AIIMS moves Delhi HC against order allowing minor rape survivor to terminate pregnancy
AIIMS
) on Thursday moved the
Delhi High Court
against an order allowing a 27-week pregnant
minor rape survivor
to
terminate pregnancy
.
A high court single judge on June 30 ordered AIIMS to terminate the 16-year-old girl's pregnancy.
AIIMS, before a bench of Chief Justice D K Upadhyaya and Justice Anish Dayal, argued that terminating her pregnancy would hamper her future
reproductive health
.
The bench asked the mother of the minor girl and chairperson or a member of the
medical board
to remain present at around 2.30 pm when hearing would continue.
The court also remarked that "advising a rape victim to prolong her pregnancy will entail anxiety" which could have a grave impact on her mental health.
Additional solicitor general Aishwarya Bhati, representing AIIMS, said the medical board opined that the girl's health needed to be protected.
"As an officer of the court today I am urging your lordships to be 'parens patriae' of this young girl and protect her. She does not want the child, understandable. We, in AIIMS, will do everything best for the child," he submitted.
On the court's query whether it would be safe to terminate the pregnancy after 34 weeks, Bhati replied in the affirmative.
She, however, underlined the precarious situation right now and the girl's well-being, prompting AIIMS to move court.
Bhati said the girl was 27-week pregnant and the termination of her pregnancy would jeopardise her reproductive life and future chances of conceiving.
Referring to the relevant law, Bhati said pregnancy could be terminated after 24 weeks of gestation period only in two situations - if there is a grave risk to the woman's life or congenital anomalies in the fetus.
AIIMS moved against a single judge's June 30 order allowing the minor sexual assault survivor to terminate her then 26-week pregnancy.
It came on record that the medical board was not in favour of allowing the termination of pregnancy in view of the advanced
gestational age
requiring most likely a cesarean section procedure which could adversely affect the girl's future reproductive health.
The medical board opined that the girl was otherwise physically fit.
The girl and her mother, however, insisted on not continuing with the pregnancy.
She moved the court after the doctors expressed their inability to proceed due to the statutory restrictions provided under the MTP Act, limiting such procedures to 20 weeks in ordinary cases and 24 weeks in certain categories such as rape survivors.
According to the girl's lawyer, the minor was sexually assaulted by a man during Diwali in 2024 but she did not disclose the incident to anyone.
She was again sexually assaulted in March by another person, resulting in her pregnancy, her lawyer said.
She learnt about the pregnancy only when she went to a doctor with her sister and when her family members got to know, she confided in them about the sexual assault, leading to the filing of the FIR.
At the time of the FIR in June, the gestational age exceeded the prescribed 24-week limit.
The police arrested the accused of the March sexual assault incident whereas the man who assaulted her last year is yet to be nabbed, the court was informed.
The single judge in its order recorded judgments, including that of the Supreme Court, in which pregnancy was allowed to be terminated in cases where gestational period exceeded 27 weeks and even of 33 weeks.
The AIIMS doctors, as a result, were ordered to maintain a complete record of the procedure aside from preserving the fetus tissue, which could be required for DNA identification and investigation purposes.
The court further directed the state authorities to bear all the expenses of the medical procedure, the girl's stay at the hospital and the expenditure of post-operative care.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
4 hours ago
- Time of India
Anxiety, depression and sleep meds may increase risk of rare neuro disease
NEW DELHI: Commonly prescribed medications for anxiety, depression and sleep disorders may be associated with a higher risk of developing amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), a progressive and fatal neurological disorder, according to a new study recently published in JAMA Neurology. The study examined the use of anxiolytics (used to relieve anxiety), hypnotics and sedatives (used to aid sleep or calm the body), and antidepressants (which work by altering brain chemistry to improve mood). Researchers found that individuals who were prescribed these medications were more likely to be diagnosed with ALS later in life compared to those who did not take them. Significantly, the study also found that people who used these medications before being diagnosed with ALS had a poorer prognosis, meaning their disease progressed more quickly and survival was shorter. However, experts caution that this finding is based on association, not causation. "These medications are often prescribed for symptoms such as anxiety, sleep disturbances, or depression, which may appear during the early (prodromal) phase of ALS - well before a formal diagnosis," explained Dr M S Panduranga, senior consultant (neurology), Dharamshila Narayana Superspecialty Hospital. "So, the link may reflect early, subtle neurological changes rather than the harmful effect of the drugs themselves." by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 5 Books Warren Buffett Wants You to Read In 2025 Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo The study, conducted in Sweden, analysed nationwide data from over 1,000 ALS patients and more than 5,000 healthy individuals using the Swedish Motor Neuron Disease Quality Registry. The average age of participants was 67.5 years, and just over half (53.1%) were male. Dr Manjari Tripathi, professor and head of neurology at AIIMS, explained that most neuropsychiatric medications act on the brain's inhibitory pathways, which could interfere with motor neuron activity. "There could also be a toxic effect, especially with long-term, consistent use - not just occasional doses," she said. "Motor neuron disease leads to slow but steady progression of muscle weakness," she added. "Patients begin to struggle with everyday tasks - buttoning a shirt, combing their hair, walking. Eventually, they become wheelchair bound. Swallowing and speech become difficult, and muscles visibly shrink." One type of ALS, she noted, was the same condition renowned physicist Stephen Hawking lived with for decades. While the exact timeline between medication use and ALS onset remains unclear, Dr Madhukar Bhardwaj, director and head of neurology, Aakash Healthcare, said that a longer history of psychiatric symptoms and prolonged medication use appears to be associated with increased ALS risk. "In some observational studies, individuals using anxiety or depression medications for more than 10 years showed a stronger link with ALS, especially in younger patients," he said. "It's not yet certain whether this reflects a true biological risk or simply earlier diagnosis due to more medical attention." "While there's no definitive proof that these medications cause ALS, we need to be cautious, especially when prescribing them to individuals with signs of neurological disease," said Dr Anshu Rohatgi, vice-chairperson (neurology), Sir Ganga Ram Hospital. Doctors emphasise that patients should not stop their medications on their own. Instead, they should speak with their healthcare providers if they have concerns.
Time of India
10 hours ago
- Time of India
Drug regulator issues list of 17 drugs which should be flushed down if unused or expired
NEW DELHI: India's top drug regulatory body, Central Drugs Standard Control Organisation (CDSCO), has released a list of 17 drugs which, it says, should be flushed down the sink if lying unused or expired at home. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now This includes fentanyl, Tramadol and several other painkiller drugs and Diazepam which is an anti-anxiety medication. According to the CDSCO, these drugs may be especially harmful and, in some cases, fatal with just one dose if they are used by someone other than the person for whom the medicine was prescribed. If these drugs are kept unwanted, unused or expired, the drug regulatory body says, they should be flushed down the sink or toilet to prevent danger to people and pets in the home. However, for most other medications used commonly by people, the drug regulatory body in its latest guidelines on disposal of unused/expired drugs recommends that scientific disposal is needed to prevent environmental pollution. For that, it suggests the initiation of 'drug take back' initiative that could be led by either the state drug control department or local chemists initially but eventually, the CDSCO recommends, the state govt in coordination with local bodies needs to establish the methodology and facility for the collection of and disposal of unused or expired drugs as per the provision of Biomedical Waste Management Rules. "Initially, state drugs control departments and concerned chemists and druggists' associations may jointly launch 'drug take back' site programme at designated locations, where people can drop expired or unused drugs from their homes and that can be disposed finally by such associations under intimation to concerned state drug licencing authority with the help of registered/licenced external agencies. The CDSCO guideline follows multiple reports and studies that show how unscientific disposal of unused or unexpired drugs is causing environmental pollution, eventually affecting human life. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now A study by led by Dr T Velpandian of AIIMS' ocular pharmacology division that analysed water samples from seven places in Yamuna river, including the entry and exit points, 35 bore wells in Delhi NCR and the water percolating from waste at Ghazipur landfill site in 2018 showed drugs thrown in the waste bins end up in the environment and contribute to the emergence of multi-drug resistant pathogens. The study showed presence of antibiotics and other drugs in the surface water of river Yamuna and in areas adjacent to the Ghazipur landfill. 'The govt move to formulate a guideline on disposal of unused or expired drugs is commendable. We also plan to develop a pamphlet on how to dispose of drugs that will be given to all patients' said Devarat Majumdar, director and chief of pharmacy at Max healthcare.
India Gazette
19 hours ago
- India Gazette
Union Minister L Murugan launches several healthcare initiatives at ESIC Medical College in Chennai
Chennai (Tamil Nadu) [India], July 7 (ANI): Union Minister L Murugan on Monday launched several healthcare initiatives and services under the Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana (PMJAY) and other welfare campaigns at the ESIC Medical College and Hospital in Chennai. The Union Minister reaffirmed the Centre's focus on strengthening healthcare infrastructure across the country and lauded Prime Minister Narendra Modi for several healthcare schemes. After launching the healthcare initiatives, L Murugan said, 'I am pleased to participate in this event and launch several healthcare initiatives dedicated to the welfare of the people. After witnessing the facilities at the college, I could sense the care and commitment of Prime Minister Narendra Modi towards the well-being of workers.' Highlighting the Centre's achievements over the past 11 years, the Minister said, 'Medical colleges and faculty have significantly increased across India. The number of medical seats has risen and will continue to expand in the coming years.' He also said that the government was not only focusing on workers but was also extending support to persons with disabilities. 'The Pradhan Mantri Jan Aushadhi Kendras (Prime Minister's Medical Stores) have been set up to ensure affordable access to quality medicines for all. Our Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, is always concerned about the nation's health. That's why he implemented the Arogya Mandir scheme, Ayushman Bharat, and Jan Aushadhi Kendras,' he said. 'Apart from that, the medical college infrastructure has also increased. 75,000 new MBBS seats have been added. Every district now has a medical college, and the number of medical seats is rising... Before 2014, there were only 7 AIIMS, but in the last 11 years, 15 new AIIMS have been established in the country,' he added. Murugan stressed the importance of preventive healthcare and urged citizens to reduce daily oil consumption by at least 10 per cent to lead healthier lives. 'India's medical infrastructure is growing rapidly, and many more development projects are in the pipeline. Every District should have a medical college,' he stated. Earlier on Sunday, Union Health Minister JP Nadda and Delhi Chief Minister Rekha Gupta distributed appointment letters to 1400 nurses. CM Gupta said that the government is making efforts to tackle the shortage of medical staff and medicines. Rekha Gupta told the reporters, 'It is a matter of great joy that, after many years in the history of the Delhi government, appointment letters for permanent nursing staff have been distributed by the government. F For years, due to a shortage of staff, Delhi's hospitals have been running in a disorganised manner. The government has made significant efforts within its tenure to fill these vacancies, and today, approximately 1,400 nurses have been given appointment letters.'Delhi CM further congratulated the health department and the Health Ministry. (ANI)
