
Humans believe they understand their dogs. Our research gave us pause.
Dog owners don't understand their pet's emotions as well as they think they do.
Clive D.L. Wynne is a professor of psychology and director of the Canine Science Collaboratory at Arizona State University. Holly Molinaro has recently completed her PhD at Arizona State.
Most of us have powerful intuitions about how our dog is feeling — starting with that flag attached to the rear end, the tail. Tail wagging: dog happy. Tail tucked: dog sad or scared. And yet the scientific literature is surprisingly quiet about whether we are actually good at reading a dog's emotions. If people are going to care for dogs, they need to know how their pet is really feeling — so we studied just how well they understand dogs' emotions.
Our work started during the pandemic with one of us, Clive, in Arizona and the other, Holly, in Connecticut. As we struggled to master Zoom, we realized that manipulating video could help us investigate this question.
First, Holly filmed her dog Oliver playing with her father in several situations. Some positive, like giving him a treat …
... and some negative, like showing his nemesis, Saffron.
Holly then edited the videos, so they showed only Oliver against a black backdrop.
The videos were shown to hundreds of people who were asked how Oliver was feeling. A key finding was that people couldn't say how Oliver was feeling without any context.
Holly filmed her (now much-missed) dog Oliver playing with her father, Rich. Some of the time Rich set up situations that would be considered positive; such as playing with Oliver, showing him his leash or giving him a treat. Rich also created negative situations, such as showing Oliver his nemesis in the house, Saffron the cat.
Holly filmed everything, and then, just as Zoom makes it possible to obscure the background, she edited the videos so that viewers only saw Oliver against a black backdrop.
We then showed 400 people these videos and asked them how Oliver was feeling. First, we showed just Oliver on the black background, and then we let people see the same videos with the full context: Oliver, Rich and anything Rich had with him — like a treat or Saffron. No surprise, when given full context, an overwhelming majority of people rated Oliver as happy in positive situations and less happy in negative ones. But in videos without contextual information — no Rich, no leash, no Saffron or anything else — they couldn't tell us how Oliver was feeling.
Story continues below advertisement
Advertisement
This was a shock. Surely people could tell a happy dog from an unhappy one? We delved deeper. Since context seemed so important, what if the context was … wrong?
Holly and her dad (and Oliver!) went back to work. Holly made movies of Rich and Oliver in different scenarios and manipulated some videos to make it appear that Oliver was playing with Rich when the unedited footage was actually of Oliver being reprimanded. In others, Oliver appeared to be responding to a reprimand, when in reality he had been shown his leash which promised a fun walk.
We sent this second survey to 500 people and found that when they saw Rich doing something fun, such as offering Oliver a treat, they responded consistently that Oliver was feeling good, regardless of whether the footage they saw was of Oliver actually reacting to a positive or a negative situation. When people saw Rich doing something a little mean to Oliver, they thought the dog was more sad and anxious, regardless of what Oliver was actually reacting to. Our participants rated how Oliver was feeling based solely on what Rich was doing.
Story continues below advertisement
Advertisement
You might think, 'Okay, well, that's someone else's dog. I surely know my own dog the best.'
Holly showed her dad the edited videos as well. When Rich watched, even he was stumped as to what his dog was really feeling.
'Oh, that video was definitely the one where I showed Oliver some cheese. He loves cheese!'
'Actually, no, Dad. That is the one where he is being shown the cat.'
'Well, then — '
So what is going on here? Are we truly just terrible at understanding if our dog is happy or not?
Can you guess Oliver's emotion?
Happy Sad
The owner is playing with Oliver, asking him to roll over.
Happy Sad
Oliver is being reprimanded, with the owner pointing a finger at him.
Happy Sad
Oliver is facing an enemy – a cat named Saffron.
A pair of studies in Italy a decade ago helps fill out this picture. A team at the Universities of Bari and Trieste put dogs one by one in a wooden box with cameras above them and a window in front. The cameras were trained on the dogs' wagging tails while the researchers presented things to look at through the window. The researchers showed the dogs their owner, an unfamiliar person and an unfamiliar dog. The dogs showed a strong, consistent bias to wag their tails to the right when shown their owner or an unfamiliar human but a left bias toward the unfamiliar dog, indicating that dogs' wagging tails show their emotional state not simply by how much they wag them but also the side of the body they wag their tails toward.
This likely is connected to how the left side of the brain is more specialized for approach and the right side for withdrawal. In the dog these signals cross over on their way from brain to tail, leading to more rightward wagging for something the dog would like to approach and more leftward wagging for something it would rather retreat from. This is a striking finding, because in all the millennia people have been watching dogs and writing about them, nobody had ever noticed that the direction a tail wags makes any difference.
While humans may be blind to this aspect of emotional expression in dogs, our canine friends certainly notice. In a follow-up study, the researchers connected dogs to heart rate monitors and showed them videos of other dogs wagging their tails. If the dogs saw a left-wagging tail, their heart rate revealed they were more anxious than when they watched a right-wagging tail.
People and dogs have been living together for more than 15,000 years. In that time, what have we learned? Our study along with the research from Italy, shows that, despite intense intuitions, people are poor at recognizing the emotional state of dogs. Instead, we look at everything around the dog to guess what our pet must be feeling but fail to look closely at the animal itself.
This might not seem so surprising. After all, we don't have tails to wag, and we don't sniff our friends' backsides to learn how they're feeling. But it's crucial to the success of our lives together because the world we share with our dogs has changed dramatically over recent decades. Our dogs no longer live in kennels in the backyard, as their great-grandparents did. More than three-quarters of dogs in America today curl up each night in bed with people who consider them family members. Highly trained hounds console patients in hospitals, and there are even churches that involve dogs as part of their ministry. This increased intimacy requires us to accurately gauge our dogs' moods.
Story continues below advertisement
Advertisement
Meanwhile, at the other end of the leash, several studies have shown that dogs are remarkably good at recognizing human emotional expressions. They can tell what emotion a human face is showing or respond with empathetic concern to a weeping person. Where our comprehension of dogs' emotions is so weak, their understanding of us is remarkably strong.
We need to confront our biases and be more modest in our assessment of canine emotions. We have to recognize that it isn't easy to know how a dog is feeling, but with careful attention to each individual dog we might be able to learn what their happiness looks like.
Post Opinions wants to know: How did your relationship with your dog evolve over time? Share your responses and they might be published as letters to the editor.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CBS News
7 minutes ago
- CBS News
Chinese research ship detected off Alaskan coast, Coast Guard says
A China-flagged research vessel was detected Friday off the coast of Alaska, the U.S. Coast Guard said. The Coast Guard reported Saturday that the Xue Long 2, an icebreaker, was detected about 290 nautical miles north of Utqiagvik, Alaska, in the U.S. Arctic. The Xue Long 2 is operated by China's Polar Research Institute. The ship was in the U.S.'s Extended Continental Shelf, or ECS, which is a portion of the continental shelf that goes beyond 200 miles nautical miles off the coast, according to the State Department. The ship was determined to be 130 nautical miles inside the ECS. "The U.S. has exclusive rights to conserve and manage the living and non-living resources of its ECS," the Coast Guard said in its news release. A Coast Guard C-130J Hercules, a long-range surveillance aircraft, responded to the ship. The Coast Guard also released a photo of the vessel. "The U.S. Coast Guard, alongside partners and other agencies, vigilantly monitors and responds to foreign government vessel activity in and near U.S. waters to secure territorial integrity and defend sovereign interests against malign state activity," said Rear Adm. Bob Little, commander of the U.S. Coast Guard Arctic District, in a statement. CBS News reached out the Coast Guard for clarification on how it was dealing with the vessel. Earlier this week, Canada's CBC News reported that the Canadian military was monitoring the movements of the Xue Long 2 in the Arctic. In a statement provided to the CBC Tuesday, Maj. Alexander Naraine, a spokesperson for the military's joint operations centre said that the Xue Long 2 was "not currently in Canadian territorial waters." Canada was using a Lockheed CP-140 Aurora aircraft based out of Alaska to "actively" monitor the Chinese ship, Naraine said. This comes after four Russian military planes were spotted and tracked flying near the Alaskan coast Tuesday by North American Aerospace Defense Command. The aircraft flew through a section of international airspace called the Alaskan Air Defense Identification Zone. While the Alaska ADIZ is considered part of international airspace, it is defined as an area where sovereign U.S. airspace ends but "that requires the ready identification of all aircraft in the interest of national security," according to NORAD. In January, American and Canadian fighter jets were scrambled after Russian warplanes were also spotted in the Arctic, NORAD said. The Russian warplanes remained in international airspace. And in July 2024, the U.S. intercepted several Chinese or Russian bombers near the Alaskan coast. At the time, a U.S. defense officials said it marked the first time ever that Russian and Chinese aircraft have jointly entered the Alaska ADIZ, and the first time Chinese H-6s have encroached off Watson, Emily Mae Czachor and Stephen Smith contributed to this report.
Yahoo
35 minutes ago
- Yahoo
‘Star Trek: Starfleet Academy' Debuts Hopeful First Trailer With Holly Hunter and Paul Giamatti
'Star Trek: Starfleet Academy,' the newest series in the nearly 60-year-old franchise, warped into San Diego Comic-Con on Saturday with an introduction of its full cast and the first trailer for the show, which will debut in early 2026. The series takes place in the 32nd century after the events of 'Star Trek: Discovery,' with Starfleet relaunching the titular educational institution outside of San Francisco after the Federation's absence on Earth for more than 120 years. More from Variety 'American Dad' Producers on No Longer Getting to Swear as They Return to Fox; Upcoming Guest Stars Include RuPaul, Chris Pine 'The Simpsons' Upcoming Guests Include Kieran Culkin, Viola Davis, Idris Elba; Matt Groening on How to Liberate Parents from MAGA: 'Delete Fox News' 'Star Trek: Strange New Worlds' Teases Puppet Episode for Season 4 'We look at the generation now that is inheriting all of this division and all these major issues,' executive producer Alex Kurtzman said on the Hall H stage. 'We wanted to create a show that anchored us back to [Gene] Rodneyberry's essential vision of hope. How do you find it, how do you rebuild it?' Oscar-winner Holly Hunter plays Nahla Ake, the school's chancellor and the captain of the USS Athena; she greets the new class of cadets in the teaser, as it cuts to the cast exploring various parts of the campus. The teaser ends with a shot of Paul Giamatti as the season's main villain, Nus Braka, who is part-Klingon, part-Tellarite and is described in a Paramount release as 'a man with an ominous past connected to one of our cadets.' The main cadets on the show were revealed as: • Caleb Mir (Sandro Rosta), 'an orphan with a troubled past, and unlikely Starfleet cadet.'• Jay-Den Kraag (Karim Diané), 'a Klingon cadet who dreams of becoming a medical officer.'• Series Acclimation Mil (Kerrice Brooks), a.k.a. Sam, 'the first of her kind to ever attend Starfleet Academy.'• Darem Reymi (George Hawkins), 'an aspiring captain from a wealthy home world.'• Genesis Lythe (Bella Shepard),' an admiral's daughter determined to make her own name in Starfleet.' Other new characters include Tarima Sadal (Zoë Steiner), 'a Betazoid and daughter of the president of Betazed' and Commander Lura Thok (recurring guest star Gina Yashere), 'a Klingon/Jem'Hadar hybrid who is the chancellor's First Officer and Cadet Master.' Picardo is recurring his 'Star Trek: Voyager' character the Doctor, and Tig Notaro and Oded Fehr are reprising their 'Discovery' roles of Jett Reno and Admiral Vance, respectively. Best of Variety New Movies Out Now in Theaters: What to See This Week 'Harry Potter' TV Show Cast Guide: Who's Who in Hogwarts? Final Emmy Predictions: Talk Series and Scripted Variety - New Blood Looks to Tackle Late Night Staples
Yahoo
35 minutes ago
- Yahoo
‘Star Trek: Starfleet Academy' Introduces a New Next Generation in Comic-Con Teaser
Academy chancellor Holly Hunter welcomes the first batch of new students in more than 100 years in the teaser for the upcoming Paramount+ series At long last, Paramount+ offered a first look at season one of 'Star Trek: Starfleet Academy' on Saturday at San Diego Comic Con (SDCC). 'You're all the first academy class to return to our camps in San Francisco — after more than 120 years,' Holly Hunter as the chancellor of Starfleet Academy tells the group of new students gathered at the James T. Kirk Pavilion. More from TheWrap 'Star Trek: Starfleet Academy' Introduces a New Next Generation in Comic-Con Teaser | Video 'Star Trek: Strange New Worlds' Reveals Captain Pike as a Puppet in Comic-Con Season 4 Teaser Michael Smerconish Thinks Trump Could've Easily Avoided Epstein Storm: 'Here's What He Should Have Said' | Video The 7 Best Sci-Fi Shows on Hulu Right Now 'Some of you are here for your families,' she continues, 'some for yourselves. Together, you are the best and the brightest from across the galaxy.' The students will be asked 'to give more of yourselves than you know you have,' Hunter adds, 'to dream without limitations. Whatever challenges came before today led you to this moment. You're here now, you weave together the future.' 'So go out and seek, explore, boldy go where no one has gone before,' she concludes. The series was ordered in March 2023. The official logline is as follows: 'Under the watchful and demanding eyes of their instructors, they will discover what it takes to become Starfleet officers as they navigate blossoming friendships, explosive rivalries, first loves and a new enemy that threatens both the Academy and the Federation itself.' Sandro Rosta, Kerrice Brooks, Bella Shepard, George Hawkins, Karim Diané and Zoë Steiner star as Academy students. In addition to Hunter, Tig Notaro returns as Jett Reno from 'Star Trek: Discovery' and Robert Picardo returns as the holographic Doctor from 'Star Trek: Voyager'. Oded Fehr and Mary Wiseman are also reprising their 'Discovery' roles as Admiral Vance and Sylvia Tilly. The post 'Star Trek: Starfleet Academy' Introduces a New Next Generation in Comic-Con Teaser | Video appeared first on TheWrap.