Stabbed man's partner witnessed his death in incident ‘so brutal and cruel'
Keith Smithers (41) and Peter White (40) had pleaded not guilty to the unlawful killing and robbery of Brian Hogan on January 13th, 2023, at Collins Place in Finglas.
Smithers, of Barry Close, Finglas, Dublin 11, was convicted on both charges following a trial at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court, while White, of Casement Drive, Finglas, was acquitted of the unlawful killing of Mr Hogan, but was convicted of robbing him.
Smithers has just over 90 previous convictions, including offences for criminal damage, drugs, possession of knives and handling stolen property, while White has 264 previous convictions, including offences for assault causing harm, robbery, theft, drugs and road traffic offences.
READ MORE
On Monday, Smithers was handed a global sentence of nine years, while White was jailed for four and a half years for robbery.
Lyndsey Doyle's victim impact statement was read into the record during the sentencing hearing.
Ms Doyle was with Mr Hogan that evening when they went to a house where Smithers and White were over a dispute about Mr Hogan's phone. The court heard he had given it to the men as security for a rock of cocaine the previous day. Ms Doyle was pregnant at the time with the couple's daughter.
Ms Doyle said in her statement she witnessed Mr Hogan's 'life being taken so brutal and cruel in a way no human being deserved'.
She said 'it will haunt me', and said he has left behind a broken family, referring to Mr Hogan's elderly father 'who is lost without him', as Mr Hogan had been his carer.
Ms Doyle said her daughter will grow up without a father, who would have adored her as he adored his older son. Mr Hogan has an older son from a different relationship.
She said Mr Hogan's death has 'left a huge void' in all their lives. She described him as 'a well-liked, decent fella' who did not deserve the end he got.
Ms Doyle concluded her statement by thanking Sgt Shane Behan for helping them 'getting justice for Brian and knowing that his life mattered'. She said she hopes Mr Hogan rests in peace now.
Judge Martin Nolan said the events which led to this prosecution were 'serious', adding that 'unfortunately a man died' on this date.
He said there was 'little formal mitigation' for either of the defendants, and noted they both had a record of previous convictions.
The judge said he had considered Smithers's background, his history of addiction and the contents of letters submitted by extended family.
Judge Nolan said the court was of the view that Smithers was remorseful for his actions, which was 'a small level of mitigation'.
He handed Smithers a sentence of nine years for manslaughter and a concurrent sentence of four and a half years on the robbery charge.
In relation to White, the judge said the context of the robbery was 'quite serious' and imposed a sentence of four and a half years.
The judge directed the men should receive credit for any time served in custody on these matters alone and granted a defence application to extend legal aid in the event of an appeal.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
8 hours ago
- Irish Times
Criminal who kidnapped, tortured Kevin Lunney challenges constitutionality of conviction
One of the men jailed for the kidnap and torture of Quinn Industrial Holdings director Kevin Lunney has argued against the constitutionality of his conviction by the Special Criminal Court. Alan Harte (43) was sentenced to 30 years in prison by the non-jury, three-judge Special Criminal Court for committing serious harm and falsely imprisoning Mr Lunney at a yard in Drumbrade, Ballinagh, Co Cavan, in September 2019. At the Court of Appeal on Monday, Michael O'Higgins SC, for Harte, said there were two grounds to the appeal: whether it was possible for the Special Criminal Court to deliver a majority verdict and whether that court was entitled not to disclose whether the verdict was unanimous or not. 'If a person is convicted, they should know if it is a unanimous or majority verdict,' Mr O'Higgins said. 'When taking someone's liberty away, it should be done with absolute transparency.' READ MORE He said that a court, when not making rulings, was in effect acting as a juror, so the judges of the Special Criminal Court were engaged in the same exercise as a jury. 'It's irrelevant who is doing it, they're carrying out the same task with the same criteria. If the verdict falls below a level, the trial becomes unacceptable,' Mr O'Higgins said. He said that while there were procedural differences between the courts, once a jury or judges retired to consider their verdict they were in the same category. Remy Farrell SC, for the State, said a jury trial involved trial by a reasonable cross-section of society, but the Special Criminal Court comprised judges who were not representative of a cross-section of society, so these were completely different concepts. Mr Justice John Edwards, presiding, said the court would reserve judgment.
Irish Times
9 hours ago
- Irish Times
Drug addict with nearly 190 convictions who twice robbed same pharmacy given seven years
A robber with 189 previous convictions who twice targeted the same pharmacy has been given a seven-year sentence with the final three years suspended. Robert Clinch (43) told the court in a letter that he wants to rehabilitate and change his life. Dublin Circuit Criminal Court heard Clinch, a long-time drug addict, was previously released during the Covid pandemic with no support and within hours, had broken into a McDonald's restaurant to make himself food and steal cash. Clinch, of Millbrook Grove, Kilbarrack, Dublin, pleaded guilty to two counts of robbery of a pharmacy in Coolock on dates in February and July 2023. READ MORE Passing sentence on Monday,Judge Elma Duffy noted the same shop and the same victims had been targeted twice. She said Clinch knew the consequences of this offending for himself and his victims. She noted he had been described as being a pathetic figure doing what he needed to do to get his next fix. She took into account that he wants to change his life and has been motivated to engage with services and become drug-free while in custody. She told him that no matter what is put in place for him on his release, at some point, he must be the person who has to break the cycle. The judge imposed consecutive sentences totalling seven years and suspended the final three on strict conditions. Garda Alan Davis told Patrick Jackson, prosecuting, that in the first robbery on February 16th, 2023, Clinch entered the store through security doors as another customer was leaving. His face was covered and he was armed with a knife. He asked the staff to open the till and took €150. He also took about 300 tablets and warned staff not to press the panic button. He said sorry before he left the scene. Garda Davis said on July 4th, 2023, the same staff were working, when one of them saw a man roll a black beanie down over his face and knew he was going to rob the store. He banged the security door with his shoulder to force it open and used a rock to prevent it from closing. Staff activated the panic alarm. Clinch asked them why they had pressed the panic button and ran to the dispensary, where tablets were put into a bag. While the staff member was doing this, he leaned over and took her phone. Gardaí were able to identify Clinch on CCTV and trace him on footage walking to and from his home before and after the robberies. He was arrested and made denials. The court heard Clinch was a drug addict who was committing offences to feed his habit.
Irish Times
9 hours ago
- Irish Times
Somali diplomat challenges detention in Dublin jail over alleged people smuggling
A Somali diplomat arrested at Dublin Airport and charged with people-smuggling offences has launched a High Court challenge against his detention in an Irish prison, claiming diplomatic immunity. Mohamed Abdallatif Hussein, who is attached to the Federal Republic of Somalia embassy in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, was arrested by gardaí at Dublin Airport on November 26th last year. He was brought before Dublin District Court later that day accused of two counts of alleged people smuggling under the Criminal Justice (Smuggling of Persons) Act, 2021, at Dublin Airport's terminal one. On the same date, he was also charged with two further offences under the Act. READ MORE Last January at Cloverhill District Court he was further charged with four counts of alleged people smuggling under the Act at terminal two, Dublin Airport, on November 6th and September 30th last year. He has not yet entered a plea on any of the eight charges. Barry Ward SC, for Mr Hussein, told the High Court on Monday his client has been held here 'unlawfully' since November and was entitled to diplomatic immunity. While only Mr Hussein's side was represented in court, Mr Ward told Ms Justice Marguerite Bolger his client was travelling under a diplomatic passport at the time of his arrest last November. Mr Ward is bringing the High Court application to have his client released from Cloverhill Prison. On Friday, Faisal Sadiq Khan of FSK Solicitors wrote to the prison governor, requesting his client's 'immediate' release under the Constitution's Article 40.4.2, which concerns the lawfulness of a person's detention. The request was refused by the prison, which said the release of Mr Hussein required a High Court order. Mr Hussein's lawyers say he is entitled to diplomatic immunity under the Vienna Convention. In a sworn statement to the court, Mr Khan said his client was a diplomatic agent 'within' the meaning ... the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, 1961, transposed into Irish law'. Mr Hussein is bringing the High Court application against the Director of Public Prosecutions and the governor of Cloverhill Prison. The matter is back before the High Court later this week.
