Informal sperm donation is on the rise in Australia. So are the risks
It's also one that carries huge risks. Without urgent changes, governments are sleepwalking into a public health crisis.
The story of a 32-year-old Melbourne man donating his sperm to 15 women (resulting in 27 half-siblings) highlights the scale of problems associated with informal sperm donation. In Victoria, the limit is a maximum of 10 families, and lower in other states.
It's estimated that as many as 4000 children have been born via informal sperm donation in the past decade, but one private Facebook group that connects informal donors and women says they recorded 692 births in 2022 alone.
Loading
In large part, this practice – where sperm donors and those hoping to conceive connect through informal channels like Facebook or donor apps – is growing in popularity due to the prohibitive costs, wait times and lack of donor diversity available via IVF clinics.
While many sperm donors may be altruistic and have good intentions, anecdotal evidence and research suggests that others are acting unscrupulously – for example, donating in order to have sex with women under the false implication that natural insemination has a higher success rate than IVF or artificial insemination (where sperm is placed into a cup before being injected with a syringe). As The Age previously reported, one woman alleged she was sexually assaulted by an informal donor, while others reported feeling that their vulnerability and desperation for a child was played upon by informal donors, and used as a way to coerce them into sex.
Because of the informal nature of these arrangements, there is little oversight and even less data. But my research suggests these experiences are underreported. Whatever the exact numbers, no woman should have to go through this kind of trauma in the pursuit of parenthood.
While a rapid review has been announced in Victoria, this issue requires in-depth exploration nationwide to understand how many people are choosing informal donation, how many donations have resulted in live births, and how to track donor children.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
5 days ago
- Perth Now
Mysterious illness lands newlywed on honeymoon in ICU
It was supposed to be the trip of a lifetime, but for one Aussie newlywed, it soon became a holiday nightmare. Layton McCann was on his honeymoon with his new wife Whitney in Mexico after spending two weeks in the United States. They arrived in the coastal resort town of Playa Del Carmen but within days their start to married life began to take a turn. Mr McCann begun to experience severe abdominal pain with the couple quickly calling the hotel doctor. The doctor gave Mr McCann something for his pain and then left. Mrs McCann's sister, Bronte Holland, told the DailyMail her sister called the doctor back after 10 minutes as his condition had not improved and he was in intense pain. Layton and Whitney McCann enjoying their honeymoon Credit: Facebook It has ended up in a lengthy hospital stay, ruining their honeymoon. 'They sent him to hospital and he's been there now for nearly two weeks,' she said. The hospital stay showed that Mr McCann had contracted an infection that led to pancreatitis and he was rushed to intensive care - but they're unsure of what caused it. The couple's Mothers flew to Mexico to support the newlyweds the same day Mr McCann was put in an induced coma and placed on a ventilator. The family considered medically evacuating Mr McCann but he was too unstable to travel. 'I'm a nurse and from what my sister's telling me, they're doing a really good job taking care of him. They've been checking his bloods, doing CT scans every day,' Ms Holland said. Layton and Whitney enjoy their honeymoon before disaster struck Credit: Facebook 'My sister's travel insurance also set up a doctor in Australia she can liaise with.' Despite this, Ms Holland said the language barrier added additional stress to an already pressure-filled situation. The couple are facing additional costs for staying on in Mexico, despite health insurance covering Mr McCann's medical bills. 'Everyone's stressed and everyone's a mess,' Ms Holland said. 'It just breaks my heart and I feel so helpless. She's my baby sister and there's just nothing we can do for them. It's awful.' A Go Fund Me page has been set up which you can donate to here.
Sydney Morning Herald
6 days ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Informal sperm donation is on the rise in Australia. So are the risks
The decision to find a sperm donor online and to conceive a child with a donor is a practice that's not only entirely unregulated, but also becoming increasingly common. It's also one that carries huge risks. Without urgent changes, governments are sleepwalking into a public health crisis. The story of a 32-year-old Melbourne man donating his sperm to 15 women (resulting in 27 half-siblings) highlights the scale of problems associated with informal sperm donation. In Victoria, the limit is a maximum of 10 families, and lower in other states. It's estimated that as many as 4000 children have been born via informal sperm donation in the past decade, but one private Facebook group that connects informal donors and women says they recorded 692 births in 2022 alone. Loading In large part, this practice – where sperm donors and those hoping to conceive connect through informal channels like Facebook or donor apps – is growing in popularity due to the prohibitive costs, wait times and lack of donor diversity available via IVF clinics. While many sperm donors may be altruistic and have good intentions, anecdotal evidence and research suggests that others are acting unscrupulously – for example, donating in order to have sex with women under the false implication that natural insemination has a higher success rate than IVF or artificial insemination (where sperm is placed into a cup before being injected with a syringe). As The Age previously reported, one woman alleged she was sexually assaulted by an informal donor, while others reported feeling that their vulnerability and desperation for a child was played upon by informal donors, and used as a way to coerce them into sex. Because of the informal nature of these arrangements, there is little oversight and even less data. But my research suggests these experiences are underreported. Whatever the exact numbers, no woman should have to go through this kind of trauma in the pursuit of parenthood. While a rapid review has been announced in Victoria, this issue requires in-depth exploration nationwide to understand how many people are choosing informal donation, how many donations have resulted in live births, and how to track donor children.
The Age
6 days ago
- The Age
Informal sperm donation is on the rise in Australia. So are the risks
The decision to find a sperm donor online and to conceive a child with a donor is a practice that's not only entirely unregulated, but also becoming increasingly common. It's also one that carries huge risks. Without urgent changes, governments are sleepwalking into a public health crisis. The story of a 32-year-old Melbourne man donating his sperm to 15 women (resulting in 27 half-siblings) highlights the scale of problems associated with informal sperm donation. In Victoria, the limit is a maximum of 10 families, and lower in other states. It's estimated that as many as 4000 children have been born via informal sperm donation in the past decade, but one private Facebook group that connects informal donors and women says they recorded 692 births in 2022 alone. Loading In large part, this practice – where sperm donors and those hoping to conceive connect through informal channels like Facebook or donor apps – is growing in popularity due to the prohibitive costs, wait times and lack of donor diversity available via IVF clinics. While many sperm donors may be altruistic and have good intentions, anecdotal evidence and research suggests that others are acting unscrupulously – for example, donating in order to have sex with women under the false implication that natural insemination has a higher success rate than IVF or artificial insemination (where sperm is placed into a cup before being injected with a syringe). As The Age previously reported, one woman alleged she was sexually assaulted by an informal donor, while others reported feeling that their vulnerability and desperation for a child was played upon by informal donors, and used as a way to coerce them into sex. Because of the informal nature of these arrangements, there is little oversight and even less data. But my research suggests these experiences are underreported. Whatever the exact numbers, no woman should have to go through this kind of trauma in the pursuit of parenthood. While a rapid review has been announced in Victoria, this issue requires in-depth exploration nationwide to understand how many people are choosing informal donation, how many donations have resulted in live births, and how to track donor children.
