Judge throws out man's €75,000 defamation claim against Lidl
Enable Ireland
caretaker and bus escort for people with disabilities has lost a damages claim for up to €75,000 for defamation of character against a Dublin
Lidl
store and a security firm.
Eric Swift, of Glenayle Road, Raheny, claimed he was publicly accused by security staff at Lidl in Baldoyle of having not paid for a bottle of wine in May 2023.
Dismissing the claim, Judge Geoffrey Shannon said Mr Swift told the court he had picked up a bottle of wine in the alcohol aisle and put it in his bag, but then changed his mind and put it back on the shelf.
After he had gone to join his wife, Geraldine, who was waiting for him in the car park, he said a uniformed security guard approached him and loudly declared he was required to return to the supermarket on suspicion of theft.
READ MORE
Judge Shannon said Lidl admitted the security guard asked Mr Swift to return to the store, but claimed the request was made discreetly and that the security man had not alleged theft and, regardless, the store was protected by qualified privilege.
Mr Swift told the Circuit Civil Court he went to get a jar of coffee and put one in his bag and paid for it. He then thought his wife would enjoy some wine later and put a bottle in his bag. He sent his wife a text and she replied to say she did not want any alcohol. Mr Swift then put the bottle back on the shelf.
He told the court he had been Garda vetted for his trusted position working with vulnerable people and after having returned to the store, the matter was dealt with in front of a number of other shoppers.
When he showed the contents of his bag and the receipt for the coffee, the manager apologised, he said.
Barrister EJ Walsh, for Lidl, told Mr Swift in cross-examination that the entire situation was an unfortunate misunderstanding that was his fault for not having used a trolley or basket.
The security guard saw him put the wine in his bag but was looking away when he returned it to the shelf.
Security guard Can Uygunyoy, working for RFC Security, said he simply asked Mr Swift if perhaps he had forgotten to pay for something. Part of his training was not to constantly stare at customers despite keeping them under observation and he had not seen him return the bottle to the shelf.
Judge Shannon said he accepted that the evidence of all parties concerned was truthful but found that the balance of credibility lay in the version of events outlined by the defence.
He said shopkeepers had a legal right to protect their property and the court accepted that the remarks made to Mr Swift were protected by qualified privilege, in that they had not been made with malice.
'I believe Mr Uygunyoy acted in the heat of the moment in that delay would obviously have been fatal to his chances of recovery of the wine which he believed had been taken, not having seen Mr Swift return it to the shelf,' he said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Sexual abuse in schools inquiry
Sir, –This week the Minister for Education Helen McEntee announced the establishment of a Commission of Investigation into sexual abuse in all day and boarding schools. I attended Willow Park and Blackrock College as a boarder in the 1960s. Sadly, I experienced many years of physical and mental abuse. It is very disappointing that the dreadful abuse of corporal punishment, suffered by so many in this country, has not been included in this investigation. Any kind of abuse, be it sexual or otherwise, leaves dreadful lifelong scars, and stays with victims for the rest of their lives. – Yours, etc, BRIAN McDEVITT, READ MORE Glenties, Co Donegal.
Irish Times
9 hours ago
- Irish Times
Girl (12) dies after getting into swimming difficulties in Co Tipperary
A 12-year-old girl has died after she got into swimming difficulties in Co Tipperary on Friday afternoon. The incident occurred at a local swimming spot in the village of Newcastle, located close to Ballymacarbry near the Co Waterford border, shortly after 4pm. The swimming area is along the Suir Blueway, and the girl had been swimming with a number of others when the incident occurred. Emergency services and gardaí attended the scene and the girl was transferred to Cork University Hospital (CUH) by the Irish Coast Guard Air and Sea Rescue 117 helicopter, after being recovered from the water at around 4.45pm. READ MORE It is understood that the young girl's family is from Newcastle. In a statement, An Garda Síochána said they and the emergency services attended an incident where 'a female child got into difficulty in the water at River Suir, Newcastle, Co Tipperary at approximately 4.20pm today'. The statement continued: 'She was airlifted by Rescue 117 to Cork University Hospital in a serious condition. She has since passed away.' A file will be prepared for the Coroner's Court. Garda investigations are ongoing.
Irish Times
9 hours ago
- Irish Times
Wife of man being sued by John Magnier over Barne estate row says couple ‘steamrolled' into litigation they could not afford
The wife of a man being sued by John Magnier over the purported sale of a coveted Co Tipperary estate to him has told the High Court the bloodstock billionaire allegedly threatened any sale of Barne estate to anyone other than him, as he claims was agreed, would put the defendants in 'litigation for years' and cost 'millions'. Anna Thomson-Moore, the wife of defendant Richard Thomson-Moore, has told the High Court that the family had to take out a commercial loan in order to fight the case taken by Mr Magnier over the collapse of the alleged deal for the land. Mr Magnier wants the court to enforce a €15 million deal he claims he agreed with Mr Thomson-Moore in a handshake deal for 751 acres of the land in Co Tipperary on August 22nd, 2023, at Mr Magnier's Coolmore home. In her evidence on Friday, Ms Thomson-Moore told defence barrister Martin Hayden SC that on September 7th, 2023 – two weeks after the claimed handshake deal – Mr Magnier called to Barne with his son, JP, and met the Thomson-Moores, who told Mr Magnier they had to work through tax issues and involve the trustees of the estate to complete any deal. READ MORE Ms Thomson-Moore said at the end of that conversation their estate agent, John Stokes, who had walked out with the Magniers, returned to the house with two brown envelopes given to him by JP containing a total of €50,000 in cash about which she felt 'uncomfortable' and told Mr Stokes this. Ms Thomson-Moore told Mr Hayden the money was put in their safe at Barne and that the following morning they decided to return the money as Ms Thomson-Moore was now 'very uncomfortable' with the situation. The Magnier side has told the court the money was a token of 'appreciation' to the Thomson-Moores for letting the Magnier side on to the land before any sale was finalised. John Magnier arriving at the High Court in Dublin in May. Photograph: Collins Courts The Magnier side was ultimately gazumped by Irish-born, US-based construction magnate Maurice Regan, who offered €22.25 million and was made the preferred bidder. Mr Regan is not a party to the case. The Magnier side has sued the Barne estate, Mr Thomson-Moore and three companies of IQEQ (Jersey) Ltd group, seeking to enforce the purported deal, which they say had been 'unequivocally' agreed. The Barne defendants say there was never any such agreement, as they needed the consent of the trustees to finalise any agreement, and subsequently they preferred to sell the estate to Mr Regan. The Barne estate has been held for the benefit of Richard Thomson-Moore and others by a Jersey trust. Mr Magnier claims the deal had been agreed at the kitchen meeting and there had been no mention of it being subject to trustee approval, which he has said to the court on numerous occasions. Ms Thomson-Moore told the High Court on Friday Mr Magnier was told a number of times before the alleged deal that any agreement was subject to the consent of the trustees. Both sides entered into an exclusivity agreement from August 31st to September 30th, 2023, stipulating the estate would not permit itself or its representatives to solicit or encourage any expression of interest, inquiry or offer on the property from anyone other than Mr Magnier. During September 2023, said Ms Thomson-Moore, Mr Regan had offered around €20 million for the estate but the trustees recommended honouring the exclusivity agreement with Mr Magnier. Ms Thomson-Moore said she was 'frustrated' that the trustees were not looking at the higher offer at all. After the expiry of the exclusivity deal, she said there was a 'flurry' of calls in early October 2023, during which time Mr Stokes told the Thomson-Moores Mr Magnier had told the estate agent he would take the matter to court and 'tie this up for years and millions in litigation'. Ms Thomson-Moore said a commercial loan was taken out by the defendants under Barne Estate Ltd to provide liquidity to defend the Magnier action. 'We did not have the means to defend these proceedings without a loan. I think it is important to have access to justice and we were being steamrolled into proceedings because of a lack of cash and it would not be fair. It felt like an onslaught of proceedings that kicked off very quickly,' she told the court. Ms Thomson-Moore, a solicitor, said the stress and impact of the proceedings initiated against them had been 'enormous' and that this had become 'oppressive'. She said it also had delayed the family's plans to move to her native Australia to attend to the health needs of their son, who needs around-the-clock care. The case continues before Mr Justice Max Barrett.
