Hillary Clinton OK'd plan to ‘smear' Donald Trump with Russia collusion, documents prove
The 24-page intelligence annex was compiled from memos and emails obtained by the Obama administration in the lead-up to Election Day that laid out 'confidential conversations' between leaders of the Democratic National Committee — including then-Chair Debbie Wasserman Schultz — and liberal billionaire George Soros' Open Society Foundations.
The plot, the brainchild of the Clinton campaign's then-foreign policy adviser, Julianne Smith, included 'raising the theme of 'Putin's support for Trump'' and 'subsequently steering public opinion toward the notion that it needs to equate' the Russian leader's political influence campaign with actual hacking of election infrastructure.
Smith would go on to serve as former President Joe Biden's ambassador to NATO. 'I don't have any comment,' she told The Post when reached by phone Thursday.
Open Society senior vice president Leonard Benardo was looped in on the scheme and laid out its intended effect in a series of emails in late July 2016.
'Julie [sic] says it will be a long-term affair to demonize Putin and Trump,' Benardo was quoted as writing July 25. 'Now it is good for a post-convention bounce. Later the FBI will put more oil into the fire.'
Two days later, Benardo wrote: 'HRC approved Julia's idea about Trump and Russian hackers hampering U.S. elections. That should distract people from her own missing email, especially if the affair goes to the Olympic level,' an apparent reference to revelations of a massive state-sponsored doping campaign by Russia following the 2014 Winter Games in Sochi.
'The point is making the Russian play a U.S. domestic issue,' Benardo also stated. 'In absence of direct evidence, Crowdstrike and ThreatConnect will supply the media, and GRU [Russia's foreign intelligence arm] will hopefully carry on to give more facts.'
Special counsel John Durham uncovered the files during a multi-year probe into intelligence activities during the 2016 election.
Durham consulted the FBI and CIA, both of which assessed that the information was 'likely authentic' but couldn't corroborate exact copies of the Benardo emails with Open Society Foundations. The CIA also determined that the intelligence was not 'the product of Russian fabrications.'
'Smith was, at minimum, playing a role in the Clinton campaign's efforts to tie Trump to Russia,' Durham concluded.
The Trump-Russia investigation was part of what a March 2016 memo included in the annex described as a 'two-prong DP [Democratic Party] opposition [that] is focused on discrediting Trump…. [a]mong other things, the Clinton staff, with support from special services, is preparing scandalous revelations of business relations between Trump and the 'Russian Mafia.''
The 'special services' cited in one of the memos referred to intelligence activities of Obama's CIA and FBI, which may have included the work of 'Trump dossier author Christopher Steele.'
The memos also claim then-President Barack Obama was 'put[ing] pressure on FBI Director James Comey through Attorney General [Loretta] Lynch' to wrap up the probe of Clinton's use of a private email server to receive highly classified information while secretary of state.
'Obama,' a January 2016 memo read, 'has no intention to darken the final part of his presidency and 'legacy' by the scandal surrounding the main contender from the [Democratic Party].'
The March 2016 memo claimed the 44th president had 'sanctioned the use of all administrative levers to remove possibly negative effects from the FBI investigation of cases related to the Clinton Foundation and the email correspondence in the State Department.'
In December 2016, Obama ordered a post-election intelligence assessment of nefarious Russian activity surrounding that year's election.
That assessment, published in January 2017 included — over the objections of senior CIA officials — details from the Steele dossier, an opposition research project funded in part by Clinton's campaign and the DNC.
In March 2016, then-FBI Deputy Director Andrew McCabe shared the memos with senior officials at the Department of Justice, suggesting a plot to launch an investigation based on the Democratic campaign document.
'During the first stage of the campaign, due to lack of direct evidence, it was decided to disseminate the necessary information through the FBI-affiliated … technical structures … in particular, the Crowdstrike and ThreatConnect companies, from where the information would then be disseminated through leading U.S. publications,' one Benardo email read.
Durham concluded: 'The Office's best assessment is that the … emails that purport to be from Benardo were ultimately a composite of several emails that were obtained through Russian intelligence hacking of the U.S.-based Think Tanks, including the Open Society Foundations, the Carnegie Endowment, and others.'
Attorney General Pam Bondi, FBI Director Kash Patel and other members of the US Intelligence Community declassified the Durham annex at the request of Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa).
'Based on the Durham annex, the Obama FBI failed to adequately review and investigate intelligence reports showing the Clinton campaign may have been ginning up the fake Trump-Russia narrative for Clinton's political gain, which was ultimately done through the Steele Dossier and other means,' Grassley said in a statement.
'These intelligence reports and related records, whether true or false, were buried for years. History will show that the Obama and Biden administration's law enforcement and intelligence agencies were weaponized against President Trump,' he added.
'This political weaponization has caused critical damage to our institutions and is one of the biggest political scandals and cover-ups in American history. The new Trump administration has a tremendous responsibility to the American people to fix the damage done and do so with maximum speed and transparency.'
Ratcliffe said in a statement that the files — some of which came from the CIA — showed 'a coordinated plan to prevent and destroy Donald Trump's presidency.'
Bondi and Patel insisted that the public disclosures would restore Americans' trust in the government and provide accountability.
'This Department of Justice, alongside the CIA, is committed to truth and transparency and will continue to support good-faith efforts by Congress to hold our government accountable,' Bondi said. 'Chairman Grassley is leading by example and shining light on critical issues of great interest to the American people.'
'The American people deserve the full, unfiltered truth about the Russia collusion hoax and the political abuse of our justice system it exposed,' added Patel. 'Today's declassification and release of documents tied to the Durham report is another step toward that accountability.'
'I'm grateful to Chairman Grassley for his steadfast leadership on this issue, and I look forward to our continued partnership in exposing one of the most shameful frauds ever perpetrated on the American public.'
The Post reached out to Benardo, reps for Clinton and the Open Society Foundations for comment.
Originally published as Hillary Clinton OK'd plan to 'smear' Donald Trump with Russia collusion, documents prove
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

The Age
an hour ago
- The Age
‘A threat was made': Trump repositions nuclear subs after online spat with ex-Russian leader
Washington: In a warning to Russia, US President Donald Trump said Friday he's ordering the repositioning of two US nuclear submarines 'based on the highly provocative statements' of the country's former president, Dmitry Medvedev, who has raised the prospect of war online. Trump posted on his social media site that, based on the 'highly provocative statements' from Medvedev, he had 'ordered two Nuclear Submarines to be positioned in the appropriate regions, just in case these foolish and inflammatory statements are more than just that'. The president added, 'Words are very important, and can often lead to unintended consequences, I hope this will not be one of those instances.' He told US cable network Newsmax Friday night Washington time (Saturday AEST) that the submarines had been moved closer to Russia. It wasn't clear what impact Trump's order would have on US nuclear subs, which are routinely on patrol in the world's hotspots, but it comes at a delicate moment in the Trump administration's relations with Moscow. Trump said later Friday that he was alarmed by Medvedev's attitude. 'He's got a fresh mouth,' he said in an interview with Newsmax on Saturday AEST. Trump has said that special envoy Steve Witkoff is heading to Russia to push Moscow to agree to a ceasefire in its war with Ukraine and has threatened new economic sanctions if progress is not made. He cut his 50-day deadline for action to 10 days, with that window set to expire next week. The post about the sub repositioning came after Trump, in the wee hours of Thursday morning, had posted that Medvedev was a 'failed former President of Russia' and warned him to 'watch his words'.

Sydney Morning Herald
3 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Inaction on pokies harm is gambling with lives
The pokies article by Peter FitzSimons (' MPs servants to 'predatory' pokies ', July 27) emphasises the most important point of the pokies disaster. It can't be fixed because both sides of politics are so dependent on pokies donations that once in power they realise the pokies lobby is in charge, not them. And fixing that by increasing campaign funding for political parties from the budget means increasing taxes. It's easy for the pokies lobby and its media backers to stoke public outrage when increased taxes are suggested. There even is a term for it, 'state capture'. Whoever wins the election, lobby groups are still in charge. It's relevant more widely, such as the fossil fuel lobby slowing down climate action. It's a pernicious problem and the Herald is to be commended for running an anti-gambling campaign. It's hard to see a solution until someone is brave enough to have a policy calling for higher taxes to tackle some of the bigger problems we face. Maybe braver politicians? Gary Barnes, Mosman Take my advice Senator James Paterson says 'Labor would be judged on the results of proposed consultant cuts' (' Labor's splurge on advice revealed ', July 27). That's rich coming from anyone in the Liberal party. It's not the spending of money on consultants that I mind so much as the pretence practised by the Liberals that ditching public service jobs to do it, while ignoring the alternate costs, is somehow saving money. Equally objectionable is the sneakiness of hiring people – using eye-watering amounts of public funds – to tell you what you want to hear instead of what you should be told, while claiming it's somehow a 'partnership'. Driven by their own 'ideological obsession' of antipathy towards the public service dating as far back as the Howard era, the Liberals were avid practitioners of an identical reverse bias. And while Labor's pot so far seems decidedly tarnished at keeping its promise to negate it, they've got a long way to go to match the blackness of the Liberals' kettle. Adrian Connelly, Springwood The criticism of the Albanese government's use of consultants is misplaced. They have pledged to rebuild the capacity of the public service, laid waste by the previous Coalition. Does anyone really believe this will happen overnight? While there are green shoots, it will take years to restore an objective, expert public service. The damage wrought to good government by the previous Coalition administration, venal in its attempts to politicise the public service, promote mates and create a supine culture (remember robo-debt?), nearly destroyed it. As Labor rebuilds, of course consultants will be needed, especially as this government wants to achieve something. Hopefully, the best can be encouraged into an invigorated public service for the national good. Wayne Duncombe, Lilyfield False piety America likes to think of itself as a God-fearing nation of Christians, yet it puts up with Trump (' America's shame: Despite all the evidence Trump remains shameless ', July 27). There seems to be no shame that their president breaks all those Christian ideals they hold so dear. Their sin is not their lack of shame. It is their hypocrisy. Neville Turbit, Russell Lea Fertility lifeline The importance of IVF to many families cannot be underestimated, but to those with life-threatening genetic conditions it is especially important (' There have been 17 million IVF babies. Rebecca was one of the first ', July 27). For these families IVF can allow the possibility of a mutant gene to be isolated and sidelined and ultimately dismissed from the family line, allowing hope for a more positive future. We can only be grateful for the process. Janice Creenaune, Austinmer So fertility rates are 'nosediving'? Perhaps a truer word has never been used. It's well known that modern perfumes contain hormone disruptors such as phthalates, isn't it? And to say that perfumes are pervasive is an understatement. We live and move in a sea of fake scent. You can't even walk down a bush track without being nasally assaulted by the smell of the person (man or woman) 10 minutes ahead of you, whom you may not actually ever see. It must drive the wildlife, well, wild. Ironically, perfume formulas are designed to make the wearer more attractive, but may in fact result in lower fertility. Pass the nose peg, please. Carolyn Little, Mortdale

The Age
4 hours ago
- The Age
In dark times, hope is the sunshine
Unseen, uncaring? Many correspondents have emphasised we must act to stop the killing and hunger in Gaza because we are seeing this unravel before our eyes through pictures and video. This poses a question: If we don't see vision of other catastrophic wars in the world, should we care? I am distressed at what is happening in Gaza, but I am also disturbed by the starvation and killing of hundreds of thousands people in countries such as Sudan. The BBC has reported that 13 children have died of starvation in a displacement camp in East Darfur. And, last year UNICEF reported harrowing accounts of armed men in Sudan raping and sexually assaulting children. But Australia's media rarely reports and shows pictures of what is happening in other war-torn countries. We don't even get stories about the effect of what is happening in Sudan on our Sudanese community in Victoria. If we did read and see pictures about killing and hunger in other parts of the world, would we call for this to stop? Would the weekly CBD protests call for an end to all catastrophic wars? Erica Cervini, Prahran The Trump remedy Donald Trump firing the statistician who reports poor jobs data reminds me of his proposed remedy when faced with steeply increasing COVID cases: stop testing. Soon on the agenda: stop voting. Ralph Böhmer, St Kilda West A Tigers fan softens Thanks for the apology Bob Murphy (″ I owe the Tigers an apology ″, 1/8). As a lifetime Tiger supporter, I was one of many Tiger fans extremely disappointed in his pre-season prediction of a winless Tigers 2025 season. Today I'm still that little boy from the 1960s who wore Bill Brown's No. 40 on my Richmond jumper and that little boy was shattered by his statement. While always believing in his ability on the playing field, my assessment of his performance as a 774 radio host was tempered by his ill-advised prediction. I, too, witnessed the great deeds of Matthew Knights in the 1995 final comeback victory against the Bombers and was also at his fourth game when all hell broke loose between the Doggies and Tigers. Fortunately I have become the grandfather of two young passionate Doggie supporters and while they tell me they hate the Tigers, I now have a very big soft spot for their Doggies and I have been able to let go of my feelings from that day. My assessment of his performance on the airwaves is now unencumbered by his poor Tigers 2025 prediction So Bob, I forgive you. Paul Gooley, Ringwood East Do the maths Your correspondent (Letters, 31/7) took me back to my 1980s sixth grade at Brunswick North West Primary School. Before curriculum and assessment design became a political plaything, teachers were provided with the freedom to adopt models from a range of expert mathematics educators. For eight months, my students treated numbers and their patterns like fun manipulative toys. Along the way they became experts at automatic response. Today's content driven/test proven/NAPLAN-backed regime would have straightjacketed my teaching. My students loved mathematics, declaring it the easiest subject. Would they say this today? Sadly, I doubt it. Ian Whitehead, Traralgon Profit v care Why on earth, 40 years after Margaret Thatcher and Ronald Reagan tried to persuade us that all public services should be privatised, are we still surprised at the shocking revelations coming out of the ″childcare industry″? The two underlying motivations are completely divergent and at odds: private childcare to maximise private profit (largely supported by government subsidies), and public services to care for children. Keep it simple. Tony Adami, Caulfield South When new is the norm Reading Scott Farquhar's comments about AI reminds me of Alexis de Tocqueville's observations about capitalists in 19th-century America (″ Tech boss calls for boost to AI as 150 jobs cut ″, 31/7). He observed, ″The idea of newness is closely linked with that of improvement. Nowhere in his mind does he see any limit placed by nature to human endeavour.″ On the question of AI, we are encouraged to exalt what is new, to exploit it, remaining indifferent to the destruction of the old ways. There will, of course, be radical social change, high unemployment and entire industries erased, but those entranced by newness will have moved on by then. Anders Ross, Heidelberg Reward the teachers It's a significant achievement that Victorian primary schoolchildren have scored highly in NAPLAN tests (″ Victorian kids are the brightest sparks ″, 30/7). It's also heartening that Education Minister Ben Carroll acknowledges the reasons for these improvements and recognises teachers play a pivotal role in this progress. As a parent of one I hope this will translate into tangible outcomes for our hard-working and undervalued teachers.