Europe Fractures Over Palestine? Italy's Meloni Rejects France's Recognition Push As ‘Illusion'
Speaking to La Repubblica on Saturday, Meloni said, 'I am very much in favour of the State of Palestine, but I am not in favour of recognising it before its establishment.'
'If something that does not exist is recognised on paper, the problem could appear to be solved when it is not,' she further said.
Her statement has come at a time when France's President Emmanuel Macron is preparing to make what he called a 'historic' declaration at the upcoming United Nations General Assembly in September.
Macron has earlier declared, 'True to its historic commitment to a just and lasting peace in the Middle East, I have decided that France will recognise the State of Palestine.'
The message appeared on both X and Instagram and has since been echoed across international headlines.
France's pivot is more than symbolic. It places one of the EU's core powers squarely in the camp of the 142 nations that already recognise Palestinian statehood, according to an AFP count. This includes major countries across Asia, Africa and Latin America, but it notably excludes the United States, Germany and Italy.
Like Italy, Germany has signalled its hesitation. Berlin made it clear it is not ready to follow Macron's lead, emphasising instead the need to achieve 'long-overdue progress' toward a two-state solution, rather than simply affirming it in principle.
But Macron's announcement has reignited tensions with Israel and the United States, both of which have long opposed unilateral recognition of Palestinian statehood. According to diplomats aligned with Tel Aviv and Washington, the fear is that such moves could sideline negotiations and embolden hardliners.
The backdrop to all this is the historical arc that began in 1947, when the United Nations approved a resolution dividing British-mandated Palestine into two separate entities – one Jewish and one Arab. The next year, Israel declared statehood. The Arab state, meanwhile, has remained caught in limbo, recognised by many, but without defined borders, sovereignty or a unified government.
Meloni's concern is rooted in that unresolved reality. While carefully worded, her message delivered a warning that premature recognition could solidify the illusion of peace without delivering it, leaving both Israelis and Palestinians trapped in the very limbo that generations of diplomacy have failed to escape.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Indian Express
28 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
Trump's claim on Russian crude rubbished
NEW DELHI: US President Donald Trump on Saturday said he had heard about India stopping purchasing Russian crude, adding it would be a good step, a claim the government denied. Trump made the remark after announcing 25% reciprocal tariff on Indian imports, along with additional penalties linked to Russian crude imports. 'I understand that India is no longer going to be buying oil from Russia. That's what I heard, I don't know if that's right or not. That is a good step. We will see what happens,' Trump said. The petroleum ministry, however, clarified that India has not stopped importing Russian crude. A ministry official said Indian oil marketing companies (OMCs) continue to buy Russian oil, with supply decisions based on factors such as price, crude grade, inventories, logistics, and other economic considerations. 'These are long-term oil contracts. It is not so simple to just stop buying overnight,' the official said. The official also emphasised that Indian OMCs do not import crude from Iran or Venezuela — both sanctioned by the US. Russian oil, however, is not sanctioned by the US or the EU. Instead, it is subject to the G7-EU price-cap mechanism, which aims to restrict Russia's revenue while ensuring global oil supplies continue. India has consistently complied with the US-recommended price cap of $60 per barrel on Russian oil. Recently, the EU proposed a lower price cap of $47.6 per barrel, to be enforced from September. The official said India's purchases remain legitimate and fully within international frameworks.
Mint
28 minutes ago
- Mint
Who is Evyatar David? Harrowing Hamas video shows ‘living skeleton' in Gaza, Israel PM Netanyahu slams ‘Nazi-like abuse'
An armed wing of Palestinian militant group Hamas released a video of 24-year-old Evyatar David on Saturday, triggering protests at Tel Aviv's "Hostage Square". The videos were released as ceasefire talks between Israel and Hamas have stalled, and Palestinians in Gaza face a mounting starvation crisis. The videos, released by militant groups Hamas and the Palestinians, showed Israeli hostages Evyatar David and Rom Braslavski in a visibly fragile state. In the 40-second clip, David looked skeletal and weak in a narrow concrete tunnel, for the second night in a row. The undated footage of David is juxtaposed with images of starving Palestinian children. According to the New York Post, Evyatar David was forced to dig a grave by Hamas leaders. In the video, David said he hasn't eaten in days. "This is the grave where I think I am going to be buried," he reportedly said in the video. His family authorised the release of this harrowing footage. David's family, according to the New York Post, said in a statement sent to the Hostages Families Forum Headquarters, 'We are forced to witness our beloved son and brother, Evyatar David, deliberately and cynically starved in Hamas's tunnels in Gaza — a living skeleton, buried alive." "Hamas is using our son as a live experiment in a vile hunger campaign. The deliberate starvation of our son as part of a propaganda campaign is one of the most horrifying acts the world has seen," David's family was quoted by news agency AFP as saying. Demonstrators take part in a protest to demand the immediate release of hostages held in Gaza since the October 7, 2023, attack on Israel by Hamas and to end the war, as a video released by Hamas of hostage Evyatar David is displayed, in Tel Aviv, Israel, August 2, 2025. REUTERS/Ammar Awad NO RESALES. NO ARCHIVES TPX IMAGES OF THE DAY Evyatar David was reportedly abducted, along with his friend Gal Gilboa-Dalal, during the Hamas attack on October 7, 2023. that sparked the Gaza war. Both had been attending the Nova music festival in southern Israel. They were among 44 festival-goers seized. Palestinian militants killed 370. Of the 251 hostages taken during the Hamas attack, 49 are still being held in Gaza, including 27, the Israeli military says, are dead. In late February, Hamas had released a video showing David and Gilboa-Dalal being held inside a vehicle and forced to watch a hostage release ceremony a short distance away, AFP reported. Israeli restrictions on the entry of goods and aid into Gaza have reportedly led to severe shortages of food and other essentials, stoking international demands for a ceasefire. Hamas has included this issue in their hostage videos, warning that the hostages are going hungry alongside their captors and that time is running out for a ceasefire. However, the Israel military has the allegation of "deliberate starvation". On July 23, Israel's Foreign Ministry released a purported video showing 'Hamas about full meals in their tunnels, far from the suffering above and stocked with items not from humanitarian aid.' The appalling video sparked outrage in Israel and across the globe. Thousands flooded the Israeli streets, demanding that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu make a deal for the hostages after Hamas showed footage of the emaciated captive underground. Meanwhile, Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu said he spoke with the families of Hamas hostages Rom Braslavsky and Evyatar David. "I expressed to them my deep shock at the harsh footage published by the Hamas terror organisation. I told them in the clearest way – we are continuing the effort to bring back all the hostages, relentlessly, with determination, and without tire," he said in a post on X. Netanyahu said the "cruelty of Hamas knows no bounds." "While the State of Israel allows the entry of humanitarian aid to the residents of Gaza, Hamas terrorists deliberately starve our hostages, documenting them in a cynical, humiliating, and malicious manner," he added. "They also deliberately starve the residents of the Strip," Netanyahu alleged. "They prevent aid from reaching them, and then lie to the world and conduct a false propaganda campaign against Israel," he said. Netanyahu called on all the countries of the world – stand against this 'Nazi-like abuse. Do not stand by. This is a moral test.'
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
28 minutes ago
- First Post
No change in India's Russian oil import policy despite Trump's sanction threats: Report
India has said it will continue purchasing crude from Russia, despite Trump's remarks that it has stop buying Russian oil, clarifying that there's been no change in its energy policy, says report. read more Indian officials have said that oil refineries will continue purchasing crude from Russia, dismissing claims by US President Donald Trump that New Delhi has halted imports, news agency ANI reported. The clarification comes as Washington prepares to impose fresh sanctions next week on nations maintaining energy ties with Moscow amid the war in Ukraine. Earlier, speaking to reporters on Friday, Trump said he had 'heard' India would stop buying Russian oil—calling it a 'good step'—just days after he accused New Delhi of having deep trade and military ties with the Kremlin. 'Well, I understand India no longer is going to be buying oil from Russia. That's what I heard. I don't know if that's right or not,' he said. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Indian officials: No directive to halt Russian crude However, Indian government sources, cited by ANI and Reuters, rejected Trump's assertion. 'There has been no change in policy. Oil companies make sourcing decisions based on price, quality, logistics, and market conditions. No directive has been issued to stop Russian imports,' an official said. Russia remains a key crude supplier to India India, the world's third-largest oil importer, has become a major buyer of Russian crude since Western sanctions pushed Moscow to offer steep discounts. Between January and June this year, India imported about 1.75 million barrels per day of Russian oil—accounting for 35% of its total crude imports. A government source defended the policy, saying India's purchases had helped stabilise global oil markets. 'Had India not absorbed discounted Russian crude—alongside OPEC+ production cuts—prices could have soared past the 2022 high of $137 a barrel,' the official said. India adheres to G7-EU price cap mechanism Unlike oil from Iran or Venezuela, Russian crude is not directly sanctioned by the US or EU. It is subject to a G7-EU price cap mechanism aimed at curbing Kremlin revenues while maintaining global supply. Indian oil firms have been buying within this price cap, officials said, maintaining that imports are in line with international norms. Trump's latest comments come amid his new executive order imposing 25 per cent tariffs on Indian goods and a warning of penalties for countries importing Russian oil or weapons. He has given an August 8 deadline for Russian President Vladimir Putin to end the war or face further punitive action. Long-term oil contracts still in force, say officials Despite the pressure, two senior Indian officials told The New York Times that state-run refiners had not received any instructions to halt Russian purchases. 'These are long-term oil contracts. It is not so simple to just stop buying overnight,' one official explained. There have been recent reports that Indian refiners such as Indian Oil Corp and Bharat Petroleum paused fresh Russian orders after July discounts narrowed to their lowest levels since sanctions began in 2022. But sources say this was a commercial—not political—decision. Energy policy driven by market logic: MEA At a weekly press briefing, External Affairs Ministry spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal reiterated that India's energy decisions are guided by market factors: 'We take decisions based on price, availability, and the global situation.' Trump slams India's trade barriers, defense ties with Moscow While Trump has often praised India as a 'friend,' he has also criticised its tariffs and defense ties with Russia. 'India has the most strenuous and obnoxious non-monetary trade barriers,' he said, noting that it remains one of Russia's top arms and energy customers. Still, Indian officials insist their oil policy serves both national interests and global market stability—and they are unlikely to back down, at least for now. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
