Vedanta Group promoters siphoning profits via exclusive HZL supply deal: Viceroy
It alleged that Minova Runaya Pvt. Ltd (MRPL), a 49% promoter-owned entity, has an exclusive contract with HZL for the supply of products including resin capsules, rock bolting systems and wire mesh. Used in mining, these products are typically commoditized and low-margin, but MRPL was selling them at a 30% mark-up to HZL, the short-seller alleged, adding the company does little manufacturing itself. HZL was MRPL's only customer, Viceroy added.
'This company (MRPL) has only one purpose, to buy commoditized products, slap a 30% markup on them, and then sell them to a captured HZL,' the short-seller said in its note, adding that there was 'more to come.'
Between FY21 and FY24, Minova Runaya made an aggregate revenue of ₹ 553 crore with a profit of ₹ 92 crore, the short-seller disclosed citing the company's regulatory filings.
Vedanta has denied all allegations. 'The said short sellers have consistently shared extremely ill-informed 'reports' with misleading information,' a Hindustan Zinc spokesperson said. The latest allegations disregard the 'stringent' governance protocols followed by Hindustan Zinc, the spokesperson said.
Earlier, former Chief Justice of India D.Y. Chandrachud said in a legal opinion to Vedanta that Viceroy's report lacked credibility and is based on dubious credentials. He further said the report contains serious, reputationally damaging allegations.
Shares of Vedanta and HZL had fallen following the publication of Viceroy's first report on 9 July, but have since recovered and not reacted to its subsequent eight reports.
Hindustan Zinc's shares gained 0.82% to close at ₹ 446.9 on the BSE on Wednesday. Vedanta Ltd's shares settled 1.12% higher at ₹ 455.6. The benchmark Sensex closed 0.66% higher.
Viceroy Research has a short position of undisclosed size on the debt of London-based group holding company Vedanta Resources.
While the Vedanta Group holds a 49% stake in MRPL, the remaining 51% stake in the company is held by Minova Minetek, which is a Hyderabad-based manufacturer of mining, quarrying and construction equipment, as per private company data platform Tracxn.
'MRPL has a long-term sales contract with HZL, which provides it with strong revenue visibility,' Crisil Ratings noted in November 2024, when it rated HZL's long-term debt as A- with a stable outlook.
'As per the contract, HZL must procure its entire ground support product requirement from MRPL. This ensures healthy utilisation for the manufacturing capacities of MRPL,' the rating agency had noted.
MRPL was onboarded by Hindustan Zinc as a reliable supplier for ground support after undergoing due screening processes and approvals from the Audit Committee and Board, as per the company spokesperson. The company has developed solutions that meet the unique specifications and standards of Hindustan Zinc's underground mines, they said. Transactions with MRPL were supported by benchmarking by independent firms, they said.
Regarding the lack of MRPL's manufacturing capabilities, Viceroy noted that the company's accounts acknowledge that it manufactured nothing until at least FY24.
"Even then, the only product it manufactured was wire mesh, a product so simple and cheap that a fully automated line can be set up for under ₹ 1 crore,' the short-seller said.
Viceroy also pointed to some discrepancies in the financial statements of MRPL. For instance, income from HZL accounted for 114% of MRPL's revenue in FY24. The same year, MRPL declared ₹ 216 crore of tangible asset sales while only carrying ₹ 66 crore of tangible assets on its balance sheet. These discrepancies were persistently observed in preceding years too.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India.com
an hour ago
- India.com
No Entry For GM Crops, Says New Delhi; India-US Trade Talks Hit A Sacred Wall
New Delhi: Genetically modified (GM) crops will not be crossing India's borders anytime soon, no matter how urgently the United States knocks. As trade negotiations between New Delhi and Washington enter a crucial phase, insiders say one red line is not up for discussion. 'There are things that are not about negotiation. Some things are a matter of principle,' said a senior official close to the development. That principle, sources say, is GM corn and soy. While American negotiators have made agricultural access a central demand, pressing India for a wider entry gate for U.S. farm goods, New Delhi is not blinking, especially on GM imports. Over the years, the issue has mutated from a mere trade disagreement into a symbolic fight over sovereignty, food safety and grassroots politics. The United States Trade Representative (USTR) has repeatedly flagged India's restrictions on GM products, calling them 'non-tariff barriers'. But Indian authorities remain unmoved, largely because of the hardline stance taken by domestic groups closely aligned with the ruling establishment. Last month, the message from Sangh affiliates was if America insists on forcing GM crops into the Indian market, there may be no trade deal at all. Carried in Business Standard, that warning echoed the sentiments of influential groups such as the Bharatiya Kisan Sangh (BKS) and the Swadeshi Jagran Manch (SJM), which have long opposed agricultural concessions to Washington, particularly in sectors like dairy and GM crops. Their argument? Food security. The BKS has often warned that allowing U.S. crops into India, especially without clear labelling or transparency, could sabotage domestic farming ecosystems and compromise health safety standards. On the other hand, the SJM sees this as a direct attack on economic self-reliance. Meanwhile, the clock is ticking. U.S. officials have privately hinted at the urgency of the moment, pointing to a deadline set by President Donald Trump, who is seeking a revival of his trade agenda. Trump has marked August 1 as a red-letter day. If no interim deal is inked by then, India could be hit with reciprocal tariffs, potentially as high as 26 percent. Indian trade negotiators are not indifferent to that pressure. But according to officials involved in the process, the sixth round of talks will only happen in the second half of August after Trump's deadline expires. Any hope for a short-term resolution seems, at best, unrealistic. As one official put it, 'We are not looking at compromise in areas that touch the lives of millions.' In other words, GM corn is off the table. And perhaps, so is the deal, at least for now.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
On the run for 25 years: When law fails to catch up with 800 POs
Mohali: After constituting a special team to crack down on long-standing fugitives, the Mohali Police discovered that it has over 800 proclaimed offenders (POs), many of whom have been evading the law for up to 25 years. In the past 30 days alone, 23 POs were arrested, marking the beginning of an aggressive and focused campaign to bring long-absconding criminals to justice. These POs — accused in cases ranging from cheating, robbery, theft, accidents, assaults, extortion, and fights — either jumped bail or stopped attending court hearings and continued to live normal lives in parts of Punjab, Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, and even abroad. Taking serious note of the backlog, Mohali senior superintendent of police (SSP) Harmandeep Singh Hans constituted a special committee comprising SP (operations), DSP, and ASIs, tasked with identifying, tracking, and apprehending these offenders. "After assuming charge, I reviewed our PO list and realised the urgency to act. We formed a dedicated team to compile data, verify case statuses, and initiate arrests," said SSP Hans. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like No annual fees for life UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo "In just one month, we arrested 23 POs. The drive will continue until we reach our target of 800." SP (detective) Saurav Jindal, heading the data compilation effort, stated that the team worked diligently to track down offenders and initiate the legal process. DSP Naveen Pal Singh Lehal added that several of the arrested individuals were found to have jumped bail, while others were already serving sentences in different cases — in such cases, production warrants were obtained to bring them under trial for pending charges. Some POs, however, fled the country, making their arrest more complex. "During our investigation, we found that fraud accused Preet Brar and his brother Amrit Brar, involved in a Rs 51 lakh cheating case, escaped to Canada. Similarly, Gaurav Kumar, accused in a journalist's murder, is now in Uttar Pradesh, and the wife of Armenia-based gangster Gaurav Padial has also reportedly left for Canada," the DSP added.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Arms seized from ISI-backed gang in Punjab
Arms seized from ISI-backed gang in Punjab AMRITSAR: Amritsar Police intercepted a cache of arms and ammunition and arrested five persons on Sunday. SSP, Amritsar-rural, Maninder Singh, said police have dismantled a major trans-border smuggling network of sophisticated arms and drug money, operated by Pakistan's ISI-backed handlers. Among the seizures are an AK Saiga rifle with two magazines, two Glock 9mm pistols with four magazines, 100 rounds of ammo, and Rs 7.5 lakh in drug money, apart from a car and three mobile phones, police said. The intercepted consignment was intended to be delivered to Nav Pandori, a known associate of gangster Jaggu Bhagwanpuria, indicating a broader terror-gangster nexus, police said. Those arrested have been identified as Jobanjit Singh alias Joban, Gora Singh, Shenshan alias Shahu, Sunny Singh alias Gana, and Jaspreet Singh alias Motu. Preliminary investigation revealed that the accused had direct links to Pakistan-based operatives, said the SSP.
