John Curtice: Pro-independence Holyrood majority 'matters for future'
Speaking during a live recording of the Holyrood Sources podcast in Edinburgh on Wednesday evening, the polling expert also warned it is 'not inconceivable' that Nigel Farage's Reform UK win an outright majority at Westminster at the next General Election.
Hours earlier, Electoral Calculus had published a Multi-level Regression and Post-stratification (MRP) poll of 5400 UK voters which projected that Reform UK would win 31% of the vote and 377 Westminster seats – none of which were in Scotland. Labour were projected to drop to just 118 MPs on 22%, and the Tories to just 29 MPs – below the LibDems on 69.
Curtice told the Holyrood Sources podcast that no UK party in the history of political polling had lost support as quickly after being elected as Keir Starmer's Labour Party had.
READ MORE: EU, taxes, and Labour 'out of step': What we learned in John Curtice's polling report
He said that in 2024 Labour's 'essential appeal was, 'well, we know you don't like the SNP, so you need to vote for us to send a message to them, and we know you hate the Tories, so you need to vote for us'.
'The trouble is that they are now in government – and the truth is one of the key messages of the 2024 election was that being in government sucks.'
Curtice added: 'Then essentially the whole of the Scottish revival for Labour that began actually with Partygate, continued with Liz Truss, much like the case south of the border, and only latterly was to do with the difficulties of the SNP. All of that has gone.'
In Scotland, the University of Strathclyde professor said that Reform's support was not as strong as south of the border because the party's vote is 'heavily embedded in those who voted Leave'. Scotland voted to Remain in the EU in the 2016 referendum by 62% to 38%.
However, Curtice said that Reform and Labour were both running at around one-fifth of the Scottish vote, adding that Farage's party, 'if they can run at that kind of level on the regional list vote, they will have a significant presence in the Holyrood chamber'.
File photo of polling expert Professor John Curtice (Image: BBC) 'There are various possibilities at this point, and this is why the election's still a knife edge,' the polling expert went on.
'It's still possible, because of the way in which the electoral system operates and because the SNP – although they're only at 33%, are currently something like 14-15 points over everybody else – could get so much in terms of the constituency seats that we might still just get a pro-independence majority at Holyrood, and that matters, by the way, for the future of politics.
'But equally, it's also perfectly possible that we will get an SNP government that looks much closer to the one of 2007 to 2011 in terms of its position in the parliament.
'But of course the crucial difference between now and then is that there is no prospect of Russell Findlay being the person who keeps the SNP minority government going, which is what Annabel Goldie did between 2007 and 2011.
'So I think therefore managing that parliament could be – you talked earlier on about the SNP will still be in power. Well, they might still be in office. I think what's still at stake in this election is whether the SNP will still be in power.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
2 hours ago
- Times
SNP councillor resigns from party after £500,000 drug bust
An SNP politician has stepped down from the party after being charged with drug offences following the discovery of a cannabis farm at a rural property. Aileen Orr, a councillor and one-time party staff member for Mike Russell, the former SNP president and Nicola Sturgeon ally, was arrested after a drugs bust in the Borders in February last year. Orr, now 71, called the emergency services to report a break-in at a farmhouse on the outskirts of the Berwickshire village of Paxton. When police arrived at the property they did not locate any burglars but did find a cannabis cultivation with an estimated street value of £500,000. Orr was arrested and charged last year, as was her 29-year-old son, Duncan Orr. A report is due to be submitted to prosecutors and a court date will be set in due course.
South Wales Argus
2 hours ago
- South Wales Argus
Monmouthshire council will lobby for Magor walkway station
The UK Government announced in its comprehensive spending review it would make £445 million available, with most of the money to be spent within the next three years, for rail upgrades in Wales. The Welsh Government intends pressing ahead with five new stops between Cardiff and Chepstow to ease congestion on the M4. Monmouthshire County Council agreed at its July meeting it would write to decision makers in the Cardiff and Westminster governments, and the rail industry, to 'ensure that Magor Station is recognised as a quick win and is delivered immediately and without delay' with the funding announced by Chancellor Rachel Reeves. Magor West independent councillor Frances Taylor, who put the motion asking for the council's to once again commit to the village 'walkway' station, intended to be accessed on foot rather than by car, said she was glad when plans for an M4 relief road were dropped. But she said Magor station could have been delivered at any time since the Burns report, that considered alternatives, was published in early 2021 and said she couldn't see any of its recommendations have been implemented. 'Critically Magor station does not need to wait for relief line enhancements it could be delivered tomorrow for circa £10m,' said Cllr Taylor who added two hourly trains, from Cardiff, to Taunton and Cheltenham could service it. READ MORE: 'Magor should be priority of five new stations near Newport' The councillor said the five stations require improvements to the relief line, which carries freight, and she said that work hasn't been included in the £445m announced in the spending review. Cllr Catrin Maby, the council's Labour cabinet member with responsibility for transport, said while the walkway station as first proposed by local campaigners, in 2013, isn't reliant on upgrading the relief line that would likely be required for it to be 'fully functional' with the others proposed and to accommodate freight, fast trains passing through and stopping trains. The Drybridge councillor said the relief line upgrade is 'on the radar' of Westminster's Department of Transport, which is providing the funding. Labour member for Magor East with Undy John Crook said the council should focus on working with MP Catherine Fookes to lobby the government in London. An amendment put forward by Cllr Maby, who said she 'didn't disagree with the motion', suggested 'clarifying' timing of the relief line, but that was rejected by Cllr Taylor who said: 'It is not about clarifying the timescale, there is no timescale to the relief line upgrade.' The amendment was rejected by one vote and Labour councillor Armand Watts said he couldn't vote due to a technical problem. Cllr Maby also said the council is committed to other recommendations to ease M4 congestion including a Rogiet relief road which could also make travel to the Severn Tunnel Junction station easier.
.jpg%3Fwidth%3D1200%26height%3D800%26crop%3D1200%3A800&w=3840&q=100)
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
This is the last chance for Labour and the Tories to stay relevant
Although many voters will be horrified at the idea that Nigel Farage could become prime minister, Reform UK's consistent lead in the opinion polls means the prospect must be taken seriously. In his latest pitch, Mr Farage has struck an unlikely pose as the leader who can save our democratic system from an extreme right-wing government much more dangerous than a Reform-led one. His argument is nakedly self-serving. Mr Farage wants to build on Reform's growing support by making his party more respectable to voters who have not made the leap. He has distanced himself from the right-wing criminal Tommy Robinson, but said that, while he is not in the camp of Andrew Tate, the misogynist influencer, he can 'see why he's doing well'. Mr Farage told The Sunday Times he hopes young men will turn to him to give them a voice 'because if I don't, you wait till what comes after me'. He added: 'Those who try to demonise me could be in for a terrible shock once I'm gone. That's why we say we believe that we are the last chance to restore confidence in the democratic system, to change things.' The Independent thinks voters should not be taken in by Mr Farage's attempt to make his distasteful nationalist-populist product more palatable. They should remember that the mask slipped when he called for the two-child benefit cap to be lifted; he said this should be limited to 'British families', excluding 'those that come into the country and suddenly decide to have a lot of children'. Nor has Mr Farage put away his dog whistle on immigration: he shamelessly twisted the words of Anas Sarwar, the Scottish Labour leader, to claim he would prioritise the needs of Pakistanis – a tactic used by the very right-wing extremist groups the Reform leader purports to be better than. Reform MPs have also deliberately stirred tensions by calling for a ban on the burqa. However, both Labour and the Conservatives have lessons to learn from Mr Farage's latest attempt to invade their natural territory. He argued that Labour has 'become the party of the bourgeoisie, very middle-class'. Although Sir Keir Starmer and his ministers champion 'working people,' Labour has lost much of its traditional class-based support. Last week's British social attitudes survey reported that, even in last year's landslide, Labour won the support of only 30 per cent of people in semi-routine and routine occupations, compared with 42 per cent of those in professional and managerial jobs. Age and education have supplanted class as the main dividing line in politics: only 5 per cent of graduates voted for Reform, compared with 25 per cent of those with qualifications below an A-level. As The Independent reported yesterday, Britons earning more than £70,000 a year are more likely to vote Labour than for any other party, while 32 per cent of people in households with an income of £20,000 or less now support Reform, with Labour well behind on 19 per cent. Pendulum politics, when either Labour or the Tories do well and the other badly, appears to be over: five parties now register 10 per cent or more in the polls, with the Liberal Democrats not far behind the Tories and the Greens also making inroads into Labour's support. However, it seems Labour strategists want to preserve the two-party system by writing off the Tories as 'a dead party walking' and 'sliding into brain-dead oblivion,' as Sir Keir put it. Labour wants to turn the next general election into a presidential contest between Sir Keir and Mr Farage, hoping that disillusioned centrist and left-of-centre voters will hold their nose and back Labour to keep the Reform leader out of Downing Street. It's a crude tactic and, to work, will surely need to be coupled with some positive reasons for voting Labour, such as tangible improvements on public services and the cost of living. Sir Keir should think through the consequences of kicking the Tories while they are down. Although their leaders would never admit in public, both Labour and the Tories have an interest in the other doing better than they currently are. It would help the Tories if Labour's justified attacks on Reform's 'fantasy economics' damage Mr Farage's party, and Labour can show the government machine is not broken. It might suit Labour if the irrelevant-looking Tories get back in the game and prevent a Reform victory by splitting the right-wing vote. The public has voted for change three times and been disappointed – in the 2016 Brexit referendum and the 2019 and 2024 general elections. If Sir Keir cannot turn things round after his difficult first year as prime minister, the fear of many voters that mainstream parties are 'all the same' will be justified. Mr Farage, not an extremist party of the right or left, will be the beneficiary. Labour and the Tories are both drinking in the last chance saloon.
