Sex-abuse priest's promotion draws attacks on Catholic Church
Victim support groups and traditionalists have expressed outrage over the case of Dominique Spina, who was found guilty of raping a 16-year-old boy in 2006 and sentenced to five years in prison.
The archbishop of Toulouse, Guy de Kerimel, set off the controversy in June when he named Spina as diocesan chancellor, putting him in charge of archives.
The canonical code lays down that the chancellor must be "of honest reputation and above all suspicion."
Kerimel said he had acted out of "mercy" in making the appointment and that he had "nothing to reproach" the priest for in an "administrative function."
In a statement released Thursday in the face of mounting protests, Kerimel acknowledged the "incomprehension" and "questions" among Catholics but said again that without "mercy" Spina risked a "social death."
"This is in no way about downplaying a crime" and the victim must be "recognized and helped," he insisted.
Because of the sensitivity of the topic, Catholic leaders have been reluctant to speak publicly, but one bishop said, on condition of anonymity, that the appointment was "a great shame" for the Church.
"A priest convicted of serious sexual acts cannot hold a position of responsibility again. We should be able to say that," the bishop added.
In a joint statement, several groups of victims of sexual abuse in Catholic schools expressed their "deep indignation" and "anger" at the appointment.
The Catholic media has also lambasted the appointment.
La Croix, a Catholic daily newspaper, said that "the principle of mercy cannot be used as a hasty justification."
The traditionalist website Riposte Catholique called the appointment "unjustifiable" and said the Vatican should intervene.
"Compassion does not consist of rehabilitating a condemned man to a canonical position," commented the christian website Tribune Chretienne, known for its conservative line.
France's Catholic Church is already reeling from several sexual scandals in schools it runs and accusations of longtime sexual abuse made against Abbe Pierre, once an icon of the defense of the poor who died in 2007.
The Church has set up two commissions on acknowledging and compensating for the widespread abuses uncovered by an independent inquiry released in 2021.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NHK
21 hours ago
- NHK
China seeks to maintain ties with EU amid rising US trade pressure
China is seeking to maintain stable relations with the European Union. The efforts are believed to be part of its strategy to prepare for a prolonged confrontation with Washington, as the United States ramps up pressure on its trading partners. Chinese President Xi Jinping met with European Council President Antonio Costa and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen in Beijing on Thursday. Xi said, "The more complex and challenging the international situation becomes, the more China and Europe need to strengthen communication, enhance mutual trust, and deepen cooperation, so as to contribute greater stability and certainty to the world through a steady and healthy China-Europe relationship." Von der Leyen said that in terms of total trade, the EU is China's largest trading partner, while China is the bloc's third. She added, "Europe has supported China's economic development for decades and continues to do so." But she noted that as cooperation has grown, so have imbalances, adding that it is vital for both sides to acknowledge each other's concerns. China and Europe are both dealing with the impact of US President Donald Trump's trade policies. China's deadline to reach a trade agreement is approaching on August 12. Chinese negotiators are expected to meet with US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent early next week in Stockholm. Bessent told Bloomberg TV on Wednesday that the Trump administration could extend the deadline by another 90 days.
Nikkei Asia
2 days ago
- Nikkei Asia
With eye on China, Quad aims to expand regional cooperation
Quad foreign ministers pose before the start of their meeting in Washington on July 1. © Reuters KIRAN SHARMA NEW DELHI -- The Quad, often seen as a counterweight to China's growing assertiveness in the Indo-Pacific, is seeking to expand regional cooperation through trilateral partnerships, even as expanded membership remains a distant prospect. The group, consisting of the U.S., Japan, India and Australia, is looking into working with members of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations and other like-minded nations, with one idea being India-France-Indonesia cooperation, Noriaki Abe, an official in charge of political affairs at the Japanese Embassy in New Delhi, told Nikkei Asia on the sidelines of an event on July 10.
Japan Times
2 days ago
- Japan Times
U.S.-funded contraceptives for poor nations to be burned in France: sources
U.S.-funded contraceptives worth nearly $10 million are being sent to France from Belgium to be incinerated after Washington rejected offers from the United Nations and family planning organizations to buy or ship the supplies to poor nations, according to two sources. A spokesperson for the U.S. State Department confirmed on Wednesday that a decision had been taken to destroy the stock. The supplies have been stuck for months in a warehouse in Geel, a city in the Belgian province of Antwerp, following U.S. President Donald Trump's decision to freeze U.S. foreign aid in January. They comprise contraceptive implants and pills as well as intrauterine devices to help prevent unwanted pregnancies, according to seven sources and a screenshot shared by an eighth source confirming the planned destruction. The U.S. government will spend $167,000 to incinerate the stocks at a facility in France that handles medical waste, the U.S. State Department confirmed. The spokesperson said that a preliminary decision had been made to destroy certain products from terminated U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) contracts. "Only a limited number of commodities have been approved for disposal," the spokesperson said via email, adding that no condoms or HIV medications would be destroyed. U.S. lawmakers have introduced two bills this month to prevent the destruction of the supplies following Trump's decision to shut down USAID, but aid groups say the bills are unlikely to be passed in time to stop the incineration. The Belgian foreign ministry said Brussels had held talks with U.S. authorities and "explored all possible options to prevent the destruction, including temporary relocation." "Despite these efforts, and with full respect for our partners, no viable alternative could be secured. Nevertheless, Belgium continues to actively seek solutions to avoid this regrettable outcome," it said in a statement on Tuesday. "Sexual and reproductive health must not be subject to ideological constraints," it added. The supplies, worth $9.7 million, are due to expire between April 2027 and September 2031, according to an internal document listing the warehouse stocks and verified by three sources. Sarah Shaw, Associate Director of Advocacy at MSI Reproductive Choices, said the nongovernmental organization had volunteered to pay for the supplies to be repackaged without USAID branding and shipped to countries in need, but the offer was declined by the U.S. government. "MSI offered to pay for repackaging, shipping and import duties but they were not open to that. ... We were told that the U.S. government would only sell the supplies at the full market value," said Shaw. She did not elaborate on how much the NGO was prepared to pay, but said she felt the rejection was based on the Trump's administration's more restrictive stance on abortion and family planning. "This is clearly not about saving money. It feels more like an ideological assault on reproductive rights, and one that is already harming women." She added that many countries in sub-Saharan Africa had relied on USAID for access to contraception and that the aid cuts would lead to a rise in unsafe abortions. The United Nations' sexual and reproductive health agency, UNFPA, also offered to buy the contraceptives outright, three sources said, without disclosing the financial terms of the proposal. However, negotiations broke down, a source with knowledge of the talks said, in part due to a lack of response from the U.S. government. UNFPA declined to comment. One of the sources with knowledge of the issue said that the Trump administration was acting in accordance with the Mexico City Policy, an anti-abortion pact in which Trump reinstated U.S. participation in January. The pact forbids the U.S. government from contributing to or working with organizations providing funding or supplies that offer access to abortions. The source said there was no way for the U.S. government to ensure that UNFPA would not share the contraceptives with groups offering abortions, violating the Mexico City Policy. The State Department also said these were factors in their decision on Wednesday, and added that it had avoided $34.1 million in costs by cancelling other orders placed under the administration of former U.S. President Joe Biden. The source also said the matter was complicated by the fact that the contraceptives in Belgium were embossed with the USAID trademark and Washington did not want any USAID-branded supplies to be rerouted elsewhere. UNFPA did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the concerns raised by the source. One of the two sources who revealed that the stocks of contraceptives were being trucked to France said it would likely take dozens of truckloads and at least two weeks to move the supplies out of the Geel warehouse, with a third source also confirming the scale of the operation. The French government did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Chemonics, the contractor managing the supply chain for USAID's family planning program, declined to comment on the plans to destroy the supplies.
