings A quick glance at the news for the upcoming day. And if you truly believe that Canada is flawed, you can do your part to make it better. It is, in fact, your job to help to make it better. Citizenship isn't meant to be a comfortable recliner or a spectator sport. You can take part in our democracy: vote, campaign for politicians you support, even run for office yourself if you feel you have something to offer other Canadians. Working together, living together, enjoying the things that make us a community and a nation, helping those among us who need our help. But don't simply complain and expect a politician — of any stripe — will magically make things better for you. They may echo your complaints to get your votes, but without the benefit of a clear and functional plan, they're merely demonstrating the old adage that misery loves company. What we need is something we saw a flicker of when U.S. President Donald Trump began to threaten us with annexation, and directly harm us with tariffs — we saw the willingness of Canadians to band together, to be united as a country, to set goals and to be willing to make sacrifices. Unity is refreshing after experiencing a long dose of the politics of alienation. Make a better Canada. Be a better Canadian. And enjoy tomorrow … together.
Toronto Star
an hour ago
- Toronto Star
Israel's strike on Iran's Evin prison sparks fear for political prisoners
BEIRUT (AP) — Sayeh Seydal, a jailed Iranian dissident, narrowly escaped death when Israeli missiles struck Tehran's Evin Prison, where she was imprisoned. She had just stepped out of the prison's clinic, moments before it was destroyed in the blasts. The June 23 strikes on Iran's most notorious prison for political dissidents killed at least 71 people, including staff, soldiers, visiting family members and people living nearby, Iranian judiciary spokesman Asghar Jahangir said Sunday. In the ensuing chaos, authorities transferred Seydal and others to prisons outside of Tehran — overcrowded facilities, known for their harsh conditions.
Winnipeg Free Press
an hour ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Women can be drafted into the Danish military as Russian aggression and military investment grows
HOVELTE, Denmark (AP) — Peering across a dense stretch of woodland outside of Denmark's capital with camouflage paint smeared across her face, 20-year-old Katrine scans the horizon for approaching threats. After nearly four months of military training, the young soldier and the rest of her unit spent early June completing their final exercises near the Danish army's barracks in Hovelte, 25 kilometers (15 miles) north of Copenhagen. Katrine and other female soldiers, all of whom spoke to The Associated Press on June 11 on the condition that only their first names be used because of operational security, volunteered for military service earlier this year. Until now, that was the only way for women to be part of the armed forces. The Scandinavian country is seeking to increase the number of young people in the military by extending compulsory enlistment to women for the first time. Men and women can both still volunteer, and the remaining places will be filled by a gender-neutral draft lottery. 'In the situation the world is in now, it's needed,' Katrine said. 'I think it's only fair and right that women participate equally with men.' Under new rules passed by Denmark's parliament earlier in June, Danish women who turn 18 after Tuesday will be entered into the lottery system, on equal footing with their male compatriots. The change comes against a backdrop of Russian aggression and growing military investment across NATO countries. Russia's looming threat Even from the relative safety of Denmark, Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine casts its shadow. Lessons from the Ukrainian battlefields have even filtered down into their training. 'That makes it very real,' Katrine said. Denmark's gender-parity reforms were originally outlined in 2024 as part of a major defense agreement. The program was originally expected to be implemented by early 2027, but has been brought forward to summer 2025. Col. Kenneth Strøm, head of the conscription program, told AP the move is based on 'the current security situation.' 'They could take part in NATO collective deterrence,' Strøm added. 'Raising the number of conscripts, that would simply lead to more combat power.' Denmark, a nation of 6 million people, has about 9,000 professional troops. The new arrangement is expected to bring up to 6,500 annual conscripts by 2033, up from 4,700 last year. Under Danish law, all physically fit men over age 18 are called up for military service. But because there are usually enough volunteers, there's a lottery system so not all young men serve. Women, by contrast, could only volunteer previously, making up roughly a quarter of 2024's cohort. 'Some will probably be very disappointed being chosen to go into the military,' Anne Sofie, part of Katrine's cohort of volunteers, said of the new female conscripts. 'Some will probably be surprised and like it a lot more than they think they would.' The duration of service is also being extended from four to 11 months. Conscripts will first spend five months in basic training, followed by six months of operational service, plus additional lessons. Military buildup The move is part of a broader military buildup by the Nordic nation. Monday Mornings The latest local business news and a lookahead to the coming week. In February, Denmark's government announced plans to bolster its military by setting up a $7 billion fund that it said would raise the country's defense spending to more than 3% of gross domestic product this year. Parts of the conscript program are being financed by the so-called Acceleration Fund. 'We see a sharpened security situation in Europe. We have the ongoing conflict in Ukraine. We have focus on the Baltic countries, where Denmark is contributing a lot of soldiers. So, I think it's a general effort to strengthen the Danish defense,' said researcher Rikke Haugegaard from the Royal Danish Defense College. But Haugegaard notes there are many challenges, from ill-fitting equipment and a lack of additional barracks, to potential cases of sexual harassment. 'For the next year or two, we will be building a lot of new buildings to accommodate all these people. So, it will be a gradual process,' she added. In 2017, neighboring Sweden instituted a military draft for both men and women after its government spoke of a deteriorating security environment in Europe. Norway introduced its own law applying military conscription to both sexes in 2013.
