logo
Bush-appointed judge torches Trump with 27 exclamation points — and a gumbo recipe — in a ruling against an executive order

Bush-appointed judge torches Trump with 27 exclamation points — and a gumbo recipe — in a ruling against an executive order

Independent27-05-2025
A conservative federal judge has ruled that Donald Trump 's executive order punishing a law firm tied to his political opponents 'must be struck down in its entirety as unconstitutional,' dealing yet another blow to the president's retaliatory campaign against lawyers and legal groups that opposed his agenda.
'Indeed, to rule otherwise would be unfaithful to the judgment and vision of the founding fathers!' wrote Judge Richard Leon in Washington D.C.
Leon's colorful 73-page opinion uses 27 exclamation points — including in the very second sentence — and compares Trump's executive order against the law firm WilmerHale to a gumbo that gives him 'heartburn,' whose recipe he included.
'The cornerstone of the American system of justice is an independent judiciary and an independent bar willing to tackle unpopular cases, however daunting,' wrote Leon, who was appointed by George W. Bush.
'The Founding Fathers knew this! Accordingly, they took pains to enshrine in the Constitution certain rights that would serve as the foundation for that independence,' he added.
But nearly 250 years later, 'several executive orders have been issued directly challenging these rights and that independence' within the last few months, Leon wrote.
Trump's executive orders single out individual firms that worked for prominent Democratic officials or represented causes he opposed while imposing punitive measures on the law firms like banning their employees from federal buildings and stripping their security clearances.
Several firms arranged deals with the Trump administration — including agreeing to perform millions of dollars in pro-bono work — to avoid the president's sanctions.
WilmerHale had previously employed former special counsel Robert Mueller, who returned to the firm after leading the investigation into whether Russia interfered with the 2016 presidential election to boost Trump's chances of winning.
The firm also represented Democrats against Trump's 2020 election challenges, members of Congress seeking his tax records, and inspectors general who sued Trump after they were abruptly terminated at the start of his administration, among others.
In his order on March 27, Trump claimed the firm 'abandoned the profession's highest ideals and abused its pro bono practice to engage in activities that undermine justice and the interests of the United States.'
The order accuses so-called 'Big Law' firms of actions that 'threaten public safety and national security, limit constitutional freedoms, degrade the quality of American elections, or undermine bedrock American principles.'
In his order, Judge Leon slammed the administration for throwing 'a kitchen sink of severe sanctions on WilmerHale for this protected conduct!'
He added: 'Taken together, the provisions constitute a staggering punishment for the firm's protected speech! It both threatens and imposes sanctions and uses other means of coercion to suppress WilmerHale's representation of disfavored causes and clients.'
Leon said Trump's executive order is clearly 'motivated by the president's desire to retaliate against WilmerHale for its protected activity.'
This is 'not a legitimate government interest, and the order's unsupported assertion of national security will not save it!' he wrote.
In a footnote in his ruling, Leon said Trump's executive order is 'akin to a gumbo.'
Sections of the order outlining sanctions against the firm 'are the meaty ingredients—e.g., the Andouille, the okra, the tomatoes, the crab, the oysters,' Leon wrote.
'But it is the roux … which holds everything together,' he added, pointing to the president's justification for attacking the firm.
'A gumbo is served and eaten with all the ingredients together, and so too must the sections of the Order be addressed together,' Leon wrote. 'This gumbo gives the Court heartburn.'
Several federal judges in recent days have struck down similar orders.
Last week, District Judge John Bates, another Bush appointee, blocked a near-identical order targeting the firm Jenner Block after finding it was clear retaliation for the firm's employment of Andrew Weissmann, whom Trump accused of making a career out of 'weaponized government and abuse of power.'
'Like the others in the series, this order … makes no bones about why it chose its target: it picked Jenner because of the causes Jenner champions, the clients Jenner represents and a lawyer Jenner once employed,' Bates wrote.
Another federal judge is currently weighing a decision in a similar case against Trump's order targeting the law firm Susman Godfrey.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Equities dip as earnings weigh; Fed statement on deck
Equities dip as earnings weigh; Fed statement on deck

Reuters

time21 minutes ago

  • Reuters

Equities dip as earnings weigh; Fed statement on deck

NEW YORK, July 29 (Reuters) - The S&P 500 and the Nasdaq retreated from record highs on Tuesday as some corporate earnings disappointed, as investors waded through the latest round of economic data ahead of a Federal Reserve policy statement. A host of Dow components reported earnings, with UnitedHealth (UNH.N), opens new tab, Boeing (BA.N), opens new tab and Merck (MRK.N), opens new tab all trading lower after their quarterly results. Health insurer UnitedHealth fell 5.2% as the biggest drag on the Dow after a disappointing profit forecast, while Boeing lost 3.7% despite reporting a smaller second-quarter loss. Merck shed 2.6% after the drugmaker reported its quarterly results and said it was extending its pause on shipments of HPV vaccine Gardasil to China until at least the end of 2025 due to persistent weakness in demand. "Earnings have been a bit of a mix. Economic data has been somewhat mixed too, but not enough to move the needle in terms of the Fed," said Tim Ghriskey, senior portfolio strategist at Ingalls & Snyder in New York. "The next two days, you have Microsoft, Meta, Apple, Amazon - those are big companies, and they will move markets depending on how the earnings are and how the outlooks are." Earnings from megacaps Meta (META.O), opens new tab, Microsoft (MSFT.O), opens new tab, Amazon (AMZN.O), opens new tab and Apple (AAPL.O), opens new tab are scheduled later this week and are likely to have a strong impact on market direction. The Dow Jones Industrial Average (.DJI), opens new tab fell 228.54 points, or 0.51%, to 44,608.93, the S&P 500 (.SPX), opens new tab lost 17.15 points, or 0.27%, to 6,372.62 and the Nasdaq Composite (.IXIC), opens new tab lost 51.25 points, or 0.24%, to 21,127.34. United Parcel Service (UPS.N), opens new tab shares plunged 9.3% as the package delivery company posted earnings and again declined to issue annual revenue and margin forecasts, deepening concerns that U.S. President Donald Trump's continually changing trade policy is weighing on the company. The Dow Jones Transport average (.DJT), opens new tab fell 2.2% and was on track for its biggest daily percentage decline since late May. Likewise, Whirlpool (WHR.N), opens new tab plummeted more than 12% after the home appliances maker slashed its annual earnings forecast and dividend, as the appliance maker cited pressure from a pull-forward in imports by rivals ahead of Trump's tariffs. With nearly 200 S&P 500 components having reported earnings, 79.7% have topped analyst expectations, according to LSEG data, compared with a 6.3% beat rate over the last four quarters. On the economic front, consumer confidence in July increased more than expected to 97.2. In June, U.S. job openings and hiring, or JOLTS data, had decreased, pointing to a further slowdown in labor market activity. The JOLTS report was the first in a string of data on the labor market this week, culminating in Friday's government payrolls report. The Fed is expected to leave rates unchanged at its policy announcement on Wednesday and traders will closely analyze remarks by Fed Chair Jerome Powell to gauge the timing of any potential rate cuts. The S&P had notched a sixth straight closing record high on Monday, after a U.S.-EU trade deal that halved tariffs to 15% and boosted expectations of more agreements ahead of Trump's August 1 deadline. Trump has also floated a potential "world tariff" of 15% to 20% for non-negotiating countries. Key negotiations between the U.S. and China completed their second day in Stockholm as the world's two leading economies aim to resolve their trade conflict, with Trump saying he was told by Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent that he had a very good meeting with Chinese officials. Declining issues outnumbered advancers by a 1.02-to-1 ratio on the NYSE and by a 1.98-to-1 ratio on the Nasdaq. The S&P 500 posted 32 new 52-week highs and nine new lows, while the Nasdaq Composite recorded 71 new highs and 67 new lows.

Foreign oil companies in Venezuela await US authorizations, sources say
Foreign oil companies in Venezuela await US authorizations, sources say

Reuters

time22 minutes ago

  • Reuters

Foreign oil companies in Venezuela await US authorizations, sources say

HOUSTON, July 29 (Reuters) - About a half dozen foreign partners of Venezuela's state-owned oil company PDVSA are awaiting authorizations from the U.S. Treasury and State departments, following talks last week about fresh licenses to allow them to operate in the sanctioned South American country, according to six company sources. The companies' licenses, including a key one for U.S. oil major Chevron (CVX.N), opens new tab, were revoked by President Donald Trump's administration in March over the Venezuelan government's response to migration issues and what Trump said was its lack of progress toward restoring democracy. Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro said last week that Chevron had informed his government about a fresh authorization to come, and PDVSA began preparations to allocate oil cargoes to its joint-venture partners in coming months, once authorized. But companies including Chevron, Italy's Eni ( opens new tab, Spain's Repsol ( opens new tab, France's Maurel & Prom ( opens new tab and India's Reliance Industries ( opens new tab are still waiting for the licenses, the sources said. Most of the companies are minority stakeholders in key oil and gas projects with PDVSA, while others including Reliance are among Venezuela's largest buyers of oil. In the first quarter this year, before their licenses were canceled, they were responsible for about 40% of the country's total 881,000 barrels per day of exports. Some firms have informed staff and contractors in Venezuela about permits to come, without elaborating on dates or terms, according to two of the sources. Chevron declined to comment specifically on the licenses. The company said it conducts its business globally in compliance with laws and regulations, as well as the U.S. sanctions framework. A spokesperson for Maurel & Prom told Reuters in an email on Tuesday that the firm has not received any license yet. Eni, Repsol, Reliance and PDVSA did not immediately reply to requests for comment. Secretary of State Marco Rubio said on Sunday the U.S. remained firm in its "unwavering support to Venezuela's restoration of democratic order and justice." Rubio had in May blocked a move by U.S. special envoy Richard Grenell to extend the period in which the previous authorizations for oil operations were allowed to wind down. He did not refer to the oil authorizations in Sunday's release. The Treasury Department did not immediately reply to a request for comment on the licenses. A State Department spokesperson said they would not comment about any specific licenses, but the U.S. government would not allow Maduro's administration to profit from the sale of oil. Chevron has not yet instructed tankers' owners or captains to go to Venezuelan waters for an eventual resumption of oil cargoes, while PDVSA's loading schedules do not show any supplies to its joint-venture partners for July, according to shipping documents and sources.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store