I grilled Myra Hindley on where final Moors Murders victim is buried… could Brady's chilling secret memoir hold answer?
MOORS MYSTERY I grilled Myra Hindley on where final Moors Murders victim is buried… could Brady's chilling secret memoir hold answer?
FOR 60 years the final resting place of 12-year-old Keith Bennett has remained a mystery - a tragic secret that vile killer Ian Brady took with him to the grave.
Despite multiple searches, his body was never recovered and Keith's heartbroken mother Winnie Johnson died not being able to give her son a proper burial.
Advertisement
13
Ian Brady and Myra Hindley achieved infamy in the 1960s as the Moors murderers after killing five children
Credit: SWNS:South West News Service
13
Twelve-year-old Keith Bennett's body was never recovered
Credit: PA
13
Brady's secret autobiography, along with case files found gathering dust in a solicitor's attic, could provide vital clues to the location of Keith's grave
Credit: BBC
But now, 60 years on, Brady's secret autobiography, along with case files found gathering dust in a solicitor's attic, could provide vital clues to the location of his grave.
Keith was one of five children murdered by Brady and his accomplice Myra Hindley, who buried their bodies on Saddleworth Moor.
Journalist Duncan Staff - who's worked on the case for years and even grilled Hindley in prison to see if she could pinpoint where Keith was buried - has discovered a partial manuscript written by Brady about the murders, along with the original defence case files for the murder trial.
Brady's biographer, Dr Alan Keightley, wrote in his own book that Brady had written a 600 page autobiography called Black Light.
Advertisement
Dr Keightley died in 2023, but his widow Joan handed over his Brady files to Duncan - including his own copy of Black Light.
The manuscript details how they selected the site for Pauline Reade's burial and gives specific information about the location. But it is only 394 pages long and stops the night before John Kilbride's murder -leading Duncan to believe the missing pages could detail Keith's murder and burial site.
He says: 'I think it is incredibly frustrating for the families to know that Ian Brady has written an autobiography, Black Light, that is only surfacing now and the copy we have is incomplete.
"So the pages that describe exactly where Keith Bennett is buried could be out there somewhere.'
Advertisement
In the hours before his death in 2017, Brady asked for locked suitcases to be removed from his cell and handed to his solicitor Robin Makin.
The police and Keith Bennett's family have requested access to the paperwork inside, but this has been denied.
Cops dig for Moors Murder victim Keith Bennett as 'skull' found 58 years after Ian Brady & Myra Hindley killing spree
Duncan says: 'Ian Brady has been allowed to maintain control of this story even in death.
'Brady knew exactly what he was doing. It's absolute madness that the police haven't been able to look inside the suitcases.'
Advertisement
The findings are featured in a new BBC documentary, The Moors Murders: A Search for Justice, alongside the original case files for Hindley and Brady's defence.
One of Brady's solicitors, Benedict Birnberg, died in 2023. His firm told Duncan that any material left with them had been sent to Brady's other solicitor Robin Makin, who also had Brady's suitcases.
The BBC contacted Makin but he has not responded.
Astonishing discovery
13
Ian Brady, right, pictured arriving at the courthouse in Hyde, Cheshire to be convicted of the Moors murders of five children
Credit: 1965 AP
Advertisement
13
Brady's biographer, Dr Alan Keightley, wrote in his own book that Brady had written a 600 page autobiography called Black Light
Credit: Rex
13
Tragically Keith Bennett's mother Winnie Johnson died without ever knowing her son's final resting place
Credit: News Group Newspapers Ltd
Duncan explains how he met Hindley in the 1990s when he started working on the case and quizzed her about her version of events.
"I asked her where Keith Bennett is buried. I never got a clear answer. That's why, if I like it or not, I'm still working on the case all those years later," he says.
Advertisement
'A lot of the paperwork disappeared after the trial of Myra Hindley and Ian Brady.'
Duncan had tried to get access to transcripts from their trial for decades but the CPS told him they had been shredded.
He says: 'When I was told that the original defence case files existed I went to look at the material and I was astonished by what I found.
I asked her where Keith Bennett is buried. I never got a clear answer. That's why, if I like it or not, I'm still working on the case all those years later
Duncan Staff
"Notes written by Myra Hindley and photographs taken by Ian Brady, all put together by the defence team in the 1960s."
Advertisement
It was October 1965 that Saddleworth Moor in Oldham became a grisly household name.
Edward Evans was the last of Hindley and Brady's victims - but the first to be discovered after Hindley's brother-in-law, David Smith, who witnessed the murder, called the police.
Children had been going missing in the area for years - and the investigation into Edward Evans' death would lead police to the abduction and murders of John Kilbride, Lesley Anne Downey, Pauline Reade and Keith Bennett.
Trophy photos taken by Brady of Hindley on the Moors would later help police find the tragic graves of John and Lesley Anne.
Advertisement
Hindley and Brady were charged with three murders - Edward Evans, John Kilbride and Lesley Anne Downey, as the other two bodies had not been found.
They were convicted and sentenced to life sentences with a whole life tariff.
But the case was reopened in 1985 after Brady was reported as having confessed to the murders of Pauline and Keith.
Hindley stopped claiming her innocence in 1987 and confessed to all of the murders.
Advertisement
Brady and Hindley were taken separately to Saddleworth Moor to assist in the search for the graves.
Information provided by Hindley helped police to find Pauline's body. But Keith's still remains on the moors.
Troubling photo
13
A picture of Myra Hindley holding a puppy on a rock in the moor, in a very similar photograph to the one taken on John Kilbride's grave, troubled the team
Credit: BBC
13
Winnie Johnson with her son Joey, then 23, digging on Saddleworth Moor in a bid to find the remains of her son Keith Bennett in 1988
Credit: Alamy
Advertisement
13
Officers from Greater Manchester Police search Saddleworth Moor for the remains of the body of 12-year-old Keith Bennett in 2022
Credit: PA
13
An un-searched gas pipe on Saddleworth Moor
Credit: BBC
Hindley and Brady both maintained that Keith's body had been buried where two streams - Shiny Brook and Hoe Grane - met.
Despite extensive searches by police, and forensic investigators working for the Bennett family, nothing was found.
Advertisement
But Duncan, forensic archaeologist John Hunter and retired detective Martin Slevin now think photos found in the recently discovered case files could be pointing in a different direction.
John says: 'It also means that Brady and Hindley are complete liars and had taken us to the wrong place.'
The team decided to focus on photographs found in the defence case files taken by Brady.
It means that Brady and Hindley are complete liars and had taken us to the wrong place
John Hunter
There is one picture in particular that troubled the team - one of Myra Hindley holding a puppy on a rock in the moor, in a very similar photograph to the one taken on John Kilbride's grave.
Advertisement
In the background is a concrete gas pipe marker - leading the team to question whether this could also be marking Keith's grave.
Retired detective Geoff Knupfer was one of the officers who worked on the case in the 80s. He said he raised the issue at the time.
He says: 'There was a thought that these two children (Pauline and Keith) could have been disposed of in the trench of the pipeline and that enquiries they made would suggest it would be far too expensive to re-excavate it and check.
'I think a decision was taken at some level with the service or Home Office that enough was enough.
Advertisement
"These two people have been convicted of three murders, they have been sentenced to life imprisonment, the likelihood of them ever being released is remote indeed.
"I don't want to criticise former colleagues too much, it is all well and good if it is not your children who are missing or your family involved in it.'
The BBC team brought in modern technology including drones and GPS to the now 60-year-old case.
And the findings cemented their belief that the area around the gas pipe marker warranted further investigation.
Advertisement
Duncan says: 'I believe the police should search the areas that Martin and John have identified, and we are going to hand all the evidence over to them.
"But I don't think they are likely to search without an X marks the spot.'
'Lack of accountability'
13
Moors Murders victims John Kilbride and Pauline Reade
13
Maureen and David Smith - Myra Hindley's sister and brother-in-law - who denounced Hindley and Brady to the police after Edward Evans' murder
Credit: News Group Newspapers Ltd
Advertisement
Martin Slevin and Duncan also trawled through Brady's other materials to find any insight into his way of thinking and hopefully any information that could lead to Keith's grave.
Martin says: 'We have got pretty much his whole music collection here, really eclectic mix. German marching songs, classical music, Snow White and the Seven Dwarves.'
Also included in the haul are press cuttings and media coverage of Hindley and Brady.
Duncan says: 'He's living in the past, it matters to him. The murders mattered to him and possession of Keith Bennett matters to him, and he views himself as a superstar.'
Advertisement
They discovered a copy of Detective Chief Superintendent Peter Topping's book - the man who led the hunt for Keith and Pauline's bodies in the 1980s.
In the chapters when DCS Topping detailed his interviews with Hindley, where she described not being able to hear Brady and Keith on the moors, Brady had made side notes saying: 'You could not keep her away, she enjoyed it.'
Martin says: 'He's clearly saying that she was part, hands-on Keith Bennett's murder [sic]. That is the first time we have had a direct contradiction of that account.'
Brady's living in the past, it matters to him. The murders mattered to him and possession of Keith Bennett matters to him, and he views himself as a superstar
Duncan Staff
Duncan says: 'And that means she was at the burial site.'
Advertisement
Martin adds: 'She would have known exactly where Keith Bennett is buried.'
The police have had Hindley's maps of the area since 2001. But there is no complete record of where they have searched.
Duncan: 'What has struck me about this case is the lack of accountability.
"How no-one can be held responsible because police today can say those decisions were taken back in the Sixties, it was nothing to do with me, therefore I don't need to do anything.
Advertisement
'But for the families there is this constant enduring pain. I think all of them are still impacted by the fact Keith is still missing, no matter which family it is, because they are all intertwined.
"You can't divorce their stories.'
Greater Manchester Police initially told the BBC they were interested to see their findings, but then changed its mind.
In a statement to the BBC, GMP said its investigation remains open and it would 'continue to seek the answers the family deserve and will act upon any credible evidence".
Advertisement
'There have been so many missed opportunities to find Keith, and we can't let this be another one,' says Duncan.
'We have to make sure that everything is done and that every effort is made to get hold of the missing pages of Black Light and to finally remove Ian Brady's control.'
The Moors Murders: A Search for Justice is on BBC Two tonight (Wednesday 30 July). Both episodes are available on iPlayer now.
13
The search for Keith Bennet on Saddleworth Moor in 1992
Credit: BBC
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Glasgow Times
2 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
Murdered mother and children ‘together and finally safe'
Crowds flooded into the Co Clare village of Barefield for the funeral of Vanessa Whyte, 45, and her children James Rutledge, 14, and Sara Rutledge, 13, who died in a shooting at their home in Maguiresbridge, Co Fermanagh. Many of the mourners wore GAA jerseys and bright colours as requested by the family as they lined the main street to watch the three hearses pass by. Vanessa Whyte and her children Sara Rutledge and James Rutledge died following a shooting in Co Fermanagh (Handout/PA) Those in attendance at the funeral at the Church of the Immaculate Conception on Saturday included a representative for the Taoiseach Micheal Martin and GAA president Jarlath Burns. Delivering the eulogy, Ms Whyte's sister Regina said they have been robbed of their loved ones. 'Vanessa, James and Sara were taken from this world in a cruel and vicious manner – there are no words available to express how this has impacted our family and their friends,' she said. 'We as a family have been robbed of both a relationship with our sister and a chance to see James and Sara grow up, and they have been robbed of the remainder of their lives. 'It has taken us 11 days to be in a position to have Vanessa, James and Sara back to Clare. Crowds turned out for the service (Noel Sweeney/PA) 'This was supposed to be a joyous occasion where Vanessa would see her new nephew, and Sara and James would meet their baby cousin for the first time. Instead we are in the position of choosing coffins, final burial places and funeral hymns. 'For us as a family, the only comfort we have is that Vanessa, James and Sara are together and finally safe. 'Vanessa will have her children at either side of her forever, as they were when they were alive.' She described her sister as 'witty, bright, kind and determined', and said James and Sara were the 'focus of her world'. She recalled James's love of the GAA, playing both hurling and football, and also cricket, adding he has been acknowledged as the 'kind, bright, determined teenager we as a family know so well'. 'James's smile was infectious, and his loyalty was strong,' she said. GAA President Jarlath Burns attended the funeral (Noel Sweeney/PA) Sara was remembered as having a deep love for animals, and aspiring to follow in her mother's footsteps to become a vet, as well as loving sport. 'She was an excellent hurler, a footballer and skilled at netball. She was a team player, a quiet leader, and like every sister, never let James away with anything,' she said. Amazing Grace and Somewhere Over The Rainbow were among the music played during the service. Bishop Ger Nash, Bishop of Ferns and a family friend, described heartbreak over the 'tragic and unspeakable loss of three lives with so much to give to the world'. Delivering the homily, he said every story and shared memory since their deaths 'reminds us of the irreplaceable part they played in the lives of their families, their community, their schools, workplaces, teams and clubs'. 'The tragic events of last week, and the ripping away of three people from their family and friends leave us searching for answers and coming back again and again to the only answer that is completely true: 'We don't know',' he said. Members of the St Joseph's Doora-Barefield GAA Club formed part of the guard of honour (Noel Sweeney/PA) He noted messages of condolences for the mother and her children including from neighbours, but also many from those who simply described themselves as 'A Waterford Mammy', 'A Cork Granny', and 'A Wicklow Mother'. 'There were some with both dads and mams mentioned, but there were many where a woman spoke from her own heart,' he said. 'They don't know you, nor you them, but they know your story, and if they hug their teenagers more tightly and call a ceasefire in the perpetual war about tidy rooms, then they have learned that life is precious, and we must be grateful for every day given to us and to those we love. 'Over and over, I could see that women and mothers, as individuals, reached out in their shock and sadness at the loss of a mother and children, but also conscious that there were heartbroken mothers left behind. 'The messages highlighted the vulnerability of women to pain inflicted by others and were signs of solidarity in the face of that pain.' Last week crowds also turned out for Ms Whyte, James and Sara for a service of removal in Maguiresbridge on Wednesday. Agricultural contractor Ian Rutledge, 43, who died on Monday, is understood to be the only suspect in the shooting of his family. Police in Northern Ireland have said a triple murder and attempted suicide was a line of inquiry. Ms Whyte, James and Sara are to be buried together in Templemaley Cemetery later.
Scottish Sun
5 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Migrants blow kisses from hotel window as they film protesters clashing with police on streets below
Protesters shouted 'get these scum off our streets' while waving England flags. HOTEL STAND-OFF Migrants blow kisses from hotel window as they film protesters clashing with police on streets below Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) MIGRANT hotel residents have been spotted laughing while they video protesters and counter-demonstrators clash. People believed to be asylum seekers inside the Thistle City Barbican Hotel, in Islington, waved and blew kisses at protesters in the street below. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 3 People believed to be asylum seekers were watching from the windows Credit: PA 3 Migrant hotel residents have been spotted laughing while they video protesters Credit: PA 3 They filmed the clash from their rooms Credit: PA The protest outside the north London hotel was sparked today, while another demonstration will also take place in Newcastle outside The New Bridge Hotel. The Metropolitan Police said the display was organised by local residents under the banner "Thistle Barbican needs to go - locals say no". Online groups called Patriots of Britain and Together for the Children have voiced their support for the demonstration. A counter-protest, created by Stand Up To Racism, has also unfolded. On student involved said he wants migrants to "feel safe" in the UK. Pat Prendergast, 21, said: "I want people to feel safe. I think the (rival protesters) over there are making people feel unsafe. "I want to stand up in solidarity and say that, you know, we want people here. "We want migrants. We want asylum seekers." Meanwhile people against the hotel being used for migrants shouted "get these scum off our streets", while waving England flags. A large group of masked protesters dressed in black and chanted "we are anti-fascist". A man donning an England football shirt was also arrested by police after an aggressive altercation with officers. There were clashes before cops separate the two groups. Chief Superintendent Clair Haynes, in charge of the policing operation, said: "We have been in discussions with the organisers of both protests in recent days, building on the ongoing engagement between local officers, community groups and partners. "We understand that there are strongly held views on all sides. "Our officers will police without fear or favour, ensuring those exercising their right to protest can do so safely, but intervening at the first sign of actions that cross the line into criminality. "We have used our powers under the Public Order Act to put conditions in place to prevent serious disorder and to minimise serious disruption to the lives of people and businesses in the local community. "Those conditions identify two distinct protest areas where the protests must take place, meaning the groups will be separated but still within sight and sound of each other." In a statement, the organisers of the counter protest said: "Yet again far-right and fascist thugs are intent on bringing their message of hate to Newcastle. "They aim to build on years of Islamophobia, anti-migrant sentiment and scapegoating. "In Epping and elsewhere recently we have already seen intimidation and violence aimed at refugees, migrants and asylum seekers. "Newcastle, like the rest of the North East, has a well-earned reputation for unity in the face of those who seek to divide us. "Whatever problems we face, racism and division are not the answer." More to follow... For the latest news on this story keep checking back at The Sun Online is your go-to destination for the best celebrity news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures and must-see video. Like us on Facebook at and follow us from our main Twitter account at @TheSun.
South Wales Argus
6 hours ago
- South Wales Argus
Murdered mother and children ‘together and finally safe'
Crowds flooded into the Co Clare village of Barefield for the funeral of Vanessa Whyte, 45, and her children James Rutledge, 14, and Sara Rutledge, 13, who died in a shooting at their home in Maguiresbridge, Co Fermanagh. Many of the mourners wore GAA jerseys and bright colours as requested by the family as they lined the main street to watch the three hearses pass by. Vanessa Whyte and her children Sara Rutledge and James Rutledge died following a shooting in Co Fermanagh (Handout/PA) Those in attendance at the funeral at the Church of the Immaculate Conception on Saturday included a representative for the Taoiseach Micheal Martin and GAA president Jarlath Burns. Delivering the eulogy, Ms Whyte's sister Regina said they have been robbed of their loved ones. 'Vanessa, James and Sara were taken from this world in a cruel and vicious manner – there are no words available to express how this has impacted our family and their friends,' she said. 'We as a family have been robbed of both a relationship with our sister and a chance to see James and Sara grow up, and they have been robbed of the remainder of their lives. 'It has taken us 11 days to be in a position to have Vanessa, James and Sara back to Clare. Crowds turned out for the service (Noel Sweeney/PA) 'This was supposed to be a joyous occasion where Vanessa would see her new nephew, and Sara and James would meet their baby cousin for the first time. Instead we are in the position of choosing coffins, final burial places and funeral hymns. 'For us as a family, the only comfort we have is that Vanessa, James and Sara are together and finally safe. 'Vanessa will have her children at either side of her forever, as they were when they were alive.' She described her sister as 'witty, bright, kind and determined', and said James and Sara were the 'focus of her world'. She recalled James's love of the GAA, playing both hurling and football, and also cricket, adding he has been acknowledged as the 'kind, bright, determined teenager we as a family know so well'. 'James's smile was infectious, and his loyalty was strong,' she said. GAA President Jarlath Burns attended the funeral (Noel Sweeney/PA) Sara was remembered as having a deep love for animals, and aspiring to follow in her mother's footsteps to become a vet, as well as loving sport. 'She was an excellent hurler, a footballer and skilled at netball. She was a team player, a quiet leader, and like every sister, never let James away with anything,' she said. Amazing Grace and Somewhere Over The Rainbow were among the music played during the service. Bishop Ger Nash, Bishop of Ferns and a family friend, described heartbreak over the 'tragic and unspeakable loss of three lives with so much to give to the world'. Delivering the homily, he said every story and shared memory since their deaths 'reminds us of the irreplaceable part they played in the lives of their families, their community, their schools, workplaces, teams and clubs'. 'The tragic events of last week, and the ripping away of three people from their family and friends leave us searching for answers and coming back again and again to the only answer that is completely true: 'We don't know',' he said. Members of the St Joseph's Doora-Barefield GAA Club formed part of the guard of honour (Noel Sweeney/PA) He noted messages of condolences for the mother and her children including from neighbours, but also many from those who simply described themselves as 'A Waterford Mammy', 'A Cork Granny', and 'A Wicklow Mother'. 'There were some with both dads and mams mentioned, but there were many where a woman spoke from her own heart,' he said. 'They don't know you, nor you them, but they know your story, and if they hug their teenagers more tightly and call a ceasefire in the perpetual war about tidy rooms, then they have learned that life is precious, and we must be grateful for every day given to us and to those we love. 'Over and over, I could see that women and mothers, as individuals, reached out in their shock and sadness at the loss of a mother and children, but also conscious that there were heartbroken mothers left behind. 'The messages highlighted the vulnerability of women to pain inflicted by others and were signs of solidarity in the face of that pain.' Last week crowds also turned out for Ms Whyte, James and Sara for a service of removal in Maguiresbridge on Wednesday. Agricultural contractor Ian Rutledge, 43, who died on Monday, is understood to be the only suspect in the shooting of his family. Police in Northern Ireland have said a triple murder and attempted suicide was a line of inquiry. Ms Whyte, James and Sara are to be buried together in Templemaley Cemetery later.
