Controversy brews over Nurul Izzah's ‘silent' efforts for Indian community
It drew criticism from MIC deputy president M Saravanan, who has demanded proof of her efforts to support the community.
Now, the Member of Parliament for Batu, P Prabakaran has offered to mediate by proposing a roundtable to try to resolve the conflict.
Explaining her point, Nurul Izzah said, 'For the longest time, I have chosen to work quietly because I believe in substance before spectacle.'
On Thursday, she insisted that her silence does not equate to inaction. She cited year-long roundtables with economists, civil society groups, and community leaders that developed proposals including technical training hubs, preschool education policies, and entrepreneurship incubators under the upcoming 13th Malaysia Plan (13MP).
However, Saravanan has challenged her claims, demanding proof of concrete outcomes.
'So, we ask Nurul Izzah, if you are indeed working for the community, please start by disclosing what has been done or proposed on the matriculation intake issue. Let the Indian community see for themselves whether your silent efforts have translated into real, visible outcomes,' Saravanan said.
He warned against repeating MIC's past mistake of remaining silent on community demands during BN's rule.
'MIC has submitted an eight-point agenda for the 13th Malaysia Plan, outlining clear and measurable reforms to address long-standing challenges faced by the Indian community,' Saravanan added.
Amid the clash, P Prabakaran has offered to mediate by proposing a roundtable involving the government, opposition, civil society, and Indian community leaders to 'objectively evaluate existing objectives and policies' and form inclusive solutions.
P Prabakaran said finger-pointing was not constructive, and that a more mature approach was required.
'As such, I propose a roundtable be held soon,' he said in a statement yesterday. Prabakaran said, adding that a joint forum could resolve tensions threatening Madani government unity. —July 6, 2025
Main image: Bernama
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Focus Malaysia
31 minutes ago
- Focus Malaysia
Staunch Reformasi activist Ezam wants cops to investigate PMX for power abuse, delaying CJ's appt
IT seems that more former and even present PKR leaders are openly showing their disgruntlement towards their party's president and Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim. Former PKR Youth chief (1990-2007) Datuk Ezam Mohd Nor is the latest to do so by lodging a police report yesterday (July 8) which called on cops to open an investigation paper and arrest PMX over alleged abuse of power in the appointment of the new Chief Justice (CJ). Ezam who has officially joined PAS in Sept 2024 contended that such action was necessary to avert a crisis involving an important national institution, namely the judiciary, with the mastermind holding the PM position. 'We feel that there is a sense of urgency here given there is a case involving the PM in court that has not yet been heard,' HarakahDaily cited him after filing a police report at the Dang Wangi District Police Headquarters (IPD) yesterday (July 7). 'We've reason to believe there's even abuse of power in connection to the PM's case involving a civil suit (on sexual assault) filed by an individual named Yusoff Rawther against him which has been postponed several times. 'This strengthens our belief that action must be taken immediately by the police.' Also present were the Gerakan Pembela Ummah (UMMAH) chairman Mohd Zai Mustafa, Pertubuhan Pribumi Perkasa Malaysia (PERKASA) president Syed Hasan Syed Ali and the Gabungan Mahasiswa Islam Se-Malaysia (GAMIS) president Mohammad Azamuddin Sahar. '180-degree turn of heart' Recall that former PKR deputy president and Pandan MP Datuk Seri Rafizi Ramli had also on yesterday (July 8) led a team of nine PKR MPs (including himself) to break rank from their party by calling for the setting up of a royal commission of inquiry (RCI) to probe allege irregularities in the appointment of senior judges, including the CJ. Elaborating farther, Ezam also insisted that PMX should also be prevented from discharging his PM duties given his presence in office could entail adverse implication to the country by virtue of the severity of his pending lawsuit. 'Anwar had faced a similar case which is abuse of power when he was deputy PM. He was charged with blackmailing witnesses in his sodomy case,' asserted Ezam who was the Parti Rakyat Malaysia (PRM) deputy president prior to joining PAS. That Ezam has openly opposed PMX has raised eyebrows given that the former PMX political secretary during his tenure as deputy PM had fiercely defended PMX by taking to the streets in the Federal capital to protest PMX's sacking by Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad. In his quest to staunchly defend PMX when the latter was jailed at the Sungai Buloh Prison on corruption and sodomy charges, Ezam himself was detained twice for almost three years at the Kamunting Detention Camp and Kajang Prison under the now repealed Internal Security Act (ISA) and Official Secrets Act 1972 (OSA). Aside from yesterday's police report, PAS will be staging a rally in the Federal capital to call for the stepping down of PMX on July 26 . – July 8, 2025 Main image credit: HarakahDaily
Malaysiakini
an hour ago
- Malaysiakini
70 years on, still waiting: Cost of political point-scoring
COMMENT | While politicians continue trading blows, the reality is this: the plight of the Indian community remains not a national priority. What should be a serious, sustained effort to address structural inequality has instead become a game of tit-for-tat rhetoric, where scoring points takes precedence over delivering real, tangible change. The community watches on...
![[UPDATED] AGC: Allegations of irregularities in judicial appointments unfounded, speculative](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fassets.nst.com.my%2Fimages%2Farticles%2FAGC13-6_c87295008fbd4bbc8ef3673828c9caa3_1751943461.jpg&w=3840&q=100)
![[UPDATED] AGC: Allegations of irregularities in judicial appointments unfounded, speculative](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fassets.nst.com.my%2Fassets%2FNST-Logo%402x.png%3Fid%3Db37a17055cb1ffea01f5&w=48&q=75){kind=small}
New Straits Times
2 hours ago
- New Straits Times
[UPDATED] AGC: Allegations of irregularities in judicial appointments unfounded, speculative
KUALA LUMPUR: The Attorney-General's Chambers (AGC) has dismissed allegations of irregularities and delays in judicial appointments, saying that such claims must be assessed within the framework of the Federal Constitution. Responding to public statements made by Datuk Seri Rafizi Ramli and several other PKR members of Parliament yesterday (July 7), the AGC said the prime minister cannot be viewed merely as a conduit for recommendations from any party, as he holds a constitutional responsibility to advise the King on judicial appointments. This duty, the statement said, is essential to safeguard the independence, credibility and integrity of the judiciary. The AGC added that the King had consented to the appointment of several High Court and Court of Appeal judges last month, but that these appointments were still undergoing necessary formalities. "Such appointments must be conducted with proper order and decorum," it said. Addressing claims that a Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) meeting had been convened without sufficient notice, the AGC said that under Section 13(2) of the Judicial Appointments Commission Act 2009 (Act 695), the JAC is empowered to regulate its own procedures. In urgent circumstances, meetings can proceed with short notice if all members agree. "Procedural matters should not invalidate the JAC's deliberations unless there is clear evidence of mala fide intent or prejudice," it added. The AGC also addressed a serious allegation involving a Federal Court judge allegedly influencing judicial decisions and judge reassignments. It said deliberations within the JAC are legally protected and remain confidential, and such claims cannot be equated with proven misconduct or taken as a threat to judicial independence. "These remain premature and purely speculative allegations," it said. The AGC added that comparisons with the 2007 VK Lingam case were unwarranted, as that case involved clear evidence of interference, which led to the formation of a royal commission of inquiry (RCI). "In contrast, the current situation is based merely on unsubstantiated claims," the AGC said. Yesterday (July 7), nine PKR MPs called for an RCI to investigate what they claimed were alleged irregularities in the appointment of senior judges, including the Chief Justice. He claimed that nominations for the positions of Chief Justice and President of the Court of Appeal had already been decided by the JAC before the retirement of Tun Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat and submitted to the prime minister, but the appointments were not made, resulting in the current vacancies. He also claimed a JAC meeting was called last Friday without adhering to the required 10-day notice period, allegedly to renominate candidates for the vacant positions. Led by Pandan MP and former PKR deputy president Rafizi, the group said they would formally request that proceedings and an inquiry be conducted by the Parliamentary Special Select Committee on Human Rights, Elections and Institutional Reform, including top government officials to testify. "The Parliament, as an independent legislative body, must play a key role in safeguarding the independence of the judiciary," he said in a special press conference. Rafizi outlined four issues surrounding the judicial appointment controversy which are now circulating in the public domain that require clarification from the government. This includes that in the appointment of new judges (whether to the High Court, Court of Appeal, or Federal Court), nominations submitted by the JAC to the government were not acted upon in a timely manner, leading to urgent vacancies.
